Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
151 lines (117 loc) · 13.9 KB

attack-tree.md

File metadata and controls

151 lines (117 loc) · 13.9 KB

Attack Tree Analysis for jstedfast/mailkit

Objective: Compromise Application Using MailKit

Attack Tree Visualization

Root: Compromise Application Using MailKit **[CRITICAL NODE]**
├─── 1. Exploit MailKit Vulnerabilities Directly **[CRITICAL NODE]**
│    └─── 1.1.4. Denial of Service (DoS) via Protocol Abuse **[HIGH RISK PATH]**
│         └─── 1.1.4.1. Send malformed or excessively large emails designed to consume excessive resources during parsing, leading to application DoS.
├─── 1.2. Content Processing Vulnerabilities **[CRITICAL NODE]**
│    ├─── 1.2.1. Attachment Handling Vulnerabilities **[HIGH RISK PATH]** **[CRITICAL NODE]**
│    │    ├─── 1.2.1.1. Exploit vulnerabilities in attachment parsing libraries used by MailKit (if any, or within MailKit's own attachment handling logic).
│    │    │    └─── 1.2.1.1.a. Trigger arbitrary code execution by sending email with a malicious attachment (e.g., crafted ZIP, PDF, or other file types). **[HIGH RISK PATH]**
│    │    ├─── 1.2.1.2. Path Traversal via Attachment Filenames **[HIGH RISK PATH]**
│    │    │    └─── 1.2.1.2.a. Send email with attachment filename containing path traversal sequences to write files outside intended directories (if application saves attachments based on MailKit's parsing without sanitization).
│    │    └─── 1.2.1.3. Denial of Service via Malicious Attachments **[HIGH RISK PATH]**
│    │         └─── 1.2.1.3.a. Send email with extremely large or deeply nested attachments (e.g., ZIP bomb) to cause resource exhaustion when processed by MailKit or the application.
│    ├─── 1.2.2. HTML Email Rendering Vulnerabilities (Indirect via Application) **[HIGH RISK PATH]**
│    │    └─── 1.2.2.1. Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) via HTML Email Content **[HIGH RISK PATH]**
│    │         └─── 1.2.2.1.a. Send email with malicious JavaScript in HTML body. If application renders this HTML without proper sanitization after retrieving it using MailKit, XSS vulnerability can be exploited in the application's frontend. (Note: MailKit itself doesn't render HTML, but facilitates retrieval).
│    └─── 1.2.3. Email Header Injection Vulnerabilities (Indirect via Application) **[HIGH RISK PATH]**
│         └─── 1.2.3.1. Manipulate email headers (e.g., `From`, `To`, `Subject`) if application uses MailKit to *send* emails and doesn't properly sanitize input used to construct headers. This is more of an application-level vulnerability facilitated by MailKit's sending capabilities.
├─── 1.3. Authentication and Authorization Vulnerabilities (Less likely in MailKit itself, more in application usage) **[HIGH RISK PATH]** **[CRITICAL NODE]**
│    ├─── 1.3.1. Credential Exposure via MailKit Logging/Error Handling **[HIGH RISK PATH]**
│    │    └─── 1.3.1.1. MailKit logs sensitive information like passwords or authentication tokens in logs or error messages, which attacker can access. (Likely application configuration issue, but triggered by MailKit usage).
│    └─── 1.3.2. Insecure Credential Storage by Application (Indirect) **[HIGH RISK PATH]**
│    │    └─── 1.3.2.1. Application stores email credentials insecurely (e.g., plain text in configuration files) which are then used by MailKit. This is an application vulnerability, but directly impacts MailKit's security context.
└─── 2. Exploit Dependencies of MailKit (Supply Chain Attack) **[HIGH RISK PATH]** **[CRITICAL NODE]**
     └─── 2.1. Compromise a Dependency Library **[HIGH RISK PATH]**
          └─── 2.1.1. Vulnerability in a library that MailKit depends on (directly or indirectly) is exploited to compromise MailKit and subsequently the application. **[HIGH RISK PATH]**
               └─── 2.1.1.1. Identify and exploit known vulnerabilities in MailKit's dependencies (check dependency tree and known CVEs). **[HIGH RISK PATH]**

Attack Tree Path: Root: Compromise Application Using MailKit

This is the ultimate goal of the attacker. Success means gaining unauthorized access or control over the application using MailKit.

Attack Tree Path: 1. Exploit MailKit Vulnerabilities Directly

This branch focuses on directly exploiting potential vulnerabilities within the MailKit library itself.

Attack Tree Path: 1.1.4. Denial of Service (DoS) via Protocol Abuse

  • Attack Vector: 1.1.4.1. Send malformed or excessively large emails designed to consume excessive resources during parsing, leading to application DoS. * Likelihood: Medium * Impact: Medium (Application unavailability, service disruption) * Effort: Low * Skill Level: Low * Detection Difficulty: Low * Description: Attackers send specially crafted emails that exploit weaknesses in MailKit's protocol parsing logic to cause resource exhaustion (CPU, memory) and make the application unavailable.

Attack Tree Path: 1.2. Content Processing Vulnerabilities

This branch focuses on vulnerabilities related to how MailKit processes email content, especially attachments and HTML.

Attack Tree Path: 1.2.1. Attachment Handling Vulnerabilities

This is a critical area due to the inherent risks associated with processing attachments.

Attack Tree Path: 1.2.1.1. Exploit vulnerabilities in attachment parsing libraries used by MailKit (if any, or within MailKit's own attachment handling logic).

  • 1.2.1.1.a. Trigger arbitrary code execution by sending email with a malicious attachment (e.g., crafted ZIP, PDF, or other file types). [HIGH RISK PATH] * Likelihood: Low to Medium * Impact: High (Code Execution, Full Compromise) * Effort: Medium * Skill Level: Intermediate to Advanced * Detection Difficulty: Medium * Description: Attackers craft malicious attachments that exploit vulnerabilities in file format parsers used by MailKit or the application to achieve arbitrary code execution on the server.

Attack Tree Path: 1.2.1.2. Path Traversal via Attachment Filenames

  • 1.2.1.2.a. Send email with attachment filename containing path traversal sequences to write files outside intended directories (if application saves attachments based on MailKit's parsing without sanitization). * Likelihood: Medium * Impact: Medium (File system access, potential for further compromise) * Effort: Low * Skill Level: Low * Detection Difficulty: Medium * Description: Attackers use specially crafted attachment filenames with ".." sequences to bypass directory restrictions and write files to unintended locations on the server if the application saves attachments without proper sanitization.

Attack Tree Path: 1.2.1.3. Denial of Service via Malicious Attachments

  • 1.2.1.3.a. Send email with extremely large or deeply nested attachments (e.g., ZIP bomb) to cause resource exhaustion when processed by MailKit or the application. * Likelihood: Medium * Impact: Medium (Application unavailability, service disruption) * Effort: Low * Skill Level: Low * Detection Difficulty: Low * Description: Attackers send emails with attachments designed to consume excessive resources (CPU, memory, disk space) when processed, leading to a denial of service. ZIP bombs are a common example.

Attack Tree Path: 1.2.2. HTML Email Rendering Vulnerabilities (Indirect via Application)

  • 1.2.2.1. Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) via HTML Email Content [HIGH RISK PATH] * 1.2.2.1.a. Send email with malicious JavaScript in HTML body. If application renders this HTML without proper sanitization after retrieving it using MailKit, XSS vulnerability can be exploited in the application's frontend. (Note: MailKit itself doesn't render HTML, but facilitates retrieval). * Likelihood: Medium to High * Impact: Medium to High (XSS, session hijacking, account compromise in the application) * Effort: Low * Skill Level: Low to Intermediate * Detection Difficulty: Medium * Description: Attackers embed malicious JavaScript in HTML emails. If the application retrieves and renders these emails in a web browser without proper sanitization, XSS vulnerabilities can be exploited in the application's frontend, even though MailKit itself is not rendering the HTML.

Attack Tree Path: 1.2.3. Email Header Injection Vulnerabilities (Indirect via Application)

  • 1.2.3.1. Manipulate email headers (e.g., From, To, Subject) if application uses MailKit to send emails and doesn't properly sanitize input used to construct headers. This is more of an application-level vulnerability facilitated by MailKit's sending capabilities. * Likelihood: Medium * Impact: Medium (Spamming, phishing, email spoofing, potentially more) * Effort: Low * Skill Level: Low * Detection Difficulty: Medium * Description: If the application uses MailKit to send emails and constructs email headers based on user input without proper sanitization, attackers can inject malicious headers. This can be used for spamming, phishing, or manipulating email routing.

Attack Tree Path: 1.3. Authentication and Authorization Vulnerabilities (Less likely in MailKit itself, more in application usage)

This branch highlights vulnerabilities related to how the application handles authentication credentials used by MailKit.

Attack Tree Path: 1.3.1. Credential Exposure via MailKit Logging/Error Handling

  • 1.3.1.1. MailKit logs sensitive information like passwords or authentication tokens in logs or error messages, which attacker can access. (Likely application configuration issue, but triggered by MailKit usage). * Likelihood: Medium * Impact: High (Credential compromise, access to email account and potentially application) * Effort: Low * Skill Level: Low to Medium * Detection Difficulty: Low to Medium * Description: If MailKit or the application's logging configuration is not properly secured, sensitive credentials (passwords, tokens) might be logged in plain text, making them accessible to attackers who gain access to the logs.

Attack Tree Path: 1.3.2. Insecure Credential Storage by Application (Indirect)

  • 1.3.2.1. Application stores email credentials insecurely (e.g., plain text in configuration files) which are then used by MailKit. This is an application vulnerability, but directly impacts MailKit's security context. * Likelihood: Medium to High * Impact: High (Credential compromise, access to email account and potentially application) * Effort: Low * Skill Level: Low * Detection Difficulty: Low * Description: If the application stores email credentials used by MailKit in an insecure manner (e.g., plain text in configuration files, database without encryption), attackers who gain access to these storage locations can steal the credentials.

Attack Tree Path: 2. Exploit Dependencies of MailKit (Supply Chain Attack)

This branch focuses on the risk of vulnerabilities in MailKit's dependencies.

Attack Tree Path: 2.1. Compromise a Dependency Library

  • 2.1.1. Vulnerability in a library that MailKit depends on (directly or indirectly) is exploited to compromise MailKit and subsequently the application. [HIGH RISK PATH] * 2.1.1.1. Identify and exploit known vulnerabilities in MailKit's dependencies (check dependency tree and known CVEs). [HIGH RISK PATH] * Likelihood: Low to Medium * Impact: High (Potentially full compromise) * Effort: Medium * Skill Level: Intermediate to Advanced * Detection Difficulty: Medium to High * Description: Attackers identify and exploit known vulnerabilities in libraries that MailKit depends on. By compromising a dependency, they can indirectly compromise MailKit and subsequently the application that uses it. This is a supply chain attack.