Comment list is always empty

[Feuerfuchs]

I just switched from the last stable version to the master branch of this repository. Now the comment list API endpoint (/?uri=...) is broken for me since it will always return a 404 error, regardless of how many comments there actually are. The count API endpoint (/count?uri=...) works fine, though.

You can see this problem live here: https://newtest.feuerfuchs.eu/en/blog/2014/05/02/another-hugo-post/ (Comments are now disabled, URLs below still work)
Fetch API result: https://comments.feuerfuchs.eu/?uri=/en/blog/2014/05/02/another-hugo-post/
Count API result: https://comments.feuerfuchs.eu/count?uri=/en/blog/2014/05/02/another-hugo-post/
Admin interface screenshot

[pozitron57]

Do you have the same problem when there are more than zero comments? See #301, isso returns 404 when there are no comments.

[Feuerfuchs]

Yes, that's the point of my issue. On my website, you will see in the article header that there are currently 2 comments for this article (which is the number reported by /count?uri=...). However, if you scroll down to the actual comments list, it says "No Comments Yet" (as reported by /?uri=...).

The comments must show up here because I posted them myself on that page and the admin panel shows a matching URI for the comments (see the screenshot I linked). That means it's not an issue with the count API endpoint but the fetch API endpoint.

[pozitron57]

Now I see, sorry, didn't read your post attentively enough.

[Feuerfuchs]

No problem, my description wasn't quite clear about what the issue actually is. I fixed it now. :)

[jelmer]

can you still reproduce this with 0.11.1?

[Feuerfuchs]

I will check as soon as possible! It might take a few days, though, since I'm very busy right now.

[Feuerfuchs]

That went faster than expected so here we go: The issue is still there, unfortunately.
The comment list returns error 404: https://comments.feuerfuchs.eu/?uri=/en/blog/2014/05/02/another-hugo-post/
The counter reports 2: https://comments.feuerfuchs.eu/count?uri=/en/blog/2014/05/02/another-hugo-post/
The admin interface lists 2 comments:
screenshot_2018-11-26 isso admin
Isso version is 0.11.1:

edit: Also, here's the URL where the comments are supposed to be displayed: https://www.feuerfuchs.eu/en/blog/2014/05/02/another-hugo-post/
As you can see, under the subtitle it says "2 Comments", but the actual comment list says "No Comments Yet".

[ix5]

Is this still current?

[fahmifan]

I still get empty comments with isso 0.12.5 running in local.
The data exists in DB, the query seems to working too

[ix5]

Could you please post something that makes it possible to reproduce your issue? A screenshot is of little to no value when verifying.

At the very least, your isso config, server config, embed code on the site and, if possible, a sanitized DB dump are needed.

[fahmifan]

Sorry, I found the issue, apparently, it was the config, I set the moderation to true, but I expect it to return the result immediately

[ix5]

What do you mean, "return the result immediately"? What is the expected behaviour?

[ix5]

Also note, the original poster had already approved the comments (or had no moderation enabled) and they still did not show up, so I do not think your moderation-related issue is the same as OP's.

[fahmifan]

Yeah, I think my issue is not related to the OP's.
Actually, I am not sure what the cause of my issue is, but after I turn the moderation off in config, the comment showed up after I create it and refresh the page.

[ycpei]

I had the same problem, my config uses an nginx reverse proxy with sub-uri and https redirection. My location and X-Script-Name fields are different, and by making them the same, I got into a 308 redirect loop. Following hints at #622 (comment), I reverted to my original location but added a trailing slash which fixed it.