Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
178 lines (158 loc) · 17.3 KB

attack-tree.md

File metadata and controls

178 lines (158 loc) · 17.3 KB

Attack Tree Analysis for nopsolutions/nopcommerce

Objective: Compromise nopCommerce Application via High-Risk Attack Paths

Attack Tree Visualization

Compromise nopCommerce Application **[CRITICAL NODE]**
├───(OR) Exploit nopCommerce Vulnerabilities **[HIGH RISK PATH]**
│   ├───(OR) Exploit Code Vulnerabilities **[HIGH RISK PATH]**
│   │   ├───(OR) SQL Injection (SQLi) **[HIGH RISK PATH]**
│   │   │   ├───(AND) Identify SQL Injection Point
│   │   │   │   ├───(OR) User Login/Registration     [L: M, Imp: Hi, Eff: Me, Sk: In, Det: Mo] **[CRITICAL NODE]**
│   │   │   │   └───(OR) Plugin-Specific Queries     [L: H, Imp: Hi, Eff: Me, Sk: In, Det: Mo] **[CRITICAL NODE]**
│   │   │   └───(AND) Execute Malicious SQL Query     [L: H, Imp: Hi, Eff: Me, Sk: In, Det: Mo] **[CRITICAL NODE]**
│   │   │       ├───(OR) Data Exfiltration (Customer Data, Admin Credentials, Product Info) [L: H, Imp: Hi, Eff: Me, Sk: In, Det: Mo] **[CRITICAL NODE]**
│   │   │       └───(OR) Privilege Escalation (Gain Admin Access via SQL Injection)       [L: M, Imp: Cr, Eff: Me, Sk: In, Det: Mo] **[CRITICAL NODE]**
│   │   ├───(OR) Authentication/Authorization Bypass **[HIGH RISK PATH]**
│   │   │   ├───(AND) Identify Authentication Flaw
│   │   │   │   ├───(OR) Privilege Escalation Vulnerabilities in Admin Roles [L: L, Imp: Hi, Eff: Me, Sk: In, Det: Mo] **[CRITICAL NODE]**
│   │   │   │   └───(OR) API Authentication Bypass (if APIs are exposed) [L: L, Imp: Hi, Eff: Me, Sk: In, Det: Mo] **[CRITICAL NODE]**
│   │   │   └───(AND) Exploit Flaw to Gain Unauthorized Access [L: M, Imp: Hi, Eff: Me, Sk: In, Det: Mo] **[CRITICAL NODE]**
│   │   │       ├───(OR) Access Admin Panel              [L: M, Imp: Cr, Eff: Me, Sk: In, Det: Mo] **[CRITICAL NODE]**
│   │   │       └───(OR) Access Customer Accounts          [L: M, Imp: Hi, Eff: Me, Sk: In, Det: Mo] **[CRITICAL NODE]**
│   │   ├───(OR) Remote Code Execution (RCE) **[HIGH RISK PATH]** **[CRITICAL NODE]**
│   │   │   ├───(AND) Identify RCE Vulnerability
│   │   │   │   ├───(OR) Deserialization Vulnerabilities (Less common in modern .NET, but possible in older versions or plugins) [L: L, Imp: Cr, Eff: Hi, Sk: Ex, Det: Di] **[CRITICAL NODE]**
│   │   │   │   ├───(OR) File Upload Vulnerabilities (e.g., Plugin Upload, Theme Upload) [L: M, Imp: Cr, Eff: Me, Sk: In, Det: Mo] **[CRITICAL NODE]**
│   │   │   │   └───(OR) Code Injection in Configuration Files (Less likely, but consider if custom config parsing is used) [L: VL, Imp: Cr, Eff: Hi, Sk: Ex, Det: Di] **[CRITICAL NODE]**
│   │   │   └───(AND) Execute Arbitrary Code on Server  [L: M, Imp: Cr, Eff: Me, Sk: In, Det: Mo] **[CRITICAL NODE]**
│   │   │       ├───(OR) Gain Full Control of Server      [L: M, Imp: Cr, Eff: Me, Sk: In, Det: Mo] **[CRITICAL NODE]**
│   │   │       └───(OR) Install Backdoor               [L: M, Imp: Cr, Eff: Me, Sk: In, Det: Mo] **[CRITICAL NODE]**
│   │   │       └───(OR) Data Breach                    [L: M, Imp: Hi, Eff: Me, Sk: In, Det: Mo] **[CRITICAL NODE]**
│   ├───(OR) Exploit Configuration/Deployment Weaknesses **[HIGH RISK PATH]**
│   │   ├───(OR) Default Credentials **[HIGH RISK PATH]** **[CRITICAL NODE]**
│   │   │   ├───(AND) Attempt Default Credentials for Admin Account [L: M, Imp: Cr, Eff: Lo, Sk: No, Det: Ea] **[CRITICAL NODE]**
│   │   │   │   └───(OR) Common nopCommerce Default Credentials (if any exist or are poorly changed) [L: M, Imp: Cr, Eff: Lo, Sk: No, Det: Ea] **[CRITICAL NODE]**
│   │   │   └───(AND) Gain Access to Admin Panel        [L: M, Imp: Cr, Eff: Lo, Sk: No, Det: Ea] **[CRITICAL NODE]**
│   │   │       └───(OR) Full Application Control      [L: M, Imp: Cr, Eff: Lo, Sk: No, Det: Ea] **[CRITICAL NODE]**
│   │   ├───(OR) Misconfigured Permissions
│   │   │   └───(AND) Exploit Permissions to Access Sensitive Files [L: L, Imp: Hi, Eff: Me, Sk: In, Det: Mo] **[CRITICAL NODE]**
│   │   │       ├───(OR) Configuration Files (e.g., connection strings) [L: L, Imp: Hi, Eff: Me, Sk: In, Det: Mo] **[CRITICAL NODE]**
│   │   │       └───(OR) Database Backups                [L: L, Imp: Hi, Eff: Me, Sk: In, Det: Mo] **[CRITICAL NODE]**
│   │   │       └───(OR) Source Code (if accessible)     [L: VL, Imp: Hi, Eff: Me, Sk: In, Det: Mo] **[CRITICAL NODE]**
│   │   └───(OR) Unpatched nopCommerce Version **[HIGH RISK PATH]**
│   │       └───(AND) Exploit Known Vulnerabilities in that Version [L: M, Imp: Hi, Eff: Me, Sk: In, Det: Mo] **[CRITICAL NODE]**
│   │           ├───(OR) Publicly Available Exploits    [L: M, Imp: Hi, Eff: Lo, Sk: No, Det: Ea] **[CRITICAL NODE]**
│   │           └───(OR) Research and Develop Custom Exploit [L: L, Imp: Hi, Eff: Hi, Sk: Ex, Det: Di] **[CRITICAL NODE]**
│   └───(OR) Exploit Plugin/Extension Vulnerabilities **[HIGH RISK PATH]** **[CRITICAL NODE]**
│       └───(AND) Exploit Vulnerability in Plugin      [L: H, Imp: Hi, Eff: Me, Sk: In, Det: Mo] **[CRITICAL NODE]**
│           ├───(OR) SQL Injection in Plugin          [L: H, Imp: Hi, Eff: Me, Sk: In, Det: Mo] **[CRITICAL NODE]**
│           ├───(OR) File Upload Vulnerability in Plugin [L: M, Imp: Cr, Eff: Me, Sk: In, Det: Mo] **[CRITICAL NODE]**
│           ├───(OR) Authentication Bypass in Plugin  [L: M, Imp: Hi, Eff: Me, Sk: In, Det: Mo] **[CRITICAL NODE]**
│           ├───(OR) RCE in Plugin                    [L: M, Imp: Cr, Eff: Me, Sk: In, Det: Mo] **[CRITICAL NODE]**
└───(OR) Exploit Dependencies Vulnerabilities
    └───(AND) Exploit Vulnerability in Dependency   [L: M, Imp: Hi, Eff: Me, Sk: In, Det: Mo] **[CRITICAL NODE]**
        ├───(OR) Publicly Available Exploits for Dependency [L: M, Imp: Hi, Eff: Lo, Sk: No, Det: Ea] **[CRITICAL NODE]**
        └───(OR) Develop Custom Exploit for Dependency [L: L, Imp: Hi, Eff: Hi, Sk: Ex, Det: Di] **[CRITICAL NODE]**

Attack Tree Path: 1. Exploit nopCommerce Vulnerabilities -> Exploit Code Vulnerabilities -> SQL Injection (SQLi) [HIGH RISK PATH]:

  • Attack Vectors:
    • User Login/Registration [CRITICAL NODE]:
      • Maliciously crafted input in username or password fields during login or registration to inject SQL queries.
      • Exploiting stored procedures or database functions used in authentication logic.
    • Plugin-Specific Queries [CRITICAL NODE]:
      • Vulnerabilities in custom SQL queries within plugins, often due to lack of parameterized queries or input sanitization.
      • Exploiting plugin functionalities that interact with the database without proper security measures.
  • Impact:
    • Data Exfiltration (Customer Data, Admin Credentials, Product Info) [CRITICAL NODE]: Stealing sensitive information from the database.
    • Privilege Escalation (Gain Admin Access via SQL Injection) [CRITICAL NODE]: Modifying database records to grant attacker administrative privileges.

Attack Tree Path: 2. Exploit nopCommerce Vulnerabilities -> Exploit Code Vulnerabilities -> Authentication/Authorization Bypass [HIGH RISK PATH]:

  • Attack Vectors:
    • Privilege Escalation Vulnerabilities in Admin Roles [CRITICAL NODE]:
      • Exploiting flaws in role-based access control (RBAC) to elevate privileges from a lower-level user to an administrator.
      • Bypassing checks that should restrict access to admin functionalities based on user roles.
    • API Authentication Bypass (if APIs are exposed) [CRITICAL NODE]:
      • Exploiting vulnerabilities in API authentication mechanisms, such as weak tokens, insecure OAuth implementations, or lack of proper authentication.
      • Directly accessing administrative or sensitive APIs without proper authorization.
  • Impact:
    • Exploit Flaw to Gain Unauthorized Access [CRITICAL NODE]: Successfully bypassing authentication or authorization.
    • Access Admin Panel [CRITICAL NODE]: Gaining unauthorized access to the nopCommerce administration panel.
    • Access Customer Accounts [CRITICAL NODE]: Gaining unauthorized access to customer accounts and their data.

Attack Tree Path: 3. Exploit nopCommerce Vulnerabilities -> Exploit Code Vulnerabilities -> Remote Code Execution (RCE) [HIGH RISK PATH] [CRITICAL NODE]:

  • Attack Vectors:
    • Deserialization Vulnerabilities (Less common in modern .NET, but possible in older versions or plugins) [CRITICAL NODE]:
      • Exploiting insecure deserialization of objects, allowing execution of arbitrary code when malicious serialized data is processed.
      • Targeting older versions of .NET or plugins that might use vulnerable deserialization patterns.
    • File Upload Vulnerabilities (e.g., Plugin Upload, Theme Upload) [CRITICAL NODE]:
      • Uploading malicious files (e.g., ASPX, PHP, executable) through plugin or theme upload functionalities.
      • Bypassing file type validation or insufficient security checks on uploaded files.
    • Code Injection in Configuration Files (Less likely, but consider if custom config parsing is used) [CRITICAL NODE]:
      • Injecting malicious code into configuration files if the application uses custom configuration parsing logic that is vulnerable.
      • Manipulating configuration settings to execute arbitrary commands.
  • Impact:
    • Execute Arbitrary Code on Server [CRITICAL NODE]: Successfully running attacker-controlled code on the nopCommerce server.
    • Gain Full Control of Server [CRITICAL NODE]: Achieving complete administrative control over the server.
    • Install Backdoor [CRITICAL NODE]: Establishing persistent access to the server for future attacks.
    • Data Breach [CRITICAL NODE]: Stealing sensitive data from the server and application.

Attack Tree Path: 4. Exploit Configuration/Deployment Weaknesses -> Default Credentials [HIGH RISK PATH] [CRITICAL NODE]:

  • Attack Vectors:
    • Attempt Default Credentials for Admin Account [CRITICAL NODE]:
      • Trying common default usernames and passwords for the nopCommerce administrator account.
      • Exploiting situations where administrators fail to change default credentials during installation.
    • Common nopCommerce Default Credentials (if any exist or are poorly changed) [CRITICAL NODE]:
      • Utilizing publicly known default credentials if nopCommerce or specific plugins have them.
      • Exploiting weak or easily guessable passwords set by administrators.
  • Impact:
    • Gain Access to Admin Panel [CRITICAL NODE]: Successfully logging into the nopCommerce administration panel with default credentials.
    • Full Application Control [CRITICAL NODE]: Achieving complete control over the nopCommerce application and its data.

Attack Tree Path: 5. Exploit Configuration/Deployment Weaknesses -> Misconfigured Permissions -> Exploit Permissions to Access Sensitive Files [CRITICAL NODE]:

  • Attack Vectors:
    • Configuration Files (e.g., connection strings) [CRITICAL NODE]:
      • Reading configuration files that contain database connection strings, API keys, or other sensitive information due to misconfigured web server or file system permissions.
    • Database Backups [CRITICAL NODE]:
      • Accessing database backup files stored in publicly accessible locations due to misconfigured permissions.
    • Source Code (if accessible) [CRITICAL NODE]:
      • Accessing application source code files if web server or file system permissions are incorrectly set, potentially revealing vulnerabilities and sensitive logic.
  • Impact:
    • Exploit Permissions to Access Sensitive Files [CRITICAL NODE]: Successfully reading sensitive files due to permission misconfigurations.
    • Configuration Files (e.g., connection strings) [CRITICAL NODE]: Obtaining database credentials and other sensitive configuration data.
    • Database Backups [CRITICAL NODE]: Accessing complete database contents, including customer data and admin credentials.
    • Source Code (if accessible) [CRITICAL NODE]: Understanding application logic, identifying vulnerabilities, and potentially finding hardcoded credentials.

Attack Tree Path: 6. Exploit Configuration/Deployment Weaknesses -> Unpatched nopCommerce Version [HIGH RISK PATH]:

  • Attack Vectors:
    • Exploit Known Vulnerabilities in that Version [CRITICAL NODE]:
      • Identifying the nopCommerce version and searching for publicly disclosed vulnerabilities (CVEs) affecting that version.
      • Utilizing publicly available exploits for known vulnerabilities.
    • Publicly Available Exploits [CRITICAL NODE]:
      • Using pre-written exploit code to target known vulnerabilities in the outdated nopCommerce version.
    • Research and Develop Custom Exploit [CRITICAL NODE]:
      • Analyzing the outdated nopCommerce version to identify vulnerabilities and developing custom exploit code if no public exploits are available.
  • Impact:
    • Exploit Known Vulnerabilities in that Version [CRITICAL NODE]: Successfully exploiting vulnerabilities specific to the outdated nopCommerce version.
    • Publicly Available Exploits [CRITICAL NODE]: Quickly and easily compromising the application using readily available exploits.
    • Research and Develop Custom Exploit [CRITICAL NODE]: Achieving compromise even if no public exploits exist, requiring more effort but potentially bypassing common defenses.

Attack Tree Path: 7. Exploit Plugin/Extension Vulnerabilities [HIGH RISK PATH] [CRITICAL NODE]:

  • Attack Vectors:
    • Exploit Vulnerability in Plugin [CRITICAL NODE]:
      • Identifying vulnerabilities within installed nopCommerce plugins.
      • Targeting common plugin vulnerabilities such as SQL Injection, XSS, File Upload vulnerabilities, Authentication Bypass, RCE, and Logic Flaws.
    • SQL Injection in Plugin [CRITICAL NODE]: SQL Injection vulnerabilities specifically within plugin code.
    • File Upload Vulnerability in Plugin [CRITICAL NODE]: File upload vulnerabilities within plugin functionalities.
    • Authentication Bypass in Plugin [CRITICAL NODE]: Bypassing authentication mechanisms implemented by plugins.
    • RCE in Plugin [CRITICAL NODE]: Remote Code Execution vulnerabilities within plugin code.
  • Impact:
    • Exploit Vulnerability in Plugin [CRITICAL NODE]: Successfully exploiting a vulnerability in a plugin.
    • SQL Injection in Plugin [CRITICAL NODE]: Data exfiltration, modification, or privilege escalation via plugin SQLi.
    • File Upload Vulnerability in Plugin [CRITICAL NODE]: Remote Code Execution via malicious file uploads through plugins.
    • Authentication Bypass in Plugin [CRITICAL NODE]: Unauthorized access to plugin functionalities and potentially wider application access.
    • RCE in Plugin [CRITICAL NODE]: Full server compromise via RCE vulnerabilities in plugins.

Attack Tree Path: 8. Exploit Dependencies Vulnerabilities -> Exploit Vulnerability in Dependency [CRITICAL NODE]:

  • Attack Vectors:
    • Publicly Available Exploits for Dependency [CRITICAL NODE]:
      • Identifying vulnerable dependencies (e.g., NuGet packages, JavaScript libraries) used by nopCommerce.
      • Utilizing publicly available exploits targeting vulnerabilities in these dependencies.
    • Develop Custom Exploit for Dependency [CRITICAL NODE]:
      • Analyzing dependencies to identify vulnerabilities and developing custom exploits if no public exploits are available.
  • Impact:
    • Exploit Vulnerability in Dependency [CRITICAL NODE]: Successfully exploiting a vulnerability in a dependency.
    • Publicly Available Exploits for Dependency [CRITICAL NODE]: Quickly compromising the application using readily available exploits for dependencies.
    • Develop Custom Exploit for Dependency [CRITICAL NODE]: Achieving compromise even if no public exploits exist for dependencies, requiring more effort.