Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
71 lines (51 loc) · 6.3 KB

attack-tree.md

File metadata and controls

71 lines (51 loc) · 6.3 KB

Attack Tree Analysis for flutter/devtools

Objective: Attacker's Goal: To compromise application that use given project by exploiting weaknesses or vulnerabilities within the project itself.

Attack Tree Visualization

Compromise Application via DevTools **[HIGH-RISK PATH]**
├─── 1. Exploit DevTools Connection **[HIGH-RISK PATH]**
│   └─── 1.2. Unauthorized Access to DevTools Instance **[CRITICAL NODE]** **[HIGH-RISK PATH]**
│       ├─── 1.2.2. Lack of Authentication/Authorization **[CRITICAL NODE]** **[HIGH-RISK PATH]**
│       │   └─── 1.2.2.1. Connect to DevTools without Credentials
│       │       └─── Insight: Implement authentication/authorization for DevTools access.
├─── 2. Abuse DevTools Features for Malicious Actions **[HIGH-RISK PATH]**
│   ├─── 2.1. Code Injection/Execution via DevTools **[HIGH-RISK PATH]**
│   │   └─── 2.1.1. Evaluate Expressions (Malicious Code) **[CRITICAL NODE]** **[HIGH-RISK PATH]**
│   │       └─── 2.1.1.1. Execute Arbitrary Dart Code in Application Context
│   │           └─── Insight: Limit DevTools access to trusted developers.
│   └─── 2.2. Data Exfiltration via DevTools **[HIGH-RISK PATH]**
│       └─── 2.2.1. Inspect Application State (Sensitive Data) **[CRITICAL NODE]** **[HIGH-RISK PATH]**
│           └─── 2.2.1.1. View Variables, Objects, Memory Contents
│               └─── Insight: Be mindful of sensitive data in application state during development.

Attack Tree Path: 1. Compromise Application via DevTools [HIGH-RISK PATH]:

  • This is the overall attacker goal and represents the starting point of all high-risk paths. It signifies that exploiting DevTools is a viable avenue to compromise the application.

Attack Tree Path: 2. Exploit DevTools Connection [HIGH-RISK PATH]:

  • This path highlights that vulnerabilities in the connection mechanism between DevTools and the application are a significant risk. If the connection is not secure or access is not controlled, it opens doors for attacks.

Attack Tree Path: 3. Unauthorized Access to DevTools Instance [CRITICAL NODE] [HIGH-RISK PATH]:

  • Critical Node: This is a central point of vulnerability. If an attacker gains unauthorized access to a DevTools instance, they can leverage its powerful features for malicious purposes.
  • High-Risk Path: Unauthorized access directly leads to high-impact attacks like code injection and data exfiltration.
  • Attack Vector:
    • 1.2.2. Lack of Authentication/Authorization [CRITICAL NODE] [HIGH-RISK PATH]:
      • Critical Node: The absence of authentication is the primary enabler of unauthorized access.
      • High-Risk Path: Directly leads to trivial unauthorized access if DevTools is reachable.
      • 1.2.2.1. Connect to DevTools without Credentials: If DevTools lacks authentication, anyone who can reach the DevTools port can connect and gain full control.
      • Insight: Implementing authentication and authorization for DevTools access is paramount to mitigate this high-risk path. This is a critical feature gap in default DevTools usage that needs to be addressed, especially in non-local development environments.

Attack Tree Path: 4. Abuse DevTools Features for Malicious Actions [HIGH-RISK PATH]:

  • This path emphasizes that even if the initial connection is secure (in theory), the inherent capabilities of DevTools can be abused if unauthorized access is gained.

Attack Tree Path: 5. Code Injection/Execution via DevTools [HIGH-RISK PATH]:

  • This path highlights the severe risk of code injection through DevTools features.

Attack Tree Path: 6. Evaluate Expressions (Malicious Code) [CRITICAL NODE] [HIGH-RISK PATH]:

  • Critical Node: The "Evaluate Expressions" feature is a particularly dangerous tool in the hands of an attacker.
  • High-Risk Path: Directly enables arbitrary code execution within the application's context.
  • Attack Vector:
    • 2.1.1.1. Execute Arbitrary Dart Code in Application Context: Using the "Evaluate Expression" functionality, an attacker can execute any Dart code they want, effectively gaining full control over the application's behavior and data.
    • Insight: Restricting access to DevTools and educating developers about the risks of this feature are crucial. In a compromised scenario, this feature can be used to inject backdoors, steal data, or perform other malicious actions.

Attack Tree Path: 7. Data Exfiltration via DevTools [HIGH-RISK PATH]:

  • This path highlights the risk of sensitive data leakage through DevTools' inspection capabilities.

Attack Tree Path: 8. Inspect Application State (Sensitive Data) [CRITICAL NODE] [HIGH-RISK PATH]:

  • Critical Node: The ability to inspect application state is a powerful debugging feature, but also a significant data exfiltration risk if unauthorized access is gained.
  • High-Risk Path: Allows direct access to potentially sensitive data residing in the application's memory and variables.
  • Attack Vector:
    • 2.2.1.1. View Variables, Objects, Memory Contents: DevTools provides detailed views into the application's runtime state, allowing an attacker to browse variables, objects, and memory contents. This can expose sensitive information like API keys, user credentials, personal data, or business logic.
    • Insight: Developers should be extremely cautious about storing sensitive data in application state during development and debugging. Minimize the exposure of sensitive information and be aware that DevTools provides deep inspection capabilities.