Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
61 lines (50 loc) · 5.87 KB

threat-modeling.md

File metadata and controls

61 lines (50 loc) · 5.87 KB

Threat Model Analysis for elastic/elasticsearch-net

Threat: Man-in-the-Middle (MITM) Attack with Spoofed Elasticsearch Response

  • Description: An attacker intercepts the network traffic between the application and the Elasticsearch cluster. They present a fake TLS certificate (or bypass TLS entirely if misconfigured) and return forged responses to the application.
    • Impact: The application receives and processes incorrect data, potentially leading to incorrect decisions, data corruption, or even execution of malicious logic if the response is used to control application flow.
    • Affected Component: Connection, Transport, underlying .NET networking stack (if TLS is misconfigured at the OS level).
    • Risk Severity: Critical
    • Mitigation Strategies:
      • Strict HTTPS Enforcement: Configure elasticsearch-net to only use HTTPS. Do not allow any fallback to HTTP.
      • Robust Certificate Validation: Implement rigorous certificate validation. This includes:
        • Checking the certificate's validity period.
        • Verifying the certificate's signature chain up to a trusted root CA.
        • Checking for certificate revocation (using OCSP or CRLs).
        • Potentially using certificate pinning (though this can be brittle).
      • Client Certificate Authentication (mTLS): If the Elasticsearch cluster supports it, use mutual TLS (mTLS) to provide an additional layer of authentication and prevent spoofing.

Threat: DNS Spoofing/Hijacking

  • Description: An attacker compromises the DNS resolution process, causing the application to connect to a malicious server controlled by the attacker instead of the legitimate Elasticsearch cluster.
    • Impact: Similar to MITM, the application receives and processes incorrect data, leading to data corruption, incorrect decisions, or potential code execution.
    • Affected Component: Connection, Transport, SniffingConnectionPool (if sniffing is enabled and relies on DNS).
    • Risk Severity: Critical
    • Mitigation Strategies:
      • DNSSEC: Use DNSSEC (DNS Security Extensions) to ensure the integrity and authenticity of DNS responses.
      • Secure DNS Servers: Use trusted and secure DNS servers.
      • Monitor DNS Resolution: Monitor DNS resolution for the Elasticsearch cluster to detect any anomalies.
      • Hardcoded IP Addresses (If Feasible): In highly controlled environments, consider using hardcoded IP addresses for the Elasticsearch nodes.

Threat: Custom Serializer Tampering

  • Description: If a custom serializer/deserializer is used with elasticsearch-net, an attacker might exploit vulnerabilities in that custom component to inject malicious data or manipulate the serialization/deserialization process.
    • Impact: Potentially arbitrary code execution, data corruption, or other security issues, depending on the vulnerability in the custom serializer.
    • Affected Component: Custom serializer/deserializer implementation used with IElasticsearchSerializer.
    • Risk Severity: Critical (if the custom serializer has vulnerabilities)
    • Mitigation Strategies:
      • Thoroughly Secure Custom Serializer: If using a custom serializer, ensure it is rigorously tested and secured against common serialization vulnerabilities (e.g., deserialization attacks).
      • Prefer Built-in Serializer: Whenever possible, use the built-in serializer provided by elasticsearch-net, as it is generally well-tested and maintained.

Threat: Exposure of Sensitive Data in Error Messages

  • Description: elasticsearch-net exceptions or error messages (if not handled properly) might reveal sensitive information about the Elasticsearch cluster, such as internal IP addresses, index names, or even query details.
    • Impact: Leakage of sensitive information that could be used by an attacker to further compromise the system.
    • Affected Component: IConnection, Transport, exception handling in application code.
    • Risk Severity: High
    • Mitigation Strategies:
      • Careful Exception Handling: Implement robust exception handling. Catch ElasticsearchClientException and other relevant exceptions. Log detailed error information internally for debugging, but return generic error messages to the user. Never expose raw Elasticsearch error details to end-users.
      • Custom Error Messages: Create custom error messages that provide user-friendly information without revealing sensitive details.

Threat: Unauthorized Access via Misconfigured Credentials

  • Description: The application uses overly permissive Elasticsearch credentials, or the credentials are leaked or compromised.
    • Impact: An attacker gains unauthorized access to the Elasticsearch cluster with elevated privileges.
    • Affected Component: ConnectionSettings, application configuration.
    • Risk Severity: Critical
    • Mitigation Strategies:
      • Principle of Least Privilege: Use credentials with the minimum necessary permissions.
      • Secure Credential Storage: Store credentials securely (e.g., using environment variables, a secrets management system, or secure configuration files). Do not hardcode credentials in the application code.
      • Regular Credential Rotation: Rotate Elasticsearch credentials regularly.
      • Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA): If supported by your Elasticsearch setup, use multi-factor authentication for access.