Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
115 lines (84 loc) · 11.9 KB

mitigations.md

File metadata and controls

115 lines (84 loc) · 11.9 KB

Mitigation Strategies Analysis for argoproj/argo-cd

Mitigation Strategy: Enforce Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA) for Argo CD Users

  • Description:

    • Step 1: Configure Argo CD to integrate with an enterprise Identity Provider (IdP) that supports MFA, such as OIDC or SAML. This is typically done during Argo CD installation or configuration using command-line flags or Helm chart values.
    • Step 2: Within Argo CD's authentication settings, ensure that the chosen IdP is correctly configured and enabled as the authentication source.
    • Step 3: Verify that Argo CD is configured to require authentication for all users or specific roles based on your security policy.
    • Step 4: Test the MFA integration by attempting to log in to Argo CD with a user account managed by the integrated IdP. Ensure the MFA challenge is presented during login.
    • Step 5: Regularly review Argo CD's authentication configuration to confirm MFA remains enabled and correctly configured.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Compromised User Credentials - Severity: High
    • Brute-force Attacks on User Accounts - Severity: Medium
    • Phishing Attacks Targeting User Passwords - Severity: High

  • Impact:

    • Compromised User Credentials: High reduction - MFA significantly reduces the risk of unauthorized access even if passwords are compromised.
    • Brute-force Attacks on User Accounts: Medium reduction - MFA makes brute-force attacks significantly harder and less likely to succeed.
    • Phishing Attacks Targeting User Passwords: High reduction - MFA adds an extra layer of security beyond passwords, making phishing less effective.

  • Currently Implemented: Partially implemented - Argo CD is integrated with an IdP, and MFA is enabled for administrator accounts through the IdP, but not yet enforced for all developer accounts within Argo CD's access control policies.

  • Missing Implementation: Enforce MFA for all developer accounts accessing Argo CD by configuring Argo CD's authentication policies to require MFA for all roles or groups.

Mitigation Strategy: Implement Role-Based Access Control (RBAC) with Least Privilege within Argo CD

  • Description:

    • Step 1: Define custom roles within Argo CD's RBAC configuration (e.g., using argocd-rbac-cm.yaml ConfigMap or declarative configuration). These roles should align with job functions and access needs.
    • Step 2: For each custom role, explicitly define the allowed actions (e.g., get, create, update, delete, sync) on specific Argo CD resources (e.g., applications, projects, repositories). Grant only the minimum necessary permissions.
    • Step 3: Define groups within Argo CD (either local groups or groups synced from the integrated IdP).
    • Step 4: Bind the defined roles to users or groups within Argo CD's RBAC configuration.
    • Step 5: Regularly review and audit Argo CD's RBAC policies using argocd admin rbac validate command or by inspecting the argocd-rbac-cm ConfigMap. Refine policies as needed to maintain least privilege.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Unauthorized Access to Sensitive Applications within Argo CD - Severity: High
    • Privilege Escalation within Argo CD - Severity: High
    • Accidental or Malicious Configuration Changes by Unauthorized Users within Argo CD - Severity: Medium

  • Impact:

    • Unauthorized Access to Sensitive Applications within Argo CD: High reduction - RBAC restricts access to applications and Argo CD features based on roles, preventing unauthorized actions within Argo CD.
    • Privilege Escalation within Argo CD: High reduction - Least privilege RBAC minimizes the impact of compromised accounts by limiting their potential actions within Argo CD.
    • Accidental or Malicious Configuration Changes by Unauthorized Users within Argo CD: Medium reduction - RBAC reduces the risk of unintended changes within Argo CD by limiting who can modify configurations.

  • Currently Implemented: Partially implemented - Basic roles like admin and readonly are used, but more granular custom roles tailored to specific teams and application sets within Argo CD are missing.

  • Missing Implementation: Define and implement granular custom roles within Argo CD for different teams and application sets. Automate RBAC policy review and auditing within Argo CD configuration management.

Mitigation Strategy: Integrate Argo CD with HashiCorp Vault for Secrets Management

  • Description:

    • Step 1: Install and configure the necessary Argo CD plugin or integration component that enables Vault secret retrieval (e.g., kustomize-vault plugin, or using Argo CD's built-in support for external secrets).
    • Step 2: Configure Argo CD's settings to connect to the HashiCorp Vault instance. This typically involves providing Vault address, authentication method (e.g., Kubernetes auth, token), and any necessary credentials within Argo CD's configuration.
    • Step 3: When defining Argo CD Applications or ApplicationSets, utilize templating or plugin mechanisms within manifests (e.g., Kustomize, Helm) to reference secrets stored in Vault using Vault paths instead of embedding plain text secrets.
    • Step 4: Ensure Argo CD's service account or configured authentication method has the necessary permissions within Vault to read the required secrets.
    • Step 5: Test the integration by deploying an application through Argo CD that retrieves secrets from Vault. Verify that secrets are correctly injected into the application without being exposed in Git or Argo CD's configuration.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Secrets Stored in Git Repositories used by Argo CD - Severity: High
    • Exposure of Secrets in Kubernetes Secrets managed by Argo CD (etcd) - Severity: Medium
    • Hardcoded Secrets in Application Manifests managed by Argo CD - Severity: High

  • Impact:

    • Secrets Stored in Git Repositories used by Argo CD: High reduction - Vault integration eliminates the need to store secrets in Git repositories managed by Argo CD, preventing accidental exposure in version control.
    • Exposure of Secrets in Kubernetes Secrets managed by Argo CD (etcd): Medium reduction - While Kubernetes Secrets might still be used as an intermediary, Vault becomes the source of truth, and secrets are managed and rotated securely outside of Argo CD's direct storage.
    • Hardcoded Secrets in Application Manifests managed by Argo CD: Low to Medium reduction - Vault integration encourages better secrets management practices within Argo CD workflows, but requires developers to actively use it in manifests.

  • Currently Implemented: Not implemented - Argo CD is currently not integrated with HashiCorp Vault. Secrets are managed using Kubernetes Secrets and sometimes environment variables within Argo CD managed applications.

  • Missing Implementation: Implement full integration of Argo CD with HashiCorp Vault for all applications deployed through Argo CD. Configure Argo CD to use Vault for secret retrieval.

Mitigation Strategy: Implement Manifest Validation with OPA (Open Policy Agent) as an Argo CD Admission Controller

  • Description:

    • Step 1: Configure Argo CD to use a webhook admission controller. This is typically done by configuring Argo CD settings to point to the OPA instance's webhook endpoint.
    • Step 2: Deploy OPA policies (Rego policies) that are relevant to Kubernetes manifests and Argo CD deployments. These policies will be enforced by OPA when Argo CD attempts to deploy or synchronize applications.
    • Step 3: Within Argo CD's settings, configure the webhook admission controller to be enabled for specific actions (e.g., Create, Update, Sync) and resource types (e.g., Applications, Deployments, Services).
    • Step 4: Test the integration by attempting to deploy an application through Argo CD that violates an OPA policy. Verify that Argo CD rejects the deployment and provides an error message based on the OPA policy violation.
    • Step 5: Regularly update and refine OPA policies to ensure they remain effective and aligned with security and compliance requirements for Argo CD deployments.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Misconfigurations in Kubernetes Manifests Deployed by Argo CD - Severity: Medium to High (depending on misconfiguration)
    • Deployment of Non-Compliant Applications through Argo CD - Severity: Medium
    • Accidental Introduction of Vulnerabilities through Manifest Changes in Argo CD Workflows - Severity: Medium

  • Impact:

    • Misconfigurations in Kubernetes Manifests Deployed by Argo CD: Medium to High reduction - OPA policies enforced by Argo CD can catch common misconfigurations and enforce best practices, reducing the risk of vulnerabilities in deployments managed by Argo CD.
    • Deployment of Non-Compliant Applications through Argo CD: Medium reduction - OPA ensures that applications deployed through Argo CD adhere to defined security and compliance standards.
    • Accidental Introduction of Vulnerabilities through Manifest Changes in Argo CD Workflows: Medium reduction - OPA acts as a gatekeeper within Argo CD, preventing the deployment of manifests that violate security policies during Argo CD synchronization.

  • Currently Implemented: Not implemented - Argo CD does not currently use OPA or any webhook admission controller for manifest validation.

  • Missing Implementation: Configure Argo CD to integrate with OPA as a webhook admission controller. Define and implement relevant OPA policies for Argo CD deployments.

Mitigation Strategy: Regularly Update Argo CD Components

  • Description:

    • Step 1: Monitor Argo CD releases and security advisories by subscribing to the Argo CD mailing list or watching the Argo CD GitHub repository.
    • Step 2: Plan and schedule regular updates of Argo CD components to the latest stable version. Follow Argo CD's upgrade documentation for the specific installation method used (e.g., Helm, manifests).
    • Step 3: Before updating the production Argo CD instance, perform testing of the new Argo CD version in a staging or non-production Argo CD environment. Verify compatibility with existing applications and configurations.
    • Step 4: Apply the Argo CD update to the production environment during a planned maintenance window.
    • Step 5: After the update, verify the Argo CD instance is functioning correctly and monitor for any issues.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Exploitation of Known Vulnerabilities in Argo CD Components - Severity: High
    • Denial of Service Attacks Targeting Vulnerable Argo CD Components - Severity: Medium

  • Impact:

    • Exploitation of Known Vulnerabilities in Argo CD Components: High reduction - Regular updates patch known vulnerabilities in Argo CD itself, significantly reducing the attack surface of the deployment pipeline.
    • Denial of Service Attacks Targeting Vulnerable Argo CD Components: Medium reduction - Updates often include performance improvements and fixes for denial-of-service vulnerabilities within Argo CD.

  • Currently Implemented: Partially implemented - Argo CD components are updated periodically, but the process is not strictly scheduled or consistently applied immediately after new releases.

  • Missing Implementation: Formalize a scheduled process for Argo CD component updates, including proactive monitoring of releases, testing in staging Argo CD, and documented update procedures. Implement automated notifications for new Argo CD releases and security advisories.