Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
226 lines (195 loc) · 19.3 KB

attack-tree.md

File metadata and controls

226 lines (195 loc) · 19.3 KB

Attack Tree Analysis for taosdata/tdengine

Objective: Compromise Application Data and Availability via TDengine Exploitation

Attack Tree Visualization

└── Compromise Application Using TDengine [CRITICAL NODE] ├── [AND] Exploit TDengine Software Vulnerabilities [CRITICAL NODE] │ ├── [OR] Remote Code Execution (RCE) in taosd [CRITICAL NODE, HIGH-RISK PATH] │ │ └── Exploit Buffer Overflow/Memory Corruption for RCE [HIGH-RISK PATH] │ ├── [OR] SQL/TSQL Injection (if applicable in TDengine's context) [HIGH-RISK PATH] │ │ └── Inject Malicious TSQL via Application Input [HIGH-RISK PATH] │ │ └── Exploit Lack of Parameterized Queries/Input Sanitization in Application [HIGH-RISK PATH] │ ├── [OR] Authentication/Authorization Bypass in taosd [HIGH-RISK PATH] │ │ ├── Exploit Vulnerabilities in Authentication Mechanisms [HIGH-RISK PATH] │ │ │ ├── Exploit Logic Flaws in Authentication Handlers [HIGH-RISK PATH] │ │ ├── Exploit Vulnerabilities in Authorization Mechanisms [HIGH-RISK PATH] │ │ │ ├── Privilege Escalation via Authorization Bypass [HIGH-RISK PATH] │ │ │ ├── Access Data Without Proper Permissions [HIGH-RISK PATH] │ └── [OR] Data Exfiltration via Direct TDengine Access [CRITICAL NODE, HIGH-RISK PATH] │ └── [AND] Gain Unauthorized Access to TDengine [CRITICAL NODE, HIGH-RISK PATH] │ ├── [OR] Exploit Authentication Weaknesses (as above) [HIGH-RISK PATH] │ │ └── Exploit Logic Flaws in Authentication Handlers [HIGH-RISK PATH] (Redundant, but included for path completeness) │ ├── [OR] Exploit Network Exposure of TDengine [HIGH-RISK PATH] │ │ └── Access Exposed taosd Port (6030 by default) [HIGH-RISK PATH] │ │ └── Exploit Lack of Firewall or Network Segmentation [HIGH-RISK PATH] │ └── [OR] Compromise TDengine Credentials [HIGH-RISK PATH] │ ├── [OR] Weak Passwords [HIGH-RISK PATH] │ ├── [OR] Credential Stuffing/Brute-force (if exposed) [HIGH-RISK PATH] │ ├── [OR] Phishing/Social Engineering for Credentials [HIGH-RISK PATH] │ └── [OR] Compromise Application Server to Steal Credentials [HIGH-RISK PATH] ├── [AND] Abuse TDengine Features/Misconfigurations │ ├── [OR] Exploit Default Configurations [HIGH-RISK PATH] │ │ └── Use Default Ports/Credentials if not changed [HIGH-RISK PATH] │ ├── [OR] Misconfigured Access Controls [HIGH-RISK PATH] │ │ └── Exploit Overly Permissive User Permissions [HIGH-RISK PATH] │ │ └── Gain Access to Sensitive Data or Functions [HIGH-RISK PATH] │ │ └── Exploit Lack of Role-Based Access Control (RBAC) if not implemented properly [HIGH-RISK PATH] └── [AND] Indirect Exploitation via Client Libraries/Integrations └── [OR] Man-in-the-Middle (MitM) Attacks on Client-Server Communication (if not properly secured) [HIGH-RISK PATH] └── Intercept and Modify Communication between Application and TDengine [HIGH-RISK PATH] └── Downgrade Encryption or Exploit Lack of Encryption (if applicable and configurable) [HIGH-RISK PATH]

Attack Tree Path: 1. Compromise Application Using TDengine [CRITICAL NODE]:

  • Attack Vector: This is the overarching goal. Success means the attacker has achieved a significant compromise of the application by exploiting TDengine.
  • Impact: Critical - Full compromise of application data and availability.
  • Likelihood: Varies, but achievable through multiple high-risk paths detailed below.
  • Effort: Varies significantly depending on the chosen path.
  • Skill Level: Varies significantly depending on the chosen path.
  • Detection Difficulty: Varies significantly depending on the chosen path.

Attack Tree Path: 2. Exploit TDengine Software Vulnerabilities [CRITICAL NODE]:

  • Attack Vector: Targeting vulnerabilities within the TDengine software itself (specifically taosd).

  • Impact: High to Critical - Can lead to RCE, DoS, Data Breach, depending on the vulnerability.

  • Likelihood: Medium - Software vulnerabilities are a constant threat, especially in complex systems.

  • Effort: Medium to High - Requires vulnerability research, exploit development, or leveraging existing exploits.

  • Skill Level: Medium to High - Requires reverse engineering, exploit development skills.

  • Detection Difficulty: Hard - Exploits can be subtle and difficult to detect without deep system monitoring and security tools.

    • 2.1. Remote Code Execution (RCE) in taosd [CRITICAL NODE, HIGH-RISK PATH]:

      • Attack Vector: Exploiting vulnerabilities (like Buffer Overflows) to execute arbitrary code on the server running taosd.
      • Impact: Critical - Full system compromise, complete control over TDengine and potentially the application server.
      • Likelihood: Low - RCE exploits are harder to develop and less frequent in mature software, but extremely dangerous if successful.
      • Effort: High - Requires deep exploit development expertise.
      • Skill Level: High - Exploit Developer.
      • Detection Difficulty: Hard - Exploit execution can be subtle, post-exploitation activity is more detectable.

    • 2.2. SQL/TSQL Injection (if applicable in TDengine's context) [HIGH-RISK PATH]:

      • Attack Vector: Injecting malicious TSQL code through application inputs due to lack of parameterized queries or input sanitization.
      • Impact: Medium-High - Data breach, data manipulation, potentially DoS.
      • Likelihood: Medium - Common web application vulnerability, depends on application development practices.
      • Effort: Low - Automated tools and readily available techniques.
      • Skill Level: Low - Basic Scripting/Web App knowledge.
      • Detection Difficulty: Medium - Can be detected with WAFs, input validation logging, query analysis.

    • 2.3. Authentication/Authorization Bypass in taosd [HIGH-RISK PATH]:

      • Attack Vector: Exploiting flaws in TDengine's authentication or authorization mechanisms to gain unauthorized access or escalate privileges.

      • Impact: High - Unauthorized access to data, potential privilege escalation to administrative roles.

      • Likelihood: Low - Logic flaws are harder to find, but misconfigurations or subtle vulnerabilities can exist.

      • Effort: Medium - Requires understanding of authentication/authorization logic and potential flaws.

      • Skill Level: Medium - Network/System Admin, some reverse engineering helpful.

      • Detection Difficulty: Medium - May require deeper log analysis and understanding of authentication/authorization flow.

      • 2.3.1. Exploit Logic Flaws in Authentication Handlers [HIGH-RISK PATH]: (Specific case of 2.3)

        • Attack Vector: Finding and exploiting logical errors in how TDengine handles authentication requests.
        • Impact: High - Unauthorized access, privilege escalation.
        • Likelihood: Low - Logic flaws are harder to find but possible.
        • Effort: Medium - Requires reverse engineering and understanding of authentication logic.
        • Skill Level: Medium - Network/System Admin, some reverse engineering.
        • Detection Difficulty: Medium - May require deeper log analysis and understanding of authentication flow.

      • 2.3.2. Privilege Escalation via Authorization Bypass [HIGH-RISK PATH]: (Specific case of 2.3)

        • Attack Vector: Bypassing authorization checks to gain higher privileges than intended.
        • Impact: High - Gain administrative privileges within TDengine.
        • Likelihood: Low - Authorization flaws are less common than authentication bypass, but possible.
        • Effort: Medium - Requires understanding of authorization model and potential flaws.
        • Skill Level: Medium - Network/System Admin, understanding of RBAC.
        • Detection Difficulty: Medium - Requires auditing of access logs and permission configurations.

      • 2.3.3. Access Data Without Proper Permissions [HIGH-RISK PATH]: (Specific case of 2.3)

        • Attack Vector: Exploiting misconfigurations or lack of proper authorization to access data that should be restricted.
        • Impact: Medium - Data breach - access to sensitive data.
        • Likelihood: Medium - Misconfigurations are common, overly permissive roles.
        • Effort: Low - Simple exploration of accessible data.
        • Skill Level: Low - Basic database user.
        • Detection Difficulty: Medium - Requires monitoring of data access patterns and permission audits.

Attack Tree Path: 3. Data Exfiltration via Direct TDengine Access [CRITICAL NODE, HIGH-RISK PATH]:

  • Attack Vector: Gaining unauthorized direct access to the TDengine server and exfiltrating data.

  • Impact: High - Data Breach, loss of confidential information.

  • Likelihood: Medium - Depends on network security and credential management.

  • Effort: Low to Medium - If access is gained, data exfiltration is relatively straightforward.

  • Skill Level: Low to Medium - Basic database and network knowledge.

  • Detection Difficulty: Medium to Hard - Depends on logging and monitoring of database access and network traffic.

    • 3.1. Gain Unauthorized Access to TDengine [CRITICAL NODE, HIGH-RISK PATH]:

      • Attack Vector: The prerequisite for data exfiltration. Achieving unauthorized access to TDengine.

      • Impact: High - Enables data exfiltration and other malicious activities.

      • Likelihood: Medium - Achievable through various paths like network exposure, credential compromise, authentication bypass.

      • Effort: Varies depending on the chosen path.

      • Skill Level: Varies depending on the chosen path.

      • Detection Difficulty: Varies depending on the chosen path.

      • 3.1.1. Exploit Network Exposure of TDengine [HIGH-RISK PATH]:

        • Attack Vector: TDengine port (default 6030) is directly accessible from the internet or untrusted networks due to lack of firewall or network segmentation.
        • Impact: High - Direct access to database, data breach.
        • Likelihood: Medium - Common misconfiguration in cloud/on-premise deployments.
        • Effort: Low - Network scanning tools.
        • Skill Level: Low - Basic Network knowledge.
        • Detection Difficulty: Easy - Network scans, firewall logs.

      • 3.1.2. Compromise TDengine Credentials [HIGH-RISK PATH]:

        • Attack Vector: Obtaining valid TDengine credentials through various means.

        • Impact: High - Direct access to database, data breach.

        • Likelihood: Medium - Weak passwords, credential reuse, phishing are common attack vectors.

        • Effort: Low to Medium - Password cracking, credential stuffing, phishing kits.

        • Skill Level: Low to Medium - Basic password cracking, social engineering skills.

        • Detection Difficulty: Medium to Hard - Depends on password policies, logging, and user awareness.

        • 3.1.2.1. Weak Passwords [HIGH-RISK PATH]: (Specific case of 3.1.2)

          • Attack Vector: Using easily guessable or cracked passwords for TDengine accounts.
          • Impact: High - Direct access to database, data breach.
          • Likelihood: Medium - Weak passwords are still prevalent.
          • Effort: Low-Medium - Password cracking tools.
          • Skill Level: Low-Medium - Basic password cracking knowledge.
          • Detection Difficulty: Medium - Failed login attempts, password complexity monitoring.

        • 3.1.2.2. Credential Stuffing/Brute-force (if exposed) [HIGH-RISK PATH]: (Specific case of 3.1.2)

          • Attack Vector: Using lists of compromised credentials or brute-forcing login attempts to gain access.
          • Impact: High - Direct access to database, data breach.
          • Likelihood: Low-Medium - Depends on exposure and rate limiting.
          • Effort: Low-Medium - Automated tools, readily available lists.
          • Skill Level: Low-Medium - Basic scripting, understanding of credential stuffing.
          • Detection Difficulty: Medium - Failed login attempts, anomaly detection in login patterns.

        • 3.1.2.3. Phishing/Social Engineering for Credentials [HIGH-RISK PATH]: (Specific case of 3.1.2)

          • Attack Vector: Tricking users into revealing their TDengine credentials through phishing emails or social engineering tactics.
          • Impact: High - Direct access to database, data breach.
          • Likelihood: Low-Medium - Depends on organization's security awareness.
          • Effort: Low-Medium - Phishing kits, social engineering techniques.
          • Skill Level: Low-Medium - Social engineering skills, basic phishing knowledge.
          • Detection Difficulty: Hard - Difficult to detect at technical level, relies on user awareness and reporting.

        • 3.1.2.4. Compromise Application Server to Steal Credentials [HIGH-RISK PATH]: (Specific case of 3.1.2)

          • Attack Vector: Compromising the application server to steal stored TDengine credentials (if application stores them insecurely or they are accessible).
          • Impact: High - Direct access to database, data breach, potential application compromise.
          • Likelihood: Low-Medium - If application server is well-secured, lower likelihood.
          • Effort: Medium - Depends on application server security, could be complex or simple.
          • Skill Level: Medium-High - Application security knowledge, server exploitation skills.
          • Detection Difficulty: Medium-Hard - Requires monitoring of application server and database access patterns.

Attack Tree Path: 4. Abuse TDengine Features/Misconfigurations:

  • 4.1. Exploit Default Configurations [HIGH-RISK PATH]:

    • Attack Vector: Leveraging default configurations that are insecure, such as default ports or credentials (if any exist and are not changed).
    • Impact: Medium-High - Unauthorized access, potential data breach.
    • Likelihood: Low - Default credentials should be changed, but ports might be overlooked.
    • Effort: Low - Checking documentation, network scanning.
    • Skill Level: Low - Basic knowledge.
    • Detection Difficulty: Medium - If default port is used, network scans can detect. Default credentials harder to detect without specific logging.

  • 4.2. Misconfigured Access Controls [HIGH-RISK PATH]:

    • Attack Vector: Exploiting overly permissive user permissions or lack of proper RBAC to gain unauthorized access to data or functions.

    • Impact: Medium - Unauthorized data access, potential data breach, privilege escalation.

    • Likelihood: Medium - Common misconfiguration, especially in complex systems.

    • Effort: Low to Medium - Exploring accessible data and functions, analyzing permission structure.

    • Skill Level: Low to Medium - Basic database user, understanding of RBAC concepts.

    • Detection Difficulty: Medium - Requires regular permission audits and monitoring of data access.

    • 4.2.1. Exploit Overly Permissive User Permissions [HIGH-RISK PATH]: (Specific case of 4.2)

      • Attack Vector: Users or roles have more permissions than necessary, allowing access to sensitive data or functions.
      • Impact: Medium - Unauthorized data access, potential data breach.
      • Likelihood: Medium - Common misconfiguration, especially in complex systems.
      • Effort: Low - Exploring accessible data and functions.
      • Skill Level: Low - Basic database user.
      • Detection Difficulty: Medium - Requires regular permission audits and monitoring of data access.

    • 4.2.2. Exploit Lack of Role-Based Access Control (RBAC) if not implemented properly [HIGH-RISK PATH]: (Specific case of 4.2)

      • Attack Vector: RBAC is not implemented effectively, leading to gaps in access control and potential privilege escalation.
      • Impact: Medium - Unauthorized data access, potential privilege escalation.
      • Likelihood: Medium - If RBAC is not properly planned and implemented, gaps can exist.
      • Effort: Medium - Analyzing permission structure and identifying weaknesses.
      • Skill Level: Medium - Understanding of RBAC concepts.
      • Detection Difficulty: Medium - Requires RBAC policy audits and monitoring of role assignments.

Attack Tree Path: 5. Indirect Exploitation via Client Libraries/Integrations:

  • 5.1. Man-in-the-Middle (MitM) Attacks on Client-Server Communication (if not properly secured) [HIGH-RISK PATH]:

    • Attack Vector: Intercepting and potentially modifying communication between the application and TDengine if encryption (TLS/SSL) is not properly implemented or is downgraded.

    • Impact: Medium - Data interception, data manipulation.

    • Likelihood: Low - If TLS/SSL is enforced, MitM is harder. Depends on configuration and strength of encryption.

    • Effort: Medium - Requires network access and MitM tools.

    • Skill Level: Medium - Network knowledge, MitM techniques.

    • Detection Difficulty: Medium - Network traffic analysis, certificate pinning can help.

    • 5.1.1. Downgrade Encryption or Exploit Lack of Encryption (if applicable and configurable) [HIGH-RISK PATH]: (Specific case of 5.1)

      • Attack Vector: Forcing a downgrade to weaker encryption or exploiting the lack of encryption to intercept communication.
      • Impact: Medium - Data interception, data manipulation.
      • Likelihood: Low - Depends on encryption configuration and protocol negotiation.
      • Effort: Medium - Requires network access and MitM tools.
      • Skill Level: Medium - Network knowledge, MitM techniques.
      • Detection Difficulty: Medium - Network traffic analysis, monitoring encryption protocols.