Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
78 lines (67 loc) · 7.14 KB

threat-modeling.md

File metadata and controls

78 lines (67 loc) · 7.14 KB

Threat Model Analysis for twitter/twemproxy

Threat: Backend Server Spoofing

  • Description: An attacker manipulates DNS resolution or network routing to make Twemproxy connect to a malicious server instead of the legitimate backend (Redis/Memcached). The attacker could achieve this through ARP spoofing, DNS cache poisoning, or compromising a service discovery system. Twemproxy's lack of built-in backend authentication makes it vulnerable.
    • Impact:
      • Data theft: The attacker can read all data intended for the real backend.
      • Data modification: The attacker can alter data before it reaches the application.
      • Data fabrication: The attacker can inject false data into the application.
      • Denial of Service: The attacker can prevent the application from accessing the backend data.
    • Twemproxy Component Affected: Configuration parsing (conf.c, related functions that handle server address resolution), connection establishment logic (functions within nc_connection.c that handle connecting to backend servers).
    • Risk Severity: Critical
    • Mitigation Strategies:
      • Static Configuration: Use a static, hardcoded list of backend server IP addresses in the Twemproxy configuration file. Avoid dynamic configuration updates if possible.
      • Network Segmentation: Place Twemproxy and backend servers in a dedicated, isolated network segment with strict firewall rules.
      • IP Whitelisting: Configure firewall rules to allow Twemproxy to connect only to the specific IP addresses of the backend servers.
      • mTLS (If Supported/Modified): Ideally, use mutual TLS (mTLS) between Twemproxy and the backend servers. This requires modifications to Twemproxy or a wrapper, as it's not a standard feature.
      • Secure Service Discovery: If using dynamic configuration, ensure the service discovery mechanism is highly secure (e.g., using strong authentication, encryption, and integrity checks).

Threat: Configuration File Tampering

  • Description: An attacker gains unauthorized access to the Twemproxy server and modifies the nutcracker.yml (or equivalent) configuration file. They could change server addresses, sharding rules, timeouts, or other settings, directly impacting Twemproxy's behavior.
    • Impact:
      • Redirection of traffic to malicious servers.
      • Disruption of sharding, leading to data inconsistency or loss.
      • Denial of service by setting inappropriate timeouts or resource limits.
      • Exposure of sensitive configuration details.
    • Twemproxy Component Affected: Configuration file parsing (conf.c and related functions).
    • Risk Severity: Critical
    • Mitigation Strategies:
      • File Integrity Monitoring (FIM): Use a FIM tool to monitor the configuration file for changes and alert on any modifications.
      • Secure Configuration Management: Use a configuration management system (Ansible, Chef, Puppet, etc.) to manage the configuration and ensure its integrity.
      • Read-Only Mount: Mount the configuration file as read-only to prevent modifications.
      • Principle of Least Privilege: Run Twemproxy as a non-root user with minimal permissions.
      • Regular Audits: Regularly audit the configuration file for unauthorized changes.

Threat: Denial of Service (DoS) - Twemproxy Overload

  • Description: An attacker floods Twemproxy with a large number of connections or requests, exhausting its resources (CPU, memory, file descriptors). This directly targets Twemproxy's ability to handle connections and process requests.
    • Impact:
      • Application unavailability: Legitimate clients cannot connect to the application.
      • Potential server instability.
    • Twemproxy Component Affected: Connection handling (nc_connection.c), request processing (nc_request.c), and overall resource management.
    • Risk Severity: High
    • Mitigation Strategies:
      • Resource Limits: Configure Twemproxy with appropriate resource limits (e.g., max_connections, timeouts) in the configuration file.
      • Rate Limiting (External): Implement rate limiting in front of Twemproxy using a firewall, load balancer, or reverse proxy.
      • Connection Timeouts: Configure appropriate connection timeouts in Twemproxy to prevent slow clients from tying up resources.

Threat: Denial of Service (DoS) - Backend Amplification

  • Description: An attacker sends specially crafted requests to Twemproxy (e.g., large multiget in Memcached) that Twemproxy then forwards to the backend, amplifying the attack. This leverages Twemproxy's request forwarding behavior.
    • Impact:
      • Backend server overload: The backend servers become unavailable, impacting the application.
      • Potential resource exhaustion on the backend servers.
    • Twemproxy Component Affected: Request parsing and forwarding logic (particularly related to multiget handling in nc_request.c and nc_memcache.c).
    • Risk Severity: High
    • Mitigation Strategies:
      • Application-Level Limits: The application should limit the number of keys allowed in a multiget request before sending it to Twemproxy. This is the most effective mitigation.
      • Twemproxy Configuration (Limited): Twemproxy has limited built-in mechanisms to control this; application-level control is crucial.
      • Backend Monitoring: Monitor the backend servers for signs of overload.

Threat: Code Execution Vulnerability (Hypothetical)

  • Description: A buffer overflow, format string vulnerability, or other code execution vulnerability exists in Twemproxy (though less likely in a mature project, it's still a possibility). An attacker exploits this vulnerability to gain control of the Twemproxy process. This is a direct vulnerability within Twemproxy's code.
    • Impact:
      • Complete system compromise: The attacker could gain full control of the Twemproxy server.
      • Data theft, modification, or deletion.
      • Use of the server for further attacks.
    • Twemproxy Component Affected: Potentially any part of the codebase, depending on the specific vulnerability.
    • Risk Severity: Critical
    • Mitigation Strategies:
      • Run as Non-Root: Run Twemproxy as a non-root user with limited privileges.
      • Regular Updates: Keep Twemproxy and its dependencies up to date to patch any discovered vulnerabilities.
      • Vulnerability Scanning: Regularly scan the Twemproxy server for vulnerabilities.
      • Security Hardening: Apply security hardening best practices to the server.
      • Code Audits (For Developers): Conduct regular code audits to identify and fix potential vulnerabilities.