Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
240 lines (200 loc) · 21.2 KB

sec-design.md

File metadata and controls

240 lines (200 loc) · 21.2 KB

Project Design Document: MongoDB Server

Version: 1.1 Date: 2023-10-27 Author: AI Expert

1. Introduction

This document provides a detailed design overview of the MongoDB server, based on the open-source project available at https://github.com/mongodb/mongo. This document is specifically created to serve as a foundation for threat modeling and security analysis of the MongoDB system. It comprehensively outlines the key components, data flow, security mechanisms, and deployment considerations of MongoDB, focusing on aspects relevant to security.

2. Project Overview

MongoDB is a source-available, cross-platform, document-oriented database program categorized as a NoSQL database. It utilizes JSON-like documents with optional schemas, emphasizing high scalability, performance, and developer agility. This design document concentrates on the core MongoDB server (mongod) and related components that are crucial for security considerations in various deployment scenarios, including standalone, replica sets, and sharded clusters.

3. System Architecture

MongoDB's architecture revolves around the mongod process, the central database server. Deployments can range from a single standalone server to highly available replica sets or horizontally scalable sharded clusters. This document emphasizes architectural components common across deployment types, with specific notes for different configurations where relevant to security.

3.1. Detailed Architecture Diagram

graph LR
    subgraph "Client Application"
        A["Client Application"]
    end

    subgraph "MongoDB Deployment"
        subgraph "mongos (Sharded Cluster - Optional)"
            B["mongos Router"]
        end

        subgraph "mongod Server(s)"
            C["mongod Server"]

            subgraph "Core Components"
                D["Storage Engine (WiredTiger, etc.)"]
                E["Authentication & Authorization"]
                F["Query Engine"]
                G["Networking Layer"]
                H["Auditing Subsystem"]
                I["Replication Engine (Replica Sets)"]
                J["Sharding Engine (Sharded Clusters)"]
                K["Transaction Manager"]
                L["Cache & Memory Management"]
            end
        end

        subgraph "Configuration Server Replica Set (Sharded Cluster - Required)"
            M["Config Server Replica Set"]
        end
    end

    A -->|Network Connection (MongoDB Protocol, TLS Optional)| B
    A -->|Network Connection (MongoDB Protocol, TLS Optional)| C
    B -->|Query Routing & Aggregation| C
    C -->|Storage Operations (CRUD)| D
    C -->|Authentication Requests & Session Management| E
    C -->|Authorization Checks (RBAC)| E
    C -->|Query Parsing & Execution Planning| F
    C -->|Network Communication (Client & Internal)| G
    C -->|Audit Event Generation & Logging| H
    C -->|Replication Data Synchronization (Replica Sets)| I
    C -->|Shard Key Based Data Distribution (Sharded Clusters)| J
    C -->|ACID Transaction Management| K
    C -->|Data Caching & Memory Allocation| L
    C -->|Configuration Data Retrieval (Sharded)| M

    style A fill:#f9f,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px
    style B fill:#ccf,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px
    style C fill:#ccf,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px
    style D fill:#eee,stroke:#333,stroke-width:1px,stroke-dasharray: 5 5
    style E fill:#eee,stroke:#333,stroke-width:1px,stroke-dasharray: 5 5
    style F fill:#eee,stroke:#333,stroke-width:1px,stroke-dasharray: 5 5
    style G fill:#eee,stroke:#333,stroke-width:1px,stroke-dasharray: 5 5
    style H fill:#eee,stroke:#333,stroke-width:1px,stroke-dasharray: 5 5
    style I fill:#eee,stroke:#333,stroke-width:1px,stroke-dasharray: 5 5
    style J fill:#eee,stroke:#333,stroke-width:1px,stroke-dasharray: 5 5
    style K fill:#eee,stroke:#333,stroke-width:1px,stroke-dasharray: 5 5
    style L fill:#eee,stroke:#333,stroke-width:1px,stroke-dasharray: 5 5
    style M fill:#ccf,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px
Loading

3.2. Component Description (Detailed)

  • "Client Application": Any application, tool, or driver (e.g., application backend, mongo shell, language-specific MongoDB drivers) that initiates communication with the MongoDB server to perform database operations. Security considerations here include secure coding practices within the client application to prevent vulnerabilities like NoSQL injection and proper handling of database credentials.
  • "mongos Router" (Optional): Specifically for sharded clusters, mongos acts as a smart query router and load balancer. It receives client requests, determines the target shard(s) based on the shard key, routes the query, aggregates results from shards, and returns a unified response to the client. mongos itself does not store data but plays a crucial role in security by enforcing access control policies delegated to the underlying mongod servers and by potentially being a target for DoS attacks.
  • "mongod Server": The core MongoDB database server process, responsible for data storage, query processing, security enforcement, and replication/sharding functionalities. Key sub-components include:
    • "Storage Engine (WiredTiger, etc.)": Manages all aspects of persistent data storage. WiredTiger, the default, provides features critical for security:
      • Encryption at Rest: Supports transparent encryption of data files on disk, protecting data if storage media is compromised. Encryption keys can be managed internally or externally via KMS.
      • Document-Level Locking: Enhances concurrency but also impacts resource management and potential DoS scenarios if locking is abused.
      • Compression: Reduces storage footprint and I/O, indirectly impacting performance and potentially security-related performance issues.
    • "Authentication & Authorization": Manages user identity verification and access control:
      • Authentication Mechanisms: Supports multiple mechanisms including SCRAM-SHA-256 (default), x.509 certificate authentication (for mutual TLS), LDAP, Kerberos, and internal keyfile authentication for replica set/sharded cluster members. Choice of mechanism impacts security strength and operational complexity.
      • Role-Based Access Control (RBAC): Implements granular permission management. Roles define privileges on specific databases and collections, allowing for least privilege access control. Misconfigured roles can lead to privilege escalation.
      • Session Management: Manages authenticated sessions, session timeouts, and potential session hijacking vulnerabilities.
    • "Query Engine": Parses, validates, optimizes, and executes queries. Security considerations include:
      • Query Parsing and Validation: Should prevent NoSQL injection attacks by properly validating and sanitizing user inputs within queries.
      • Query Optimization: Inefficient queries can lead to performance degradation and potential DoS. Query profiler and optimization tools are important for security and performance.
    • "Networking Layer": Handles all network communication:
      • MongoDB Wire Protocol: The binary protocol used for communication. Understanding the protocol is crucial for network security analysis.
      • TLS/SSL Support: Enables encryption of network traffic between clients and servers, and between server components (replica set/sharded cluster members). Essential for protecting data in transit. Configuration weaknesses in TLS can lead to man-in-the-middle attacks.
      • Network Interface Binding: Restricting mongod to specific network interfaces limits exposure to unwanted network traffic.
      • Connection Limits and Rate Limiting: Controls to prevent resource exhaustion and DoS attacks at the network level.
    • "Auditing Subsystem": Records security-relevant events for monitoring, forensics, and compliance:
      • Audit Event Types: Configurable to log various events like authentication attempts, authorization failures, schema changes, and data access operations.
      • Audit Log Destinations: Logs can be written to files, syslog, or other destinations. Secure storage and access control for audit logs are critical.
      • Performance Impact: Auditing can have a performance overhead. Proper configuration is needed to balance security and performance.
    • "Replication Engine (Replica Sets)": Manages data replication across replica set members for high availability and data durability. Security considerations include secure communication between members and ensuring data consistency in the face of network partitions or node failures.
    • "Sharding Engine (Sharded Clusters)": Distributes data across shards. Security implications include ensuring consistent security policies across all shards and secure communication within the sharded cluster.
    • "Transaction Manager": Provides ACID transaction capabilities. Transaction management needs to be robust to prevent data corruption and maintain data integrity, which are indirectly related to security.
    • "Cache & Memory Management": Manages in-memory data caching and memory allocation. Improper memory management can lead to performance issues and potentially exploitable vulnerabilities.
  • "Config Server Replica Set" (Sharded Cluster - Required): Stores cluster metadata. Security of config servers is paramount as compromise can lead to cluster-wide disruption or data corruption. They are always deployed as a replica set for high availability and require strong access control and secure communication.

4. Data Flow (Detailed Security Perspective)

The data flow, from a security perspective, involves these key stages:

  1. Client Request Initiation: Client application constructs a request. Security starts here with secure coding practices to prevent injection vulnerabilities and protect credentials.
  2. Network Transmission (Insecure/Secure): Request is transmitted over the network. If TLS/SSL is not enabled, data is transmitted in plaintext, vulnerable to eavesdropping and modification. TLS/SSL configuration must be robust (strong ciphers, proper certificate validation).
  3. Connection Handling and Authentication: mongod (or mongos) receives the connection. Authentication process begins. Weak authentication mechanisms or misconfigurations are critical vulnerabilities. Brute-force protection and account lockout policies are important.
  4. Authorization Enforcement: After successful authentication, authorization checks are performed based on RBAC. Bypassing authorization checks is a major security threat. Proper role assignment and privilege management are crucial.
  5. Query Processing and Data Access: Query engine processes the request. Input validation and sanitization are critical to prevent NoSQL injection. Access control is enforced during data retrieval.
  6. Storage Engine Interaction: Storage engine performs data operations. Encryption at rest protects data on disk. Access control within the storage engine layer is also relevant.
  7. Response Transmission (Insecure/Secure): Response is sent back to the client. Similar to request transmission, TLS/SSL is needed to protect the response data in transit.
  8. Auditing and Logging: Security events are logged. Secure storage and access control for audit logs are essential to prevent tampering and ensure accountability.

5. Technology Stack (Security Relevant Details)

  • Programming Languages: C++ (core server - performance and security critical), JavaScript (server-side scripting - potential injection risks).
  • Operating Systems: OS-level security features (firewall, SELinux/AppArmor, kernel hardening) are important for MongoDB security.
  • Network Protocols: TCP/IP (fundamental network layer), MongoDB Wire Protocol (application protocol - understanding its structure is important for security analysis).
  • Storage Engines: WiredTiger (default - encryption at rest, performance characteristics), MMAPv1 (deprecated - known security limitations, avoid using).
  • Security Libraries:
    • OpenSSL/LibreSSL: (TLS/SSL, cryptography - vulnerabilities in these libraries can directly impact MongoDB security). Regular updates are crucial.
    • Cyrus SASL: (Authentication mechanisms - vulnerabilities here can compromise authentication).
    • libsasl2-modules: (Specific SASL modules - ensure only necessary and secure modules are enabled).
  • Build System: SCons, Python (build process security - prevent supply chain attacks by ensuring build integrity).

6. Deployment Models (Security Implications)

  • Standalone Server: Simplest, but least resilient. Single point of failure. Security relies solely on the single instance. Best for development/testing only.
  • Replica Set: High availability and data redundancy. Improves resilience against node failures. Security configuration needs to be consistent across all members. Secure internal communication between members is crucial.
  • Sharded Cluster: Horizontal scalability. Increased complexity. Security needs to be managed across multiple shards and mongos routers. Configuration of config servers is critical. Network segmentation and access control become more complex.
  • Cloud Deployments (e.g., MongoDB Atlas): Managed service. Security is a shared responsibility. Cloud provider's security posture and MongoDB Atlas's security features are important. Understand the shared responsibility model.

7. Security Considerations (Categorized and Expanded)

Security considerations are categorized for clarity:

7.1. Access Control:

  • Authentication:
    • Strong Authentication Mechanisms: Enforce strong authentication mechanisms like x.509 certificate authentication or Kerberos where applicable. SCRAM-SHA-256 is a good default but evaluate if stronger mechanisms are needed.
    • Password Policies: Implement strong password policies (complexity, rotation, length) if using password-based authentication.
    • Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA): Consider MFA for privileged accounts for enhanced security. (Note: Native MFA is not directly supported by MongoDB server, but can be implemented at application level or using external authentication providers).
    • Disable Default Credentials: Ensure default administrative accounts are removed or have strong, unique passwords.
  • Authorization (RBAC):
    • Principle of Least Privilege: Grant users only the necessary privileges. Regularly review and refine roles.
    • Role Granularity: Utilize fine-grained roles to control access at the database, collection, and even document level where possible.
    • Regular Role Audits: Periodically audit role assignments and user permissions to ensure they are still appropriate and minimize unnecessary privileges.

7.2. Network Security:

  • TLS/SSL Encryption:
    • Enable TLS/SSL Everywhere: Enforce TLS/SSL for all client-to-server and server-to-server communication (replica set/sharded cluster members, mongos to mongod).
    • Strong TLS Configuration: Use strong cipher suites, disable weak protocols, and ensure proper certificate management (valid certificates, revocation mechanisms).
    • Mutual TLS (x.509): Consider mutual TLS for enhanced authentication and authorization, especially in sensitive environments.
  • Firewalling and Network Segmentation:
    • Restrict Network Access: Use firewalls to limit access to MongoDB ports (default 27017) only from trusted networks or IP addresses.
    • Network Segmentation: Segment MongoDB deployments into separate network zones to limit the impact of breaches.
    • Principle of Least Exposure: Only expose necessary ports and services to the network.
  • Bind to Specific Interfaces: Configure mongod to bind to specific network interfaces to limit its exposure to the network.

7.3. Data Security:

  • Encryption at Rest:
    • Enable Encryption at Rest: Utilize WiredTiger's encryption at rest feature to protect data on disk.
    • Key Management: Implement secure key management practices. Use external KMS for better key security and separation of duties. Rotate encryption keys periodically.
  • Data Masking and Anonymization: Consider data masking or anonymization techniques for sensitive data in non-production environments.
  • Data Validation and Sanitization: Implement robust input validation and sanitization in client applications to prevent NoSQL injection attacks.

7.4. Auditing and Monitoring:

  • Enable Auditing: Enable the auditing subsystem and configure it to log relevant security events.
  • Secure Audit Log Storage: Store audit logs securely and protect them from unauthorized access and tampering.
  • Log Monitoring and Alerting: Implement monitoring and alerting for security-related events in audit logs (authentication failures, authorization violations, etc.). Integrate with SIEM systems.
  • Regular Security Reviews: Periodically review audit logs and system logs for suspicious activities.

7.5. Operational Security:

  • Security Hardening:
    • Regular Security Updates: Keep MongoDB server and underlying OS and libraries up-to-date with security patches.
    • Disable Unnecessary Features: Disable or remove any unnecessary features or services to reduce the attack surface.
    • Secure OS Configuration: Follow OS security hardening guidelines.
  • Backup and Recovery: Implement secure backup and recovery procedures. Encrypt backups and protect backup storage.
  • Incident Response Plan: Develop and maintain an incident response plan for security incidents involving MongoDB.
  • Security Awareness Training: Train developers and administrators on MongoDB security best practices.

8. Threat Modeling Focus Areas (Actionable and Specific)

For effective threat modeling, focus on these areas with specific threat examples:

  • Authentication and Authorization Bypass:
    • Threat: Brute-force attacks against authentication mechanisms (e.g., password guessing).
    • Threat: Exploitation of vulnerabilities in authentication protocols (e.g., weaknesses in SCRAM-SHA-256 implementation).
    • Threat: Misconfiguration of authentication mechanisms (e.g., allowing anonymous access unintentionally).
    • Threat: Privilege escalation due to RBAC misconfiguration or vulnerabilities in RBAC implementation.
    • Threat: Session hijacking or session fixation attacks.
  • Data Breaches and Data Exfiltration:
    • Threat: SQL/NoSQL injection attacks leading to unauthorized data access.
    • Threat: Exploitation of vulnerabilities to bypass authorization and directly access data files.
    • Threat: Insider threats - malicious users with excessive privileges exfiltrating data.
    • Threat: Data breaches due to insecure network communication (lack of TLS/SSL).
    • Threat: Physical theft of storage media containing unencrypted data (if encryption at rest is not enabled or improperly configured).
  • Injection Attacks (NoSQL Injection):
    • Threat: Query injection through improperly sanitized user inputs in queries.
    • Threat: Server-Side JavaScript injection if server-side scripting is enabled and not properly secured.
    • Threat: Command injection through MongoDB operators if input validation is insufficient.
  • Denial of Service (DoS):
    • Threat: Network-level DoS attacks targeting MongoDB ports.
    • Threat: Query-based DoS attacks using resource-intensive queries to overload the server.
    • Threat: Exploitation of vulnerabilities leading to server crashes or resource exhaustion.
    • Threat: Authentication DoS attacks (e.g., repeated failed authentication attempts).
  • Privilege Escalation:
    • Threat: Exploiting vulnerabilities to gain administrative privileges from a lower-privileged account.
    • Threat: Abusing misconfigured roles or permissions to gain unintended access.
    • Threat: Exploiting vulnerabilities in the authorization enforcement mechanism.
  • Supply Chain Vulnerabilities:
    • Threat: Compromised dependencies (e.g., vulnerabilities in OpenSSL, Cyrus SASL).
    • Threat: Malicious code injected into the MongoDB codebase during build or distribution.
  • Insider Threats:
    • Threat: Data theft or modification by disgruntled or compromised employees/contractors.
    • Threat: Sabotage or intentional disruption of service by insiders.
  • Configuration Errors and Misconfigurations:
    • Threat: Leaving default settings unchanged (e.g., default ports, weak authentication).
    • Threat: Disabling security features (e.g., disabling authentication, auditing).
    • Threat: Misconfiguring access controls (e.g., overly permissive roles, incorrect firewall rules).
    • Threat: Insecure deployment practices (e.g., running mongod as root).

This improved design document provides a more detailed and security-focused foundation for threat modeling MongoDB deployments. By considering these detailed components, data flows, security considerations, and specific threat examples, security professionals can conduct a more comprehensive and effective threat analysis.