Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
381 lines (337 loc) · 19.3 KB

sec-design.md

File metadata and controls

381 lines (337 loc) · 19.3 KB

Project Design Document: NuGet Client

BUSINESS POSTURE

NuGet Client is a crucial component of the .NET ecosystem, enabling developers to discover, install, and manage packages. The primary business priorities and goals are:

  • Enable efficient and reliable package management for .NET developers.
  • Provide a secure and trustworthy mechanism for distributing and consuming packages.
  • Maintain compatibility with the NuGet.org package repository and other package sources.
  • Support a wide range of .NET project types and platforms.
  • Offer a consistent and user-friendly experience across different development environments (Visual Studio, command-line interface, etc.).

The most important business risks that need to be addressed are:

  • Malicious Packages: The introduction of malicious packages into the ecosystem could compromise the security of applications built using NuGet.
  • Supply Chain Attacks: Compromise of the NuGet client itself or its dependencies could lead to widespread vulnerabilities.
  • Availability and Performance: Downtime or performance issues with the NuGet client or the NuGet.org repository can disrupt developer workflows.
  • Package Integrity: Ensuring that packages are not tampered with during download and installation is critical.
  • Dependency Confusion: Attackers might exploit similar package names to trick developers into installing malicious packages.

SECURITY POSTURE

Existing security controls and accepted risks, based on the provided GitHub repository, are inferred as follows:

  • security control: Code signing of NuGet client binaries. (Inferred from common practice and NuGet's importance)
  • security control: Use of HTTPS for communication with package repositories. (Inferred from common practice and NuGet documentation)
  • security control: Package signature verification. (Described in NuGet documentation and client features)
  • security control: Static analysis tools used during development. (Inferred from the presence of build scripts and common practice)
  • security control: Vulnerability scanning of dependencies. (Inferred from common practice and Microsoft's security policies)
  • security control: Code reviews and pull request process. (Observed in the GitHub repository)
  • security control: Two-factor authentication for maintainers with publishing rights to NuGet.org. (Inferred from NuGet.org policies)
  • accepted risk: Reliance on third-party package authors to maintain the security of their packages. (Inherent risk in the open-source package ecosystem)
  • accepted risk: Potential for zero-day vulnerabilities in the NuGet client or its dependencies. (Inherent risk in any software)
  • accepted risk: Limited control over the security practices of private NuGet repositories. (NuGet client can connect to various repositories)

Recommended security controls (high priority):

  • security control: Implement a comprehensive Software Bill of Materials (SBOM) for the NuGet client and its dependencies.
  • security control: Integrate dynamic analysis (fuzzing) into the development process.
  • security control: Conduct regular penetration testing of the NuGet client and its interactions with NuGet.org.
  • security control: Enhance supply chain security by implementing in-toto or a similar framework.
  • security control: Implement robust telemetry and monitoring to detect and respond to security incidents.

Security Requirements:

  • Authentication:
    • The client must support secure authentication mechanisms for accessing private package repositories (e.g., API keys, personal access tokens, OAuth).
    • The client must securely store and manage credentials used for authentication.
  • Authorization:
    • The client must respect access control policies defined by package repositories.
    • The client should support granular permissions for different operations (e.g., installing, updating, publishing packages).
  • Input Validation:
    • The client must validate all user inputs, including package names, versions, and repository URLs.
    • The client must sanitize inputs to prevent injection attacks.
    • The client must handle malformed package metadata gracefully.
  • Cryptography:
    • The client must use strong cryptographic algorithms and protocols for secure communication (HTTPS with TLS 1.2 or higher).
    • The client must verify the integrity of downloaded packages using digital signatures.
    • The client must securely store any cryptographic keys used for signing or encryption.

DESIGN

C4 CONTEXT

graph LR
    A["Developers"] --> B["NuGet Client"];
    B --> C["NuGet.org"];
    B --> D["Private NuGet Repositories"];
    B --> E["Local Package Cache"];
    B --> F[".NET Projects"];
    C --> G["Package Authors"];

    classDef element fill:#ddd,stroke:#000,stroke-width:2px;
    class A,B,C,D,E,F,G element;
Loading

Element Descriptions:

  • Element:
    • Name: Developers
    • Type: Person
    • Description: Software developers who use NuGet to manage dependencies in their .NET projects.
    • Responsibilities: Use the NuGet client to search, install, update, and manage packages.
    • Security controls: Use strong passwords and enable two-factor authentication where available.
  • Element:
    • Name: NuGet Client
    • Type: Software System
    • Description: The client-side tool that interacts with package repositories and manages package installations.
    • Responsibilities: Download packages, verify signatures, resolve dependencies, install packages into projects.
    • Security controls: Package signature verification, HTTPS communication, input validation, secure credential storage.
  • Element:
    • Name: NuGet.org
    • Type: Software System
    • Description: The official public NuGet package repository.
    • Responsibilities: Host packages, provide search functionality, manage package metadata.
    • Security controls: HTTPS, access controls, vulnerability scanning, intrusion detection.
  • Element:
    • Name: Private NuGet Repositories
    • Type: Software System
    • Description: Privately hosted NuGet repositories used by organizations to share internal packages.
    • Responsibilities: Host packages, provide search functionality, manage package metadata.
    • Security controls: HTTPS, access controls, authentication, authorization (implementation varies).
  • Element:
    • Name: Local Package Cache
    • Type: Software System
    • Description: A local cache on the developer's machine that stores downloaded packages.
    • Responsibilities: Store downloaded packages to speed up subsequent installations.
    • Security controls: File system permissions, potentially package signature verification upon retrieval.
  • Element:
    • Name: .NET Projects
    • Type: Software System
    • Description: .NET projects that consume NuGet packages.
    • Responsibilities: Utilize the functionality provided by the installed packages.
    • Security controls: Dependent on the security practices of the project and the packages it uses.
  • Element:
    • Name: Package Authors
    • Type: Person
    • Description: Developers who create and publish packages to NuGet.org.
    • Responsibilities: Develop and maintain packages, follow security best practices.
    • Security controls: Use strong passwords, enable two-factor authentication for their NuGet.org accounts, follow secure coding practices.

C4 CONTAINER

graph LR
    A["Developer"] --> B["Command Line Interface (CLI)"];
    A --> C["Visual Studio Package Manager UI"];
    B --> D["NuGet Client Library"];
    C --> D;
    D --> E["Package Source Mapper"];
    D --> F["Package Downloader"];
    D --> G["Dependency Resolver"];
    D --> H["Package Installer"];
    D --> I["Local Cache Manager"];
    F --> J["NuGet.org API"];
    F --> K["Private Repository API"];
    J --> L["NuGet.org"];
    K --> M["Private NuGet Repositories"];
    I --> N["Local Package Cache"];
    H --> O[".NET Project"];

    classDef element fill:#ddd,stroke:#000,stroke-width:2px;
    class A,B,C,D,E,F,G,H,I,J,K,L,M,N,O element;
Loading

Element Descriptions:

  • Element:
    • Name: Developer
    • Type: Person
    • Description: Software developer interacting with NuGet.
    • Responsibilities: Initiates package management operations.
    • Security controls: Uses secure development environment.
  • Element:
    • Name: Command Line Interface (CLI)
    • Type: Container: Application
    • Description: Provides a command-line interface for interacting with NuGet (e.g., dotnet CLI).
    • Responsibilities: Parses commands, interacts with the NuGet Client Library.
    • Security controls: Input validation, secure communication with the library.
  • Element:
    • Name: Visual Studio Package Manager UI
    • Type: Container: Application
    • Description: Graphical user interface integrated into Visual Studio.
    • Responsibilities: Provides a visual interface for managing packages, interacts with the NuGet Client Library.
    • Security controls: Input validation, secure communication with the library.
  • Element:
    • Name: NuGet Client Library
    • Type: Container: Library
    • Description: Core library that implements NuGet functionality.
    • Responsibilities: Manages package sources, downloads, resolves dependencies, installs packages.
    • Security controls: Input validation, signature verification, secure communication.
  • Element:
    • Name: Package Source Mapper
    • Type: Container: Component
    • Description: Maps package IDs to configured package sources.
    • Responsibilities: Determines where to download a package from.
    • Security controls: Validate package source URLs.
  • Element:
    • Name: Package Downloader
    • Type: Container: Component
    • Description: Downloads packages from remote repositories.
    • Responsibilities: Retrieves package files, verifies integrity.
    • Security controls: HTTPS, signature verification, retry mechanisms.
  • Element:
    • Name: Dependency Resolver
    • Type: Container: Component
    • Description: Resolves package dependencies.
    • Responsibilities: Determines the correct versions of all required packages.
    • Security controls: Handles version conflicts, avoids vulnerable versions (if vulnerability data is available).
  • Element:
    • Name: Package Installer
    • Type: Container: Component
    • Description: Installs packages into .NET projects.
    • Responsibilities: Adds package references, copies files.
    • Security controls: Verifies package integrity before installation.
  • Element:
    • Name: Local Cache Manager
    • Type: Container: Component
    • Description: Manages the local package cache.
    • Responsibilities: Stores and retrieves downloaded packages.
    • Security controls: File system permissions.
  • Element:
    • Name: NuGet.org API
    • Type: Container: API
    • Description: API endpoint for interacting with NuGet.org.
    • Responsibilities: Provides package metadata, download links.
    • Security controls: HTTPS, API rate limiting.
  • Element:
    • Name: Private Repository API
    • Type: Container: API
    • Description: API endpoint for interacting with private NuGet repositories.
    • Responsibilities: Provides package metadata, download links.
    • Security controls: HTTPS, authentication, authorization (implementation varies).
  • Element:
    • Name: NuGet.org
    • Type: Container: External System
    • Description: The official public NuGet package repository.
    • Responsibilities: Hosts packages.
    • Security controls: See Context Diagram.
  • Element:
    • Name: Private NuGet Repositories
    • Type: Container: External System
    • Description: Privately hosted NuGet repositories.
    • Responsibilities: Hosts packages.
    • Security controls: See Context Diagram.
  • Element:
    • Name: Local Package Cache
    • Type: Container: File System
    • Description: Local storage for downloaded packages.
    • Responsibilities: Stores packages.
    • Security controls: See Context Diagram.
  • Element:
    • Name: .NET Project
    • Type: Container: Application
    • Description: The project receiving the NuGet packages.
    • Responsibilities: Uses the installed packages.
    • Security controls: Dependent on project and package security.

DEPLOYMENT

Possible deployment solutions:

  1. Developer Machine: NuGet client is typically installed as part of the .NET SDK or Visual Studio.
  2. Build Server: NuGet client is used on build servers (e.g., Azure DevOps, Jenkins) to restore packages during the build process.
  3. Containerized Environments: NuGet client can be used within Docker containers for building and running .NET applications.

Chosen solution (Developer Machine):

graph LR
    A["Developer Machine"] --> B["Operating System (Windows, macOS, Linux)"];
    B --> C[".NET SDK"];
    B --> D["Visual Studio (optional)"];
    C --> E["NuGet Client (CLI)"];
    D --> F["Visual Studio Package Manager (UI)"];
    E --> G["Local Package Cache"];
    F --> G;

    classDef element fill:#ddd,stroke:#000,stroke-width:2px;
    class A,B,C,D,E,F,G element;
Loading

Element Descriptions:

  • Element:
    • Name: Developer Machine
    • Type: Node: Device
    • Description: The developer's workstation.
    • Responsibilities: Runs the operating system, .NET SDK, and development tools.
    • Security controls: Operating system security, firewall, antivirus.
  • Element:
    • Name: Operating System (Windows, macOS, Linux)
    • Type: Node: Operating System
    • Description: The underlying operating system.
    • Responsibilities: Provides the foundation for running software.
    • Security controls: OS updates, user account management, file system permissions.
  • Element:
    • Name: .NET SDK
    • Type: Node: Software
    • Description: The .NET Software Development Kit.
    • Responsibilities: Provides tools for building and running .NET applications, includes the NuGet client CLI.
    • Security controls: Regularly updated, code-signed binaries.
  • Element:
    • Name: Visual Studio (optional)
    • Type: Node: Software
    • Description: The Visual Studio IDE.
    • Responsibilities: Provides a development environment, includes the NuGet Package Manager UI.
    • Security controls: Regularly updated, code-signed binaries.
  • Element:
    • Name: NuGet Client (CLI)
    • Type: Node: Software
    • Description: The command-line interface for NuGet.
    • Responsibilities: See Container Diagram.
    • Security controls: See Container Diagram.
  • Element:
    • Name: Visual Studio Package Manager (UI)
    • Type: Node: Software
    • Description: The graphical user interface for NuGet within Visual Studio.
    • Responsibilities: See Container Diagram.
    • Security controls: See Container Diagram.
  • Element:
    • Name: Local Package Cache
    • Type: Node: File System
    • Description: Local storage for downloaded packages.
    • Responsibilities: See Container Diagram.
    • Security controls: See Container Diagram.

BUILD

graph LR
    A["Developer"] --> B["Source Code (GitHub)"];
    B --> C["Build Server (Azure Pipelines)"];
    C --> D["Static Analysis (SAST)"];
    C --> E["Dependency Scanning"];
    C --> F["Unit Tests"];
    C --> G["Integration Tests"];
    C --> H["Code Signing"];
    C --> I["NuGet Packages (Signed)"];
    C --> J["Publish to NuGet.org / Internal Repository"];

    classDef element fill:#ddd,stroke:#000,stroke-width:2px;
    class A,B,C,D,E,F,G,H,I,J element;
Loading

Build Process Description:

  1. Developer: A developer commits code changes to the GitHub repository.
  2. Source Code (GitHub): The source code is hosted on GitHub.
  3. Build Server (Azure Pipelines): Azure Pipelines is used as the CI/CD system. A build pipeline is triggered by commits to the repository.
  4. Static Analysis (SAST): Static analysis tools are run to identify potential security vulnerabilities in the code.
  5. Dependency Scanning: The build process scans dependencies for known vulnerabilities.
  6. Unit Tests: Unit tests are executed to verify the functionality of individual components.
  7. Integration Tests: Integration tests are executed to verify the interaction between different components.
  8. Code Signing: The built NuGet client binaries are code-signed to ensure authenticity and integrity.
  9. NuGet Packages (Signed): The output of the build process is a set of signed NuGet packages.
  10. Publish to NuGet.org / Internal Repository: The signed packages are published to NuGet.org or an internal repository.

Security Controls in Build Process:

  • security control: Static analysis (SAST) to identify code vulnerabilities.
  • security control: Dependency scanning to detect known vulnerable dependencies.
  • security control: Code signing to ensure the authenticity and integrity of the binaries.
  • security control: Automated build process to ensure consistency and repeatability.
  • security control: Use of a secure build environment (Azure Pipelines).
  • security control: Limited access to build server and publishing credentials.

RISK ASSESSMENT

  • Critical Business Processes:

    • Package Acquisition: Developers must be able to reliably and securely acquire packages for their projects.
    • Package Publishing: Package authors must be able to securely publish packages to repositories.
    • Dependency Management: The NuGet client must accurately and securely manage project dependencies.

  • Data to Protect:

    • Package Content: The actual code and assets within NuGet packages. (Sensitivity: Varies from public open-source code to proprietary code)
    • Package Metadata: Information about packages, including dependencies, versions, and authors. (Sensitivity: Public for public packages, potentially sensitive for private packages)
    • Credentials: API keys, access tokens, and other credentials used to access private repositories. (Sensitivity: High)
    • User Data: Information about developers and package authors (e.g., email addresses). (Sensitivity: Medium)

QUESTIONS & ASSUMPTIONS

  • Questions:

    • What specific static analysis tools are used in the build process?
    • What is the process for handling reported vulnerabilities in the NuGet client or its dependencies?
    • What are the specific security requirements for private NuGet repositories that the client interacts with?
    • Are there any specific compliance requirements (e.g., FedRAMP, HIPAA) that the NuGet client needs to adhere to?
    • What is the process for rotating code signing certificates?
    • What kind of dynamic analysis is performed?
    • What is the frequency of penetration testing?

  • Assumptions:

    • The NuGet client uses HTTPS for all communication with package repositories.
    • The NuGet client verifies package signatures before installation.
    • The build process includes static analysis and dependency scanning.
    • Developers and package authors follow security best practices.
    • NuGet.org implements appropriate security controls to protect its infrastructure and data.
    • Private NuGet repository administrators are responsible for securing their own repositories.
    • The .NET SDK and Visual Studio are regularly updated to the latest versions.
    • Azure Pipelines is configured securely.