Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
140 lines (121 loc) · 8.55 KB

attack-tree.md

File metadata and controls

140 lines (121 loc) · 8.55 KB

Attack Tree Analysis for jstedfast/mailkit

Objective: Gain unauthorized access to email data, manipulate email content, or disrupt email services of the application using MailKit.

Attack Tree Visualization

                                  [Attacker's Goal: Gain unauthorized access to email data, manipulate email content, or disrupt email services]
                                                    /                                 |                                 
                                                   /                                  |                                                                   
              {1. Unauthorized Email Access/Manipulation}          [2. Denial of Service (DoS)]             
              /              |              \                      /              |              \                    
             /               |               \                    /               |               \

{1.1 Vuln in Parsing} [1.2 Auth Bypass] [1.3 Injection] {2.1 Resource Exh}
/ | \ / | \ / | \ / | \
/ | \ / | \ / | \ / | \
<<1.1.1 MIME Parsing Bugs>> [1.1.2 S/MIME] [1.1.3 PGP] {1.2.1 Weak Auth} [1.3.2 Header Inj] {2.1.1 Mem Exh} {2.1.2 CPU Exh} {2.1.3 Conn Exh} <<3.3.1 Cred Exposure>>

Attack Tree Path: 1. Unauthorized Email Access/Manipulation

  • 1.1 Vulnerabilities in Parsing ({ }):

    • <<1.1.1 MIME Parsing Bugs>> (Critical Node):

      • Description: Exploiting vulnerabilities in MailKit's MIME parsing logic to achieve arbitrary code execution, data exfiltration, or denial of service. This involves crafting malformed MIME messages to trigger buffer overflows, out-of-bounds reads/writes, or other memory corruption issues.
      • Likelihood: Medium
      • Impact: Very High
      • Effort: Medium to High
      • Skill Level: Intermediate to Advanced
      • Detection Difficulty: Medium to Hard
      • Mitigation:
        • Extensive fuzz testing of the MIME parser with a wide variety of malformed and valid inputs.
        • Regular security audits and code reviews of the parsing logic.
        • Staying up-to-date with MailKit security patches and updates.
        • Consider using memory-safe languages or libraries if feasible.

    • [1.1.2 S/MIME Parsing/Verification Issues]:

      • Description: Bypassing S/MIME signature checks, decrypting messages without the correct key, or injecting malicious content into signed messages by exploiting vulnerabilities in MailKit's S/MIME handling.
      • Likelihood: Low to Medium
      • Impact: High
      • Effort: High
      • Skill Level: Advanced
      • Detection Difficulty: Hard
      • Mitigation:
        • Thorough testing of S/MIME functionality with various certificate scenarios (valid, invalid, expired, revoked, weak keys).
        • Enforcing strict certificate chain validation.
        • Regularly updating MailKit and cryptographic libraries.

    • [1.1.3 PGP Parsing/Verification Issues]:

      • Description: Similar to S/MIME, exploiting vulnerabilities in MailKit's PGP handling to bypass signature checks, decrypting messages without the correct key, or injecting malicious content.
      • Likelihood: Low to Medium
      • Impact: High
      • Effort: High
      • Skill Level: Advanced
      • Detection Difficulty: Hard
      • Mitigation:
        • Thorough testing of PGP functionality with various key scenarios (valid, invalid, expired, revoked, weak algorithms).
        • Enforcing proper key validation and revocation checks.
        • Regularly updating MailKit and cryptographic libraries.

  • 1.2 Authentication Bypass:

    • {1.2.1 Weak Authentication Handling}:
      • Description: Bypassing authentication mechanisms to gain unauthorized access to mail servers. This could involve exploiting weak passwords, credential stuffing, or vulnerabilities in the authentication protocol implementation (SASL, OAuth 2.0). This is primarily an application-level concern, but how the application uses MailKit's API is crucial.
      • Likelihood: Medium
      • Impact: High
      • Effort: Low to Medium
      • Skill Level: Novice to Intermediate
      • Detection Difficulty: Medium
      • Mitigation:
        • Enforcing strong password policies.
        • Using secure authentication mechanisms (e.g., OAuth 2.0 with proper token validation).
        • Implementing multi-factor authentication (MFA).
        • Avoiding storing credentials directly in the code; using secure credential storage.
        • Monitoring for failed login attempts and implementing account lockout policies.

  • 1.3 Injection:

    • [1.3.2 Header Injection]:
      • Description: Injecting malicious email headers to conduct phishing attacks, spam, or email spoofing.
      • Likelihood: Medium
      • Impact: Medium to High
      • Effort: Low to Medium
      • Skill Level: Novice to Intermediate
      • Detection Difficulty: Medium
      • Mitigation:
        • Validate and sanitize all user-supplied header values.
        • Encode header values properly.
        • Consider using a whitelist of allowed headers.

Attack Tree Path: 2. Denial of Service (DoS)

  • 2.1 Resource Exhaustion ({ }):

    • {2.1.1 Memory Exhaustion}:

      • Description: Causing the application to consume excessive memory by sending crafted emails (e.g., large attachments, deeply nested MIME structures), leading to a denial-of-service condition.
      • Likelihood: Medium
      • Impact: Medium to High
      • Effort: Low to Medium
      • Skill Level: Novice to Intermediate
      • Detection Difficulty: Easy to Medium
      • Mitigation:
        • Implement limits on email size, attachment size, and MIME nesting depth.
        • Monitor memory usage and set appropriate resource limits.

    • {2.1.2 CPU Exhaustion}:

      • Description: Causing the application to consume excessive CPU resources by sending crafted emails with complex MIME structures or triggering computationally expensive operations (e.g., S/MIME decryption with weak algorithms).
      • Likelihood: Medium
      • Impact: Medium to High
      • Effort: Low to Medium
      • Skill Level: Novice to Intermediate
      • Detection Difficulty: Easy to Medium
      • Mitigation:
        • Implement timeouts for email processing operations.
        • Monitor CPU usage and set appropriate resource limits.
        • Avoid using weak cryptographic algorithms.

    • {2.1.3 Connection Exhaustion}:

      • Description: Exhausting available connections to mail server by opening a large number of connections.
      • Likelihood: Medium
      • Impact: Medium to High
      • Effort: Low
      • Skill Level: Novice
      • Detection Difficulty: Easy
      • Mitigation:
        • Implement connection limits and rate limiting.
        • Monitor the number of open connections.

Attack Tree Path: 3. Information Disclosure

  • <<3.3.1 Credential Exposure>> (Critical Node):
    • Description: Exposing MailKit configuration credentials (server addresses, usernames, passwords) due to improper storage or handling, leading to unauthorized access. This is primarily an application-level vulnerability.
    • Likelihood: Low
    • Impact: Very High
    • Effort: Low to Medium
    • Skill Level: Novice to Intermediate
    • Detection Difficulty: Medium to Hard
    • Mitigation:
      • Store configuration securely (e.g., using environment variables, a secure configuration management system, or a secrets vault).
      • Never store credentials directly in the code.
      • Implement least privilege principles – only grant the necessary permissions to the MailKit user account.
      • Regularly audit configuration and access controls.