Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
77 lines (68 loc) · 11.6 KB

attack-surface.md

File metadata and controls

77 lines (68 loc) · 11.6 KB

Attack Surface Analysis for flutter/engine

Attack Surface: Native Code Interoperability Vulnerabilities (Platform Channels & Plugins)

  • Description: Vulnerabilities arising from insecure communication and data handling between Dart code and native platform code through platform channels and plugins.
  • Engine Contribution: The Flutter Engine's architecture fundamentally relies on platform channels to bridge the gap between the Dart framework and platform-specific functionalities. The engine manages the serialization, deserialization, and communication flow across these channels, making it a critical component in this attack surface. Insecure handling within the engine or assumptions about data integrity can directly contribute to vulnerabilities.
  • Example: The Flutter Engine might not enforce strict type checking or validation on data received from native plugins via platform channels. A malicious plugin could send unexpected data types or malformed data that the Dart side is not prepared to handle, leading to crashes, unexpected behavior, or even exploitable conditions if the Dart code makes unsafe assumptions based on the expected data format.
  • Impact: Arbitrary file system access, data breaches, privilege escalation, arbitrary code execution within the plugin's context, denial of service.
  • Risk Severity: High to Critical
  • Mitigation Strategies:
    • Developers:
      • Secure Plugin Development (Crucial): Implement rigorous input validation and sanitization in plugin native code for all data received from Dart. Assume all data from Dart is potentially malicious.
      • Strict Data Type Handling in Dart: Implement robust type checking and validation in Dart code when receiving data from platform channels. Do not make assumptions about data integrity or format without explicit validation.
      • Minimize Native Code Complexity: Reduce the amount of complex native code in plugins to minimize the potential for vulnerabilities. Favor Dart implementations where possible.
    • Flutter Team (Engine Level):
      • Strengthen Platform Channel Security: Explore options to enhance platform channel security within the engine, such as built-in data validation mechanisms or stricter type enforcement (where feasible without breaking compatibility).
      • Provide Secure Channel API Guidance: Offer clear and comprehensive documentation and best practices for developers on how to securely use platform channels, highlighting potential pitfalls and secure coding patterns.
    • Users:
      • Review App Permissions: Be vigilant about permissions requested by Flutter applications, especially those utilizing plugins that access sensitive resources.
      • Keep Apps Updated: Update applications to benefit from plugin and potentially engine security updates.

Attack Surface: Skia Rendering Engine Vulnerabilities

  • Description: Vulnerabilities present within the Skia graphics library, which is deeply integrated into the Flutter Engine for all UI rendering.
  • Engine Contribution: The Flutter Engine directly incorporates and relies on Skia as its core rendering engine. The engine's rendering pipeline feeds data to Skia for processing. Any vulnerability in Skia's code directly becomes a vulnerability in the Flutter Engine and, consequently, in Flutter applications. The engine's exposure of Skia to potentially untrusted or crafted content (images, fonts, shaders) is the primary contribution to this attack surface.
  • Example: A critical heap buffer overflow vulnerability exists in Skia's JPEG decoding routine. The Flutter Engine, through Skia, processes JPEG images for UI elements. An attacker could craft a malicious JPEG image and deliver it to a Flutter application (e.g., via a network image, user-uploaded profile picture). When the engine attempts to render this image using Skia, the buffer overflow is triggered, potentially leading to arbitrary code execution within the application's process.
  • Impact: Arbitrary code execution, denial of service, UI rendering manipulation, application crashes, potential sandbox escape (depending on the platform and vulnerability).
  • Risk Severity: Critical
  • Mitigation Strategies:
    • Developers & Flutter Team:
      • Regular Flutter Engine Updates (Critical): The Flutter team must prioritize timely updates of the Skia library within the engine to incorporate security patches released by the Skia project. Developers must update their Flutter SDK and applications regularly to benefit from these engine updates. This is the most crucial mitigation.
      • Content Security Policies (Where Applicable - e.g., Web): In web contexts, Content Security Policies can help limit the sources of images and other renderable content, reducing the attack surface.
    • Flutter Team (Engine Level):
      • Proactive Skia Security Monitoring: Actively monitor Skia security advisories and vulnerability disclosures. Implement processes for rapid integration of Skia security patches into the Flutter Engine.
      • Fuzzing and Security Testing of Skia Integration: Conduct regular fuzzing and security testing specifically targeting the Flutter Engine's integration with Skia, focusing on image, font, and shader processing.
    • Users:
      • Keep Apps Updated (Essential): Updating applications is the primary way for users to benefit from Flutter Engine updates that include patched Skia versions and vulnerability fixes.

Attack Surface: Memory Safety Issues in Flutter Engine (C++ Core)

  • Description: Memory corruption vulnerabilities such as buffer overflows, use-after-free, double-free, and other memory management errors within the Flutter Engine's core C++ codebase.
  • Engine Contribution: The Flutter Engine's core is implemented in C++, a language known for requiring careful memory management. Memory safety vulnerabilities in the engine's core code are directly introduced by the engine's development and implementation choices. These vulnerabilities are inherent to the engine itself and affect all applications built with a vulnerable engine version.
  • Example: A use-after-free vulnerability exists in the Flutter Engine's text layout or rendering pipeline. Under specific conditions, related to complex text rendering or resource management during UI updates, a memory region is freed prematurely and then accessed again. This can lead to crashes, memory corruption, and potentially arbitrary code execution if an attacker can control the memory layout after the free operation.
  • Impact: Arbitrary code execution, denial of service, application crashes, memory corruption, potential for privilege escalation.
  • Risk Severity: Critical
  • Mitigation Strategies:
    • Flutter Team (Crucial):
      • Prioritize Memory Safety in Engine Development: Employ rigorous secure coding practices focused on memory safety throughout the engine development lifecycle. This includes:
        • Memory-Safe Coding Techniques: Utilize modern C++ features and coding patterns that minimize memory management errors (e.g., smart pointers, RAII).
        • Static Analysis Tools: Integrate and regularly use static analysis tools to automatically detect potential memory safety vulnerabilities in the engine's C++ code.
        • Fuzzing and Dynamic Analysis: Implement comprehensive fuzzing and dynamic analysis to uncover runtime memory safety issues.
        • Thorough Code Reviews: Conduct rigorous code reviews, specifically focusing on memory management aspects and potential vulnerability patterns.
      • Rapid Vulnerability Response: Establish a robust process for promptly addressing and patching reported memory safety vulnerabilities in the engine. Release security updates quickly and efficiently.
    • Developers:
      • Use Stable Flutter Channels: Utilize stable Flutter channels for production applications to benefit from thoroughly tested engine versions that have undergone more extensive scrutiny and bug fixing.
      • Report Suspected Engine Vulnerabilities: Report any suspected engine-level vulnerabilities, especially memory-related issues, to the Flutter team with detailed reproduction steps if possible.
    • Users:
      • Keep Apps Updated (Essential): Updating applications is the primary way for users to receive Flutter Engine updates that include critical memory safety fixes.

Attack Surface: Third-Party Dependency Vulnerabilities (Engine Dependencies)

  • Description: Security vulnerabilities present in third-party libraries that the Flutter Engine directly depends upon for its functionality.
  • Engine Contribution: The Flutter Engine integrates numerous third-party libraries (e.g., ICU, libpng, zlib, etc.) to provide various functionalities. The engine's dependency on these libraries means that any vulnerability in these dependencies is indirectly introduced into the Flutter Engine and, consequently, into Flutter applications. The engine's build process and dependency management directly contribute to this attack surface.
  • Example: A critical remote code execution vulnerability is discovered in zlib, a compression library used by the Flutter Engine (potentially indirectly through other dependencies). If the engine uses a vulnerable version of zlib, and if an attacker can somehow influence the engine to process compressed data using the vulnerable zlib code path (e.g., through a malicious asset or network resource), they could potentially exploit this vulnerability to execute arbitrary code within the application's context.
  • Impact: Arbitrary code execution, denial of service, application crashes, data breaches, potential supply chain compromise.
  • Risk Severity: High to Critical (depending on the vulnerability and the affected dependency).
  • Mitigation Strategies:
    • Flutter Team (Crucial):
      • Robust Dependency Management: Maintain a comprehensive and up-to-date inventory of all third-party dependencies used by the Flutter Engine.
      • Automated Dependency Vulnerability Scanning: Implement automated systems to continuously scan engine dependencies for known security vulnerabilities using vulnerability databases and security advisories.
      • Timely Dependency Updates: Establish a process for promptly updating vulnerable dependencies to patched versions as soon as security updates are released by the dependency maintainers. Prioritize security updates for critical dependencies.
      • Dependency Pinning and Reproducible Builds: Employ dependency pinning and strive for reproducible builds to ensure consistent dependency versions and reduce the risk of supply chain attacks or unexpected dependency changes.
    • Developers:
      • Use Recent Flutter SDK Versions (Best Practice): Using newer Flutter SDK versions generally includes updated dependencies and security patches. Regularly update your Flutter SDK.
    • Users:
      • Keep Apps Updated (Essential): Updating applications is the primary way for users to benefit from Flutter Engine updates that include patched dependencies and vulnerability fixes.