Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
109 lines (89 loc) · 9.04 KB

mitigations.md

File metadata and controls

109 lines (89 loc) · 9.04 KB

Mitigation Strategies Analysis for redis/hiredis

Mitigation Strategy: Parameterized Commands (Using redisCommandArgv)

  • Description:

    1. Identify redisCommand and redisvCommand calls: Locate all instances in your code where you're using redisCommand or redisvCommand to send commands to Redis. These functions are vulnerable when used with string concatenation and user input.
    2. Replace with redisCommandArgv: Replace every instance of redisCommand and redisvCommand with redisCommandArgv. This is the core of the mitigation.
    3. Restructure Arguments: Instead of a single formatted command string, prepare two arrays:
      • const char* argv[]: An array of C-style strings, where each element is a separate part of the Redis command (e.g., command name, key, value).
      • size_t argvlen[]: An array of size_t values, where each element corresponds to the length (in bytes) of the string at the same index in argv.
    4. Call redisCommandArgv: Use the following function signature: 
      redisReply *redisCommandArgv(redisContext *c, int argc, const char **argv, const size_t *argvlen);
      • c: Your redisContext pointer.
      • argc: The number of elements in the argv and argvlen arrays.
      • argv: The array of command argument strings.
      • argvlen: The array of argument string lengths.
    5. Example: 
      // Vulnerable:
char command[256];
snprintf(command, sizeof(command), "SET %s %s", key, value); // DANGEROUS!
redisReply *reply = redisCommand(context, command);

// Secure (using redisCommandArgv):
const char *argv[] = {"SET", key, value};
size_t argvlen[] = {3, strlen(key), strlen(value)};
redisReply *reply = redisCommandArgv(context, 3, argv, argvlen);
    6. Thorough Testing: Rigorously test all code paths that use redisCommandArgv to ensure correct functionality and that no regressions have been introduced.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Redis Command Injection (Critical): This is the primary threat mitigated. redisCommandArgv ensures that arguments are properly escaped by hiredis before being sent to the Redis server, preventing attackers from injecting arbitrary commands.
    • Data Modification/Deletion (High): By preventing command injection, you prevent unauthorized modification or deletion of data.
    • Data Exfiltration (High): Prevents attackers from using injected commands to read sensitive data.
    • Server Compromise (Critical): If CONFIG commands are enabled, injection could lead to server compromise. Parameterization prevents this.

  • Impact:

    • Redis Command Injection: Risk reduced to near zero. This is the core purpose of using parameterized commands.
    • Data Modification/Deletion: Risk significantly reduced.
    • Data Exfiltration: Risk significantly reduced.
    • Server Compromise: Risk significantly reduced.

  • Currently Implemented: Partially implemented. Used in user_data.c for user profile management.

  • Missing Implementation: Missing in session_management.c (session token handling) and cache.c (cache management).

Mitigation Strategy: Robust hiredis Error Handling

  • Description:

    1. redisContext Check: Immediately after calling redisConnect or redisConnectWithTimeout, check if the returned redisContext* is NULL. If it is, an error occurred during connection.
      • Access context->err (integer error code) and context->errstr (error description string) to diagnose the problem.
      • Handle the error appropriately (log, retry, inform the user, etc.).
    2. redisReply Check: After every call to a command execution function (e.g., redisCommand, redisCommandArgv, redisAppendCommand, redisGetReply), check if the returned redisReply* is NULL. A NULL reply indicates a communication error with the Redis server.
      • Again, check context->err and context->errstr for details.
      • Handle the error appropriately.
    3. reply->type Check: If the redisReply* is not NULL, check the reply->type field. This tells you the type of reply received from Redis. Pay special attention to:
      • REDIS_REPLY_ERROR: Indicates that the Redis server returned an error. The error message is in reply->str. Handle this explicitly (log, retry, return an error, etc.).
      • Other reply types (REDIS_REPLY_STRING, REDIS_REPLY_INTEGER, etc.) should be handled according to your application's logic.
    4. redisSetTimeout: Use the redisSetTimeout function to set a timeout for Redis operations: 
      struct timeval timeout = { 1, 500000 }; // 1.5 seconds
redisSetTimeout(context, timeout);
      This prevents your application from blocking indefinitely if the Redis server becomes unresponsive.
    5. Resource Management (freeReplyObject, redisFree):
      • freeReplyObject(reply): Always call freeReplyObject(reply) after you are finished processing a redisReply*. Failure to do so results in memory leaks.
      • redisFree(context): Always call redisFree(context) when you are finished with a redisContext* (i.e., when you're done with the connection). This frees all resources associated with the connection.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Application Crashes (Medium): Prevents crashes caused by unhandled hiredis errors (e.g., dereferencing a NULL redisReply*).
    • Data Inconsistency (High): Prevents the application from continuing in an inconsistent state after a Redis error.
    • Denial of Service (Medium): Timeouts (via redisSetTimeout) prevent the application from hanging indefinitely.
    • Information Leakage (Low): Proper error handling can prevent sensitive information from being exposed in error messages (though this is more about how you handle the errors).

  • Impact:

    • Application Crashes: High impact; significantly reduces crashes.
    • Data Inconsistency: High impact; helps maintain data integrity.
    • Denial of Service: Moderate impact; improves resilience.
    • Information Leakage: Low impact; minor contribution to preventing information leaks.

  • Currently Implemented: Basic NULL checks for redisReply in some functions, but inconsistent and incomplete. freeReplyObject and redisFree are generally used, but potential edge cases exist.

  • Missing Implementation: Comprehensive checks of reply->type, consistent use of context->err and context->errstr, implementation of redisSetTimeout, and thorough auditing for correct resource management are missing in many parts of the application.

Mitigation Strategy: Library Updates (of hiredis itself)

  • Description:

    1. Dependency Management: Ideally, use a C/C++ dependency manager (e.g., vcpkg, Conan, or your system's package manager) to manage the hiredis library. This simplifies updates.
    2. Version Monitoring: Regularly check for new releases of hiredis. The best way to do this is to monitor the official hiredis GitHub repository: https://github.com/redis/hiredis. Look for new tags and releases.
    3. Security Advisories: While hiredis doesn't have a dedicated security advisory system, closely examine the release notes and commit history for any mentions of security fixes or vulnerability patches.
    4. Update Process: When a new version is available (especially if it addresses security concerns):
      • Review the release notes and changelog carefully.
      • Update the hiredis library in your development environment using your dependency manager (or manually, if necessary).
      • Rebuild your application.
      • Thoroughly test your application with the updated library to ensure no regressions were introduced.
      • Deploy the updated application to your production environment.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Known Vulnerabilities in hiredis (Variable Severity): This directly addresses vulnerabilities that have been discovered and patched in newer versions of the hiredis library itself. The severity depends on the specific vulnerability.

  • Impact:

    • Known Vulnerabilities: Variable impact, depending on the nature of the vulnerability. Regular updates are crucial for minimizing the window of exposure to known exploits.

  • Currently Implemented: Not implemented. The project uses a static, outdated version of hiredis (v1.0.0) that was manually included.

  • Missing Implementation: A dependency management system is not in place. There's no process for checking for or applying hiredis updates. The library is likely vulnerable to known issues.