Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
112 lines (87 loc) · 10.3 KB

mitigations.md

File metadata and controls

112 lines (87 loc) · 10.3 KB

Mitigation Strategies Analysis for apache/arrow

Mitigation Strategy: Schema Validation and Enforcement (Arrow API)

  • Description:

    1. Define Expected Schemas (Arrow API): Use pyarrow.schema() (or equivalent in other language bindings) to create Schema objects representing the precise expected structure of your Arrow data. Specify data types (pyarrow.int32(), pyarrow.string(), etc.), field names, nullability, and any relevant metadata.
    2. Validate Incoming Data (Arrow API): Immediately after receiving Arrow data (e.g., using pyarrow.ipc.open_file(), pyarrow.ipc.read_table()), obtain the schema of the received data (e.g., table.schema). Use the equals() method of your expected schema object to compare it to the received schema: expected_schema.equals(received_schema). This is a strict equality check.
    3. Reject Invalid Data: If equals() returns False, immediately reject the data. Do not proceed with any further processing. Log the schema mismatch details for debugging.
    4. Schema-Aware Processing (Arrow API): Throughout your data processing pipeline, use the validated Schema object. When accessing columns, use methods like table.column("column_name") which are schema-aware. Avoid any operations that rely on implicit type conversions or dynamic typing based on the Arrow data.
    5. Schema Evolution (Arrow API Considerations): If schema evolution is necessary, use a versioning scheme. When reading data, check for a schema version identifier (potentially stored as metadata). Use Arrow's capabilities to potentially cast data to a compatible schema only if the schemas are compatible and the cast is safe. Reject data if the schema version is unsupported or the cast is not possible.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Type Confusion Attacks (Severity: High): Prevents processing data with incorrect types, mitigating risks of crashes, misinterpretations, and potential code execution vulnerabilities.
    • Schema Injection (Severity: High): Prevents attackers from modifying the schema to bypass validation or inject malicious fields.
    • Data Corruption (Severity: Medium): Detects schema alterations due to unintentional data corruption.
    • Logic Errors (Severity: Medium): Reduces application logic errors stemming from incorrect schema assumptions.

  • Impact:

    • Type Confusion/Schema Injection: Risk reduced to near zero with correct implementation.
    • Data Corruption: Risk significantly reduced.
    • Logic Errors: Risk reduced.

  • Currently Implemented:

    • Schema validation using pyarrow.schema() and schema.equals() is implemented for data from the external API (api/data_ingestion.py).
    • Expected schemas are defined in schemas/api_schemas.py.

  • Missing Implementation:

    • Schema validation is missing for data loaded from internal CSV files (data/process_csv.py).
    • No formal schema evolution process using Arrow's metadata capabilities is in place.

Mitigation Strategy: Data Integrity Checks (Arrow Compute Functions)

  • Description:

    1. Identify Critical Columns: Determine which columns require checks beyond schema validation.
    2. Range Checks (Arrow Compute): For numerical columns, use Arrow's compute functions (e.g., pyarrow.compute.greater_equal(column, min_value), pyarrow.compute.less_equal(column, max_value)) to efficiently check if values are within acceptable bounds. Create boolean arrays indicating valid/invalid values.
    3. Length Limits (Arrow String/Binary Functions): For string/binary columns, use Arrow's functions (e.g., pyarrow.compute.utf8_length(column)) to get lengths. Compare these lengths to maximum allowed lengths using compute functions, creating boolean arrays.
    4. Sanity Checks (Arrow Compute/Custom Functions): Implement application-specific checks. You can often use Arrow's compute functions for this (e.g., pyarrow.compute.is_in(column, value_set) for checking membership in a set of allowed values). For more complex checks, you may need to write custom Python functions that operate on Arrow arrays, but try to leverage Arrow's compute functions as much as possible for performance.
    5. Handle Invalid Data: After performing the checks (resulting in boolean arrays), decide how to handle invalid data. Options include:
      • Rejecting the entire batch.
      • Filtering out invalid rows (using pyarrow.compute.filter).
      • Replacing invalid values with nulls or default values (using pyarrow.compute.if_else).

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Integer Overflow/Underflow (Severity: High): Range checks prevent values that could cause overflows/underflows.
    • Buffer Overflow (Severity: High): Length limits prevent excessively large string/binary values.
    • Denial of Service (DoS) (Severity: Medium-High): Length/range checks help prevent resource exhaustion.
    • Logic Errors (Severity: Medium): Sanity checks prevent errors from invalid data values.

  • Impact:

    • Integer/Buffer Overflow: Risk significantly reduced.
    • DoS: Risk reduced (in conjunction with other resource limits).
    • Logic Errors: Risk reduced.

  • Currently Implemented:

    • Range checks using pyarrow.compute are implemented for "age" in data/user_data.py.
    • Length limits using pyarrow.compute.utf8_length are implemented for "username" in data/user_data.py.

  • Missing Implementation:

    • No sanity checks are implemented for other columns.
    • No consistent strategy for handling invalid data (reject, filter, or replace) is defined.

Mitigation Strategy: Controlled Memory Allocation (Arrow Buffer Limits)

  • Description:

    1. Estimate Maximum Buffer Size: Before deserializing Arrow data, estimate the maximum potential size of the resulting Arrow buffers. This might involve:
      • Checking the size of the input stream (file size, network socket buffer size).
      • If the input format provides metadata about the uncompressed size (e.g., some IPC formats), use that.
    2. Enforce Size Limits: Compare the estimated size to a predefined maximum allowed size. If the estimated size exceeds the limit, reject the data before attempting to deserialize it. This prevents allocating potentially huge buffers.
    3. Streaming/Chunking (Arrow IPC): For very large datasets, use Arrow's streaming capabilities (e.g., pyarrow.ipc.open_stream, pyarrow.ipc.RecordBatchStreamReader). Read data in chunks using reader.read_next_batch(). Each chunk will be a separate RecordBatch, and you can apply schema validation and data integrity checks to each chunk individually. This avoids loading the entire dataset into memory at once.
    4. Controlled Copying (After Validation): If receiving data from an untrusted source, after successfully validating the schema and data integrity of a chunk and ensuring it's within size limits, copy the data into a new, application-controlled Arrow buffer (e.g., using pyarrow.Table.from_batches([validated_batch])). This isolates your application from the potentially malicious, untrusted memory region.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Denial of Service (DoS) (Severity: High): Prevents allocation of excessively large Arrow buffers that could exhaust memory.
    • Memory Corruption (Severity: Medium): Controlled copying reduces risks associated with directly using untrusted memory.

  • Impact:

    • DoS: Risk significantly reduced.
    • Memory Corruption: Risk reduced.

  • Currently Implemented:

    • None of the Arrow-specific memory management strategies are currently implemented.

  • Missing Implementation:

    • No estimation of maximum buffer sizes before deserialization.
    • No enforcement of size limits.
    • No use of Arrow's streaming/chunking capabilities for large datasets.
    • No controlled copying of data from untrusted sources after validation.

Mitigation Strategy: Extension Type Handling (Arrow API)

  • Description:

    1. Whitelist (Arrow API): If your application uses Arrow extension types, maintain a whitelist of allowed extension type names. This whitelist should be stored securely (e.g., in a configuration file or a dedicated module).
    2. Check for Extension Types (Arrow API): When you receive Arrow data and obtain its schema (received_schema), iterate through the fields and check if any field has an extension type using field.type.extension_name.
    3. Validate Against Whitelist: If an extension type is found, check if its name is present in your whitelist. If it's not in the whitelist, immediately reject the data.
    4. Validate Metadata (Arrow API): If the extension type is in the whitelist, retrieve its metadata using field.type.extension_metadata. Validate this metadata carefully. Ensure it's well-formed and doesn't contain any potentially malicious data (e.g., excessively long strings). The specifics of metadata validation depend on the extension type.
    5. Secure Extension Implementations (If Applicable): If you've created custom extension types, ensure their implementations (serialization, deserialization, and any associated logic) are secure and free of vulnerabilities.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Code Injection (Severity: High): Prevents attackers from using unknown or malicious extension types to inject code.
    • Data Corruption (Severity: Medium): Prevents issues caused by unsupported extension types.
    • Logic Errors (Severity: Medium): Ensures only understood extension types are handled.

  • Impact:

    • Code Injection: Risk significantly reduced.
    • Data Corruption/Logic Errors: Risk reduced.

  • Currently Implemented:

    • The application does not currently use any Arrow extension types.

  • Missing Implementation:

    • If extension types are added, a whitelisting and validation mechanism using the Arrow API must be implemented.