Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
158 lines (128 loc) · 17.1 KB

sec-design-deep-analysis.md

File metadata and controls

158 lines (128 loc) · 17.1 KB

Okay, let's perform the deep security analysis based on the provided design review.

1. Objective, Scope, and Methodology

  • Objective: To conduct a thorough security analysis of the key components of the MongoDB database system (as described in the design review), identifying potential vulnerabilities and weaknesses in its architecture, design, and implementation. This analysis will focus on the mongodb/mongo repository and associated documentation. The goal is to provide actionable mitigation strategies to enhance the security posture of MongoDB deployments.

  • Scope: This analysis covers the following components, as detailed in the C4 Context and Container diagrams, and the deployment and build process descriptions:

    • Client Libraries (Drivers): Focus on how drivers handle authentication, connection security, and data serialization/deserialization.
    • mongos (Router): Analysis of query routing, access control enforcement, and potential for information leakage.
    • Config Server (mongod): Security of metadata storage, access control, and impact of compromise.
    • Shard (mongod - Replica Set): Data storage security, replication security, and access control within the replica set.
    • Build Process: Security of the build pipeline, including source code management, CI/CD, SAST, DAST, and artifact management.
    • Deployment: Security considerations for a sharded cluster deployment on self-managed infrastructure.

  • Methodology:

    1. Architecture and Data Flow Inference: Based on the provided C4 diagrams, deployment description, and build process description, we will infer the overall architecture, data flow, and interactions between components. We will supplement this with information from the official MongoDB documentation (as referenced in the design review).
    2. Component-Specific Threat Identification: For each component within the scope, we will identify potential threats based on common attack patterns, known vulnerabilities in similar technologies, and the specific functionalities of the component. We will leverage the STRIDE threat model (Spoofing, Tampering, Repudiation, Information Disclosure, Denial of Service, Elevation of Privilege) to guide this process.
    3. Security Control Analysis: We will analyze the existing security controls (as described in the "SECURITY POSTURE" section) and assess their effectiveness against the identified threats.
    4. Mitigation Strategy Recommendation: For each identified threat and weakness, we will propose specific, actionable mitigation strategies tailored to MongoDB and its deployment context. These recommendations will be practical and consider the trade-offs between security, performance, and usability.

2. Security Implications of Key Components

We'll break down the security implications of each component, using STRIDE to categorize threats.

  • Client Libraries (Drivers)

    • Spoofing: An attacker could attempt to impersonate a legitimate client by forging credentials or manipulating connection parameters.
      • Mitigation: Enforce strong authentication (SCRAM, x.509, Kerberos, LDAP). Use TLS/SSL with proper certificate validation (including hostname verification and checking for revocation) to prevent man-in-the-middle attacks. Implement connection pooling securely to prevent connection reuse by unauthorized clients.
    • Tampering: An attacker could modify data in transit between the client and the server.
      • Mitigation: Use TLS/SSL with strong cipher suites to ensure data integrity. Consider using Client-Side Field Level Encryption (CSFLE) for sensitive fields. Validate data types and formats on the server-side.
    • Repudiation: A legitimate client could deny performing an action.
      • Mitigation: Enable auditing on the server-side to log client actions. Combine this with strong authentication to uniquely identify clients.
    • Information Disclosure: Sensitive data could be leaked through error messages, insecure logging, or network sniffing.
      • Mitigation: Use TLS/SSL to encrypt network traffic. Sanitize error messages and logs to avoid exposing sensitive information. Avoid storing sensitive data in connection strings or configuration files. Use CSFLE to encrypt sensitive data before it leaves the client.
    • Denial of Service: An attacker could flood the client library with connection requests or malformed data, causing it to crash or become unresponsive.
      • Mitigation: Implement connection limits and timeouts. Use robust input validation to handle malformed data gracefully. Consider using a connection pool with appropriate size limits.
    • Elevation of Privilege: A vulnerability in the client library could allow an attacker to execute arbitrary code with the privileges of the application using the library.
      • Mitigation: Regularly update client libraries to patch vulnerabilities. Follow secure coding practices when developing applications that use the client libraries. Use a least-privilege model for the application's user account.

  • mongos (Router)

    • Spoofing: An attacker could attempt to impersonate a legitimate mongos instance or a client connecting to mongos.
      • Mitigation: Require TLS/SSL for all connections to and from mongos. Use strong authentication (SCRAM, x.509) for clients and inter-cluster communication. Configure mongos to only accept connections from known clients and other cluster members.
    • Tampering: An attacker could modify queries or results as they pass through mongos.
      • Mitigation: Use TLS/SSL for all connections. Ensure that mongos itself is not compromised (secure deployment, regular patching). Consider using CSFLE to protect sensitive data.
    • Repudiation: A mongos instance could fail to log a routing decision or an error.
      • Mitigation: Enable auditing on mongos to log all routing decisions and errors. Regularly review audit logs.
    • Information Disclosure: mongos could leak information about the cluster topology, shard keys, or data through error messages or logging.
      • Mitigation: Sanitize error messages and logs. Configure mongos to only expose necessary information to clients. Use TLS/SSL to protect communication with clients and other cluster members.
    • Denial of Service: An attacker could flood mongos with requests, overwhelming it and preventing legitimate clients from accessing the database.
      • Mitigation: Implement connection limits and request throttling on mongos. Use a load balancer in front of multiple mongos instances. Monitor mongos performance and scale as needed. Configure appropriate timeouts.
    • Elevation of Privilege: A vulnerability in mongos could allow an attacker to gain control of the routing process or access data on the shards.
      • Mitigation: Regularly update mongos to patch vulnerabilities. Run mongos with the least necessary privileges. Implement network segmentation to isolate mongos from other systems.

  • Config Server (mongod)

    • Spoofing: An attacker could impersonate a legitimate config server.
      • Mitigation: Use TLS/SSL for all inter-cluster communication. Use strong authentication (x.509) for communication between mongos and config servers, and between config servers themselves.
    • Tampering: An attacker could modify the cluster metadata stored on the config servers, leading to incorrect routing, data loss, or denial of service.
      • Mitigation: Use TLS/SSL for all communication. Implement strong access controls (RBAC) on the config servers. Regularly back up the config server data. Use a replica set for config servers to ensure high availability and data redundancy. Crucially, restrict network access to the config servers to only mongos instances and authorized administrative hosts.
    • Repudiation: A config server could fail to log a change to the cluster metadata.
      • Mitigation: Enable auditing on the config servers. Regularly review audit logs.
    • Information Disclosure: An attacker could gain access to the cluster metadata, revealing information about the shards, shard keys, and potentially sensitive data.
      • Mitigation: Use Encryption at Rest (Enterprise Advanced) for the config server data. Implement strong access controls (RBAC). Use TLS/SSL for all communication. Restrict network access.
    • Denial of Service: An attacker could make the config servers unavailable, preventing mongos from routing queries and effectively shutting down the cluster.
      • Mitigation: Use a replica set for config servers. Implement network segmentation and firewalls to protect the config servers from external attacks. Monitor config server performance and resource utilization.
    • Elevation of Privilege: An attacker who compromises a config server could gain control of the entire cluster. This is a critical, high-impact threat.
      • Mitigation: Implement strict access controls (RBAC) with the principle of least privilege. Regularly update the config servers to patch vulnerabilities. Use strong authentication (x.509). Implement network segmentation. Monitor config server logs for suspicious activity. Consider using a dedicated, highly secured network for config server communication.

  • Shard (mongod - Replica Set)

    • Spoofing: An attacker could attempt to impersonate a legitimate shard member.
      • Mitigation: Use TLS/SSL for all inter-cluster communication. Use strong authentication (x.509) for replica set members.
    • Tampering: An attacker could modify data stored on a shard.
      • Mitigation: Use TLS/SSL for all communication. Implement strong access controls (RBAC). Use Encryption at Rest (Enterprise Advanced). Regularly verify data integrity (e.g., using checksums or background scrubbing).
    • Repudiation: A shard could fail to log a data modification.
      • Mitigation: Enable auditing on the shards. Regularly review audit logs.
    • Information Disclosure: An attacker could gain unauthorized access to data stored on a shard.
      • Mitigation: Use Encryption at Rest (Enterprise Advanced). Implement strong access controls (RBAC). Use TLS/SSL for all communication. Restrict network access to the shards. Consider using CSFLE for sensitive fields.
    • Denial of Service: An attacker could overwhelm a shard with requests, making it unavailable.
      • Mitigation: Use a replica set for each shard. Implement connection limits and request throttling. Monitor shard performance and resource utilization. Scale shards horizontally as needed.
    • Elevation of Privilege: An attacker who compromises a shard could gain access to the data stored on that shard.
      • Mitigation: Implement strict access controls (RBAC) with the principle of least privilege. Regularly update the shards to patch vulnerabilities. Use strong authentication. Implement network segmentation. Monitor shard logs for suspicious activity.

  • Build Process

    • Tampering: An attacker could inject malicious code into the MongoDB source code or build artifacts.
      • Mitigation: Use a secure code repository (GitHub) with access controls, code review processes, and branch protection rules. Use a secure CI/CD system (Evergreen) with automated builds and tests. Use SAST tools (e.g., Coverity) to scan the source code for vulnerabilities. Digitally sign build artifacts. Implement a robust vulnerability management program. Verify the integrity of third-party dependencies.
    • Information Disclosure: The build process could leak sensitive information, such as API keys or credentials.
      • Mitigation: Store secrets securely (e.g., using a secrets management system). Avoid hardcoding secrets in the source code or build scripts. Sanitize build logs.
    • Denial of Service: An attacker could disrupt the build process, preventing the release of new versions or security patches.
      • Mitigation: Use a reliable CI/CD system with redundancy and failover capabilities. Monitor the build process for performance and availability.
    • Elevation of Privilege: An attacker could compromise the build system and gain access to other systems or resources.
      • Mitigation: Implement strong access controls on the build system. Regularly update the build system and its components. Use a dedicated, isolated environment for the build process.

  • Deployment

    • Network Segmentation: Failure to properly isolate the MongoDB cluster (config servers, shards, mongos) from other networks and the public internet.
      • Mitigation: Implement strict firewall rules, allowing only necessary traffic between cluster components and from authorized client networks. Use VLANs or other network segmentation techniques to isolate the MongoDB deployment.
    • OS Hardening: Failure to harden the operating systems of the servers hosting MongoDB.
      • Mitigation: Follow OS-specific security best practices (e.g., disabling unnecessary services, configuring firewalls, enabling security auditing). Regularly apply security patches.
    • Unnecessary Open Ports: Leaving unnecessary ports open on the MongoDB servers.
      • Mitigation: Use a firewall to block all ports except those required for MongoDB operation (e.g., 27017 for mongod, 27018 for mongos, 27019 for config servers).
    • Weak or Default Credentials: Using weak or default credentials for OS accounts or MongoDB users.
      • Mitigation: Enforce strong password policies. Use key-based authentication for SSH access. Change default MongoDB credentials immediately after installation.

3. Mitigation Strategies (Actionable and Tailored)

The above threat analysis already includes specific mitigation strategies. Here's a summarized, prioritized list of key actions:

  1. Network Segmentation and Firewalling (High Priority):

    • Isolate the MongoDB cluster (config servers, shards, mongos) using firewalls and network segmentation.
    • Restrict access to config servers to only mongos instances and authorized administrative hosts.
    • Allow only necessary traffic between cluster components and from authorized client networks.

  2. Strong Authentication and Authorization (High Priority):

    • Enforce strong authentication for all clients and inter-cluster communication (SCRAM, x.509, Kerberos, LDAP).
    • Use TLS/SSL with proper certificate validation for all connections.
    • Implement granular Role-Based Access Control (RBAC) with the principle of least privilege.
    • Regularly review and update RBAC roles.

  3. Encryption (High Priority):

    • Use TLS/SSL for all network communication.
    • Consider using Encryption at Rest (MongoDB Enterprise Advanced) for sensitive data, especially on config servers and shards.
    • Use Client-Side Field Level Encryption (CSFLE) for highly sensitive fields.

  4. Auditing and Monitoring (High Priority):

    • Enable auditing on all MongoDB components (mongod, mongos).
    • Regularly review audit logs for suspicious activity.
    • Implement alerting mechanisms for security-related events.
    • Monitor server performance and resource utilization to detect potential DoS attacks.

  5. Vulnerability Management (High Priority):

    • Regularly update MongoDB server and client libraries to patch vulnerabilities.
    • Implement a robust vulnerability management program with regular scanning and patching.
    • Monitor security advisories from MongoDB Inc.

  6. Secure Build Process (Medium Priority):

    • Ensure the integrity of third-party dependencies.
    • Use SAST and DAST tools to identify vulnerabilities during the build process.
    • Digitally sign build artifacts.

  7. OS Hardening (Medium Priority):

    • Harden the operating systems of the servers hosting MongoDB.
    • Regularly apply security patches to the operating systems.

  8. Input Validation (Medium Priority):

    • Implement server-side validation of data types and formats.
    • Use parameterized queries or a similar mechanism to prevent NoSQL injection.

  9. Configuration Management (Medium Priority):

    • Avoid using default configurations.
    • Securely store and manage configuration files.
    • Use a configuration management tool to automate and enforce secure configurations.

  10. Secrets Management (Medium Priority):

    • Store secrets (passwords, API keys) securely, not in plain text or source code. Use a dedicated secrets management solution.

This detailed analysis provides a strong foundation for improving the security of MongoDB deployments. The prioritized mitigation strategies offer a roadmap for addressing the most critical threats and vulnerabilities. Remember to tailor these recommendations to the specific compliance requirements, data sensitivity, and risk profile of your particular MongoDB deployment.