Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
241 lines (218 loc) · 20.5 KB

mitigations.md

File metadata and controls

241 lines (218 loc) · 20.5 KB

Mitigation Strategies Analysis for nopsolutions/nopcommerce

Mitigation Strategy: Strict Plugin and Theme Vetting Process

Description:

  1. Establish a dedicated security review team or assign security-conscious developers to this task.
  2. Before installing any new plugin or theme in a non-development environment:
    • Download the plugin/theme files and store them securely.
    • Perform static code analysis using tools, focusing on common web vulnerabilities within the plugin/theme code.
    • Manually review the code, paying close attention to database interactions, user input handling, file uploads, and authentication mechanisms within the plugin/theme context.
    • Check for known vulnerabilities in used libraries and dependencies within the plugin/theme.
    • If possible, perform dynamic analysis in a testing environment by running the plugin/theme and observing its behavior, looking for unexpected actions or security flaws introduced by the plugin/theme.
    • Review plugin/theme permissions requests and ensure they are justified and minimal for the plugin/theme functionality.
    • Verify the reputation and trustworthiness of the plugin/theme provider. Check for security advisories or past vulnerabilities associated with them.
  3. Document the review process and findings for each plugin/theme.
  4. Only approve and deploy plugins/themes that pass the security review. List of Threats Mitigated:
  • Malicious Plugin/Theme Installation: High
  • SQL Injection via Plugin/Theme: High
  • Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) via Plugin/Theme: High
  • Remote Code Execution (RCE) via Plugin/Theme: Critical
  • Data Breach via Plugin/Theme Vulnerability: High
  • Privilege Escalation via Plugin/Theme: Medium
  • Denial of Service (DoS) via Plugin/Theme: Medium Impact:
  • Malicious Plugin/Theme Installation: High
  • SQL Injection via Plugin/Theme: High
  • Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) via Plugin/Theme: High
  • Remote Code Execution (RCE) via Plugin/Theme: Critical
  • Data Breach via Plugin/Theme Vulnerability: High
  • Privilege Escalation via Plugin/Theme: Medium
  • Denial of Service (DoS) via Plugin/Theme: Medium Currently Implemented: Partially implemented. We have a basic code review process, but it's not consistently applied to all plugins and themes, and lacks formal security focus and automated tooling. Code reviews are primarily functional, not security-focused. Missing Implementation: Formalize the security review process, integrate security-focused static and dynamic analysis tools, create a checklist for security reviews, train developers on secure plugin/theme review practices, and enforce mandatory security review before plugin/theme deployment to production.

Mitigation Strategy: Regular Plugin and Theme Updates

Description:

  1. Establish a schedule for checking for plugin and theme updates (e.g., weekly or monthly).
  2. Utilize nopCommerce's plugin management interface to check for available updates.
  3. Subscribe to plugin/theme provider's update notifications or security mailing lists if available.
  4. Before applying updates in production:
    • Backup the current nopCommerce application and database.
    • Apply updates in a staging environment that mirrors the production environment.
    • Thoroughly test the updated plugins/themes in the staging environment to ensure functionality and compatibility, and to identify any regressions or new issues introduced by the plugin/theme update.
    • If tests are successful, schedule and apply updates to the production environment during a maintenance window.
  5. Document all updates applied and any issues encountered. List of Threats Mitigated:
  • Exploitation of Known Plugin/Theme Vulnerabilities: High
  • Data Breach due to Outdated Plugin/Theme: High
  • Website Defacement due to Plugin/Theme Vulnerability: Medium
  • Denial of Service (DoS) via Exploited Plugin/Theme: Medium Impact:
  • Exploitation of Known Plugin/Theme Vulnerabilities: High
  • Data Breach due to Outdated Plugin/Theme: High
  • Website Defacement due to Plugin/Theme Vulnerability: Medium
  • Denial of Service (DoS) via Exploited Plugin/Theme: Medium Currently Implemented: Partially implemented. We check for updates occasionally, but it's not a regular, scheduled process. Updates are sometimes applied directly to production without thorough staging environment testing. Missing Implementation: Implement a scheduled update check process, establish a mandatory staging environment testing phase before production updates, automate update notifications, and document the update process and schedule.

Mitigation Strategy: Minimize Plugin Usage

Description:

  1. Regularly review the list of installed plugins within nopCommerce.
  2. For each plugin, assess its necessity and business value within the nopCommerce context.
  3. Identify plugins that are no longer actively used or provide redundant functionality within nopCommerce.
  4. Consider developing custom solutions within nopCommerce instead of relying on plugins, especially if security is a major concern.
  5. Uninstall and remove unnecessary plugins from the nopCommerce application.
  6. Document the rationale for removing plugins and update plugin usage policies. List of Threats Mitigated:
  • Increased Attack Surface due to Unnecessary Plugins: Medium
  • Vulnerability in Unused Plugin Exploited: Medium
  • Maintenance Overhead of Unnecessary Plugins: Low (Indirect Security Benefit) Impact:
  • Increased Attack Surface due to Unnecessary Plugins: Medium
  • Vulnerability in Unused Plugin Exploited: Medium
  • Maintenance Overhead of Unnecessary Plugins: Low (Indirect Security Benefit) Currently Implemented: Partially implemented. We occasionally review plugins, but there's no formal policy or regular schedule for minimizing plugin usage. Missing Implementation: Implement a plugin usage policy, schedule regular plugin reviews (e.g., quarterly), establish a process for evaluating plugin necessity, and document plugin removal decisions.

Mitigation Strategy: Change Default Admin Credentials

Description:

  1. Immediately after nopCommerce installation, log in to the admin area using the default credentials ([email protected] / password).
  2. Navigate to the administrator user settings within the nopCommerce admin panel (usually under "Customers" or "System" -> "Users").
  3. Change the default administrator username to a unique and non-obvious username. Avoid generic usernames like "administrator," "admin," "webmaster," etc.
  4. Generate a strong, unique password for the administrator account. Use a password manager to create and store complex passwords.
  5. Update the administrator account with the new username and password within the nopCommerce admin panel.
  6. Test the new credentials by logging out and logging back in with the updated username and password.
  7. Document the new administrator credentials securely. List of Threats Mitigated:
  • Brute-Force Attacks on Default Admin Account: High
  • Unauthorized Admin Access via Default Credentials: Critical Impact:
  • Brute-Force Attacks on Default Admin Account: High
  • Unauthorized Admin Access via Default Credentials: Critical Currently Implemented: Implemented. Default admin credentials were changed during initial setup. Missing Implementation: N/A - Currently implemented. However, reinforce the importance of strong passwords and regular password updates for all admin accounts.

Mitigation Strategy: Implement Two-Factor Authentication (2FA) for Admin Accounts

Description:

  1. Identify a suitable 2FA method (e.g., Time-based One-Time Password (TOTP) apps like Google Authenticator, Authy, or SMS-based verification - TOTP is recommended for better security).
  2. Install and configure a nopCommerce 2FA plugin if not already available in the core.
  3. Enable 2FA for all administrator accounts within nopCommerce.
  4. Provide clear instructions to administrators on how to set up and use 2FA on their accounts within nopCommerce.
  5. Test the 2FA implementation thoroughly to ensure it works correctly and doesn't introduce usability issues within nopCommerce.
  6. Document the 2FA setup and usage procedures. List of Threats Mitigated:
  • Account Takeover via Password Compromise: High
  • Brute-Force Attacks on Admin Accounts: Medium
  • Phishing Attacks Targeting Admin Credentials: Medium Impact:
  • Account Takeover via Password Compromise: High
  • Brute-Force Attacks on Admin Accounts: Medium
  • Phishing Attacks Targeting Admin Credentials: Medium Currently Implemented: Not implemented. 2FA is not currently enabled for admin accounts. Missing Implementation: Implement 2FA for all admin accounts using a TOTP-based method, configure a suitable 2FA plugin, provide user training, and document the 2FA process.

Mitigation Strategy: Restrict Admin Area Access by IP Address

Description:

  1. Identify the legitimate IP addresses or IP ranges from which administrators will access the nopCommerce admin area.
  2. Configure the web server (e.g., IIS, Nginx, Apache) or a firewall to restrict access to the /admin path (or renamed admin path) to only the allowed IP addresses or ranges. This is relevant to nopCommerce's admin area path.
  3. Test the IP restriction configuration to ensure that access is correctly limited and legitimate administrators can still access the admin area.
  4. Document the IP restriction configuration and the allowed IP addresses/ranges.
  5. Regularly review and update the allowed IP addresses/ranges as needed. List of Threats Mitigated:
  • Unauthorized Access to Admin Area from Untrusted Networks: High
  • Brute-Force Attacks Originating from Outside Allowed Networks: Medium Impact:
  • Unauthorized Access to Admin Area from Untrusted Networks: High
  • Brute-Force Attacks Originating from Outside Allowed Networks: Medium Currently Implemented: Not implemented. Admin area access is currently not restricted by IP address. Missing Implementation: Implement IP-based access restrictions for the admin area using web server configuration or firewall rules, document the allowed IP ranges, and establish a process for managing and updating these restrictions.

Mitigation Strategy: Rename or Move the Admin Area Path

Description:

  1. Identify the configuration file in nopCommerce that defines the admin area path (this might be in web.config or a nopCommerce settings file, depending on the version and configuration).
  2. Change the default /admin path to a unique and less predictable path (e.g., /secure-backend, /management-panel, /company-internal).
  3. Update any relevant configurations or links that point to the old /admin path to reflect the new path within nopCommerce configuration.
  4. Test the new admin area path by accessing it in a browser to ensure it works correctly.
  5. Document the new admin area path securely. List of Threats Mitigated:
  • Automated Brute-Force Attacks Targeting Default Admin Path: Low
  • Discovery of Admin Login Page by Script Kiddies: Low Impact:
  • Automated Brute-Force Attacks Targeting Default Admin Path: Low
  • Discovery of Admin Login Page by Script Kiddies: Low Currently Implemented: Not implemented. The admin area path is still the default /admin. Missing Implementation: Rename the admin area path to a non-default value in the nopCommerce configuration, update any related links or configurations, and document the new path securely.

Mitigation Strategy: Disable Unnecessary Features and Services

Description:

  1. Review the list of enabled features and services in the nopCommerce admin area (e.g., under "Configuration" -> "Settings" -> "General settings" or similar sections).
  2. Identify features and services that are not currently used or required for the application's functionality within nopCommerce.
  3. Disable these unnecessary features and services through the nopCommerce admin interface or configuration files.
  4. Verify that disabling these features does not negatively impact the required functionality of the application within nopCommerce.
  5. Document the disabled features and services and the rationale for disabling them.
  6. Regularly review enabled features and services and disable any newly identified unnecessary components. List of Threats Mitigated:
  • Increased Attack Surface due to Unnecessary Features: Medium
  • Vulnerability in Unused Feature Exploited: Medium
  • Performance Overhead from Unnecessary Services: Low (Indirect Security Benefit) Impact:
  • Increased Attack Surface due to Unnecessary Features: Medium
  • Vulnerability in Unused Feature Exploited: Medium
  • Performance Overhead from Unnecessary Services: Low (Indirect Security Benefit) Currently Implemented: Partially implemented. Some obviously unused features might be disabled, but a comprehensive review and disabling of all unnecessary features has not been performed. Missing Implementation: Conduct a thorough review of enabled nopCommerce features and services, disable all unnecessary components, document disabled features, and establish a process for regularly reviewing and minimizing enabled features.

Mitigation Strategy: Secure File Uploads

Description:

  1. Configure allowed file types for uploads in nopCommerce settings to restrict uploads to only necessary file types (e.g., images, documents). Block potentially dangerous file types like .exe, .php, .jsp, .bat, .sh, .svg (if not properly handled), etc. This leverages nopCommerce's file upload configuration.
  2. Implement file size limits for uploads to prevent denial-of-service attacks through large file uploads. Configure reasonable file size limits based on application requirements and nopCommerce's capabilities.
  3. Store uploaded files outside of the webroot if possible. This prevents direct execution of uploaded files as code. This is a general best practice, but relevant to how nopCommerce handles uploads.
  4. If files must be stored within the webroot, configure the web server to prevent execution of scripts within the upload directory (e.g., using .htaccess in Apache or IIS request filtering rules). This is a general best practice, but relevant to nopCommerce deployments.
  5. Implement file name sanitization to prevent directory traversal or other file system manipulation vulnerabilities. Rename uploaded files to unique, randomly generated names. This is a general best practice, but important for nopCommerce file handling.
  6. Perform virus scanning on uploaded files before storing them. Integrate with an antivirus solution. This is a general best practice, but relevant to user-generated content in nopCommerce.
  7. When serving uploaded files, use a secure mechanism that prevents direct execution and ensures proper content type handling (e.g., force download headers or use a dedicated file serving script). This is a general best practice, but relevant to how nopCommerce serves files. List of Threats Mitigated:
  • Malicious File Upload and Execution (RCE): Critical
  • Denial of Service (DoS) via Large File Uploads: Medium
  • Directory Traversal via File Upload: Medium
  • Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) via Maliciously Crafted Files (e.g., SVG): Medium Impact:
  • Malicious File Upload and Execution (RCE): Critical
  • Denial of Service (DoS) via Large File Uploads: Medium
  • Directory Traversal via File Upload: Medium
  • Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) via Maliciously Crafted Files (e.g., SVG): Medium Currently Implemented: Partially implemented. File type restrictions and size limits might be configured, but file storage outside webroot, script execution prevention in upload directories, filename sanitization, and virus scanning are likely missing. Missing Implementation: Implement comprehensive file upload security measures including: configuring allowed file types and size limits, storing files outside webroot, preventing script execution in upload directories, sanitizing filenames, implementing virus scanning, and ensuring secure file serving mechanisms.

Mitigation Strategy: Stay Updated with nopCommerce Security Advisories

Description:

  1. Subscribe to the official nopCommerce security mailing list or RSS feed (if available). Check the nopCommerce website for official communication channels.
  2. Regularly monitor the nopCommerce website, forums, and social media channels for security announcements, updates, and advisories specifically related to nopCommerce.
  3. Establish a process for reviewing and acting upon nopCommerce security advisories promptly.
  4. Disseminate security advisory information to relevant team members (developers, system administrators, security team).
  5. Prioritize and apply security patches and updates released by the nopCommerce team as soon as possible after advisories are published.
  6. Document the process for monitoring and responding to security advisories. List of Threats Mitigated:
  • Exploitation of Known nopCommerce Core Vulnerabilities: High
  • Zero-Day Vulnerability Exploitation (Reduced Window of Opportunity): Medium Impact:
  • Exploitation of Known nopCommerce Core Vulnerabilities: High
  • Zero-Day Vulnerability Exploitation (Reduced Window of Opportunity): Medium Currently Implemented: Partially implemented. We might occasionally check for updates, but a formal subscription to security advisories and a proactive response process are likely missing. Missing Implementation: Subscribe to official nopCommerce security advisory channels, establish a process for monitoring and responding to advisories, disseminate information to relevant teams, prioritize and apply security patches promptly, and document the advisory response process.

Mitigation Strategy: Regularly Update nopCommerce Core and Libraries

Description:

  1. Establish a schedule for regularly checking for nopCommerce core updates and updates for underlying libraries and frameworks (e.g., ASP.NET, NuGet packages). (e.g., monthly or quarterly).
  2. Utilize nopCommerce's update mechanisms or manual update procedures to check for available updates.
  3. Before applying updates in production:
    • Backup the current nopCommerce application and database.
    • Apply updates in a staging environment that mirrors the production environment.
    • Thoroughly test the updated nopCommerce application in the staging environment to ensure functionality, compatibility, and identify any regressions or new issues introduced by the nopCommerce core update.
    • Perform security testing on the updated application in the staging environment.
    • If tests are successful, schedule and apply updates to the production environment during a maintenance window.
  4. Document all updates applied and any issues encountered. List of Threats Mitigated:
  • Exploitation of Known nopCommerce Core Vulnerabilities: High
  • Exploitation of Known Library/Framework Vulnerabilities within nopCommerce: High
  • Data Breach due to Outdated Software: High
  • Website Defacement due to Core Vulnerability: Medium
  • Denial of Service (DoS) via Exploited Core Vulnerability: Medium Impact:
  • Exploitation of Known nopCommerce Core Vulnerabilities: High
  • Exploitation of Known Library/Framework Vulnerabilities within nopCommerce: High
  • Data Breach due to Outdated Software: High
  • Website Defacement due to Core Vulnerability: Medium
  • Denial of Service (DoS) via Exploited Core Vulnerability: Medium Currently Implemented: Partially implemented. We check for updates occasionally, but it's not a regular, scheduled process. Updates are sometimes applied directly to production without thorough staging environment testing and security testing. Missing Implementation: Implement a scheduled update check process, establish a mandatory staging environment testing and security testing phase before production updates, automate update notifications, and document the update process and schedule.