Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
173 lines (123 loc) · 16.8 KB

sec-design.md

File metadata and controls

173 lines (123 loc) · 16.8 KB

Project Design Document: json_serializable

Project Name: json_serializable

Project Repository: https://github.com/dart-lang/json_serializable

Document Version: 1.1 Date: October 26, 2023 Author: AI Software Architect

1. Introduction

This document provides a detailed design overview of the json_serializable Dart package. This package is a code generator designed to streamline the process of working with JSON data in Dart applications. It automates the generation of boilerplate code required for converting Dart classes to and from JSON format, thereby minimizing manual coding effort and reducing the likelihood of human errors. This document serves as a foundational resource for conducting threat modeling and security analysis of the json_serializable project.

2. Project Overview

2.1. Purpose

The core purpose of json_serializable is to automate the creation of JSON serialization and deserialization logic for Dart classes. Developers can avoid writing repetitive toJson() and fromJson() methods manually by simply annotating their Dart classes with @JsonSerializable. The build_runner tool then leverages these annotations to automatically generate the necessary code. This automation significantly boosts developer productivity and minimizes the risk of introducing errors commonly associated with manual serialization/deserialization implementations.

2.2. Target Audience

The primary target audience for json_serializable encompasses Dart developers who interact with JSON data within their applications. This includes, but is not limited to:

  • Flutter mobile application developers.
  • Backend developers utilizing Dart for server-side applications and APIs.
  • Web developers employing Dart for front-end web applications.
  • Any Dart developer working with systems or data formats that rely on JSON for data exchange.

2.3. Key Features

  • Automated Code Generation: Generates toJson() and fromJson() methods automatically for Dart classes marked with the @JsonSerializable annotation.
  • Customizable Serialization Behavior: Offers extensive customization options via annotations, enabling fine-grained control over aspects such as field naming conventions, handling of null values, and more.
  • Comprehensive Data Type Support: Handles a wide range of Dart data types, including primitive types (int, String, bool, double), collections (List, Map, Set), enums, and nested complex objects.
  • Seamless Integration with build_runner: Leverages the build_runner package as its code generation execution environment, ensuring a smooth and integrated development workflow within the Dart ecosystem.
  • Robust Error Handling Mechanisms: Provides mechanisms for managing potential errors that may occur during the serialization and deserialization processes.
  • Extensibility through Custom Converters: Supports the creation and use of custom converters, allowing developers to handle specialized data types or implement bespoke serialization logic beyond the standard capabilities.

3. System Architecture

3.1. Component Diagram

graph LR
    subgraph "Development Environment"
        "A[\"Dart Source Code with Annotations\"]" --> "B[\"json_serializable Package\"]";
        "C[\"build_runner Tool\"]" --> "B";
        "B" --> "D[\"Generated Dart Code\"]";
        "D" --> "E[\"Dart Project\"]";
    end

    subgraph "Dependencies"
        "B" --> "F[\"analyzer Package\"]";
        "B" --> "G[\"source_gen Package\"]";
        "B" --> "H[\"Dart SDK\"]";
    end
Loading

Components Description:

  • "Dart Source Code with Annotations" (A): This represents the input to json_serializable. It is the Dart code written by developers, containing classes that are annotated with @JsonSerializable and related configuration annotations to guide the code generation process.
  • "json_serializable Package" (B): This is the core code generation engine. It encapsulates the logic for parsing annotated Dart code, analyzing class structures and annotations, generating the corresponding serialization and deserialization code, and producing the output.
  • "build_runner Tool" (C): This is a Dart command-line tool that provides a generic framework for executing code generators. json_serializable is designed to integrate with build_runner to be invoked and executed as part of the standard Dart build process.
  • "Generated Dart Code" (D): This is the output produced by json_serializable. It consists of Dart code files containing the implementation of toJson() and fromJson() methods for the annotated classes. This generated code is typically placed alongside the original source code files within the project.
  • "Dart Project" (E): This represents the encompassing Dart project in which json_serializable is utilized. The generated code becomes an integral part of this project, being compiled and executed alongside the developer-written application code.
  • "analyzer Package" (F): A Dart package that provides a comprehensive API for parsing and analyzing Dart source code. json_serializable relies on analyzer to understand the structure of Dart code, resolve types, and extract information about classes and annotations.
  • "source_gen Package" (G): A Dart package that offers utilities and abstractions to simplify the development of code generators in Dart. json_serializable leverages source_gen to streamline the code generation process and manage boilerplate aspects of code generation.
  • "Dart SDK" (H): The Dart Software Development Kit, which provides the foundational Dart language runtime, core libraries, and essential tools necessary for developing, running, and building Dart applications, including code generators.

3.2. Data Flow Diagram

graph LR
    subgraph "Code Generation Process"
        "I[\"Developer Annotates Dart Class\"]" --> "J[\"build_runner Invokes json_serializable\"]";
        "J" --> "K[\"analyzer Parses Dart Source Code\"]";
        "K" --> "L[\"json_serializable Analyzes Annotations & Class Structure\"]";
        "L" --> "M[\"json_serializable Generates Serialization/Deserialization Code\"]";
        "M" --> "N[\"Generated Code Written to File\"]";
    end
Loading

Data Flow Description:

  1. "Developer Annotates Dart Class" (I): A developer identifies a Dart class that requires JSON serialization/deserialization and adds the @JsonSerializable annotation, along with any optional configuration annotations, to this class definition in their Dart source code.
  2. "build_runner Invokes json_serializable" (J): When the developer initiates the code generation process by running the build_runner tool, build_runner identifies json_serializable as a registered code generator within the project's configuration and invokes it.
  3. "analyzer Parses Dart Source Code" (K): json_serializable, upon invocation, utilizes the analyzer package to parse the Dart source code files that contain the annotated classes. This parsing step transforms the raw text of the Dart code into an abstract syntax tree (AST) representation that is easier for programmatic analysis.
  4. "json_serializable Analyzes Annotations & Class Structure" (L): json_serializable then analyzes the parsed code (AST), specifically examining the @JsonSerializable annotations and the structural details of the annotated classes, such as their fields, data types, and other relevant properties.
  5. "json_serializable Generates Serialization/Deserialization Code" (M): Based on the analysis of annotations and class structure, json_serializable proceeds to generate the Dart code for the toJson() and fromJson() methods. This generated code typically consists of boilerplate logic that handles the mapping and conversion between Dart objects and JSON structures, adhering to the specified configurations and conventions.
  6. "Generated Code Written to File" (N): Finally, json_serializable writes the generated Dart code into new files. These files are conventionally named with a .g.dart suffix and are placed in the same directory as the original source code files, making them readily accessible and importable within the Dart project.

4. Security Considerations

While json_serializable is primarily a development-time tool and does not directly process runtime data, security considerations are still pertinent, particularly concerning supply chain security and potential avenues for misuse or unintended consequences.

4.1. Input Validation and Code Generation Logic

  • Malicious Input Dart Code:

    • Threat: Although less likely to directly compromise json_serializable itself, maliciously crafted Dart code provided as input could potentially exploit vulnerabilities within the analyzer package or the code generation logic of json_serializable.
    • Example: Input designed to cause excessive resource consumption during analysis, leading to a denial-of-service during the build process. Or, in a highly improbable scenario, input that could trigger a bug in the code generator leading to the generation of syntactically invalid or semantically flawed code.
    • Mitigation: Robust input parsing and validation within analyzer and json_serializable. Defensive coding practices in the code generation logic to prevent unexpected behavior from unusual input structures.

  • Code Injection in Generated Code:

    • Threat: A critical concern is the possibility of the code generation logic inadvertently introducing vulnerabilities into the generated toJson() and fromJson() methods.
    • Example: If the code generator incorrectly handles specific data types, custom converters, or annotations, it could potentially generate code that is vulnerable to injection attacks when used in a runtime environment. For instance, flawed deserialization logic might be susceptible to type confusion or property injection if the input JSON is maliciously crafted.
    • Mitigation: Rigorous testing of code generation logic across all supported data types and annotation configurations. Secure coding practices in the code generator to ensure generated code is robust and resistant to common injection vulnerabilities. Code review and static analysis of the code generation logic.

  • Dependency Vulnerabilities:

    • Threat: json_serializable relies on external packages like analyzer and source_gen. Security vulnerabilities in these dependencies could indirectly impact json_serializable and projects that use it.
    • Example: A known vulnerability in a specific version of analyzer could be exploited if json_serializable depends on that vulnerable version.
    • Mitigation: Regularly monitor and update dependencies to their latest secure versions. Implement dependency scanning and vulnerability analysis tools in the development pipeline. Track security advisories for dependencies.

4.2. Configuration and Usage

  • Misconfiguration:

    • Threat: Incorrect configuration of json_serializable or related build settings could lead to unexpected behavior or issues during the build process. While not directly a security vulnerability in json_serializable itself, misconfiguration can result in application errors that might have security implications in a broader context.
    • Example: Incorrectly configured field naming strategies or custom converters could lead to data corruption or loss of data integrity during serialization/deserialization, potentially impacting application logic that relies on this data.
    • Mitigation: Provide clear and comprehensive documentation for configuration options. Offer validation and error reporting for common misconfiguration scenarios. Consider providing default configurations that are secure and sensible.

  • Build Process Security:

    • Threat: The security of the build environment where build_runner and json_serializable are executed is crucial. If the build environment is compromised, malicious code could be injected during the build process, potentially affecting the generated code and ultimately the deployed application. This is a broader supply chain security concern.
    • Example: If an attacker gains access to the build server, they could modify the json_serializable package or its dependencies to inject malicious code into the generated output.
    • Mitigation: Employ secure build pipeline practices, including using hardened build environments, access control, integrity checks for build tools and dependencies, and regular security audits of the build infrastructure.

4.3. Output Integrity

  • Integrity of Generated Code:
    • Threat: It is paramount to ensure that the generated code is correct, reliable, and behaves as intended. Bugs or flaws in the code generation logic could lead to incorrect serialization/deserialization, which might have downstream security implications depending on how the generated code is used within the application.
    • Example: Incorrect handling of sensitive data during serialization could lead to unintended data exposure. Flawed deserialization logic might introduce vulnerabilities in data processing logic if it misinterprets or corrupts incoming JSON data.
    • Mitigation: Extensive unit and integration testing of the code generation logic and the generated code itself. Employ property-based testing to cover a wide range of input scenarios. Code review of the code generation logic to identify potential flaws.

5. Threat Modeling Scope and Questions

The threat modeling exercise for json_serializable should primarily focus on the security aspects of the code generation process itself. To guide the threat modeling process, consider the following questions:

Input Validation & Analysis:

  • How does json_serializable validate and sanitize input Dart source code?
  • Are there any known or potential vulnerabilities in the analyzer package that could be exploited via crafted input to json_serializable?
  • What measures are in place to prevent denial-of-service attacks through maliciously crafted input code?

Code Generation Logic:

  • Is the code generation logic designed to prevent the introduction of common code vulnerabilities (e.g., injection flaws) in the generated toJson() and fromJson() methods?
  • How is the correctness and security of generated code ensured across all supported data types, annotations, and configurations?
  • Are there any scenarios where the generated code could exhibit unexpected or insecure behavior due to edge cases or complex input structures?

Dependency Management:

  • What is the process for managing and updating dependencies (especially analyzer and source_gen)?
  • Are dependencies regularly scanned for known security vulnerabilities?
  • How are security advisories for dependencies tracked and addressed?

Build Process Integration:

  • Are there any specific security considerations related to how json_serializable integrates with build_runner and the overall Dart build process?
  • Could a compromised build environment be used to inject malicious code through json_serializable?

Output Integrity:

  • How is the integrity and correctness of the generated code verified?
  • What testing strategies are employed to ensure the generated code functions as expected and does not introduce unexpected behavior or vulnerabilities?

6. Assumptions and Constraints

  • Trusted Development Environment: We assume a reasonably secure development environment where developers are not intentionally introducing malicious code as input to json_serializable.
  • Standard Usage with build_runner: We assume json_serializable is used as intended, integrated with build_runner within a standard Dart development workflow.
  • Focus on Code Generation Process Security: The primary focus is on the security of the code generation process itself, not on runtime vulnerabilities in applications that use the generated code (although the quality of generated code is crucial to minimize such risks).
  • Dart SDK Security Baseline: We assume the underlying Dart SDK and related core tools provide a reasonable level of security.

7. Conclusion

json_serializable is a critical tool for Dart developers, significantly simplifying JSON data handling and enhancing development efficiency. While primarily a development-time utility, security considerations are nonetheless important to ensure the tool itself does not become a source of vulnerabilities. This design document provides a comprehensive foundation for conducting a thorough threat model of json_serializable. By systematically addressing the security questions outlined and focusing on input validation, code generation logic robustness, dependency security, and build process integration, the json_serializable project can maintain its integrity, build user trust, and minimize the potential for inadvertently introducing security risks into the Dart ecosystem.