Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
142 lines (125 loc) · 8.33 KB

attack-surface.md

File metadata and controls

142 lines (125 loc) · 8.33 KB

Attack Surface Analysis for espressif/esp-idf

Attack Surface: Wi-Fi Stack Exploitation

  • Description: Vulnerabilities in the ESP-IDF Wi-Fi stack implementation allowing attackers to compromise the device over Wi-Fi.
    • ESP-IDF Contribution: ESP-IDF provides the core Wi-Fi stack and its configuration. Any bugs or misconfigurations in this stack are directly attributable to ESP-IDF.
    • Example: An attacker sends a crafted deauthentication frame causing a buffer overflow in the Wi-Fi driver, leading to remote code execution.
    • Impact: Complete device compromise, data exfiltration, potential for lateral movement within the network.
    • Risk Severity: Critical
    • Mitigation Strategies:
      • Developer:
        • Keep ESP-IDF updated to the latest stable release.
        • Perform rigorous fuzz testing of the Wi-Fi stack.
        • Implement robust input validation for all Wi-Fi data.
        • Use memory safety techniques in custom code.
        • Consider a separate, hardened Wi-Fi module if security is paramount.
      • User:
        • Keep device firmware updated.
        • Use strong Wi-Fi passwords (WPA2/WPA3).

Attack Surface: Bluetooth/BLE Stack Exploitation

  • Description: Vulnerabilities in the ESP-IDF Bluetooth/BLE stack implementation allowing attackers to compromise the device via Bluetooth.
    • ESP-IDF Contribution: ESP-IDF provides the Bluetooth/BLE stack and its configuration.
    • Example: An attacker exploits a buffer overflow in the handling of Bluetooth pairing requests to gain control of the device.
    • Impact: Device compromise, data theft, potential for physical control.
    • Risk Severity: High
    • Mitigation Strategies:
      • Developer:
        • Keep ESP-IDF updated.
        • Fuzz test the Bluetooth stack.
        • Implement strict input validation.
        • Limit Bluetooth functionality to the minimum required.
        • Implement strong authentication and authorization.
        • Consider a separate, hardened Bluetooth module.
      • User:
        • Keep firmware updated.
        • Disable Bluetooth when not in use.
        • Only pair with trusted devices.

Attack Surface: OTA Update Mechanism Compromise

  • Description: Attackers exploiting vulnerabilities in the ESP-IDF OTA update mechanism to install malicious firmware.
    • ESP-IDF Contribution: ESP-IDF provides the core OTA update functionality, including image handling, verification (if implemented), and flashing.
    • Example: An attacker intercepts an OTA update and replaces it with a malicious firmware image that lacks signature verification.
    • Impact: Complete and persistent device compromise, potentially affecting an entire fleet.
    • Risk Severity: Critical
    • Mitigation Strategies:
      • Developer:
        • Implement mandatory digital signature verification.
        • Use secure communication channels (HTTPS with certificate pinning).
        • Protect the private key used for signing (e.g., HSM).
        • Implement anti-rollback mechanisms.
        • Implement secure boot.
        • Consider a secure element or TPM.
      • User:
        • Ensure updates are from trusted sources.
        • Monitor for unusual behavior after updates.

Attack Surface: Flash Encryption/Secure Boot Bypass

  • Description: Attackers bypassing or circumventing ESP-IDF's flash encryption and secure boot features.
    • ESP-IDF Contribution: ESP-IDF provides the APIs and configuration options for flash encryption and secure boot. Incorrect usage or underlying hardware vulnerabilities can weaken these.
    • Example: An attacker uses a side-channel attack to extract the flash encryption key.
    • Impact: Complete device compromise, data extraction, malicious firmware installation.
    • Risk Severity: Critical
    • Mitigation Strategies:
      • Developer:
        • Follow Espressif's guidelines meticulously.
        • Use the strongest encryption and key lengths.
        • Enable all security features.
        • Consider hardware with side-channel attack resistance.
        • Perform thorough penetration testing.
        • Implement secure key management.
      • User:
        • Physically secure the device.

Attack Surface: JTAG/UART Debug Interface Access

  • Description: Attackers gaining access to the device via the JTAG or UART debug interfaces.
    • ESP-IDF Contribution: ESP-IDF provides access to these interfaces. Failure to disable them in production is a vulnerability.
    • Example: An attacker connects to JTAG and dumps the firmware.
    • Impact: Firmware extraction, code injection, complete control.
    • Risk Severity: High
    • Mitigation Strategies:
      • Developer:
        • Disable JTAG in production builds using eFuses. Critical.
        • Password-protect or disable the UART console.
        • Physically secure the device.
      • User:
        • Physically secure the device.

Attack Surface: lwIP TCP/IP Stack Vulnerabilities

  • Description: Exploitation of vulnerabilities within the lwIP TCP/IP stack used by ESP-IDF.
    • ESP-IDF Contribution: ESP-IDF integrates and configures lwIP. ESP-IDF's integration and configuration can introduce or exacerbate vulnerabilities.
    • Example: A remote attacker sends a crafted TCP packet causing a denial-of-service.
    • Impact: Denial of service, potential for remote code execution.
    • Risk Severity: High
    • Mitigation Strategies:
      • Developer:
        • Keep ESP-IDF (and lwIP) updated.
        • Implement strict input validation.
        • Use a firewall (if feasible).
        • Monitor network traffic.
        • Consider a more robust TCP/IP stack.
      • User:
        • Keep firmware updated.
        • Use a network firewall.

Attack Surface: Weak Random Number Generation

  • Description: Weaknesses in the ESP-IDF's RNG leading to predictable cryptographic keys.
    • ESP-IDF Contribution: ESP-IDF relies on the hardware RNG and provides APIs for accessing it.
    • Example: Weak encryption keys are generated, allowing data decryption.
    • Impact: Compromise of cryptographic operations, data breaches, impersonation.
    • Risk Severity: High
    • Mitigation Strategies:
      • Developer:
        • Test the quality of the RNG output.
        • Supplement with a software-based entropy source.
        • Use well-established cryptographic libraries.
        • Use key derivation functions (KDFs).
      • User: (Limited direct mitigation)

Attack Surface: Bootloader Vulnerabilities

  • Description: Vulnerabilities in the ESP-IDF second-stage bootloader allowing attackers to bypass security features.
    • ESP-IDF Contribution: ESP-IDF provides and configures the second-stage bootloader.
    • Example: An attacker exploits a buffer overflow in the bootloader to execute arbitrary code.
    • Impact: Complete device compromise, bypassing of secure boot, malicious firmware installation.
    • Risk Severity: Critical
    • Mitigation Strategies:
      • Developer:
        • Keep the bootloader updated.
        • Ensure secure boot is properly configured and enabled.
        • Review bootloader configuration.
        • Implement robust input validation and error handling.
        • Use memory safety techniques.
        • Perform penetration testing.
      • User: (Limited direct mitigation)