Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
112 lines (82 loc) · 10.3 KB

attack-tree.md

File metadata and controls

112 lines (82 loc) · 10.3 KB

Attack Tree Analysis for bvlc/caffe

Objective: Compromise Application Using Caffe by Exploiting Caffe-Specific Weaknesses.

Attack Tree Visualization

Compromise Application Using Caffe
├───(OR)─ Exploit Caffe Vulnerabilities Directly
│   └───(OR)─ Dependency Vulnerabilities [CRITICAL NODE]
│       ├───(AND)─ Identify Vulnerable Dependency
│       │   └───(OR)─ Check CVE Databases for Caffe Dependencies [HIGH-RISK PATH]
│       └───(AND)─ Exploit Vulnerable Dependency [HIGH-RISK PATH]
│           └───(OR)─ Leverage Known Exploits for Dependency [HIGH-RISK PATH]
├───(OR)─ Resource Exhaustion/DoS via Caffe [CRITICAL NODE]
│   └───(AND)─ Trigger Resource Exhaustion [HIGH-RISK PATH]
│       ├───(OR)─ Send Large Model Files [HIGH-RISK PATH]
│       ├───(OR)─ Send Complex Input Data [HIGH-RISK PATH]
│       └───(OR)─ Initiate Multiple Inference/Training Requests [HIGH-RISK PATH]
├───(OR)─ Manipulate Caffe Input/Output [CRITICAL NODE]
│   ├───(OR)─ Malicious Input Data Injection [CRITICAL NODE]
│   │   └───(AND)─ Inject Malicious Input [HIGH-RISK PATH]
│   │       └───(OR)─ Directly through Application Interface [HIGH-RISK PATH]
│   └───(OR)─ Malicious Model Injection/Substitution [CRITICAL NODE]
│       └───(AND)─ Obtain Access to Model Storage/Loading Mechanism [CRITICAL NODE]
│           └───(OR)─ Exploit Application Vulnerabilities (for file system access) [HIGH-RISK PATH]
└───(OR)─ Exploit Caffe Configuration or Integration Weaknesses [CRITICAL NODE]
    └───(OR)─ Weaknesses in Application's Caffe Integration [CRITICAL NODE] [HIGH-RISK PATH]
        ├───(AND)─ Identify Integration Weakness [HIGH-RISK PATH]
        │   ├───(OR)─ Insufficient Input Validation before Caffe [HIGH-RISK PATH]
        │   ├───(OR)─ Improper Error Handling of Caffe exceptions [HIGH-RISK PATH]
        │   └───(OR)─ Lack of Resource Limits when using Caffe [HIGH-RISK PATH]
        └───(AND)─ Exploit Integration Weakness [HIGH-RISK PATH]
            └───(OR)─ Trigger Application Errors or Crashes [HIGH-RISK PATH]

Attack Tree Path: Dependency Vulnerabilities

  • Why Critical: Caffe relies on numerous external libraries. Vulnerabilities in these dependencies are common and can be easily exploited if not patched. Exploiting a dependency vulnerability can lead to code execution and full system compromise.
  • Attack Vectors within:
    • Checking CVE databases for Caffe dependencies to identify known vulnerabilities.
    • Leveraging known exploits for vulnerable dependencies.

Attack Tree Path: Resource Exhaustion/DoS via Caffe

  • Why Critical: Caffe operations (model loading, inference, training) can be resource-intensive. Exploiting this can lead to Denial of Service, making the application unavailable. DoS attacks are relatively easy to execute.
  • Attack Vectors within:
    • Sending large model files to overload the system during loading.
    • Sending complex input data to consume excessive resources during inference.
    • Initiating multiple inference or training requests to overwhelm the application.

Attack Tree Path: Manipulate Caffe Input/Output

  • Why Critical: This is the primary interface between the application and Caffe. Compromising input or output can directly manipulate the application's behavior and data processing.
  • Sub-Nodes:
    • Malicious Input Data Injection: Injecting crafted input can lead to various outcomes, from manipulating model predictions to triggering errors or exploiting data processing vulnerabilities.
    • Malicious Model Injection/Substitution: Replacing the legitimate Caffe model with a malicious one is a highly effective attack, allowing the attacker to control the core logic of the application.

Attack Tree Path: Malicious Input Data Injection

  • Why Critical: Input data is the most common and easily accessible point of interaction with the application. Insufficient input validation makes this a high-risk attack vector.
  • Attack Vectors within:
    • Injecting malicious input directly through the application interface (e.g., web forms, APIs).

Attack Tree Path: Malicious Model Injection/Substitution

  • Why Critical: Models are the core of the application's AI functionality. Compromising the model directly compromises the application's intelligence and can lead to severe consequences.
  • Sub-Nodes:
    • Obtain Access to Model Storage/Loading Mechanism: Gaining access to where models are stored or how they are loaded is a prerequisite for model substitution. This often involves exploiting other application vulnerabilities.

Attack Tree Path: Obtain Access to Model Storage/Loading Mechanism

  • Why Critical: This is a choke point. Securing model storage and loading mechanisms is crucial to prevent model substitution attacks.
  • Attack Vectors within:
    • Exploiting general application vulnerabilities (like file upload vulnerabilities, directory traversal, or authentication bypasses) to gain file system access and modify or replace model files.

Attack Tree Path: Exploit Caffe Configuration or Integration Weaknesses

  • Why Critical: Misconfigurations and poor integration practices are common in real-world applications. These are often easier to exploit than vulnerabilities within Caffe itself.
  • Sub-Nodes:
    • Weaknesses in Application's Caffe Integration: This is the most critical sub-node within this category, as it directly addresses how the application uses Caffe.

Attack Tree Path: Weaknesses in Application's Caffe Integration

  • Why Critical: Poor integration is often the weakest link. Developers may not fully understand the security implications of how they use Caffe, leading to vulnerabilities in the integration layer. This is a High-Risk Path because it's a common source of vulnerabilities in applications using Caffe.
  • Attack Vectors within:
    • Insufficient Input Validation before Caffe: Failing to properly validate input before passing it to Caffe can allow malicious input to reach Caffe and potentially trigger vulnerabilities.
    • Improper Error Handling of Caffe exceptions: Poor error handling can lead to information disclosure or application crashes, which can be exploited.
    • Lack of Resource Limits when using Caffe: Not implementing resource limits can make the application vulnerable to DoS attacks via Caffe.
    • Exploit Integration Weakness: Actively exploiting these integration weaknesses to cause harm.
      • Trigger Application Errors or Crashes: Exploiting integration flaws to cause instability and DoS.

Attack Tree Path: Dependency Vulnerabilities -> Check CVE Databases for Caffe Dependencies -> Leverage Known Exploits for Dependency

This path represents the classic approach of finding and exploiting known vulnerabilities in software dependencies. It's high-risk because dependency vulnerabilities are common and exploits are often readily available.

Attack Tree Path: Resource Exhaustion/DoS via Caffe -> Trigger Resource Exhaustion -> (Send Large Model Files, Send Complex Input Data, Initiate Multiple Inference/Training Requests)

This path outlines the straightforward methods for launching a DoS attack against the application by overloading Caffe with resource-intensive operations. It's high-risk due to the ease of execution and potential for service disruption.

Attack Tree Path: Manipulate Caffe Input/Output -> Malicious Input Data Injection -> Inject Malicious Input -> Directly through Application Interface

This path highlights the most common and easily exploited attack vector: injecting malicious input through the application's user interface. It's high-risk because web application input interfaces are often the most exposed and targeted attack surface.

Attack Tree Path: Malicious Model Injection/Substitution -> Obtain Access to Model Storage/Loading Mechanism -> Exploit Application Vulnerabilities (for file system access)

This path describes how attackers can leverage general application vulnerabilities to gain access to the file system and replace legitimate models with malicious ones. It's high-risk because web application vulnerabilities are common, and successful exploitation can lead to complete model compromise.

Attack Tree Path: Exploit Caffe Configuration or Integration Weaknesses -> Weaknesses in Application's Caffe Integration -> Identify Integration Weakness -> (Insufficient Input Validation, Improper Error Handling, Lack of Resource Limits) -> Exploit Integration Weakness -> Trigger Application Errors or Crashes

This path represents a very common and high-risk scenario. It highlights that vulnerabilities in how the application integrates with Caffe are often more likely and easier to exploit than vulnerabilities within Caffe itself. Poor input validation, error handling, and resource management in the integration layer are frequent weaknesses.