Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
121 lines (105 loc) · 12.1 KB

attack-tree.md

File metadata and controls

121 lines (105 loc) · 12.1 KB

Attack Tree Analysis for flutter/engine

Objective: Compromise a Flutter application via the most likely and impactful vulnerabilities within the Flutter Engine.

Attack Tree Visualization

**[CRITICAL NODE]** Compromise Flutter Application via Engine Exploitation **[CRITICAL NODE]**
├───[AND] **[CRITICAL NODE]** Exploit Engine Vulnerabilities **[CRITICAL NODE]** **[HIGH-RISK PATH]**
│   ├───[OR] **[CRITICAL NODE]** Memory Corruption Vulnerabilities **[CRITICAL NODE]** **[HIGH-RISK PATH]**
│   │   ├───[AND] **[HIGH-RISK PATH]** Buffer Overflow in Rendering Pipeline (Skia) **[HIGH-RISK PATH]**
│   │   │   └───[Outcome] **[CRITICAL NODE]** Engine crashes or allows code execution **[CRITICAL NODE]**
│   │   ├───[AND] **[HIGH-RISK PATH]** Use-After-Free in Input Handling **[HIGH-RISK PATH]**
│   │   │   └───[Outcome] **[CRITICAL NODE]** Engine crashes or allows code execution **[CRITICAL NODE]**
│   ├───[OR] Logic Vulnerabilities in Engine Core
│   │   ├───[AND] **[HIGH-RISK PATH]** Insecure Platform Channel Handling **[HIGH-RISK PATH]**
│   │   │   └───[Outcome] **[CRITICAL NODE]** Bypass security checks, gain unauthorized access to native resources/functions **[CRITICAL NODE]**
│   │   ├───[AND] **[HIGH-RISK PATH]** Flaws in Resource Loading/Access Control **[HIGH-RISK PATH]**
│   │   │   └───[Outcome] **[CRITICAL NODE]** Read sensitive data, modify application behavior **[CRITICAL NODE]**
│   ├───[OR] **[CRITICAL NODE]** Dependency Vulnerabilities (Transitive via Engine) **[CRITICAL NODE]** **[HIGH-RISK PATH]**
│   │   ├───[AND] **[HIGH-RISK PATH]** Vulnerable Skia Library **[HIGH-RISK PATH]**
│   │   │   └───[Outcome] **[CRITICAL NODE]** Engine crashes, code execution via Skia flaws **[CRITICAL NODE]**
│   │   ├───[AND] **[HIGH-RISK PATH]** Other Engine Dependencies (e.g., libpng, zlib, etc.) **[HIGH-RISK PATH]**
│   │   │   └───[Outcome] **[CRITICAL NODE]** Engine crashes, code execution via dependency flaws **[CRITICAL NODE]**

Attack Tree Path: [HIGH-RISK PATH] Buffer Overflow in Rendering Pipeline (Skia)

Attack Vector Breakdown:

  • Vulnerability: Buffer overflow vulnerability within the Skia rendering library, specifically in how it processes image data, shaders, fonts, or other rendering assets.
  • Action: Attacker crafts a malicious image, font, shader, or other asset designed to trigger a buffer overflow when processed by Skia.
  • Action: Attacker triggers the Flutter Engine to render content that includes this malicious asset. This could be through displaying a crafted image, using a malicious font, or rendering a scene with a malicious shader.
  • Outcome: If successful, the buffer overflow corrupts memory within the Flutter Engine process. This can lead to:
    • Engine Crash: The application terminates unexpectedly, causing denial of service.
    • Code Execution: More critically, the attacker might be able to overwrite return addresses or other critical data in memory, allowing them to inject and execute arbitrary code within the context of the Flutter application. This grants them full control over the application and potentially the user's device.
  • Mitigation Focus:
    • Rigorous fuzz testing of Skia integration within the Flutter Engine, especially image decoding, font rendering, and shader processing paths.
    • Regularly update Skia to the latest versions to patch known vulnerabilities.
    • Implement robust input validation and sanitization for all rendering assets processed by Skia.
    • Employ memory safety techniques in Skia integration code within the Flutter Engine.

Attack Tree Path: [HIGH-RISK PATH] Use-After-Free in Input Handling

Attack Vector Breakdown:

  • Vulnerability: Use-after-free vulnerability in the Flutter Engine's input handling logic. This occurs when memory allocated for handling input events (touch, keyboard, mouse) is freed prematurely, but still accessed later.
  • Action: Attacker sends a sequence of crafted input events to the Flutter application. These events are designed to trigger the specific code path containing the use-after-free vulnerability.
  • Action: Attacker might need to trigger a specific input sequence or timing to exploit the vulnerability reliably.
  • Outcome: A use-after-free can lead to:
    • Engine Crash: The application terminates due to memory corruption.
    • Code Execution: Similar to buffer overflows, use-after-free vulnerabilities can be exploited to gain code execution by manipulating the freed memory and controlling program flow.
  • Mitigation Focus:
    • Thorough code review and static analysis of input event processing code within the Flutter Engine, focusing on memory management and object lifetimes.
    • Dynamic analysis and fuzzing of input event handling to detect use-after-free conditions.
    • Employ memory safety techniques (smart pointers, garbage collection if applicable in relevant areas) in input handling code.

Attack Tree Path: [HIGH-RISK PATH] Insecure Platform Channel Handling

Attack Vector Breakdown:

  • Vulnerability: Insecure handling of Platform Channels, which are used for communication between Dart code and native platform code. This could involve:
    • Lack of proper validation of incoming messages from native code.
    • Insufficient authorization checks before performing actions requested via platform channels.
    • Vulnerabilities in the serialization/deserialization of messages.
  • Action: Attacker intercepts or manipulates platform channel messages. This might require a Man-in-the-Middle (MITM) attack in certain scenarios or exploiting vulnerabilities in the application's native code or platform APIs.
  • Action: Attacker sends malicious messages via platform channels. These messages are crafted to bypass security checks or trigger unintended actions in the native platform code.
  • Outcome: Successful exploitation can lead to:
    • Security Bypass: Attacker bypasses intended security restrictions within the application.
    • Unauthorized Access: Attacker gains access to native platform resources or functionalities that should be restricted. This could include accessing sensitive device data, invoking privileged APIs, or performing actions outside the application's intended scope.
  • Mitigation Focus:
    • Implement robust input validation and sanitization for all incoming platform channel messages in both Dart and native code.
    • Enforce strict authorization checks before performing any actions based on platform channel messages.
    • Use secure serialization/deserialization mechanisms for platform channel communication to prevent injection attacks.
    • Principle of least privilege: Limit the native functionalities accessible via platform channels to only what is absolutely necessary.

Attack Tree Path: [HIGH-RISK PATH] Flaws in Resource Loading/Access Control

Attack Vector Breakdown:

  • Vulnerability: Flaws in how the Flutter Engine loads and manages resources (assets, files, etc.), specifically related to access control. This could include:
    • Path traversal vulnerabilities allowing access to files outside the intended asset directory.
    • Bypasses in access control checks for certain resource types.
    • Vulnerabilities in resource loading mechanisms that allow loading of malicious resources.
  • Action: Attacker manipulates resource paths or loading mechanisms. This could involve crafting malicious resource paths with path traversal sequences (e.g., ../../sensitive_file) or exploiting vulnerabilities in how resource paths are processed.
  • Action: Attacker attempts to access restricted resources by bypassing engine-level access controls.
  • Outcome: Exploiting resource loading flaws can result in:
    • Sensitive Data Exposure: Attacker reads sensitive data stored within the application's assets or accessible through path traversal.
    • Application Behavior Modification: Attacker can replace legitimate resources with malicious ones, altering the application's behavior, appearance, or functionality in unintended and potentially harmful ways.
  • Mitigation Focus:
    • Implement strict path sanitization and validation for all resource paths to prevent path traversal attacks.
    • Enforce robust access control mechanisms for resource loading, ensuring that only authorized resources can be accessed.
    • Principle of least privilege: Limit the directories and resource types that the engine can access.
    • Regularly audit resource loading code for potential vulnerabilities.

Attack Tree Path: [HIGH-RISK PATH] Vulnerable Skia Library

Attack Vector Breakdown:

  • Vulnerability: Known or zero-day vulnerabilities within the Skia graphics library, which is a core dependency of the Flutter Engine. Skia is a complex C++ library and vulnerabilities are discovered periodically.
  • Action: Attacker identifies a known vulnerability in Skia or discovers a new one.
  • Action: Attacker crafts content (images, fonts, shaders, etc.) that specifically triggers the Skia vulnerability when rendered by the Flutter Engine.
  • Outcome: Exploiting Skia vulnerabilities can lead to:
    • Engine Crash: Application crashes due to Skia error.
    • Code Execution: Skia vulnerabilities, especially memory corruption bugs, can often be exploited for arbitrary code execution within the application process.
  • Mitigation Focus:
    • Dependency Management: Maintain a rigorous process for tracking and updating Skia to the latest stable versions.
    • Vulnerability Monitoring: Actively monitor Skia security advisories and vulnerability databases for newly disclosed vulnerabilities.
    • Rapid Patching: Implement a process for quickly patching or updating the Flutter Engine when Skia vulnerabilities are announced.
    • Sandboxing (Limited): While full sandboxing of Skia might be complex, explore options to limit the impact of Skia vulnerabilities, such as process isolation or resource limits.

Attack Tree Path: [HIGH-RISK PATH] Other Engine Dependencies (e.g., libpng, zlib, etc.)

Attack Vector Breakdown:

  • Vulnerability: Vulnerabilities in other third-party libraries that the Flutter Engine depends on (beyond Skia, ICU, HarfBuzz). Examples include image decoding libraries (libpng, libjpeg), compression libraries (zlib), and others.
  • Action: Attacker identifies vulnerabilities in these dependencies (often known vulnerabilities).
  • Action: Attacker triggers engine functionality that utilizes the vulnerable dependency. For example, if libpng has a vulnerability, the attacker might provide a crafted PNG image to the application.
  • Outcome: Exploiting dependency vulnerabilities can result in:
    • Engine Crash: Application crashes due to dependency error.
    • Code Execution: Many dependency vulnerabilities, especially in C/C++ libraries, can lead to code execution.
  • Mitigation Focus:
    • Software Bill of Materials (SBOM): Maintain a comprehensive SBOM for the Flutter Engine to track all dependencies.
    • Automated Vulnerability Scanning: Implement automated tools to regularly scan engine dependencies for known vulnerabilities.
    • Dependency Updates: Establish a process for promptly updating vulnerable dependencies to patched versions.
    • Minimal Dependencies: Strive to minimize the number of dependencies and use well-maintained and actively secured libraries.