Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
107 lines (88 loc) · 8.5 KB

threat-modeling.md

File metadata and controls

107 lines (88 loc) · 8.5 KB

Threat Model Analysis for espressif/esp-idf

Threat: Buffer Overflow in Network Packet Parsing

  • Description: An attacker sends specially crafted network packets to the ESP-IDF device. The device's network stack, while parsing these packets, overflows a buffer due to insufficient bounds checking. This can lead to memory corruption and potentially arbitrary code execution.
    • Impact: Memory corruption, denial of service, remote code execution, device compromise.
    • Affected ESP-IDF Component: ESP-IDF TCP/IP stack (e.g., LwIP, esp_netif), Wi-Fi driver.
    • Risk Severity: Critical
    • Mitigation Strategies:
      • Use latest stable ESP-IDF version with bug fixes.
      • Enable stack overflow protection features in ESP-IDF configuration.
      • Implement robust input validation and sanitization for network data.
      • Conduct thorough fuzzing and penetration testing of network handling code.
      • Utilize memory-safe programming practices.

Threat: Integer Overflow in Length Calculation

  • Description: An attacker provides input that causes an integer overflow during length calculations within ESP-IDF libraries. This overflow can lead to incorrect memory allocation or buffer sizes, resulting in buffer overflows or other memory corruption issues.
    • Impact: Memory corruption, denial of service, potential code execution.
    • Affected ESP-IDF Component: ESP-IDF core libraries (e.g., memory management, string handling).
    • Risk Severity: High
    • Mitigation Strategies:
      • Use safe integer arithmetic functions and libraries where available.
      • Implement checks for potential integer overflows before memory operations.
      • Carefully review code involving length calculations and data size handling.
      • Use static analysis tools to detect potential integer overflow vulnerabilities.

Threat: Use of Outdated ESP-IDF Version with Known Vulnerabilities

  • Description: Developers use an older version of ESP-IDF that contains publicly known security vulnerabilities within ESP-IDF components. Attackers can exploit these vulnerabilities if the device is exposed to the internet or a malicious network.
    • Impact: Device compromise, data breaches, denial of service, depending on the specific vulnerability.
    • Affected ESP-IDF Component: Entire ESP-IDF framework, including RTOS, libraries, drivers.
    • Risk Severity: High (depending on the specific vulnerabilities present in the outdated version)
    • Mitigation Strategies:
      • Always use the latest stable version of ESP-IDF.
      • Regularly check for security advisories and updates for ESP-IDF.
      • Implement a process for timely updates and patching of ESP-IDF.

Threat: DMA Buffer Overflow via Peripheral

  • Description: An attacker manipulates a peripheral (e.g., SPI, I2C) to trigger a DMA transfer with incorrect parameters, causing a buffer overflow in memory due to DMA writing to an unintended memory region.
    • Impact: Memory corruption, denial of service, potential code execution.
    • Affected ESP-IDF Component: ESP-IDF DMA driver, peripheral drivers (SPI, I2C, etc.).
    • Risk Severity: High
    • Mitigation Strategies:
      • Carefully configure DMA transfers and validate buffer sizes and addresses.
      • Implement bounds checking and validation for data received from peripherals.
      • Use secure coding practices when handling DMA operations.
      • Test DMA operations thoroughly to identify potential vulnerabilities.

Threat: JTAG/Debugging Interface Backdoor

  • Description: JTAG or other debugging interfaces are left enabled and accessible in production devices. An attacker with physical access can connect to these interfaces to debug, extract firmware, modify memory, or gain full control of the device.
    • Impact: Full device control, firmware extraction, data breaches, reverse engineering, device compromise.
    • Affected ESP-IDF Component: ESP-IDF bootloader configuration, hardware configuration, JTAG/debugging interface.
    • Risk Severity: Critical
    • Mitigation Strategies:
      • Disable JTAG and other debugging interfaces in production firmware.
      • Physically disable or remove JTAG/debug headers from production hardware if possible.
      • Implement secure boot to prevent unauthorized firmware loading even if JTAG is accessible.
      • Restrict physical access to deployed devices.

Threat: Man-in-the-Middle OTA Update Injection

  • Description: During an OTA update process, if the communication channel is not properly secured by ESP-IDF features, an attacker can intercept the update download and inject a malicious firmware image. The device then installs the compromised firmware.
    • Impact: Installation of malicious firmware, complete device compromise.
    • Affected ESP-IDF Component: ESP-IDF OTA update library, network communication during OTA.
    • Risk Severity: Critical
    • Mitigation Strategies:
      • Always use HTTPS for OTA firmware downloads. (Application level, but ESP-IDF provides tools)
      • Implement mutual authentication between the device and the OTA server. (Application level, but ESP-IDF provides tools)
      • Use secure boot to verify the integrity of the firmware image before booting. (ESP-IDF Feature)
      • Sign firmware updates with a strong digital signature and verify the signature on the device before installation. (ESP-IDF Feature)

Threat: Unsigned Firmware OTA Update

  • Description: The OTA update process, if not configured properly using ESP-IDF features, does not verify the digital signature of the firmware image before installation. An attacker can provide an unsigned or improperly signed firmware image, which the device accepts and installs.
    • Impact: Installation of malicious firmware, device compromise.
    • Affected ESP-IDF Component: ESP-IDF OTA update library, firmware verification process.
    • Risk Severity: Critical
    • Mitigation Strategies:
      • Implement mandatory firmware signature verification during OTA updates using ESP-IDF features.
      • Use strong cryptographic keys for firmware signing.
      • Securely store and manage firmware signing keys.

Threat: OTA Rollback Attack

  • Description: An attacker forces the device to downgrade to a previous, potentially vulnerable firmware version through the OTA update mechanism, potentially exploiting weaknesses in ESP-IDF's rollback protection if not properly implemented. This can reintroduce known vulnerabilities that were patched in later versions.
    • Impact: Re-introduction of known vulnerabilities, device compromise.
    • Affected ESP-IDF Component: ESP-IDF OTA update library, firmware version management, rollback protection mechanisms.
    • Risk Severity: High
    • Mitigation Strategies:
      • Implement robust rollback protection mechanisms in the OTA update process using ESP-IDF features.
      • Store firmware version information securely and use it to prevent downgrades to vulnerable versions.
      • Ensure that OTA update process only allows upgrades to newer versions or authorized versions.

Threat: Insecure Boot Configuration - Disabled Secure Boot

  • Description: Secure boot is not enabled or properly configured on the ESP-IDF device. This allows attackers to load and execute unauthorized firmware, bypassing security measures provided by ESP-IDF.
    • Impact: Installation of malicious firmware, device compromise, bypass of other security features.
    • Affected ESP-IDF Component: ESP-IDF bootloader configuration, secure boot feature.
    • Risk Severity: Critical
    • Mitigation Strategies:
      • Enable and properly configure secure boot in ESP-IDF.
      • Use hardware-backed secure boot if available.
      • Securely manage secure boot keys and certificates.