Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
136 lines (107 loc) · 9.75 KB

mitigations.md

File metadata and controls

136 lines (107 loc) · 9.75 KB

Mitigation Strategies Analysis for cockroachdb/cockroach

Mitigation Strategy: Network Partitioning and Node Failure Resilience

Mitigation Strategy: CockroachDB Cluster Topology and Configuration

Description:

  1. --locality Flag: Use the --locality flag when starting each CockroachDB node. Example: cockroach start --locality=region=us-east1,zone=us-east1-a .... This is fundamental to CockroachDB's awareness of node placement.
  2. Replication Factor (Cluster-Wide): Configure the default replication factor during cluster initialization or adjust it later using: ALTER RANGE default CONFIGURE ZONE USING num_replicas = 3; (or 5). This sets the default for the entire cluster.
  3. Lease Management (Monitoring): Use SHOW TRACE FOR SESSION to debug and understand lease behavior, particularly if you suspect issues. Monitor lease acquisition times and potential leaseholder problems via CockroachDB's built-in metrics (exposed via HTTP endpoint).
  4. Clock Synchronization (Verification): While NTP is the mechanism, CockroachDB provides metrics to verify its effectiveness. Monitor clock skew using CockroachDB's built-in metrics (e.g., sys.clock-offset.meannanos).

Threats Mitigated:

  • Node Failure (High Severity): Correct --locality and replication factor ensure data redundancy.
  • Network Partition (High Severity): --locality helps CockroachDB make intelligent decisions about replica placement to survive partitions.
  • Split-Brain Scenario (Critical Severity): CockroachDB's internal consensus mechanisms (using Raft), combined with proper replication, prevent this.
  • Clock Skew Issues (High Severity): Monitoring CockroachDB's clock offset metrics helps identify and address synchronization problems that could affect consistency.

Impact:

  • Node Failure: Risk significantly reduced; cluster operation continues if a majority of replicas are available.
  • Network Partition: Risk significantly reduced; the majority partition continues to operate.
  • Split-Brain Scenario: Risk effectively eliminated by CockroachDB's design, provided the cluster is configured correctly.
  • Clock Skew Issues: Risk mitigated by proactive monitoring and addressing any significant deviations.

Currently Implemented:

  • --locality Flag: [ Placeholder: e.g., "Used with region and zone" ]
  • Replication Factor: [ Placeholder: e.g., "Set to 3" ]
  • Lease Management (Monitoring): [ Placeholder: e.g., "Not actively monitored" ]
  • Clock Synchronization (Verification): [Placeholder: e.g., "Not actively monitored"]

Missing Implementation:

  • Lease Management (Monitoring): [ Placeholder: e.g., "Add monitoring for lease-related metrics" ]
  • Clock Synchronization (Verification): [Placeholder: e.g., "Add monitoring for clock offset metrics"]

Mitigation Strategy: Data Locality and Geo-Distribution Optimization

Mitigation Strategy: CockroachDB Zone Configurations and Geo-Partitioning

Description:

  1. --locality (Again - Critical): Reinforces the importance of this flag for all locality-related features.
  2. ALTER ... CONFIGURE ZONE: Use this command extensively to control data placement. Examples:
    • ALTER TABLE users CONFIGURE ZONE USING constraints = '{'+region=us-east': 1}';
    • ALTER DATABASE my_db CONFIGURE ZONE USING num_replicas = 3, constraints = '{'+region=us-west': 1, '+region=us-east': 2}';
  3. Geo-Partitioning (if required): Use PARTITION BY LIST or PARTITION BY RANGE in your CREATE TABLE statements, in conjunction with ALTER TABLE ... CONFIGURE ZONE on the partitions. This is a CockroachDB-specific schema design technique.
  4. AS OF SYSTEM TIME (Follower Reads): Use this clause in your SQL queries to enable follower reads (if eventual consistency is acceptable). Example: SELECT * FROM my_table AS OF SYSTEM TIME '-10s'; This is a direct CockroachDB SQL feature.

Threats Mitigated:

  • High Query Latency (Medium Severity): Zone configurations and follower reads direct queries to closer replicas.
  • Data Residency Violations (Critical Severity): Geo-partitioning, controlled by CONFIGURE ZONE, ensures compliance.

Impact:

  • High Query Latency: Risk significantly reduced.
  • Data Residency Violations: Risk eliminated with correct geo-partitioning setup.

Currently Implemented:

  • --locality: [ Placeholder: e.g., "Consistently used" ]
  • ALTER ... CONFIGURE ZONE: [ Placeholder: e.g., "Partially implemented for some tables" ]
  • Geo-Partitioning: [ Placeholder: e.g., "Not implemented" ]
  • AS OF SYSTEM TIME: [ Placeholder: e.g., "Not used" ]

Missing Implementation:

  • ALTER ... CONFIGURE ZONE: [ Placeholder: e.g., "Need comprehensive zone configurations for all tables" ]
  • Geo-Partitioning: [ Placeholder: e.g., "Evaluate and implement if required by regulations" ]
  • AS OF SYSTEM TIME: [ Placeholder: e.g., "Implement for appropriate read queries" ]

Mitigation Strategy: Secure Cluster Configuration

Mitigation Strategy: CockroachDB Certificate Management and RBAC

Description:

  1. Certificate Generation: Use cockroach cert create-ca, cockroach cert create-node, and cockroach cert create-client to generate the necessary TLS certificates. This is specific to CockroachDB's secure setup.
  2. --certs-dir: Start CockroachDB nodes with the --certs-dir flag, pointing to the directory containing the certificates. This is essential for secure communication.
  3. RBAC (SQL Commands): Use CockroachDB's SQL commands for role-based access control:
    • CREATE ROLE
    • GRANT <privileges> ON <database/table> TO <role>
    • GRANT <role> TO <user>
    • SHOW GRANTS (to verify permissions)
  4. --enterprise-encryption (Encryption at Rest): Use this flag when starting CockroachDB nodes to enable encryption at rest (requires an enterprise license). This is a CockroachDB-specific feature.
  5. --log (Audit Logging): Use the --log flag with the sql_audit channel to enable audit logging. Example: cockroach start --log='{sinks: {file-groups: {default: {channels: [sql_audit]}}}}'. This is a CockroachDB-specific configuration.

Threats Mitigated:

  • Unauthorized Access (Critical Severity): RBAC (using CockroachDB's SQL commands) prevents this.
  • Data Breach (Critical Severity): --enterprise-encryption protects data at rest. Certificates and --certs-dir ensure TLS encryption for data in transit.
  • Man-in-the-Middle Attacks (High Severity): TLS encryption (via certificates) prevents this.
  • Insider Threats (High Severity): RBAC limits damage; --log with sql_audit provides audit trails.

Impact:

  • Unauthorized Access: Risk significantly reduced.
  • Data Breach: Risk significantly reduced.
  • Man-in-the-Middle Attacks: Risk eliminated with proper TLS setup.
  • Insider Threats: Risk reduced and auditability improved.

Currently Implemented:

  • Certificate Generation: [ Placeholder: e.g., "Certificates generated" ]
  • --certs-dir: [ Placeholder: e.g., "Used on all nodes" ]
  • RBAC (SQL Commands): [ Placeholder: e.g., "Basic roles defined" ]
  • --enterprise-encryption: [ Placeholder: e.g., "Not implemented" ]
  • --log (Audit Logging): [*Placeholder: e.g., "Not implemented"]

Missing Implementation:

  • RBAC (SQL Commands): [ Placeholder: e.g., "Need more granular roles" ]
  • --enterprise-encryption: [ Placeholder: e.g., "Evaluate and implement if required" ]
  • --log (Audit Logging): [Placeholder: e.g., "Implement and configure"]

Mitigation Strategy: Operational Best Practices (CockroachDB-Specific)

Mitigation Strategy: CockroachDB Backup, Restore, and Schema Change Tools

Description:

  1. Backup: Use cockroach dump (for logical backups) or BACKUP (for cluster-level backups). These are CockroachDB-specific commands.
  2. Restore: Use cockroach sql (with the output of cockroach dump) or RESTORE. Again, these are CockroachDB-specific commands.
  3. Schema Changes (Online): Leverage CockroachDB's built-in support for online schema changes whenever possible. This is a key feature of CockroachDB.
  4. Upgrades (Rolling): Follow CockroachDB's documented procedures for rolling upgrades, which are specific to its distributed architecture.

Threats Mitigated:

  • Data Loss (Critical Severity): cockroach dump and BACKUP provide the means for recovery.
  • Downtime (High Severity): CockroachDB's online schema changes and rolling upgrade capabilities minimize downtime.
  • Data Corruption (Critical Severity): Careful use of CockroachDB's schema change mechanisms reduces this risk.

Impact:

  • Data Loss: Risk significantly reduced.
  • Downtime: Risk reduced.
  • Data Corruption: Risk reduced.

Currently Implemented:

  • Backup: [ Placeholder: e.g., "Manual cockroach dump used" ]
  • Restore: [ Placeholder: e.g., "Not regularly tested" ]
  • Schema Changes (Online): [ Placeholder: e.g., "Awareness of online changes, but not consistently utilized" ]
  • Upgrades (Rolling): [Placeholder: e.g., "Ad-hoc upgrades"]

Missing Implementation:

  • Backup: [ Placeholder: e.g., "Automate and test regularly" ]
  • Restore: [ Placeholder: e.g., "Regularly test restore procedures" ]
  • Schema Changes (Online): [ Placeholder: e.g., "Fully utilize online schema change capabilities" ]
  • Upgrades (Rolling): [Placeholder: e.g., "Formalize rolling upgrade process"]