Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
118 lines (87 loc) · 16.9 KB

mitigations.md

File metadata and controls

118 lines (87 loc) · 16.9 KB

Mitigation Strategies Analysis for openresty/lua-nginx-module

Mitigation Strategy: Input Validation and Sanitization within Lua Scripts

Description:

  1. Identify Lua Input Points: Specifically within your Lua scripts running in Nginx, locate all points where external data from Nginx requests (URI arguments, headers, body) is accessed using lua-nginx-module APIs like ngx.req.get_uri_args(), ngx.req.get_headers(), ngx.req.get_body_data().
  2. Lua-Specific Validation Rules: Define validation rules tailored to the data types and formats expected by your Lua logic. Consider the context of how this data will be used within Lua and in subsequent Nginx operations.
  3. Implement Validation in Lua: Use Lua's string manipulation and conditional logic directly within your scripts to validate input. Leverage Lua libraries designed for validation if needed, ensuring they are compatible with the Nginx Lua environment.
  4. Lua-Based Sanitization: Sanitize input within Lua before further processing or use in Nginx directives. For example, if Lua generates HTML, perform HTML escaping in Lua before passing it to ngx.say or other output functions.
  5. Lua Error Handling for Invalid Input: Implement error handling in Lua to gracefully reject requests with invalid input. Use ngx.status and ngx.say to return appropriate HTTP error codes and messages directly from Lua.

Threats Mitigated:

  • SQL Injection (High Severity): If Lua scripts construct SQL queries based on unsanitized request data obtained via lua-nginx-module APIs.
  • Command Injection (High Severity): If Lua scripts execute system commands using data from Nginx requests accessed through lua-nginx-module.
  • Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) (Medium to High Severity): If Lua scripts generate web content using unsanitized request data obtained via lua-nginx-module, leading to XSS vulnerabilities when served by Nginx.
  • Lua Injection (Medium Severity): If Lua scripts use functions like loadstring or dofile with unsanitized request data obtained via lua-nginx-module.
  • Path Traversal (Medium Severity): If Lua scripts handle file paths based on unsanitized request data obtained via lua-nginx-module and interact with the file system through Nginx or Lua file operations.

Impact:

  • SQL Injection: High risk reduction. Directly addresses SQL injection risks arising from Lua's interaction with request data.
  • Command Injection: High risk reduction. Directly addresses command injection risks arising from Lua's interaction with request data.
  • XSS: Medium to High risk reduction. Reduces XSS vulnerabilities by sanitizing data within the Lua context before output.
  • Lua Injection: High risk reduction. Prevents Lua injection by validating data used in dynamic Lua code execution.
  • Path Traversal: Medium risk reduction. Mitigates path traversal by validating file paths handled in Lua scripts.

Currently Implemented: Partially implemented in API Gateway Lua scripts (e.g., API key validation). Input validation using lua-nginx-module request APIs is present, but comprehensive sanitization within Lua scripts is lacking.

Missing Implementation: Comprehensive input sanitization needs to be implemented in all Lua scripts that process request data obtained through lua-nginx-module APIs. This includes scripts handling user-generated content, API requests, and database interactions within the Nginx Lua environment.

Mitigation Strategy: Secure Coding Practices Specific to Lua-Nginx Module

Description:

  1. Least Privilege in Lua-Nginx Context: Within your Lua scripts running in Nginx, adhere to the principle of least privilege. Only use necessary lua-nginx-module APIs and functionalities. Avoid granting Lua scripts unnecessary access to Nginx internals or system resources.
  2. Cautious Use of Potentially Insecure Lua Functions in Nginx: Be extremely cautious when using Lua functions like loadstring, dofile, and os.execute within your Lua scripts running in Nginx, especially when handling data originating from Nginx requests or external sources. If necessary, implement strict sandboxing and input validation within Lua before using these functions.
  3. Lua Error Handling in Nginx Context: Implement robust error handling in your Lua scripts using pcall and xpcall to catch errors gracefully within the Nginx environment. Use ngx.log to log errors securely without exposing sensitive information in Nginx responses.
  4. Modular Lua Code for Nginx: Structure your Lua code for Nginx into modular functions and libraries to improve readability, maintainability, and security within the Nginx Lua context. This facilitates code review and reduces the risk of vulnerabilities in complex Lua logic interacting with Nginx.
  5. Lua Code Reviews Focused on Nginx Integration: Conduct code reviews specifically for Lua scripts used with lua-nginx-module, focusing on secure usage of lua-nginx-module APIs, proper error handling within Nginx, and potential vulnerabilities arising from the Lua-Nginx integration.

Threats Mitigated:

  • Privilege Escalation (High Severity): If Lua scripts within Nginx are granted excessive privileges through lua-nginx-module or insecure coding, vulnerabilities could lead to privilege escalation within the Nginx worker process context.
  • Information Disclosure (Medium Severity): Poor error handling in Lua scripts running in Nginx can expose sensitive information in Nginx error logs or responses.
  • Application Instability (Medium Severity): Unhandled errors in Lua scripts within Nginx can lead to Nginx worker process crashes or instability.
  • General Vulnerabilities Related to Lua-Nginx Integration (Variable Severity): Poor coding practices in Lua scripts interacting with lua-nginx-module increase the likelihood of introducing vulnerabilities specific to this integration.

Impact:

  • Privilege Escalation: Medium to High risk reduction. Limits the potential impact of vulnerabilities by restricting Lua script privileges within the Nginx context.
  • Information Disclosure: Medium risk reduction. Prevents accidental exposure of sensitive information through Lua-related errors in Nginx.
  • Application Instability: Medium risk reduction. Improves Nginx application stability by handling errors gracefully in Lua scripts.
  • General Vulnerabilities Related to Lua-Nginx Integration: Medium risk reduction. Proactive secure coding practices reduce vulnerabilities specific to the Lua-Nginx module.

Currently Implemented: Partially implemented. Code reviews for Lua scripts are conducted, but security aspects specific to lua-nginx-module integration are not always the primary focus. Error handling in Lua scripts within Nginx is present but inconsistent.

Missing Implementation: Enforce secure coding guidelines specifically tailored to lua-nginx-module usage. Enhance code reviews to specifically address security concerns related to Lua-Nginx integration. Provide developer training on secure Lua coding practices within the Nginx environment.

Mitigation Strategy: Resource Management and Limits for Lua Scripts in Nginx

Description:

  1. Configure Nginx Lua Directives: Utilize Nginx directives specifically designed for lua-nginx-module resource control, such as lua_max_running_threads, lua_socket_log_errors, lua_package_cpath, and lua_code_cache. Set appropriate limits in your Nginx configuration to constrain Lua script resource usage.
  2. Implement Lua Timeouts for Nginx Operations: Within your Lua scripts running in Nginx, implement timeouts for operations that interact with Nginx or external resources (e.g., ngx.socket.tcp, ngx.location.capture). Use ngx.timer.at or similar mechanisms in Lua to prevent long-running Lua tasks from blocking Nginx worker processes.
  3. Monitor Lua Script Resources within Nginx: Implement monitoring of Lua script execution time, memory consumption, and error rates within the Nginx environment. Use Nginx logging and consider Lua-specific metrics exposed by lua-nginx-module to track resource usage and identify potential issues related to Lua scripts.
  4. Lua-Based Rate Limiting in Nginx: Implement rate limiting within Lua scripts for specific API endpoints or functionalities handled by Lua in Nginx. This can complement Nginx's limit_req module and allow for more fine-grained rate limiting logic within Lua.

Threats Mitigated:

  • Denial of Service (DoS) (High Severity): Malicious or inefficient Lua scripts running within Nginx can consume excessive Nginx worker process resources (CPU, memory, connections), leading to DoS of the Nginx application.
  • Resource Exhaustion in Nginx (Medium Severity): Resource leaks or poorly performing Lua code within Nginx can gradually exhaust Nginx server resources, impacting the overall performance and availability of the Nginx application.
  • Performance Degradation of Nginx (Medium Severity): Uncontrolled resource usage by Lua scripts can degrade the performance of the entire Nginx instance, affecting all applications served by Nginx.

Impact:

  • DoS: High risk reduction. Nginx Lua resource limits and timeouts effectively prevent DoS attacks caused by resource-intensive Lua scripts within Nginx.
  • Resource Exhaustion in Nginx: Medium to High risk reduction. Monitoring and limits help identify and prevent resource leaks and inefficient Lua code running in Nginx.
  • Performance Degradation of Nginx: Medium risk reduction. Resource management improves the overall performance and stability of the Nginx instance when using Lua scripts.

Currently Implemented: Partially implemented. lua_max_running_threads and basic Nginx logging are configured. Timeouts within Lua scripts for Nginx operations are not consistently implemented. Dedicated Lua resource monitoring within Nginx is missing.

Missing Implementation: Implement timeouts in all Lua scripts performing Nginx operations or potentially long-running tasks. Set up dedicated monitoring for Lua script resource usage within Nginx (CPU, memory, execution time, Lua errors). Implement Lua-based rate limiting for critical API endpoints handled by Lua in Nginx.

Mitigation Strategy: Secure Configuration of Lua-Nginx Module Directives

Description:

  1. Restrict File System Access for Lua in Nginx Configuration: Carefully configure Nginx directives related to file system access for Lua scripts, such as lua_package_path and lua_package_cpath. Limit the directories accessible to Lua scripts running within Nginx to only those strictly necessary. Use appropriate file permissions to further restrict access.
  2. Secure Secrets Management in Nginx Lua Context: Avoid hardcoding sensitive information (API keys, database credentials, etc.) directly in Lua code or Nginx configuration files. Utilize Nginx variables populated from secure sources (e.g., environment variables, external secrets management systems) and access them within Lua scripts using ngx.var.
  3. Principle of Least Privilege for Lua-Nginx Directives: Thoroughly review and understand the security implications of all lua-nginx-module directives used in your Nginx configuration. Configure them according to the principle of least privilege, enabling only the necessary features and functionalities for your Lua scripts. Disable any unnecessary Lua modules or features in Nginx.
  4. Regular Audits of Nginx Lua Configuration: Conduct regular security audits of your Nginx and lua-nginx-module configurations to identify and rectify any misconfigurations or security weaknesses related to Lua script execution within Nginx.

Threats Mitigated:

  • Information Disclosure (Medium to High Severity): Exposing sensitive information in Nginx configuration files or Lua code accessible within the Nginx environment.
  • Unauthorized File System Access (Medium Severity): Misconfigured file permissions or overly permissive lua_package_path/lua_package_cpath directives can allow Lua scripts to access sensitive files within the Nginx server.
  • Configuration Errors Leading to Vulnerabilities (Variable Severity): Misconfigurations of lua-nginx-module directives can introduce various vulnerabilities or weaken the security posture of the Nginx application.

Impact:

  • Information Disclosure: High risk reduction. Secure secrets management in Nginx and Lua effectively prevents accidental exposure of sensitive information.
  • Unauthorized File System Access: Medium risk reduction. Restricting file system access for Lua scripts within Nginx limits the potential impact of vulnerabilities.
  • Configuration Errors Leading to Vulnerabilities: Medium risk reduction. Regular audits help identify and correct misconfigurations in Nginx Lua setup.

Currently Implemented: Partially implemented. Secrets are managed using environment variables for some services accessed by Lua scripts in Nginx. File system permissions are generally restrictive, but lua_package_path/lua_package_cpath configurations could be further tightened.

Missing Implementation: Implement a centralized secrets management solution for all sensitive credentials used by Lua scripts in Nginx. Conduct a dedicated security audit of Nginx and lua-nginx-module configurations, specifically focusing on minimizing file system access and applying the principle of least privilege to Lua-related directives. Automate configuration audits.

Mitigation Strategy: LuaJIT Specific Security Management in Nginx Context

Description:

  1. Maintain Up-to-Date LuaJIT in Nginx Environment: Ensure that the LuaJIT version used by your Nginx instance is kept updated to the latest stable version. Regularly check for LuaJIT updates and apply them to benefit from security fixes and performance improvements relevant to the Nginx Lua environment.
  2. Monitor LuaJIT Security Advisories for Nginx Deployments: Subscribe to LuaJIT security mailing lists or monitor security advisory channels to stay informed about potential LuaJIT vulnerabilities that could affect your Nginx deployments using lua-nginx-module. Apply necessary patches or workarounds promptly.
  3. Control JIT Compilation in Nginx Lua Scripts (If Necessary): In high-risk contexts within your Nginx application or when dealing with highly untrusted input processed by Lua scripts, consider disabling JIT compilation for specific Lua scripts or modules if necessary. This can be done using LuaJIT's API or environment variables within the Nginx Lua context, although it will impact performance. Evaluate the trade-off between security and performance carefully.
  4. Thorough Testing of Lua Code with LuaJIT in Nginx: Test your Lua code thoroughly with LuaJIT in a production-like Nginx environment to identify any unexpected behavior or vulnerabilities that might be introduced by the JIT compiler specifically within the Nginx Lua context. Pay close attention to edge cases and boundary conditions in your Lua scripts running under LuaJIT in Nginx.

Threats Mitigated:

  • LuaJIT Specific Vulnerabilities in Nginx (Variable Severity): Vulnerabilities that are specific to the LuaJIT JIT compiler or runtime environment and could affect Nginx applications using lua-nginx-module.
  • JIT-Related Bugs in Nginx Lua Scripts (Variable Severity): Bugs in the LuaJIT compiler that could manifest as unexpected behavior or security vulnerabilities specifically when Lua scripts are executed within Nginx using LuaJIT.

Impact:

  • LuaJIT Specific Vulnerabilities in Nginx: High risk reduction. Keeping LuaJIT updated and monitoring advisories effectively mitigates known LuaJIT vulnerabilities in the Nginx context.
  • JIT-Related Bugs in Nginx Lua Scripts: Medium risk reduction. Thorough testing helps identify and mitigate potential JIT-related bugs in Lua scripts running under Nginx. Disabling JIT in critical sections provides a fallback option for high-risk scenarios within Nginx.

Currently Implemented: Partially implemented. LuaJIT is generally kept updated in the Nginx environment, but a formal process for monitoring LuaJIT security advisories and applying patches specifically for Nginx deployments is missing. JIT compilation control is not currently utilized.

Missing Implementation: Implement a dedicated process for actively monitoring LuaJIT security advisories and applying updates promptly to the Nginx environment. Document procedures for disabling JIT compilation in specific Nginx Lua scenarios if needed. Include LuaJIT-specific testing as part of the QA process for Nginx Lua scripts.