BUSINESS POSTURE

The Flutter packages repository provides a collection of officially maintained packages that extend the core functionality of the Flutter framework. This repository is crucial for the Flutter ecosystem, enabling developers to build more complex and feature-rich applications.

Business priorities and goals:
- Provide high-quality, reliable, and secure packages to the Flutter developer community.
- Expand the capabilities of the Flutter framework through well-maintained and feature-rich packages.
- Encourage adoption of Flutter by providing a comprehensive ecosystem of tools and libraries.
- Maintain the reputation and trust of the Flutter framework and ecosystem.
Most important business risks:
- Security vulnerabilities in packages could compromise applications built using them, damaging the reputation of Flutter and the packages repository.
- Unreliable or poorly maintained packages could hinder developer productivity and adoption of Flutter.
- Supply chain attacks targeting the packages repository could distribute malicious code to a large number of developers.
- Downtime or unavailability of the packages repository or related services (like pub.dev) could disrupt Flutter development workflows.

SECURITY POSTURE

Security controls:
- security control: Code review process for contributions to the repository. (Implemented in: GitHub pull request review process)
- security control: Automated testing (unit, integration, etc.) to ensure package quality and identify potential issues. (Implemented in: GitHub Actions workflows within the repository)
- security control: Static analysis and linting tools to enforce code quality and security best practices. (Implemented in: GitHub Actions workflows within the repository)
- security control: Dependency scanning to identify known vulnerabilities in package dependencies. (Likely implemented in: GitHub Actions workflows or internal Google security tooling)
- security control: Access control to the repository via GitHub permissions, limiting who can commit and merge code. (Implemented in: GitHub repository settings)
- security control: Usage of GitHub's security features like Dependabot for vulnerability alerts. (Implemented in: GitHub repository settings)
- security control: Publicly accessible repository, allowing community scrutiny and vulnerability reporting. (Implemented in: GitHub repository settings)
Accepted risks:
- accepted risk: Potential for undiscovered vulnerabilities in packages due to the complexity of software and the open-source nature of the project.
- accepted risk: Risk of malicious contributions being merged despite code review, although mitigated by review processes and community scrutiny.
- accepted risk: Reliance on third-party dependencies, which may introduce vulnerabilities outside of the direct control of the Flutter team.
Recommended security controls:
- security control: Implement a Software Bill of Materials (SBOM) generation process for each package to improve supply chain transparency.
- security control: Integrate automated security scanning tools (SAST/DAST) into the CI/CD pipeline to proactively identify vulnerabilities.
- security control: Establish a clear vulnerability reporting and response process, including a security contact and public security policy.
- security control: Perform regular security audits and penetration testing of critical packages and infrastructure.
- security control: Implement signing of packages to ensure integrity and authenticity when distributed via pub.dev.
Security requirements:
- Authentication:
  - Only authorized Flutter team members should be able to commit and publish packages. (Implemented via GitHub authentication and repository permissions)
- Authorization:
  - Granular access control within the repository to manage permissions for different packages and functionalities. (Implemented via GitHub teams and repository settings)
- Input validation:
  - Ensure all inputs to the packages (e.g., API parameters, configuration files) are properly validated to prevent injection attacks and other input-related vulnerabilities. (Responsibility of package developers, enforced through code review and testing)
- Cryptography:
  - Packages should utilize cryptography correctly and securely when handling sensitive data. (Responsibility of package developers, guided by security best practices and code review)
  - Protect sensitive data used in the build and deployment process, such as API keys and signing certificates. (Implemented via secure secret management in CI/CD pipelines and infrastructure)

DESIGN

C4 CONTEXT

flowchart LR
    subgraph "Flutter Ecosystem"
        center["Flutter Packages Repository"]
    end

    user["Flutter Developers"]
    pubdev["pub.dev"]
    flutter_sdk["Flutter SDK"]
    github["GitHub"]

    user --> center & pubdev & flutter_sdk
    center --> pubdev & github
    flutter_sdk --> pubdev

    style center fill:#f9f,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px

Loading

C4 Context elements description:
- - Name: Flutter Packages Repository
  - Type: Software System
  - Description: GitHub repository containing officially maintained Flutter packages.
  - Responsibilities:
    - Source code management for Flutter packages.
    - Development and maintenance of Flutter packages.
    - Collaboration platform for Flutter package development.
  - Security controls:
    - security control: GitHub access control.
    - security control: Code review process.
    - security control: Automated testing and security scanning.
- - Name: Flutter Developers
  - Type: Person
  - Description: Developers who use Flutter to build applications and rely on Flutter packages.
  - Responsibilities:
    - Consume Flutter packages in their applications.
    - Report issues and contribute to Flutter packages.
  - Security controls:
    - security control: Secure development practices when using packages.
    - security control: Verification of package integrity and authenticity (ideally via package signing).
- - Name: pub.dev
  - Type: Software System
  - Description: The official package repository for Dart and Flutter, distributing Flutter packages to developers.
  - Responsibilities:
    - Package hosting and distribution.
    - Package discovery and search.
    - Package versioning and dependency management.
  - Security controls:
    - security control: Package integrity verification.
    - security control: User authentication and authorization for package publishing.
    - security control: Security scanning of published packages.
- - Name: Flutter SDK
  - Type: Software System
  - Description: The Flutter Software Development Kit, which includes tools and libraries for building Flutter applications and integrates with Flutter packages.
  - Responsibilities:
    - Provides the core Flutter framework.
    - Integrates with pub.dev to download and manage packages.
    - Provides tools for developing and testing Flutter applications.
  - Security controls:
    - security control: Secure update mechanisms for the SDK itself.
    - security control: Integration with secure package management from pub.dev.
- - Name: GitHub
  - Type: Software System
  - Description: Web-based platform for version control and collaboration, hosting the Flutter packages repository.
  - Responsibilities:
    - Provides version control infrastructure (Git).
    - Hosts the source code repository.
    - Provides collaboration features (pull requests, issues, etc.).
    - Provides CI/CD capabilities (GitHub Actions).
  - Security controls:
    - security control: GitHub platform security controls (authentication, authorization, infrastructure security).
    - security control: GitHub security features (Dependabot, code scanning, etc.).

C4 CONTAINER

flowchart LR
    subgraph "Flutter Packages Repository"
        github_repo["GitHub Repository"]
        ci_cd["CI/CD Pipeline (GitHub Actions)"]
    end

    github["GitHub"] --> github_repo
    github_repo --> ci_cd
    ci_cd --> pubdev["pub.dev"]

    style github_repo fill:#f9f,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px
    style ci_cd fill:#f9f,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px

Loading

C4 Container elements description:
- - Name: GitHub Repository
  - Type: Container
  - Description: Git repository hosted on GitHub, containing the source code of Flutter packages.
  - Responsibilities:
    - Stores the source code, history, and metadata of Flutter packages.
    - Manages version control and collaboration.
  - Security controls:
    - security control: GitHub access control.
    - security control: Branch protection policies.
    - security control: Audit logs.
- - Name: CI/CD Pipeline (GitHub Actions)
  - Type: Container
  - Description: Automated workflows defined using GitHub Actions to build, test, and publish Flutter packages.
  - Responsibilities:
    - Automates the build process for packages.
    - Runs automated tests and security scans.
    - Publishes packages to pub.dev.
  - Security controls:
    - security control: Secure configuration of CI/CD pipelines.
    - security control: Secret management for credentials used in CI/CD.
    - security control: Code signing during the release process (recommended).
- - Name: pub.dev
  - Type: External Container
  - Description: The official package registry for Dart and Flutter (same as in Context Diagram).
  - Responsibilities:
    - Package hosting and distribution.
    - Package integrity verification.
  - Security controls:
    - security control: Package integrity checks.
    - security control: Security scanning of uploaded packages.

DEPLOYMENT

Deployment architecture for Flutter packages is primarily focused on publishing to pub.dev, which then handles distribution to developers via the Flutter SDK.

flowchart LR
    subgraph "Developer Environment"
        dev_machine["Developer Machine"]
    end

    subgraph "Build Environment (GitHub Actions)"
        build_agent["Build Agent"]
    end

    subgraph "pub.dev Infrastructure"
        pubdev_storage["Package Storage"]
        pubdev_cdn["CDN"]
    end

    dev_machine --> github_repo["GitHub Repository"]
    github_repo --> build_agent
    build_agent --> pubdev_storage
    pubdev_storage --> pubdev_cdn
    pubdev_cdn --> dev_machine

    style dev_machine fill:#f9f,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px
    style build_agent fill:#f9f,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px
    style pubdev_storage fill:#f9f,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px
    style pubdev_cdn fill:#f9f,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px

Loading

Deployment elements description:
- - Name: Developer Machine
  - Type: Infrastructure
  - Description: Developer's local machine used for coding, testing, and committing changes to the repository.
  - Responsibilities:
    - Code development and local testing.
    - Committing and pushing code changes to GitHub.
    - Downloading and using Flutter packages from pub.dev.
  - Security controls:
    - security control: Developer workstation security practices.
    - security control: Secure access to GitHub and pub.dev.
- - Name: Build Agent
  - Type: Infrastructure
  - Description: Virtual machine or container running GitHub Actions workflows to build, test, and publish packages.
  - Responsibilities:
    - Executes CI/CD pipelines.
    - Builds and tests Flutter packages.
    - Publishes packages to pub.dev.
  - Security controls:
    - security control: Secure build environment configuration.
    - security control: Isolation of build environments.
    - security control: Secure secret management for publishing credentials.
- - Name: Package Storage
  - Type: Infrastructure
  - Description: Storage infrastructure within pub.dev that stores the published Flutter packages.
  - Responsibilities:
    - Securely stores package files.
    - Provides access to packages for download.
  - Security controls:
    - security control: Access control to package storage.
    - security control: Data encryption at rest and in transit.
    - security control: Regular backups and disaster recovery.
- - Name: CDN
  - Type: Infrastructure
  - Description: Content Delivery Network used by pub.dev to distribute packages efficiently to developers worldwide.
  - Responsibilities:
    - Caches and delivers package files to developers.
    - Improves download speed and availability.
  - Security controls:
    - security control: CDN security features (DDoS protection, etc.).
    - security control: Secure delivery of packages over HTTPS.

BUILD

flowchart LR
    developer["Developer"] --> commit["Commit Code to GitHub"]
    commit --> github_actions["GitHub Actions Workflow Triggered"]
    github_actions --> build["Build Package"]
    build --> test["Run Automated Tests"]
    test --> security_scan["Run Security Scans (SAST, Dependency Check)"]
    security_scan --> publish["Publish Package to pub.dev"]
    publish --> package_registry["Package Registry (pub.dev)"]

    style developer fill:#f9f,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px
    style github_actions fill:#f9f,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px
    style package_registry fill:#f9f,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px

Loading

Build elements description:
- - Name: Developer
  - Type: Person
  - Description: Software developer contributing to the Flutter packages repository.
  - Responsibilities:
    - Writes and maintains package code.
    - Commits code changes to the repository.
  - Security controls:
    - security control: Secure coding practices.
    - security control: Code review participation.
- - Name: Commit Code to GitHub
  - Type: Process
  - Description: Developer commits and pushes code changes to the GitHub repository.
  - Responsibilities:
    - Version control of code changes.
    - Triggering CI/CD pipeline.
  - Security controls:
    - security control: Authenticated commits via GitHub.
    - security control: Branch protection policies.
- - Name: GitHub Actions Workflow Triggered
  - Type: Process
  - Description: GitHub Actions workflow is automatically triggered upon code commit.
  - Responsibilities:
    - Orchestrates the build, test, and publish process.
  - Security controls:
    - security control: Secure workflow definition.
    - security control: Access control to workflow configuration.
- - Name: Build Package
  - Type: Process
  - Description: The package is built using the Flutter SDK and build tools within the CI/CD environment.
  - Responsibilities:
    - Compiling and packaging the package code.
    - Generating build artifacts.
  - Security controls:
    - security control: Secure build environment.
    - security control: Dependency management and vulnerability scanning.
- - Name: Run Automated Tests
  - Type: Process
  - Description: Automated tests (unit, integration, etc.) are executed to ensure package quality and functionality.
  - Responsibilities:
    - Verifying package functionality and stability.
    - Identifying regressions and bugs.
  - Security controls:
    - security control: Comprehensive test suite.
    - security control: Test environment security.
- - Name: Run Security Scans (SAST, Dependency Check)
  - Type: Process
  - Description: Static Application Security Testing (SAST) and dependency vulnerability checks are performed.
  - Responsibilities:
    - Identifying potential security vulnerabilities in code and dependencies.
    - Enforcing security standards.
  - Security controls:
    - security control: Integration of SAST and dependency scanning tools.
    - security control: Regular updates of security scanning tools and vulnerability databases.
- - Name: Publish Package to pub.dev
  - Type: Process
  - Description: If tests and security scans pass, the package is published to pub.dev.
  - Responsibilities:
    - Distributing the package to the Flutter developer community.
    - Making the package available for download via pub.dev.
  - Security controls:
    - security control: Secure publishing process with authentication and authorization.
    - security control: Package signing (recommended).
    - security control: Package integrity checks on pub.dev.
- - Name: Package Registry (pub.dev)
  - Type: System
  - Description: The official package registry (same as in Context and Container diagrams).
  - Responsibilities:
    - Hosting and distributing Flutter packages.
    - Providing package discovery and management.
  - Security controls:
    - security control: Package integrity verification.
    - security control: Security scanning of published packages.
    - security control: Infrastructure security of pub.dev.

RISK ASSESSMENT

Critical business processes we are trying to protect:
- Distribution of secure and reliable Flutter packages to developers.
- Maintaining the integrity and availability of the Flutter package ecosystem.
- Protecting the reputation and trust of the Flutter framework and packages.
Data we are trying to protect and their sensitivity:
- Source code of Flutter packages: High sensitivity. Compromise could lead to vulnerabilities in Flutter applications and intellectual property theft.
- Package signing keys (if implemented): Critical sensitivity. Compromise could allow attackers to publish malicious packages.
- Credentials for publishing to pub.dev: High sensitivity. Compromise could allow unauthorized package publishing.
- Build environment secrets and configurations: Medium sensitivity. Could be exploited to compromise the build process.
- Package metadata (package names, versions, descriptions): Low sensitivity. Publicly available information, but integrity is important.

QUESTIONS & ASSUMPTIONS

BUSINESS POSTURE:
- Assumption: The primary business goal is to provide a secure and reliable ecosystem of Flutter packages to encourage Flutter adoption and developer productivity.
- Question: What is the acceptable level of risk for security vulnerabilities in Flutter packages, considering the impact on the Flutter ecosystem?
- Question: What are the specific SLAs or uptime requirements for the Flutter packages repository and related services (like pub.dev)?
SECURITY POSTURE:
- Assumption: Existing security controls include standard GitHub security features, code review, and automated testing.
- Question: Are there any formal security audits or penetration testing performed on the Flutter packages repository or critical packages?
- Question: Is there a dedicated security team or individual responsible for the security of Flutter packages?
- Question: What is the current vulnerability reporting and response process for Flutter packages?
DESIGN:
- Assumption: The deployment model relies on publishing packages to pub.dev for distribution.
- Question: Are there any plans to implement package signing for Flutter packages to enhance integrity and authenticity?
- Question: What are the specific security configurations and hardening measures applied to the CI/CD pipeline and build environment?
- Question: How are secrets managed and protected within the CI/CD pipeline and build environment?

Provide feedback

Saved searches

Use saved searches to filter your results more quickly

sec-design.md

sec-design.md

BUSINESS POSTURE

SECURITY POSTURE

DESIGN

C4 CONTEXT

C4 CONTAINER

DEPLOYMENT

BUILD

RISK ASSESSMENT

QUESTIONS & ASSUMPTIONS

Files

sec-design.md

Latest commit

History

sec-design.md

File metadata and controls

BUSINESS POSTURE

SECURITY POSTURE

DESIGN

C4 CONTEXT

C4 CONTAINER

DEPLOYMENT

BUILD

RISK ASSESSMENT

QUESTIONS & ASSUMPTIONS