Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
330 lines (279 loc) · 28.6 KB

sec-design.md

File metadata and controls

330 lines (279 loc) · 28.6 KB

Project Design Document: uWebSockets (Improved)

Project Name: uWebSockets

Project Repository: https://github.com/unetworking/uwebsockets

Document Version: 1.1 Date: 2023-10-27 Author: AI Software Architect

Changes from Version 1.0:

  • Expanded Security Considerations section with more specific threats and mitigation strategies.
  • Added details to Component Descriptions, especially for Event Loop and Socket Manager.
  • Clarified Data Flow Description.
  • Added Error Handling and Logging considerations.
  • Minor formatting and wording improvements for clarity.

1. Project Overview

uWebSockets (often stylized as µWebSockets or uWS) is a highly performant and scalable C++ library for building WebSocket and HTTP servers and clients. It is engineered for exceptional resource efficiency and speed, making it an ideal choice for applications demanding real-time, high-concurrency communication. This document provides a detailed design overview of uWebSockets, specifically tailored to facilitate comprehensive threat modeling and security analysis.

1.1. Project Goals

  • Extreme Performance: Achieve industry-leading speed and minimal latency in both WebSocket and HTTP communication.
  • Massive Scalability: Efficiently manage and sustain a very large number of concurrent connections without performance degradation.
  • Minimal Resource Footprint: Optimize for low CPU and memory consumption, crucial for resource-constrained environments and maximizing server density.
  • API Flexibility and Extensibility: Offer a versatile and adaptable API that empowers developers to build a wide spectrum of WebSocket and HTTP-based applications.
  • Broad Platform Support: Ensure compatibility and consistent performance across major operating systems including Linux, macOS, and Windows.

1.2. Target Audience

This document is designed for a diverse audience:

  • Security Engineers & Auditors: Professionals responsible for conducting threat modeling, vulnerability assessments, and security audits of systems incorporating uWebSockets.
  • Software Developers: Engineers integrating uWebSockets into their applications, requiring a deep understanding of its architecture for effective and secure utilization.
  • System Administrators & DevOps: Personnel involved in deploying and managing applications built with uWebSockets, needing insights into its operational characteristics and security implications.
  • Performance Analysts: Individuals interested in understanding the internal workings of high-performance networking libraries and optimizing application performance.
  • Security Researchers: Researchers investigating the security landscape of modern networking libraries and seeking to identify potential vulnerabilities in uWebSockets.

2. System Architecture

uWebSockets employs an event-driven, non-blocking I/O architecture, leveraging operating system-specific primitives such as epoll (Linux), kqueue (macOS), and IOCP (Windows) for optimal efficiency. It presents a low-level API, granting fine-grained control over network connections and protocol handling.

graph LR
    subgraph "Application Process"
        A["Application Logic"] --> B["uWebSockets Library"];
    end

    subgraph "uWebSockets Library"
        B --> C["Event Loop"];
        C --> D["Socket Manager"];
        C --> E["HTTP Parser"];
        C --> F["WebSocket Protocol Handler"];
        C --> G["SSL/TLS Handler (Optional)"];
        C --> I["Buffer Management"];
        D --> H["Network Interface"];
    end

    H --> J["Network"];

    classDef component fill:#f9f,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px
    class A,B,C,D,E,F,G,H,I component
Loading

Description of Components:

  • Application Logic: Represents the custom application code developed by users that utilizes the uWebSockets library to implement specific WebSocket or HTTP server/client functionalities. This is where business logic and application-specific security measures reside.
  • uWebSockets Library: The core C++ library providing the fundamental API and mechanisms for high-performance network communication. It encapsulates the event loop, socket management, protocol handling, and optional security features.
  • Event Loop: The central orchestrator of uWebSockets. It continuously monitors registered file descriptors (sockets) for I/O events using OS-level mechanisms. Upon event detection, it dispatches events to the appropriate handlers, ensuring non-blocking operation and high concurrency.
  • Socket Manager: Responsible for the complete lifecycle management of network sockets. This includes:
    • Creation and binding of listening sockets for server applications.
    • Acceptance of incoming connection requests on listening sockets.
    • Creation of client sockets for initiating outgoing connections.
    • Configuration of socket options (e.g., TCP_NODELAY, SO_REUSEADDR, buffer sizes).
    • Graceful closure and resource cleanup of sockets.
    • Potentially includes internal socket pooling or reuse optimizations for performance.
  • HTTP Parser: Dedicated to parsing incoming HTTP requests and responses according to HTTP specifications (e.g., RFC 7230 series).
    • Request Parsing: Deconstructs HTTP requests to extract method, URI, headers, and body.
    • Response Parsing: Analyzes HTTP responses to retrieve status code, headers, and body (primarily for client-side operations).
    • Header Management: Handles parsing, validation, and serialization of HTTP headers.
    • May implement defenses against HTTP parsing vulnerabilities (e.g., request smuggling, header injection).
  • WebSocket Protocol Handler: Implements the WebSocket protocol (RFC 6455), enabling persistent, bidirectional communication channels over TCP.
    • Handshake Processing: Manages the WebSocket handshake negotiation between client and server.
    • Framing/Unframing: Encapsulates outgoing messages into WebSocket frames and decapsulates incoming frames to reconstruct messages.
    • Message Type Handling: Supports all standard WebSocket message types (text, binary, ping, pong, close control frames).
    • Connection State Management: Tracks the state of WebSocket connections and manages connection lifecycle events.
    • Potentially supports WebSocket extensions (e.g., compression extensions like permessage-deflate).
  • SSL/TLS Handler (Optional): Provides secure communication capabilities by integrating SSL/TLS encryption.
    • TLS Handshake: Executes the TLS handshake protocol to establish secure, encrypted connections.
    • Encryption/Decryption: Performs encryption of outgoing data and decryption of incoming data using negotiated TLS ciphers.
    • Certificate Management: Handles SSL/TLS certificate loading, validation, and management for server and client authentication (if configured). Typically relies on external libraries like OpenSSL, BoringSSL, or LibreSSL.
  • Buffer Management: Manages memory buffers used for socket I/O operations, HTTP parsing, and WebSocket framing. Efficient buffer management is critical for performance and preventing memory-related vulnerabilities. May include techniques like buffer pooling or zero-copy operations.
  • Network Interface: Represents the operating system's network stack and hardware interface through which uWebSockets interacts with the physical network.
  • Network: Represents the external network environment, which could be the internet, a local network, or any other network over which communication occurs.

3. Component Details

3.1. Event Loop (Detailed)

  • Functionality: The core of uWebSockets' non-blocking architecture. It continuously polls registered file descriptors (primarily socket file descriptors) for readiness events (readable, writable, error).
    • OS Integration: Leverages highly efficient OS-specific APIs: epoll (Linux), kqueue (macOS/BSD), IOCP (Windows). These APIs allow for monitoring a large number of file descriptors efficiently without excessive CPU usage.
    • Event Demultiplexing: When an event occurs on a monitored socket, the OS API notifies the event loop, which then identifies the socket and the type of event (e.g., EPOLLIN for readable, EPOLLOUT for writable).
    • Event Dispatching: The event loop dispatches the event to the appropriate handler function associated with the socket. This handler is typically within the Socket Manager, HTTP Parser, or WebSocket Protocol Handler components.
    • Non-Blocking Nature: Crucially, the event loop itself does not block. It quickly checks for events and dispatches them, allowing the application to remain responsive and handle many concurrent connections.
  • Key Features:
    • High Concurrency: Enables handling thousands or even millions of concurrent connections on a single thread by efficiently managing I/O events.
    • Low Latency: Minimizes latency by immediately processing events as they occur, avoiding delays associated with blocking I/O.
    • Resource Efficiency: Reduces CPU overhead compared to traditional thread-per-connection models, as the event loop efficiently manages I/O without creating excessive threads.
    • Scalability Foundation: Provides the fundamental building block for uWebSockets' scalability, allowing it to handle increasing load gracefully.

3.2. Socket Manager (Detailed)

  • Functionality: Abstracts the complexities of OS socket APIs and provides a higher-level interface for socket operations within uWebSockets.
    • Socket Creation and Binding: Creates sockets (TCP or potentially UDP in future extensions) and binds them to specific addresses and ports for server applications.
    • Listening and Accepting: Puts server sockets into listening mode and accepts incoming connection requests, creating new sockets for each accepted connection.
    • Connection Establishment (Client): Creates and connects client sockets to remote server addresses.
    • Socket Options Management: Sets various socket options to tune performance and behavior, such as:
      • TCP_NODELAY: Disables Nagle's algorithm for lower latency in TCP communication.
      • SO_REUSEADDR: Allows reuse of addresses and ports, useful for server restarts and load balancing.
      • SO_KEEPALIVE: Enables TCP keep-alive probes to detect dead connections.
      • SO_RCVBUF, SO_SNDBUF: Adjusts receive and send buffer sizes for performance tuning.
    • Socket Closure and Cleanup: Handles graceful socket closure, ensuring proper TCP connection termination and releasing associated resources.
    • Potentially Socket Pooling/Reuse: May implement internal mechanisms to pool or reuse sockets to reduce the overhead of socket creation and destruction, further enhancing performance.
  • Key Features:
    • Abstraction and Portability: Provides a consistent socket API across different operating systems, simplifying development and improving portability.
    • Performance Optimization: Manages socket options and potentially implements pooling to optimize socket operations for high performance.
    • Resource Management: Ensures proper socket lifecycle management, preventing resource leaks and contributing to overall system stability.

3.3. HTTP Parser

  • Functionality: Parses HTTP messages (requests and responses) efficiently and according to HTTP standards.
    • Stateful Parsing: Likely employs a state machine-based parser for efficient and robust parsing of HTTP streams.
    • Header Parsing: Handles parsing of various HTTP header formats, including key-value pairs, and potentially supports header folding and other complexities.
    • Body Handling: Manages HTTP message bodies, including chunked transfer encoding and content length handling.
    • Error Handling: Detects and handles HTTP parsing errors, potentially providing error codes and mechanisms for error reporting.
  • Key Features:
    • Performance Focus: Designed for speed and minimal overhead, crucial for high-throughput HTTP servers.
    • Strict or Lenient Modes: May offer configuration options to control parsing strictness, balancing security (strict parsing to reject malformed requests) and compatibility (lenient parsing for handling slightly non-compliant clients).
    • Security Considerations: Should be designed to mitigate HTTP parsing vulnerabilities such as:
      • Request Smuggling: Preventing ambiguities in request parsing that could lead to request smuggling attacks.
      • Header Injection: Protecting against injection of malicious headers that could be exploited by applications.
      • Buffer Overflows: Ensuring robust buffer management to prevent overflows during parsing of long headers or bodies.

3.4. WebSocket Protocol Handler

  • Functionality: Implements the WebSocket protocol for real-time, bidirectional communication.
    • Handshake Negotiation: Handles the WebSocket handshake process, validating client handshake requests and sending appropriate server handshake responses.
    • Frame Processing: Parses incoming WebSocket frames, extracting payload data, opcode, and flags. Constructs outgoing WebSocket frames according to the protocol specification.
    • Message Assembly/Disassembly: Assembles fragmented WebSocket messages from multiple frames and disassembles large messages into frames for transmission.
    • Control Frame Handling: Processes WebSocket control frames (ping, pong, close) for connection management and keep-alive.
    • Extension Handling: May support negotiation and handling of WebSocket extensions, such as permessage-deflate for compression.
  • Key Features:
    • RFC 6455 Compliance: Adheres strictly to the WebSocket protocol specification for interoperability.
    • Efficient Framing: Optimized for low overhead in WebSocket framing and unframing operations.
    • Security Features: Implements security aspects of the WebSocket protocol, such as:
      • Origin Validation: May provide mechanisms for validating the Origin header during the handshake to prevent cross-site WebSocket hijacking.
      • Close Frame Handling: Properly handles WebSocket close frames for graceful connection termination and error signaling.
      • Extension Security: If extensions are supported, ensures secure implementation and configuration of extensions to prevent vulnerabilities.

3.5. SSL/TLS Handler (Optional)

  • Functionality: Provides secure communication channels using SSL/TLS encryption.
    • TLS Handshake Management: Initiates and manages the TLS handshake process, negotiating cipher suites, exchanging certificates, and establishing a secure session.
    • Encryption and Decryption: Performs encryption of outgoing data before sending it over the network and decryption of incoming data received from the network.
    • Certificate and Key Management: Handles loading, storage, and management of SSL/TLS certificates and private keys.
    • Session Management: May implement TLS session resumption mechanisms to improve performance by reducing the overhead of full TLS handshakes for repeated connections.
  • Key Features:
    • Integration with Robust Libraries: Relies on well-established and security-audited SSL/TLS libraries like OpenSSL, BoringSSL, or LibreSSL.
    • Protocol Version Support: Supports modern TLS protocol versions (TLS 1.2, TLS 1.3) and potentially allows configuration of supported versions and cipher suites.
    • Performance Optimization: Aims for efficient integration with SSL/TLS libraries to minimize the performance impact of encryption and decryption.
    • Security Best Practices: Should encourage or enforce secure SSL/TLS configurations, such as:
      • Strong Cipher Suites: Defaulting to and recommending strong cipher suites that provide robust encryption.
      • Certificate Validation: Performing proper certificate validation to prevent man-in-the-middle attacks.
      • Regular Updates: Recommending and facilitating updates of the underlying SSL/TLS library to address security vulnerabilities.

3.6. Buffer Management

  • Functionality: Manages memory buffers used throughout uWebSockets for various purposes, including:
    • Socket receive and send buffers.
    • Buffers for HTTP request and response parsing.
    • Buffers for WebSocket frame processing.
    • Potentially buffers for internal data structures.
  • Key Features:
    • Efficiency: Optimized buffer allocation and deallocation to minimize memory overhead and fragmentation.
    • Buffer Pooling: May utilize buffer pooling techniques to reuse buffers, reducing the frequency of memory allocation and improving performance.
    • Zero-Copy Potential: May employ zero-copy techniques where possible to minimize data copying and improve throughput.
    • Security: Designed to prevent buffer-related vulnerabilities such as:
      • Buffer Overflows: Strict bounds checking and safe memory operations to prevent writing beyond buffer boundaries.
      • Memory Leaks: Properly releasing allocated buffers when they are no longer needed to avoid memory leaks.
      • Use-After-Free: Ensuring that buffers are not accessed after they have been freed.

4. Data Flow Diagram (Improved)

This diagram provides a more detailed illustration of the data flow for handling an incoming WebSocket message in a uWebSockets server application, including buffer management.

graph LR
    A["Network"] --> B["Network Interface"];
    B --> C["Socket Manager"];
    C --> D["Event Loop"];
    D --> E["Socket Buffer (Receive)"];
    E --> F["WebSocket Protocol Handler"];
    F --> G["Message Buffer"];
    G --> H["Application Logic (uWebSockets API)"];
    H --> I["WebSocket Connection Object"];
    I --> J["Application Message Handler"];
    J --> K["Response Buffer"];
    K --> L["WebSocket Protocol Handler"];
    L --> M["Socket Buffer (Send)"];
    M --> C;
    C --> B;
    B --> A;


    classDef component fill:#f9f,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px
    class A,B,C,D,E,F,G,H,I,J,K,L,M component
Loading

Data Flow Description (Improved):

  1. Network to Network Interface: Incoming network data (WebSocket frame) arrives at the network interface.
  2. Network Interface to Socket Manager: Network interface passes data to the Socket Manager associated with the socket.
  3. Socket Manager to Event Loop: Socket Manager signals the Event Loop that data is available on the socket.
  4. Event Loop to Socket Buffer (Receive): Event Loop directs the Socket Manager to read data from the socket into a Receive Socket Buffer.
  5. Socket Buffer (Receive) to WebSocket Protocol Handler: The WebSocket Protocol Handler reads data from the Receive Socket Buffer.
  6. WebSocket Protocol Handler to Message Buffer: The Protocol Handler processes the WebSocket frame, potentially assembling a complete message into a Message Buffer.
  7. Message Buffer to Application Logic (uWebSockets API): The Application Logic receives the message from the Message Buffer via the uWebSockets API callback.
  8. Application Logic to WebSocket Connection Object: Application Logic interacts with the WebSocket Connection Object to access connection context and prepare a response.
  9. WebSocket Connection Object to Application Message Handler: Application's message handler processes the received message and generates a response.
  10. Application Message Handler to Response Buffer: The response message is written into a Response Buffer.
  11. Response Buffer to WebSocket Protocol Handler: The WebSocket Protocol Handler frames the response message and writes it to the Response Buffer.
  12. Response Buffer to Socket Buffer (Send): The framed response is moved to the Send Socket Buffer.
  13. Socket Buffer (Send) to Socket Manager: The Socket Manager is notified that data is ready to be sent.
  14. Socket Manager to Network Interface: Socket Manager instructs the Network Interface to send data from the Send Socket Buffer.
  15. Network Interface to Network: Data is transmitted over the network.

5. Technology Stack

  • Core Programming Language: C++ (Modern C++, likely C++11 or later, leveraging features for performance and safety)
  • Operating System API Abstraction: POSIX (for Linux, macOS, other Unix-like systems), Windows API (IOCP)
  • SSL/TLS Library (Optional): OpenSSL (most probable), potentially configurable to use BoringSSL, LibreSSL, or other compatible TLS libraries.
  • Build System and Toolchain: CMake (cross-platform build system), standard C++ compiler (GCC, Clang, MSVC).
  • Networking Protocols: TCP (primary transport), HTTP (for initial handshake and HTTP server functionality), WebSocket (RFC 6455), SSL/TLS (optional for secure communication).

6. Deployment Model

uWebSockets is designed as a library to be embedded within applications. Deployment models are application-dependent:

  • Standalone Applications: Applications directly link with uWebSockets and are deployed as self-contained executables. Common for custom servers, real-time applications, and embedded systems.
  • Microservices Architecture: uWebSockets is well-suited for building high-performance microservices communicating via WebSockets or HTTP APIs. These can be containerized (Docker) and orchestrated (Kubernetes).
  • IoT and Edge Computing: Resource efficiency makes uWebSockets suitable for deployment on resource-constrained IoT devices and edge servers requiring real-time communication and low latency.
  • API Gateways and Real-time Web Servers: Can be used to build specialized API gateways or web servers focused on WebSocket and real-time functionalities, potentially as components within larger web infrastructure.
  • Embedded Systems: Due to its small footprint and efficiency, uWebSockets can be integrated into embedded systems requiring network communication capabilities.

7. Security Considerations (Detailed)

This section expands on security considerations, providing a more detailed overview of potential threats and mitigation strategies.

  • Input Validation & Sanitization:
    • Threat: Injection attacks (e.g., HTTP header injection, WebSocket message injection), buffer overflows, format string vulnerabilities.
    • Mitigation:
      • Strictly validate all inputs: HTTP headers, URIs, WebSocket messages, socket data.
      • Sanitize inputs before processing or using them in application logic.
      • Use safe parsing libraries and functions that prevent buffer overflows.
      • Implement input length limits to prevent excessive resource consumption and potential buffer overflows.
  • Memory Safety:
    • Threat: Buffer overflows, use-after-free, double-free, memory leaks, leading to crashes, denial of service, or potentially code execution.
    • Mitigation:
      • Employ safe memory management practices in C++ (RAII, smart pointers where appropriate).
      • Rigorous code reviews and static analysis to identify potential memory safety issues.
      • Use memory-safe string handling functions and libraries.
      • Consider using memory sanitizers (e.g., AddressSanitizer, MemorySanitizer) during development and testing.
  • Denial of Service (DoS):
    • Threat: Resource exhaustion (CPU, memory, network bandwidth), connection flooding, slowloris attacks, WebSocket ping floods.
    • Mitigation:
      • Implement rate limiting for connections and requests.
      • Set connection limits to prevent resource exhaustion.
      • Implement timeouts for connections and operations.
      • Employ resource monitoring and throttling mechanisms.
      • For WebSocket, implement ping/pong timeout mechanisms and limits on ping frequency.
      • Consider using techniques like SYN cookies to mitigate SYN flood attacks at the OS level.
  • WebSocket Protocol Specific Security:
    • Threat: Cross-Site WebSocket Hijacking (CSWSH), WebSocket injection, insecure WebSocket extensions.
    • Mitigation:
      • Validate the Origin header during the WebSocket handshake to prevent CSWSH.
      • Implement proper access control and authentication for WebSocket connections at the application level.
      • Carefully evaluate and secure any WebSocket extensions used.
      • Sanitize and validate data received over WebSocket connections.
      • Use TLS/SSL for WebSocket connections (wss://) to encrypt communication and protect against eavesdropping and tampering.
  • SSL/TLS Security (If Enabled):
    • Threat: Weak cipher suites, outdated TLS protocols, certificate validation errors, man-in-the-middle attacks, vulnerabilities in the underlying SSL/TLS library.
    • Mitigation:
      • Configure uWebSockets to use strong cipher suites and disable weak or outdated ones.
      • Enforce the use of modern TLS protocols (TLS 1.2, TLS 1.3).
      • Ensure proper SSL/TLS certificate validation is enabled and configured correctly.
      • Regularly update the underlying SSL/TLS library (e.g., OpenSSL) to patch security vulnerabilities.
      • Consider using certificate pinning for enhanced security in specific scenarios.
  • Dependency Management:
    • Threat: Vulnerabilities in third-party libraries (especially SSL/TLS libraries) used by uWebSockets.
    • Mitigation:
      • Maintain an inventory of all dependencies.
      • Regularly monitor dependencies for known vulnerabilities using vulnerability scanning tools.
      • Keep dependencies updated to the latest stable and secure versions.
      • Consider using dependency management tools that facilitate vulnerability scanning and updates.
  • Error Handling and Logging:
    • Threat: Information leakage through verbose error messages, denial of service due to excessive error logging, security vulnerabilities due to improper error handling.
    • Mitigation:
      • Implement robust error handling throughout the library.
      • Log errors and security-related events appropriately for auditing and debugging.
      • Avoid exposing sensitive information in error messages (especially to external clients).
      • Implement rate limiting or throttling for error logging to prevent DoS through excessive logging.
  • Access Control (Application Level):
    • Threat: Unauthorized access to resources and functionalities exposed through uWebSockets applications.
    • Mitigation:
      • Implement robust authentication and authorization mechanisms within the application logic built on top of uWebockets.
      • Follow the principle of least privilege when granting access to resources.
      • Regularly review and audit access control configurations.

8. Assumptions and Constraints

  • Performance Remains Paramount: Performance optimization is a core design principle. Security measures should be implemented without significantly degrading performance.
  • Application Developer Security Responsibility: uWebSockets provides a secure foundation, but application-level security (authentication, authorization, business logic security) is the responsibility of the developers using the library.
  • Reliance on External SSL/TLS Libraries: Security of SSL/TLS functionality is inherently tied to the security of the external SSL/TLS library used (e.g., OpenSSL). Regular updates of these libraries are crucial.
  • Cross-Platform Compatibility Trade-offs: Achieving cross-platform compatibility may introduce complexities in leveraging platform-specific security features or require careful abstraction to maintain security across different OS environments.
  • Open Source Transparency: The open-source nature of uWebSockets allows for community scrutiny and vulnerability discovery, but also means potential attackers have access to the codebase. Proactive security practices and community engagement are essential.
  • Configuration and Deployment Security: Secure configuration and deployment of applications using uWebSockets are critical. Misconfigurations can introduce vulnerabilities even if the library itself is secure.

This improved design document provides a more comprehensive foundation for threat modeling and security analysis of uWebSockets. The next step is to conduct a detailed threat modeling exercise, identifying specific threats, vulnerabilities, and developing detailed mitigation strategies based on this enhanced design understanding.