Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
196 lines (173 loc) · 27.8 KB

mitigations.md

File metadata and controls

196 lines (173 loc) · 27.8 KB

Mitigation Strategies Analysis for dotnet/docfx

Mitigation Strategy: Dependency Scanning for npm Packages

  • Description:
    1. Choose a Scanning Tool: Select a dependency scanning tool like npm audit, Snyk, or OWASP Dependency-Check. npm audit is built-in to npm.
    2. Integrate into Development Workflow: Run the chosen scanning tool regularly, specifically targeting DocFX's npm dependencies.
      • Locally: Developers should run npm audit (or the chosen tool's equivalent command) locally within the DocFX project directory before committing changes, especially after adding or updating DocFX or its plugins.
      • CI/CD Pipeline: Integrate the scanning tool into your CI/CD pipeline to automatically scan DocFX dependencies during each build. Fail the build if high-severity vulnerabilities are found in DocFX's dependencies.
    3. Review Scan Results: Analyze the output of the scanning tool, focusing on vulnerabilities reported in DocFX's direct and transitive npm dependencies.
    4. Remediate Vulnerabilities:
      • Update DocFX or Plugins: If vulnerabilities are found in DocFX itself or its plugins, check for updated versions of DocFX or the plugins that address the vulnerabilities. Update accordingly.
      • Investigate Dependency Trees: If vulnerabilities are in transitive dependencies, investigate if updating DocFX or its plugins resolves the issue. If not, consider if there are alternative DocFX configurations or plugins that might avoid the vulnerable dependency.
    5. Maintain Allowlists/Denylists (If Applicable): Some tools allow you to create allowlists or denylists for specific vulnerabilities or packages. Use these features cautiously and with proper justification, specifically in the context of DocFX dependencies.
    • List of Threats Mitigated:
      • Vulnerabilities in DocFX npm Dependencies - Severity: High
      • Supply Chain Attacks via Compromised DocFX Dependencies - Severity: High
    • Impact:
      • Vulnerabilities in DocFX npm Dependencies: High reduction. Proactively identifies and allows remediation of known vulnerabilities in DocFX's dependencies, preventing exploitation within the DocFX build and potentially the generated documentation site.
      • Supply Chain Attacks via Compromised DocFX Dependencies: Medium reduction. Reduces the risk by identifying known compromised packages used by DocFX, but doesn't fully prevent zero-day supply chain attacks targeting DocFX dependencies.
    • Currently Implemented: Yes, npm audit is run in the CI/CD pipeline as part of the build process for DocFX.
    • Missing Implementation: Not consistently run by developers locally before committing code changes related to DocFX configuration or plugin updates. Consider adding a pre-commit hook to enforce local scanning within the DocFX project.

Mitigation Strategy: Keep DocFX CLI Updated

  • Description:
    1. Check Current DocFX Version: Run docfx --version in your terminal to determine the currently installed DocFX CLI version.
    2. Check for Latest Stable Version: Visit the official DocFX GitHub repository (https://github.com/dotnet/docfx) or the DocFX documentation to find the latest stable release version.
    3. Update DocFX CLI: Follow the installation instructions in the DocFX documentation to update the CLI. This usually involves downloading the latest release from GitHub and replacing the existing executable or using a package manager if available for your system.
    4. Verify Update: After updating, re-run docfx --version to confirm the version has been updated to the latest stable release.
    5. Monitor Release Notes: Subscribe to DocFX release notes or watch the GitHub repository for new releases and security announcements specifically related to DocFX CLI.
    • List of Threats Mitigated:
      • Vulnerabilities in DocFX CLI - Severity: Medium to High (depending on the vulnerability)
    • Impact:
      • Vulnerabilities in DocFX CLI: Medium to High reduction. Reduces the risk of exploits targeting known vulnerabilities in the DocFX CLI itself, which could potentially lead to arbitrary code execution during documentation generation.
    • Currently Implemented: Yes, the DocFX CLI is updated periodically as part of build environment maintenance.
    • Missing Implementation: No automated process to check for and prompt for DocFX CLI updates. Manual process relies on team awareness of DocFX releases.

Mitigation Strategy: Secure docfx.json and Configuration Files

  • Description:
    1. Restrict File System Permissions: Ensure that docfx.json and other DocFX configuration files have restricted file system permissions, allowing only authorized users (e.g., build server user, administrators) to read and modify them.
    2. Version Control: Store docfx.json and DocFX configuration files in version control (e.g., Git) to track changes and enable rollback if necessary.
    3. Code Review Configuration Changes: Implement code reviews for any changes to docfx.json and DocFX configuration files to ensure they are intentional and do not introduce security risks or unintended behavior in DocFX.
    4. Input Validation (If Applicable): If DocFX configuration files are generated or modified programmatically based on external input, implement robust input validation to prevent injection attacks that could manipulate DocFX's behavior. Sanitize and validate all input data before using it to construct or modify DocFX configuration files.
    • List of Threats Mitigated:
      • Unauthorized Modification of DocFX Configuration - Severity: Medium
      • Configuration Injection Attacks Targeting DocFX - Severity: Medium (if DocFX configuration is dynamically generated)
    • Impact:
      • Unauthorized Modification of DocFX Configuration: Medium reduction. Prevents unauthorized users from altering DocFX behavior through configuration changes, potentially leading to malicious documentation generation or information disclosure.
      • Configuration Injection Attacks Targeting DocFX: Medium reduction. Mitigates the risk of attackers manipulating DocFX configuration files through injection vulnerabilities, potentially leading to malicious behavior during documentation generation or unintended site behavior.
    • Currently Implemented: Yes, file system permissions are generally restricted on the build server. DocFX configuration files are version controlled and code reviewed.
    • Missing Implementation: Formal input validation is not explicitly implemented for DocFX configuration file generation, although current processes are mostly static. Should be considered if DocFX configuration becomes more dynamic or user-influenced.

Mitigation Strategy: Restrict Access to Configuration Files

  • Description:
    1. File System Permissions: Apply strict file system permissions to the directory containing docfx.json and related DocFX configuration files. On Linux/macOS, use chmod and chown to restrict read and write access to only the necessary user accounts (e.g., the user running the DocFX build process, administrators). On Windows, use NTFS permissions.
    2. Access Control Lists (ACLs): For more granular control, use ACLs to define specific permissions for users and groups accessing DocFX configuration files.
    3. Regularly Review Permissions: Periodically review and audit file system permissions on DocFX configuration files to ensure they remain appropriately restricted and haven't been inadvertently changed.
    • List of Threats Mitigated:
      • Unauthorized Access to DocFX Configuration - Severity: Medium
      • Information Disclosure via DocFX Configuration Files - Severity: Low to Medium (if configuration contains sensitive paths or information related to DocFX setup)
    • Impact:
      • Unauthorized Access to DocFX Configuration: Medium reduction. Prevents unauthorized users from reading or modifying DocFX configuration files, protecting against tampering with DocFX behavior and potential information disclosure related to DocFX setup.
      • Information Disclosure via DocFX Configuration Files: Low to Medium reduction. Reduces the risk of sensitive information (if accidentally included in DocFX configuration) being exposed to unauthorized users.
    • Currently Implemented: Yes, file system permissions are restricted on the build server for DocFX configuration files.
    • Missing Implementation: Permissions on developer local machines might be less restrictive for DocFX configuration files. Guidance should be provided to developers to apply similar principles locally for their DocFX development environments.

Mitigation Strategy: Avoid Storing Secrets in Configuration

  • Description:
    1. Identify DocFX Related Secrets: Identify any sensitive information that might be used in your DocFX setup, such as API keys for external data sources used by DocFX, deployment keys for publishing the DocFX site, etc.
    2. Remove Secrets from DocFX Configuration Files: Ensure that docfx.json and other DocFX configuration files do not contain any secrets directly.
    3. Use Environment Variables: Store secrets as environment variables on the build server and in deployment environments used for DocFX builds and deployments. Access these environment variables within your DocFX build scripts or custom plugins as needed.
    4. Use Secure Secret Management Solutions: For more robust secret management related to DocFX, consider using dedicated secret management solutions like HashiCorp Vault, AWS Secrets Manager, Azure Key Vault, or Google Cloud Secret Manager to manage secrets used by DocFX build processes or plugins.
    5. Never Commit Secrets to Version Control: Ensure that secrets related to DocFX are never committed to version control systems. Use .gitignore or similar mechanisms to prevent accidental commits of files containing DocFX-related secrets.
    • List of Threats Mitigated:
      • Exposure of Secrets in DocFX Configuration Files - Severity: High
      • Hardcoded Secrets in DocFX Configuration or Build Scripts - Severity: High
    • Impact:
      • Exposure of Secrets in DocFX Configuration Files: High reduction. Prevents accidental or intentional exposure of sensitive credentials stored directly in DocFX configuration files, which could lead to unauthorized access to systems and services used by or related to DocFX.
      • Hardcoded Secrets in DocFX Configuration or Build Scripts: High reduction. Encourages best practices for secret management related to DocFX, reducing the risk of hardcoding secrets in DocFX configuration or build scripts, a common source of security vulnerabilities.
    • Currently Implemented: Yes, environment variables are used for sensitive DocFX configuration in the CI/CD pipeline. Secrets are not stored directly in docfx.json.
    • Missing Implementation: No formal secret management solution is currently in place for DocFX related secrets. Consider implementing a dedicated solution for enhanced security and scalability of DocFX secret management.

Mitigation Strategy: Sanitize User-Provided Content (If Applicable)

  • Description:
    1. Identify User Input Points in DocFX: Determine if your DocFX setup involves processing any user-provided content. This is less common in standard DocFX usage but might be relevant if you have custom DocFX plugins or extensions that handle user input (e.g., comments in documentation, forms integrated into the documentation site, dynamic content fetched based on user input).
    2. Implement Input Sanitization in DocFX Plugins/Extensions: For each user input point within DocFX plugins or extensions, implement robust input sanitization and output encoding.
      • Sanitization: Remove or neutralize potentially harmful HTML tags, JavaScript code, and other malicious input within DocFX plugins. Use a well-vetted sanitization library appropriate for your plugin's programming language.
      • Output Encoding: Encode user-provided content before displaying it on the DocFX generated pages to prevent browsers from interpreting it as executable code. Use context-aware encoding (e.g., HTML entity encoding, JavaScript encoding, URL encoding) within your DocFX plugins or extensions.
    3. Regularly Review Sanitization Logic in DocFX Plugins: Periodically review and update your sanitization and encoding logic within DocFX plugins to ensure it remains effective against evolving XSS attack techniques in the context of DocFX generated content.
    4. Security Testing for DocFX Plugins: Conduct security testing, including penetration testing and vulnerability scanning, specifically targeting your custom DocFX plugins to verify the effectiveness of your input sanitization measures within the DocFX environment.
    • List of Threats Mitigated:
      • Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) via User-Provided Content Processed by DocFX - Severity: High
    • Impact:
      • Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) via User-Provided Content Processed by DocFX: High reduction. Proper sanitization and encoding within DocFX plugins are crucial for preventing XSS attacks when DocFX handles user-provided content.
    • Currently Implemented: Not directly applicable in the current project as DocFX usage is primarily for static documentation generation without user input processed by DocFX plugins.
    • Missing Implementation: Should be considered and implemented if user-provided content handling is added to the DocFX setup in the future, especially through custom DocFX plugins or extensions.

Mitigation Strategy: Regularly Review Documentation Content

  • Description:
    1. Schedule DocFX Content Reviews: Establish a schedule for regularly reviewing the content of your documentation source files (Markdown, YAML, etc.) used by DocFX. Frequency depends on the rate of content changes and risk tolerance for DocFX generated content.
    2. Manual Review of DocFX Content: Conduct manual reviews of documentation content used by DocFX, looking for:
      • Unintentional Inclusion of Sensitive Information in DocFX Output: Check for accidentally included passwords, API keys, internal URLs, or other sensitive data that might be exposed in the DocFX generated site.
      • Malicious Content in DocFX Source Files: Look for any signs of malicious content in DocFX source files, such as embedded scripts, suspicious links, or attempts to inject code that could be processed by DocFX and become part of the generated site.
      • Outdated or Inaccurate Information in DocFX Content: Ensure the documentation generated by DocFX is up-to-date and accurate to prevent confusion and potential security misconfigurations based on outdated guidance presented by DocFX.
    3. Automated Checks (If Possible) for DocFX Content: Explore opportunities for automated checks on DocFX source files, such as scripts to scan for keywords associated with sensitive information or to validate links within DocFX documentation.
    4. Version Control History Review for DocFX Content: Utilize version control history to track changes to DocFX documentation content and identify any suspicious or unauthorized modifications to the source files used by DocFX.
    • List of Threats Mitigated:
      • Information Disclosure via DocFX Generated Documentation - Severity: Medium to High (depending on the sensitivity of disclosed information)
      • Social Engineering via Malicious Content in DocFX Documentation - Severity: Medium
      • Misconfigurations due to Outdated DocFX Documentation - Severity: Low to Medium
    • Impact:
      • Information Disclosure via DocFX Generated Documentation: Medium reduction. Reduces the risk of accidentally or intentionally publishing sensitive information in public documentation generated by DocFX.
      • Social Engineering via Malicious Content in DocFX Documentation: Low to Medium reduction. Minimizes the risk of attackers injecting malicious content into DocFX documentation source files that could then be rendered in the generated site and used for social engineering attacks.
      • Misconfigurations due to Outdated DocFX Documentation: Low to Medium reduction. Improves the accuracy and reliability of documentation generated by DocFX, reducing the likelihood of security misconfigurations based on outdated information presented in the DocFX site.
    • Currently Implemented: Yes, documentation content used by DocFX is reviewed as part of the regular documentation update process, but it's not a formalized security-focused review specifically for DocFX content.
    • Missing Implementation: Formalize documentation content reviews with a specific security focus and checklist for DocFX source files and generated output.

Mitigation Strategy: Vet Third-Party Plugins and Extensions

  • Description:
    1. Inventory DocFX Plugins/Extensions: Create an inventory of all DocFX plugins and extensions used in your project, including their sources (official DocFX repository, npm, third-party GitHub repos, etc.).
    2. Security Review Process for DocFX Plugins/Extensions: Establish a security review process for evaluating new DocFX plugins and extensions before they are added to the project. This process should include:
      • Source Code Review: Review the source code of the DocFX plugin/extension for potential vulnerabilities, malicious code, and adherence to secure coding practices relevant to DocFX plugin development.
      • Vulnerability Scanning: Run vulnerability scanners against the DocFX plugin/extension's dependencies (if it has any npm dependencies or other external libraries).
      • Reputation and Trustworthiness: Assess the reputation and trustworthiness of the DocFX plugin/extension developer or maintainer. Consider factors like community feedback specific to DocFX plugins, security track record in the DocFX plugin ecosystem, and responsiveness to security issues reported in DocFX plugins.
      • Principle of Least Privilege: Evaluate if the DocFX plugin/extension requires excessive permissions or access to sensitive resources within the DocFX build process or the generated site.
    3. Documentation Review for DocFX Plugins: Review the DocFX plugin/extension's documentation to understand its functionality, configuration options within DocFX, and any security considerations specific to its use in DocFX.
    4. Testing in Non-Production DocFX Environment: Thoroughly test new DocFX plugins/extensions in a non-production DocFX build environment before deploying them to production DocFX builds.
    5. Ongoing Monitoring for DocFX Plugin Security: Continuously monitor for security updates and vulnerabilities specifically related to the DocFX plugins and extensions you are using. Subscribe to plugin developer announcements or security mailing lists relevant to DocFX plugins.
    • List of Threats Mitigated:
      • Vulnerabilities in Third-Party DocFX Plugins/Extensions - Severity: High
      • Malicious DocFX Plugins/Extensions - Severity: High
      • Supply Chain Attacks via Compromised DocFX Plugins/Extensions - Severity: High
    • Impact:
      • Vulnerabilities in Third-Party DocFX Plugins/Extensions: High reduction. Proactively identifies and mitigates vulnerabilities in DocFX plugins and extensions, preventing exploitation within the DocFX build process and potentially the generated documentation site.
      • Malicious DocFX Plugins/Extensions: High reduction. Reduces the risk of incorporating intentionally malicious DocFX plugins or extensions into the DocFX setup.
      • Supply Chain Attacks via Compromised DocFX Plugins/Extensions: Medium reduction. Makes it more difficult for attackers to compromise the DocFX setup through compromised DocFX plugins or extensions.
    • Currently Implemented: Partially. Informal vetting of DocFX plugins occurs, but no formal documented process is in place specifically for DocFX plugin security reviews.
    • Missing Implementation: Formal documented security review process for third-party DocFX plugins and extensions needs to be established and consistently followed.

Mitigation Strategy: Principle of Least Privilege for Plugins

  • Description:
    1. Minimize DocFX Plugin Usage: Only install and enable DocFX plugins and extensions that are strictly necessary for your documentation requirements. Avoid using DocFX plugins that provide functionality you don't need in your DocFX setup.
    2. Review DocFX Plugin Permissions: If DocFX plugins require specific permissions or access to resources within the DocFX build process or generated site, carefully review these requirements and ensure they are justified and minimized.
    3. Disable Unnecessary Features in DocFX Plugins: If a DocFX plugin offers configurable features, disable any features that are not essential and could potentially introduce security risks within the DocFX context.
    4. Regularly Review DocFX Plugin List: Periodically review the list of installed and enabled DocFX plugins and remove any plugins that are no longer needed or are deemed unnecessary for your DocFX documentation generation.
    • List of Threats Mitigated:
      • Excessive DocFX Plugin Permissions - Severity: Medium
      • Attack Surface Expansion via Unnecessary DocFX Plugins - Severity: Medium
    • Impact:
      • Excessive DocFX Plugin Permissions: Medium reduction. Limits the potential damage if a DocFX plugin is compromised or contains vulnerabilities by restricting its access to resources within the DocFX environment.
      • Attack Surface Expansion via Unnecessary DocFX Plugins: Medium reduction. Reduces the overall attack surface of the DocFX setup by minimizing the number of DocFX plugins and extensions, thereby reducing the number of potential entry points for attackers targeting the DocFX build or generated site.
    • Currently Implemented: Partially. DocFX plugins are generally added only when needed, but no formal review process specifically focused on least privilege for DocFX plugins exists.
    • Missing Implementation: Formalize a process to review DocFX plugin permissions and ensure adherence to the principle of least privilege for DocFX plugins.

Mitigation Strategy: Regularly Update Plugins

  • Description:
    1. Track DocFX Plugin Versions: Keep track of the versions of all DocFX plugins and extensions used in your project.
    2. Monitor for DocFX Plugin Updates: Regularly check for updates to your DocFX plugins and extensions. Monitor the plugin developers' websites, GitHub repositories, or npm package pages for new releases and security announcements specifically for DocFX plugins.
    3. Apply DocFX Plugin Updates Promptly: When updates are available for DocFX plugins, especially security updates, apply them promptly. Follow the plugin developers' instructions for updating DocFX plugins.
    4. Test DocFX Plugin Updates: After updating DocFX plugins, thoroughly test your DocFX setup to ensure the updates haven't introduced any regressions or broken functionality in your DocFX documentation generation. Test in a non-production DocFX build environment first.
    5. Automate DocFX Plugin Update Process (If Possible): Explore opportunities to automate the DocFX plugin update process, such as using dependency management tools or scripts to check for and apply updates to DocFX plugins.
    • List of Threats Mitigated:
      • Vulnerabilities in DocFX Plugins/Extensions - Severity: Medium to High (depending on the vulnerability)
    • Impact:
      • Vulnerabilities in DocFX Plugins/Extensions: Medium to High reduction. Reduces the risk of exploits targeting known vulnerabilities in DocFX plugins and extensions by ensuring they are patched and up-to-date.
    • Currently Implemented: Yes, DocFX plugins are updated periodically as part of general maintenance, but it's not a strictly enforced or automated process specifically for DocFX plugins.
    • Missing Implementation: Implement a more formalized and potentially automated process for tracking and updating DocFX plugins and extensions, especially for security updates related to DocFX plugins.

Mitigation Strategy: Secure Plugin Development Practices (If Developing Custom Plugins)

  • Description:
    1. Secure Coding Training for DocFX Plugin Development: Provide secure coding training to developers who are involved in developing custom DocFX plugins, focusing on security considerations specific to DocFX plugin development.
    2. Security Code Reviews for DocFX Plugins: Conduct thorough security code reviews for all custom DocFX plugin code before deployment. Involve security experts familiar with DocFX plugin architecture in the code review process.
    3. Input Validation and Output Encoding in DocFX Plugins: Implement robust input validation and output encoding in custom DocFX plugins to prevent vulnerabilities like XSS and injection attacks within the context of DocFX generated content.
    4. Principle of Least Privilege for Custom DocFX Plugins: Design custom DocFX plugins to operate with the minimum necessary permissions and access to resources within the DocFX build process and generated site.
    5. Vulnerability Scanning for Custom DocFX Plugins: Run vulnerability scanners against custom DocFX plugin code and its dependencies, specifically looking for vulnerabilities relevant to DocFX plugin environments.
    6. Regular Security Testing of Custom DocFX Plugins: Conduct regular security testing, including penetration testing and vulnerability scanning, of custom DocFX plugins to identify and address any security issues specific to their integration with DocFX.
    7. Dependency Management for Custom DocFX Plugins: Follow secure dependency management practices for custom DocFX plugin dependencies, including dependency scanning and regular updates for libraries used in DocFX plugins.
    • List of Threats Mitigated:
      • Vulnerabilities in Custom DocFX Plugins - Severity: High
      • Malicious Functionality in Custom DocFX Plugins - Severity: High
    • Impact:
      • Vulnerabilities in Custom DocFX Plugins: High reduction. Significantly reduces the risk of introducing security vulnerabilities into custom DocFX plugins through secure development practices tailored for DocFX plugin development.
      • Malicious Functionality in Custom DocFX Plugins: High reduction. Code reviews and secure development practices help prevent the introduction of intentionally malicious functionality into custom DocFX plugins.
    • Currently Implemented: Not directly applicable as no custom DocFX plugins are currently being developed.
    • Missing Implementation: These practices should be implemented if custom DocFX plugin development is undertaken in the future.