Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
132 lines (114 loc) · 13.2 KB

attack-tree.md

File metadata and controls

132 lines (114 loc) · 13.2 KB

Attack Tree Analysis for signalapp/signal-android

Objective: Compromise Application Using Signal-Android by Exploiting Signal-Android Weaknesses

Attack Tree Visualization

Root: Compromise Application Using Signal-Android
    ├── 1. Exploit Vulnerabilities in Signal-Android Library [HIGH RISK PATH]
    │   ├── 1.1. Exploit Known Vulnerabilities [HIGH RISK PATH]
    │   │   ├── 1.1.1. Target Outdated Signal-Android Version [HIGH RISK, CRITICAL NODE]
    │   │   ├── 1.1.2. Exploit Publicly Disclosed Vulnerabilities (e.g., CVEs) [HIGH RISK, CRITICAL NODE]
    │   └── 1.3. Dependency Vulnerabilities within Signal-Android [HIGH RISK PATH]
    │       ├── 1.3.1. Exploit Vulnerabilities in Third-Party Libraries used by Signal-Android [HIGH RISK, CRITICAL NODE]
    ├── 2. Exploit Misuse or Misconfiguration of Signal-Android by Application Developer [HIGH RISK PATH]
    │   ├── 2.1. Improper API Usage [HIGH RISK PATH]
    │   │   ├── 2.1.1. Incorrect Parameter Handling in Signal-Android APIs [HIGH RISK, CRITICAL NODE]
    │   ├── 2.2. Insecure Data Handling Around Signal-Android [HIGH RISK PATH]
    │   │   ├── 2.2.1. Storing Sensitive Data Outside Signal-Android's Secure Storage [HIGH RISK, CRITICAL NODE]
    │   │   ├── 2.2.2. Improper Data Sanitization Before/After Signal-Android Processing [HIGH RISK NODE]
    │   │   ├── 2.2.3. Logging Sensitive Information Related to Signal-Android [HIGH RISK NODE]
    │   └── 2.4. Lack of Security Best Practices in Application Development [HIGH RISK PATH]
    │       ├── 2.4.1. Insufficient Input Validation in Application Code [HIGH RISK, CRITICAL NODE]
    │       ├── 2.4.3. Lack of Regular Security Testing and Code Reviews [HIGH RISK, CRITICAL NODE]
    └── 3. Indirect Attacks Leveraging Signal-Android Functionality [HIGH RISK PATH]
        ├── 3.1. Social Engineering via Signal-Android Communication [HIGH RISK PATH]
        │   ├── 3.1.1. Phishing Attacks Through Signal-Android Messaging [HIGH RISK, CRITICAL NODE]
        └── 3.2. Denial of Service Attacks Targeting Signal-Android Resources
            ├── 3.2.1. Resource Exhaustion Attacks via Excessive Messaging [HIGH RISK NODE]

Attack Tree Path: 1. Exploit Vulnerabilities in Signal-Android Library [HIGH RISK PATH]

  • 1.1. Exploit Known Vulnerabilities [HIGH RISK PATH]:

    • 1.1.1. Target Outdated Signal-Android Version [HIGH RISK, CRITICAL NODE]:

      • Attack Vector: Exploit publicly known vulnerabilities present in older versions of the Signal-Android library.
      • Why High Risk:
        • High Likelihood: Many applications fail to update dependencies promptly, leaving them vulnerable to known exploits.
        • High Impact: Successful exploitation can lead to Remote Code Execution (RCE), data breaches, or complete application compromise.
        • Low Effort: Automated tools can easily identify outdated library versions.
        • Beginner Skill Level: Exploiting known vulnerabilities often requires minimal skill, especially if exploit code is publicly available.

    • 1.1.2. Exploit Publicly Disclosed Vulnerabilities (e.g., CVEs) [HIGH RISK, CRITICAL NODE]:

      • Attack Vector: Exploit vulnerabilities in Signal-Android that have been publicly disclosed and assigned CVE identifiers.
      • Why High Risk:
        • Medium Likelihood: CVEs are regularly discovered and disclosed in software, including complex libraries like Signal-Android.
        • High to Critical Impact: CVEs often target significant vulnerabilities that can have severe consequences, potentially allowing for data breaches or system takeover.
        • Medium Effort: Exploit development might require some effort, but proof-of-concept or exploit code often becomes available after public disclosure.
        • Intermediate Skill Level: Adapting and using exploits effectively requires intermediate skills.

  • 1.3. Dependency Vulnerabilities within Signal-Android [HIGH RISK PATH]:

    • 1.3.1. Exploit Vulnerabilities in Third-Party Libraries used by Signal-Android [HIGH RISK, CRITICAL NODE]:
      • Attack Vector: Exploit vulnerabilities present in third-party libraries that Signal-Android depends on.
      • Why High Risk:
        • Medium Likelihood: Third-party libraries are a common source of vulnerabilities and are frequently targeted by attackers.
        • Medium to High Impact: The impact depends on the vulnerable library and its role within Signal-Android and the application. It could range from information disclosure to Remote Code Execution.
        • Low to Medium Effort: Automated tools can identify vulnerable dependencies.
        • Beginner to Intermediate Skill Level: Exploiting known dependency vulnerabilities is often relatively straightforward.

Attack Tree Path: 2. Exploit Misuse or Misconfiguration of Signal-Android by Application Developer [HIGH RISK PATH]

  • 2.1. Improper API Usage [HIGH RISK PATH]:

    • 2.1.1. Incorrect Parameter Handling in Signal-Android APIs [HIGH RISK, CRITICAL NODE]:
      • Attack Vector: Exploit vulnerabilities arising from incorrect or insecure handling of parameters when calling Signal-Android APIs.
      • Why High Risk:
        • Medium to High Likelihood: Developer errors in API usage are common, especially with complex libraries and numerous API parameters.
        • Medium to High Impact: Incorrect API usage can lead to various issues like data leaks, logic bypasses, crashes, or even vulnerabilities within Signal-Android if misused in a way that triggers internal errors.
        • Low to Medium Effort: Simple testing and API fuzzing can reveal parameter handling issues.
        • Beginner to Intermediate Skill Level: Understanding API documentation and basic testing skills are sufficient.

  • 2.2. Insecure Data Handling Around Signal-Android [HIGH RISK PATH]:

    • 2.2.1. Storing Sensitive Data Outside Signal-Android's Secure Storage [HIGH RISK, CRITICAL NODE]:

      • Attack Vector: Access sensitive data related to Signal-Android (like keys, tokens, user data) that is stored insecurely by the application, outside of Signal-Android's intended secure storage mechanisms.
      • Why High Risk:
        • Medium to High Likelihood: Developers often make mistakes in secure data storage, especially if they are not fully aware of Signal-Android's secure storage options or best practices.
        • High Impact: Exposure of sensitive data like keys or tokens can lead to complete compromise of the application's security and user data, potentially bypassing Signal-Android's security features.
        • Low Effort: Static code analysis and simple checks can easily identify insecure storage locations.
        • Beginner Skill Level: Basic code review skills are sufficient.

    • 2.2.2. Improper Data Sanitization Before/After Signal-Android Processing [HIGH RISK NODE]:

      • Attack Vector: Exploit vulnerabilities due to lack of proper sanitization or validation of data before being passed to Signal-Android APIs or after being received from them.
      • Why High Risk:
        • Medium to High Likelihood: Input validation and sanitization are frequently overlooked in development, leading to common vulnerabilities.
        • Medium to High Impact: Lack of sanitization can lead to injection attacks (e.g., Cross-Site Scripting if data is displayed in a web view, SQL Injection if data is used in database queries), data corruption, or information leaks.
        • Medium Effort: Requires understanding data flow and identifying injection points, but common techniques like fuzzing and manual testing can be effective.
        • Intermediate Skill Level: Requires understanding of common injection vulnerabilities.

    • 2.2.3. Logging Sensitive Information Related to Signal-Android [HIGH RISK NODE]:

      • Attack Vector: Gain access to application logs and extract sensitive information related to Signal-Android that is inadvertently logged by the application.
      • Why High Risk:
        • Medium Likelihood: Overly verbose logging, especially in development and sometimes in production environments, is a common practice.
        • Medium Impact: Exposure of sensitive data in logs depends on the sensitivity of the logged information and the access controls on the logs themselves. It can range from minor information disclosure to more significant data leaks.
        • Low Effort: Easy to check logs for sensitive information if access is gained.
        • Beginner Skill Level: Basic log analysis skills are sufficient.

  • 2.4. Lack of Security Best Practices in Application Development [HIGH RISK PATH]:

    • 2.4.1. Insufficient Input Validation in Application Code [HIGH RISK, CRITICAL NODE]:

      • Attack Vector: Exploit general input validation vulnerabilities within the application code, not necessarily directly related to Signal-Android APIs, but within the application's broader codebase.
      • Why High Risk:
        • High Likelihood: Insufficient input validation is a pervasive vulnerability in applications across various platforms and languages.
        • Medium to High Impact: The impact is broad and depends on the specific vulnerability, ranging from information disclosure to code execution within the application context, which can indirectly affect Signal-Android integration.
        • Medium Effort: Requires code analysis and penetration testing, but standard techniques are effective.
        • Intermediate Skill Level: Requires understanding of common input validation vulnerabilities.

    • 2.4.3. Lack of Regular Security Testing and Code Reviews [HIGH RISK, CRITICAL NODE]:

      • Attack Vector: This is not a direct attack vector but a systemic weakness. The absence of regular security testing and code reviews increases the likelihood of all other vulnerabilities (including those related to Signal-Android) remaining undetected and exploitable.
      • Why High Risk:
        • High Likelihood: Lack of security practices directly leads to a higher probability of vulnerabilities accumulating in the application.
        • High Impact: Accumulation of vulnerabilities across the application, including those related to Signal-Android integration, can lead to significant compromise and broader attack surfaces.
        • Low Effort (for attacker): The attacker doesn't need to exert effort for this step, they simply benefit from the lack of security effort by the developers.
        • Beginner Skill Level (for attacker): No specific skill needed for this step from the attacker's perspective.

Attack Tree Path: 3. Indirect Attacks Leveraging Signal-Android Functionality [HIGH RISK PATH]

  • 3.1. Social Engineering via Signal-Android Communication [HIGH RISK PATH]:

    • 3.1.1. Phishing Attacks Through Signal-Android Messaging [HIGH RISK, CRITICAL NODE]:
      • Attack Vector: Utilize the messaging capabilities of Signal-Android (if exposed by the application) to conduct phishing attacks against application users.
      • Why High Risk:
        • Medium Likelihood: Phishing remains a highly effective attack vector, and leveraging the trust associated with secure communication channels like Signal-Android can increase its success rate. Users might be more likely to trust messages received through an application using Signal-Android.
        • Medium to High Impact: Successful phishing can lead to account compromise, data theft, malware installation, and other significant consequences for users and potentially the application itself.
        • Low Effort: Phishing campaigns are relatively easy to set up and launch, requiring minimal technical resources.
        • Beginner Skill Level: Basic social engineering and phishing skills are sufficient.

  • 3.2. Denial of Service Attacks Targeting Signal-Android Resources

    • 3.2.1. Resource Exhaustion Attacks via Excessive Messaging [HIGH RISK NODE]:
      • Attack Vector: Overwhelm the application or Signal-Android backend with a large volume of messages, causing resource exhaustion and denial of service.
      • Why High Risk:
        • Medium Likelihood: Relatively easy to perform, especially if the application lacks rate limiting or other DoS mitigation measures for messaging features.
        • Medium Impact: Service disruption and application unavailability, which can impact business operations and user experience.
        • Low Effort: Simple scripting can generate a large number of messages, making it easy to launch a DoS attack.
        • Beginner Skill Level: Basic scripting skills are sufficient.