Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
279 lines (230 loc) · 23.5 KB

sec-design.md

File metadata and controls

279 lines (230 loc) · 23.5 KB

NuGet Client Project Design Document for Threat Modeling - Improved Version

Project: NuGet Client Version: (As of design document creation - refer to GitHub for latest) GitHub Repository: https://github.com/nuget/nuget.client Document Version: 1.1 Date: October 26, 2023 Author: AI Expert

1. Introduction

This document provides an enhanced design overview of the NuGet client project, specifically tailored for effective threat modeling. It builds upon the previous version by providing more detailed security context and actionable information for identifying potential threats. This document outlines the system's architecture, key components, data flows, and technologies, with a strong emphasis on security implications at each stage. It serves as a robust foundation for security analysis, vulnerability identification, and risk mitigation within the NuGet client and its interactions within the broader NuGet ecosystem.

NuGet is a critical component of the .NET development ecosystem, facilitating the discovery, sharing, and consumption of reusable code packages. The NuGet client is paramount to this ecosystem's security, as it directly interacts with package sources, manages dependencies within projects, and is responsible for ensuring the integrity and authenticity of consumed packages. Compromises in the NuGet client can have significant cascading effects on the security of .NET applications and the broader software supply chain.

This document focuses on the client-side aspects of NuGet, as represented by the nuget/nuget.client repository, and is designed to be directly usable for threat modeling exercises, such as STRIDE analysis. It primarily addresses security concerns from the client's perspective, acknowledging interactions with server-side infrastructure (NuGet.org, private feeds) where relevant to client-side security.

2. System Overview

The NuGet client operates as a bridge between .NET development projects and NuGet package sources. Its primary interactions are with:

  • NuGet Package Sources (Remote, potentially untrusted): Repositories hosting NuGet packages. These sources can range from the public nuget.org to private, organization-specific feeds. A crucial security consideration is the trust relationship (or lack thereof) with these external sources.
  • .NET Projects (Local): Developer projects that depend on NuGet packages. The client manages package dependencies within these projects, directly impacting their build and runtime environments.
  • Development Environments (Local User Context): IDEs (Visual Studio), CLIs (nuget.exe, dotnet nuget), and other tools used by developers. The client operates within the security context of the developer's machine and user account.

The core functionalities, from a security perspective, are:

  • Secure Package Acquisition: Downloading packages from potentially untrusted sources while ensuring integrity and authenticity.
  • Dependency Management and Resolution: Managing complex dependency trees and preventing malicious dependency injection or confusion attacks.
  • Authentication and Authorization for Package Sources: Securely accessing and publishing to both public and private package sources, protecting credentials and preventing unauthorized access.
  • Local Package Management and Storage: Securely storing downloaded packages and managing local caches to prevent tampering or unauthorized access.
  • Configuration Management Security: Protecting NuGet configuration files containing sensitive information like API keys and package source URLs.

The following diagram provides a high-level overview of the NuGet client's position and interactions within the NuGet ecosystem:

graph LR
    subgraph "NuGet Ecosystem"
        subgraph "NuGet Client (Local Machine)"
            "NuGet Client Application" -->|"Package Management Requests"| "NuGet Client Core";
            "NuGet Client Core" -->|"HTTP(S) Requests (Potentially Untrusted)"| "NuGet Package Sources";
            "NuGet Client Core" -->|"File System Access (Local Project & Cache)"| "Local Project Files & Cache";
            "NuGet Client Core" -->|"Configuration Access (Sensitive Data)"| "NuGet Configuration";
        end
        subgraph "NuGet Package Sources (Remote - Untrusted Boundary)"
            "NuGet Package Sources" -->|"Package Files (.nupkg), Metadata (Potentially Malicious)"| "NuGet Client Core";
        end
        subgraph "Developer Environment (Local User Context)"
            "IDE / CLI" -->|"NuGet Commands (User Input)"| "NuGet Client Application";
            "Local Project Files" -->|"Project Information"| "NuGet Client Core";
        end
    end
    style "NuGet Ecosystem" fill:#f9f,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px
    style "NuGet Package Sources" fill:#fcc,stroke:#333,stroke-width:1px,stroke-dasharray: 5 5
    linkStyle 2,4,6 stroke:#cc0,stroke-width:2px,color:orange;
Loading

Note: The dashed border and orange links in the diagram highlight the "NuGet Package Sources" as an untrusted external boundary and emphasize the security-sensitive data flows.

3. Component Breakdown

This section details the key components of the NuGet client, explicitly focusing on their attack surface and security relevance for threat modeling.

3.1. NuGet Client Application (UI/CLI)

  • Description: The user-facing interface, either GUI (IDE integration) or CLI (nuget.exe, dotnet nuget). This is the primary entry point for user interaction with the NuGet client.
  • Functionality:
    • Command parsing and validation from user input (CLI arguments, GUI actions).
    • Presentation of information to the user (package listings, status updates, error messages).
    • Credential input handling (API keys, usernames/passwords).
    • Delegation of requests to the NuGet Client Core.
  • Attack Surface:
    • User Input: CLI arguments, GUI input fields, configuration settings provided through the UI.
    • Inter-Process Communication (IPC): If the application communicates with other processes (less likely in typical client scenarios, but possible in plugin architectures).
  • Security Relevance:
    • Command Injection (CLI): Improper sanitization of CLI arguments could allow execution of arbitrary commands.
    • Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) / UI Redress (GUI): If the GUI is web-based or renders external content, vulnerabilities like XSS or clickjacking could be present.
    • Input Validation Vulnerabilities: Insufficient validation of user inputs could lead to unexpected behavior or vulnerabilities in downstream components.
    • Credential Exposure: Insecure handling or logging of user-provided credentials.
    • Privilege Escalation: If the application runs with elevated privileges unnecessarily, vulnerabilities could lead to privilege escalation.

3.2. NuGet Client Core

  • Description: The central engine containing the core logic for all NuGet operations. This component is responsible for interacting with package sources, managing local files, and enforcing security policies.
  • Functionality:
    • Package source management (configuration, selection, prioritization).
    • Package discovery and search (querying package sources, parsing responses).
    • Package download (HTTP(S) requests, stream handling).
    • Package installation, update, and uninstallation (file system operations, project file modification).
    • Dependency resolution and conflict management.
    • Package Verification (Crucial Security Function): Signature verification, hash validation, certificate chain validation.
    • Configuration management (nuget.config parsing and handling).
    • Authentication and authorization with package sources (API key handling, credential management).
    • Package caching (local storage and retrieval of packages).
  • Attack Surface:
    • Network Communication: Handling HTTP(S) requests and responses from package sources (potential for MITM, malicious server responses).
    • File System Operations: Reading and writing to local file system (project files, package cache, configuration files).
    • Configuration Data: Parsing and processing NuGet configuration files (potential for injection or manipulation).
    • Dependency Libraries: Vulnerabilities in third-party libraries used by the core.
  • Security Relevance:
    • Man-in-the-Middle (MITM) Attacks: If HTTPS is not enforced or certificate validation is weak, attackers could intercept and modify package downloads.
    • Package Verification Bypass: Flaws in signature or hash verification could allow installation of malicious packages.
    • Dependency Confusion/Substitution Attacks: Vulnerabilities in dependency resolution logic could lead to the installation of attacker-controlled packages.
    • Authentication Vulnerabilities: Weaknesses in authentication mechanisms or insecure credential storage could expose private feeds or allow unauthorized package publishing.
    • Configuration Injection/Manipulation: Improper parsing of nuget.config could allow injection of malicious settings.
    • Denial of Service (DoS): Vulnerabilities that could be exploited to cause excessive resource consumption or crashes (e.g., through malicious package metadata or download streams).
    • Local File System Vulnerabilities: Improper file permissions or vulnerabilities in file handling could lead to local privilege escalation or data leakage.
    • Vulnerable Dependencies: Security vulnerabilities in libraries used by the NuGet Client Core could be exploited.

3.3. NuGet Configuration (nuget.config)

  • Description: XML-based configuration files storing NuGet settings, including package sources, API keys, and other client behaviors.
  • Functionality:
    • Storage of package source URLs and names.
    • Storage of API keys for authenticated package sources (potentially sensitive).
    • Configuration of package restore behavior, default package locations, etc.
  • Attack Surface:
    • File System Storage: nuget.config files are stored on the local file system, potentially accessible to unauthorized users or processes.
    • XML Parsing: Vulnerabilities in XML parsing libraries could be exploited if nuget.config is maliciously crafted.
  • Security Relevance:
    • Credential Exposure (API Keys): nuget.config often stores API keys in plaintext or weakly encrypted forms, making them vulnerable if the file is compromised.
    • Configuration Manipulation: Attackers could modify nuget.config to redirect package sources to malicious repositories, inject malicious settings, or disable security features.
    • Information Disclosure: Accidental or malicious exposure of nuget.config could leak API keys, private feed URLs, or other sensitive configuration details.

3.4. Local Project Files & Package Cache

  • Description: Files within a .NET project managed by NuGet (project files, packages folder) and the local NuGet package cache.
  • Functionality:
    • Project files (.csproj, .fsproj) define package dependencies.
    • Packages folders store downloaded package files for projects.
    • Package cache stores downloaded packages for reuse across projects.
    • NuGet client modifies project files to manage package references.
  • Attack Surface:
    • File System Storage: Project files and package caches are stored on the local file system, potentially writable by other processes or users.
    • Build Process Integration: Project files are used by the .NET build process, and packages can contain build scripts.
  • Security Relevance:
    • Project File Manipulation: Malicious packages or compromised processes could modify project files to inject malicious build tasks or alter dependencies.
    • Packages Folder/Cache Poisoning: If the packages folder or cache is writable by unauthorized users, malicious packages could be placed there, or legitimate packages replaced (cache poisoning).
    • Build Process Injection via Packages: NuGet packages can contain build scripts (e.g., PowerShell scripts, MSBuild targets) that are executed during the build process. Malicious packages could exploit this to inject arbitrary code into the build process.
    • Data Integrity of Cached Packages: Ensuring the integrity of packages stored in the local cache to prevent corruption or tampering.

3.5. NuGet Package Sources (External System - Untrusted)

  • Description: External repositories hosting NuGet packages. This is an external system and a critical untrusted boundary.
  • Functionality:
    • Package storage and serving (package files and metadata).
    • Package search and discovery APIs.
    • Package publishing and management APIs.
    • Authentication and authorization for private feeds.
  • Attack Surface:
    • Network APIs: Publicly accessible APIs for package metadata, download, and potentially publishing.
    • Content Storage: Storage of package files and metadata (potential for compromise at the source).
  • Security Relevance (from Client perspective):
    • Compromised Package Sources: If a package source is compromised, it could serve malicious packages to NuGet clients, leading to widespread supply chain attacks.
    • Malicious Packages: Package sources may host intentionally malicious packages uploaded by attackers.
    • MITM Attacks on Package Sources: Attacks targeting the communication between the client and package sources to intercept or modify package delivery.
    • Availability and Integrity of Package Sources: DoS attacks or data corruption on package sources can disrupt package management and development workflows.
    • Data Breaches at Package Sources: Breaches at package sources could expose package metadata, potentially including vulnerability information or usage patterns.

4. Data Flow Diagrams - Security Focused

This section illustrates key data flows with a specific focus on security considerations and potential threats at each step.

4.1. Package Installation Flow - Security Perspective

graph LR
    "Developer" -->|"1. Initiate Install Command (Potentially Malicious Input)"| "NuGet Client Application";
    "NuGet Client Application" -->|"2. Request Package Install"| "NuGet Client Core";
    "NuGet Client Core" -->|"3. Read NuGet Configuration (Potential Credential Exposure)"| "NuGet Configuration";
    "NuGet Client Core" -->|"4. Query Package Source Metadata (HTTP(S) - MITM Risk)"| "NuGet Package Sources";
    "NuGet Package Sources" -->|"5. Package Metadata (Potentially Malicious Metadata)"| "NuGet Client Core";
    "NuGet Client Core" -->|"6. Dependency Resolution (Dependency Confusion Risk)"| "NuGet Client Core";
    "NuGet Client Core" -->|"7. Download Package File (.nupkg) (HTTP(S) - MITM Risk, Malicious File)"| "NuGet Package Sources";
    "NuGet Package Sources" -->|"8. .nupkg File (Potentially Malicious)"| "NuGet Client Core";
    "NuGet Client Core" -->|"9. Package Verification (Signature, Hash - Verification Bypass Risk)"| "NuGet Client Core";
    "NuGet Client Core" -->|"10. Extract Package Contents (Malicious Code Execution Risk)"| "NuGet Client Core";
    "NuGet Client Core" -->|"11. Update Project Files (e.g., .csproj - Project File Manipulation Risk)"| "Local Project Files & Cache";
    "NuGet Client Core" -->|"12. Write Package Files to Packages Folder & Cache (Cache Poisoning Risk)"| "Local Project Files & Cache";
    "NuGet Client Core" -->|"13. Installation Success/Failure Notification"| "NuGet Client Application";
    "NuGet Client Application" -->|"14. Display Installation Status to Developer"| "Developer";
    style "NuGet Package Sources" fill:#ccf,stroke:#333,stroke-width:1px
    style "NuGet Configuration" fill:#eee,stroke:#333,stroke-width:1px
    style "Local Project Files & Cache" fill:#eee,stroke:#333,stroke-width:1px
    linkStyle 4,7 stroke:#cc0,stroke-width:2px,color:orange;
    linkStyle 5,8,9,10,11,12 stroke:#f00,stroke-width:2px,color:red;
Loading

Security Considerations for Package Installation Flow:

  • Step 1 (User Input): Vulnerable to command injection or malicious package names if input is not properly validated.
  • Step 3 (NuGet Configuration): Risk of API key exposure if nuget.config is compromised.
  • Steps 4 & 7 (HTTP(S) Communication): Susceptible to MITM attacks if HTTPS is not enforced or certificate validation is weak. Orange links highlight network communication with an untrusted source.
  • Steps 5 & 8 (.nupkg and Metadata): Package source can serve malicious metadata or package files. Red links highlight potentially malicious data from untrusted source.
  • Step 9 (Package Verification): Critical security control. Bypass or weakness here allows malicious packages to be installed.
  • Step 10 (Package Extraction): Malicious packages could contain code that executes during extraction or installation.
  • Step 11 (Project File Modification): Malicious packages could manipulate project files to inject build tasks or alter dependencies.
  • Step 12 (Local File System): Risk of cache poisoning if the package cache is writable by attackers.

4.2. Package Source Authentication Flow (API Key) - Security Perspective

graph LR
    "Developer" -->|"1. Configure API Key in NuGet Configuration (Insecure Storage Risk)"| "NuGet Configuration";
    "NuGet Client Application" -->|"2. Request Authenticated Operation (e.g., Package Push)"| "NuGet Client Core";
    "NuGet Client Core" -->|"3. Read API Key from NuGet Configuration (Credential Exposure Risk)"| "NuGet Configuration";
    "NuGet Client Core" -->|"4. Include API Key in HTTP(S) Request Header (Transmission Security Risk)"| "NuGet Package Sources";
    "NuGet Package Sources" -->|"5. Authenticate Request using API Key"| "NuGet Package Sources";
    "NuGet Package Sources" -->|"6. Authorization Decision (Success/Failure)"| "NuGet Package Sources";
    "NuGet Package Sources" -->|"7. Operation Result (Success/Failure)"| "NuGet Client Core";
    "NuGet Client Core" -->|"8. Operation Result (Success/Failure)"| "NuGet Client Application";
    "NuGet Client Application" -->|"9. Display Authentication Status to Developer"| "Developer";
    style "NuGet Package Sources" fill:#ccf,stroke:#333,stroke-width:1px
    style "NuGet Configuration" fill:#eee,stroke:#333,stroke-width:1px
    linkStyle 4 stroke:#cc0,stroke-width:2px,color:orange;
    linkStyle 1,3 stroke:#f00,stroke-width:2px,color:red;
Loading

Security Considerations for Authentication Flow:

  • Step 1 (API Key Configuration): Storing API keys in nuget.config in plaintext or weakly encrypted form is a significant vulnerability. Red link highlights insecure storage.
  • Step 3 (API Key Retrieval): Accessing the API key from configuration introduces a risk of exposure if the process or system is compromised. Red link highlights credential access.
  • Step 4 (API Key Transmission): Transmitting API keys over HTTP(S) requires HTTPS to prevent interception. Orange link highlights network communication.
  • Steps 5 & 6 (Server-Side Authentication): Security relies on the package source's authentication and authorization mechanisms being robust.

5. Technology Stack

(No changes from previous version - remains relevant)

The NuGet client is primarily built using the following technologies:

  • Programming Language: C#
  • .NET Framework / .NET: Target runtime environment.
  • HTTP(S) Libraries: For communication with package sources (e.g., System.Net.Http).
  • XML/JSON Parsing Libraries: For processing NuGet metadata and configuration files.
  • File System APIs: For local file system operations.
  • Cryptographic Libraries: For package signature verification and hash calculations.

6. Structured Security Considerations for Threat Modeling

This section provides a more structured list of security considerations, categorized for easier threat modeling using methodologies like STRIDE.

Categories based on Assets and Components:

  • NuGet Package Sources (External, Untrusted Asset):

    • Compromised Package Source: Serving malicious packages, metadata manipulation. (Integrity, Availability)
    • Malicious Packages on Source: Packages intentionally uploaded by attackers. (Integrity)
    • Package Source Availability: DoS attacks against package sources. (Availability)
    • MITM Attacks on Communication: Interception of communication with package sources. (Confidentiality, Integrity)

  • NuGet Client Core (Core Logic Component):

    • Package Verification Bypass: Flaws in signature/hash verification. (Integrity)
    • Dependency Confusion/Substitution: Exploiting dependency resolution logic. (Integrity)
    • Authentication Vulnerabilities: Weaknesses in authentication mechanisms. (Confidentiality, Integrity, Availability)
    • Configuration Injection: Exploiting vulnerabilities in nuget.config parsing. (Integrity)
    • DoS Vulnerabilities: Causing resource exhaustion or crashes. (Availability)
    • Local File System Vulnerabilities: Improper file handling, privilege escalation. (Confidentiality, Integrity, Availability)
    • Vulnerable Dependencies: Vulnerabilities in libraries used by the core. (Confidentiality, Integrity, Availability)

  • NuGet Configuration (nuget.config) (Configuration Data Asset):

    • Credential Exposure (API Keys): Insecure storage of API keys. (Confidentiality)
    • Configuration Manipulation: Modifying nuget.config to alter behavior. (Integrity, Availability)
    • Information Disclosure: Accidental or malicious leakage of nuget.config. (Confidentiality)

  • Local Project Files & Package Cache (Local File System Asset):

    • Project File Manipulation: Malicious modification of project files. (Integrity)
    • Packages Folder/Cache Poisoning: Replacing legitimate packages with malicious ones. (Integrity)
    • Build Process Injection: Malicious code execution via package build scripts. (Integrity, Availability)
    • Data Integrity of Cached Packages: Corruption or tampering of cached packages. (Integrity)

  • NuGet Client Application (UI/CLI) (User Interface Component):

    • Command Injection (CLI): Exploiting vulnerabilities in CLI argument parsing. (Integrity, Availability)
    • XSS/UI Redress (GUI): Vulnerabilities in GUI rendering. (Confidentiality, Integrity)
    • Input Validation Vulnerabilities: Insufficient input validation leading to downstream issues. (Integrity, Availability)
    • Credential Exposure via UI/Logging: Insecure handling of credentials in UI or logs. (Confidentiality)

7. Conclusion

This improved design document provides a more security-focused and actionable overview of the NuGet client project for threat modeling. By detailing components, data flows, attack surfaces, and security considerations, it facilitates a structured approach to identifying and mitigating potential threats. The explicit highlighting of untrusted boundaries and security-sensitive data flows, along with the structured security considerations, makes this document a valuable resource for conducting threat modeling exercises, such as STRIDE, and ultimately enhancing the security posture of the NuGet client and the broader .NET ecosystem. This document should be used as a starting point for a more in-depth threat modeling process, involving security experts and developers to identify specific threats and define appropriate mitigation strategies.