Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
167 lines (126 loc) · 12.5 KB

mitigations.md

File metadata and controls

167 lines (126 loc) · 12.5 KB

Mitigation Strategies Analysis for valkey-io/valkey

Mitigation Strategy: Rigorous Code Review of Authentication/Authorization Changes (Valkey-Specific)

1. Mitigation Strategy: Rigorous Code Review of Authentication/Authorization Changes (Valkey-Specific)

  • Description:

    1. Identify Valkey-Specific Changes: Use git diff (or similar) to compare Valkey's authentication/authorization code (e.g., AUTH command, ACL handling) against the exact Redis version it forked from. Isolate only Valkey's modifications.
    2. Focus on Deviations: Concentrate review on differences from Redis. Any added, modified, or (critically) removed code related to security is high priority.
    3. Valkey-Specific Features: Thoroughly review any new authentication/authorization features introduced by Valkey (e.g., new commands, configuration options, user roles).
    4. Manual Review (Security Expertise): Two+ developers with security expertise independently review the identified Valkey-specific code. Look for:
      • Logic errors in Valkey's modifications.
      • Bypasses specific to Valkey's implementation.
      • Privilege escalation within Valkey's new features.
      • Insecure defaults in Valkey's configuration.
      • Race conditions or TOCTOU vulnerabilities introduced by Valkey.
    5. Automated Analysis (Valkey Context): Configure static analysis tools to understand Valkey's codebase and specifically target the identified changes.
    6. Valkey Documentation Review: Review Valkey's documentation for accuracy and security guidance related to its authentication/authorization changes.
    7. Remediation (Valkey-Specific): Address vulnerabilities within Valkey's code. Document changes and re-review.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Unauthorized Access (Valkey-Specific) (Severity: Critical): Prevents bypasses or flaws introduced by Valkey in its authentication/authorization.
    • Privilege Escalation (Valkey-Specific) (Severity: High): Prevents escalation within Valkey's new features or modified logic.
    • Data Exposure (Valkey-Specific) (Severity: High): Reduces exposure due to vulnerabilities in Valkey's authentication/authorization changes.
    • Account Takeover (Valkey-Specific) (Severity: Critical): Prevents attackers from taking over legitimate user accounts, if vulnerability is introduced by Valkey.

  • Impact:

    • Unauthorized Access (Valkey-Specific): High (80-90% reduction of Valkey-introduced risk).
    • Privilege Escalation (Valkey-Specific): High (70-80% reduction of Valkey-introduced risk).
    • Data Exposure (Valkey-Specific): Moderate (50-60% reduction of Valkey-introduced risk).
    • Account Takeover (Valkey-Specific): High (80-90% reduction of Valkey-introduced risk).

  • Currently Implemented: (Example - Needs project-specific data)

    • Partially. Code reviews happen, but not always focused on Valkey-specific authentication changes.

  • Missing Implementation: (Example - Needs project-specific data)

    • Dedicated security review of only Valkey's deviations from Redis authentication/authorization.
    • Static analysis configured for Valkey's specific changes.

Mitigation Strategy: Penetration Testing (Valkey Auth/Authz Focus)

2. Mitigation Strategy: Penetration Testing (Valkey Auth/Authz Focus)

  • Description:

    1. Valkey-Specific Scope: The penetration test must focus on Valkey's authentication and authorization, including any new features or modifications.
    2. Test Cases (Valkey-Centric): Develop test cases to specifically target:
      • Bypassing Valkey's authentication mechanisms.
      • Escalating privileges within Valkey's features.
      • Bypassing Valkey's ACL modifications (if any).
      • Exploiting new authentication/authorization features in Valkey.
    3. Tool Selection (Valkey Awareness): Use tools, and if necessary, develop custom scripts, that understand Valkey's specific commands and configuration.
    4. Execution (Valkey Environment): Test against a Valkey instance configured as closely as possible to production.
    5. Reporting (Valkey-Specific Findings): Document vulnerabilities specific to Valkey's implementation.
    6. Remediation and Retesting (Valkey Code): Address vulnerabilities within Valkey's codebase and retest.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Unauthorized Access (Valkey-Specific) (Severity: Critical): Identifies Valkey-introduced bypasses.
    • Privilege Escalation (Valkey-Specific) (Severity: High): Finds Valkey-specific escalation paths.
    • Data Exposure (Valkey-Specific) (Severity: High): Uncovers Valkey-related data exposure vulnerabilities.
    • Account Takeover (Valkey-Specific) (Severity: Critical): Identifies Valkey-introduced vulnerabilities.

  • Impact:

    • Unauthorized Access (Valkey-Specific): High (70-80% reduction of Valkey-introduced risk).
    • Privilege Escalation (Valkey-Specific): High (60-70% reduction of Valkey-introduced risk).
    • Data Exposure (Valkey-Specific): Moderate (40-50% reduction of Valkey-introduced risk).
    • Account Takeover (Valkey-Specific): High (70-80% reduction of Valkey-introduced risk).

  • Currently Implemented: (Example)

    • Not implemented. No penetration testing focused on Valkey's authentication.

  • Missing Implementation: (Example)

    • The entire Valkey-focused penetration testing process.

Mitigation Strategy: Feature-Specific Security Audits (Valkey Additions)

3. Mitigation Strategy: Feature-Specific Security Audits (Valkey Additions)

  • Description:

    1. Identify New Valkey Features: Maintain a list of features exclusively introduced by Valkey (not present in the base Redis version).
    2. Threat Modeling (Valkey Context): For each new Valkey feature, perform threat modeling, considering how it interacts with Valkey's other features and configuration.
    3. Code Review (Valkey Code Only): Review only the code implementing the new Valkey feature.
    4. Testing (Valkey-Specific): Develop test cases (functional, security, fuzz) specifically for the new Valkey feature.
    5. Valkey Documentation: Ensure Valkey's documentation accurately describes the feature and its security implications.
    6. Remediation (Valkey Code): Address vulnerabilities within the new Valkey feature's code.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Data Exposure (Valkey-Specific) (Severity: High/Medium): Addresses vulnerabilities in new Valkey features that could expose data.
    • Denial of Service (Valkey-Specific) (Severity: High/Medium): Mitigates DoS vulnerabilities in new Valkey features.
    • Code Execution (Valkey-Specific) (Severity: Critical): Reduces risk in new Valkey modules or extensions.
    • New Attack Vectors (Valkey-Specific) (Severity: Variable): Addresses unforeseen risks in new Valkey features.

  • Impact:

    • Data Exposure (Valkey-Specific): Moderate to High (50-70% reduction of Valkey-introduced risk).
    • Denial of Service (Valkey-Specific): Moderate to High (50-70% reduction of Valkey-introduced risk).
    • Code Execution (Valkey-Specific): High (70-80% reduction of Valkey-introduced risk).
    • New Attack Vectors (Valkey-Specific): Variable, depends on the specific threats.

  • Currently Implemented: (Example)

    • Partially. Some code reviews, but not always focused on only new Valkey features.

  • Missing Implementation: (Example)

    • Formal threat modeling for each new Valkey feature.
    • Comprehensive security testing of only new Valkey features.

Mitigation Strategy: Resource Limits and Rate Limiting (Valkey-Specific Commands)

4. Mitigation Strategy: Resource Limits and Rate Limiting (Valkey-Specific Commands)

  • Description:

    1. Identify Resource-Intensive Valkey Commands: Analyze new commands and features introduced by Valkey for potential resource consumption issues. Also, analyze modified Redis commands within Valkey.
    2. Configure Valkey's Resource Limits: Use Valkey's configuration options (including any new ones) to set limits on memory, clients, timeouts, and specifically any new resource-related settings.
    3. Rate Limiting (Valkey Commands): Implement rate limiting specifically for:
      • New Valkey commands that are resource-intensive or vulnerable.
      • Modified Redis commands within Valkey that have altered performance.
    4. Monitoring (Valkey Metrics): Monitor Valkey's resource usage and performance, paying close attention to the behavior of new or modified commands.
    5. Alerting (Valkey-Specific): Set up alerts for resource usage and rate limit triggers, focusing on Valkey-specific metrics.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Denial of Service (DoS) (Valkey-Specific) (Severity: High): Prevents DoS attacks exploiting new or modified Valkey commands.
    • Resource Exhaustion (Valkey-Specific) (Severity: High): Protects against resource exhaustion caused by Valkey-specific features.

  • Impact:

    • Denial of Service (Valkey-Specific): High (70-80% reduction of Valkey-introduced risk).
    • Resource Exhaustion (Valkey-Specific): High (80-90% reduction of Valkey-introduced risk).

  • Currently Implemented: (Example)

    • Partially. Basic limits set, but no rate limiting for Valkey-specific commands.

  • Missing Implementation: (Example)

    • Rate limiting for new or modified Valkey commands.
    • Tuning of resource limits based on Valkey's performance.

Mitigation Strategy: Lua Script Auditing and Sandboxing (Valkey-Specific)

5. Mitigation Strategy: Lua Script Auditing and Sandboxing (Valkey-Specific)

  • Description:

    1. Identify Valkey's Lua Usage: Determine how Valkey uses Lua scripts, including any new mechanisms for loading or executing them.
    2. Script Auditing (Valkey Context): Audit all Lua scripts, paying close attention to how they interact with Valkey-specific features or commands.
    3. Sandboxing (Valkey's Capabilities): Utilize Valkey's sandboxing mechanisms (if any) to restrict Lua script capabilities. If Valkey extends Redis's Lua functionality, carefully review these extensions.
    4. Input Validation (Valkey Interactions): Validate input passed to Lua scripts, especially if it interacts with Valkey-specific features.
    5. Least Privilege (Valkey Context): Ensure Lua scripts have minimal privileges within the Valkey environment.
    6. Monitoring (Valkey-Specific Lua): Monitor the execution of Lua scripts within Valkey, looking for errors or unusual behavior.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Code Execution (Valkey-Specific) (Severity: Critical): Prevents code execution through vulnerable Lua scripts interacting with Valkey.
    • Data Exposure (Valkey-Specific) (Severity: High): Reduces risk from Lua scripts accessing data via Valkey-specific features.
    • Denial of Service (Valkey-Specific) (Severity: High): Prevents DoS via Lua scripts exploiting Valkey.
    • Unauthorized Access (Valkey-Specific) (Severity: High): Prevents unauthorized access through Valkey's Lua integration.

  • Impact:

    • Code Execution (Valkey-Specific): High (80-90% reduction of Valkey-introduced risk).
    • Data Exposure (Valkey-Specific): Moderate to High (50-70% reduction of Valkey-introduced risk).
    • Denial of Service (Valkey-Specific): Moderate to High (50-70% reduction of Valkey-introduced risk).
    • Unauthorized Access (Valkey-Specific): High (70-80% reduction of Valkey-introduced risk).

  • Currently Implemented: (Example)

    • Not implemented. No auditing or sandboxing of Lua scripts in the Valkey context.

  • Missing Implementation: (Example)

    • The entire Valkey-specific Lua script auditing and sandboxing process.