Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
95 lines (76 loc) · 7.97 KB

mitigations.md

File metadata and controls

95 lines (76 loc) · 7.97 KB

Mitigation Strategies Analysis for fyne-io/fyne

Mitigation Strategy: Fyne-Aware Testing and Fuzzing

  • Description:

    1. UI Testing (Fyne-Specific): Implement UI tests using a framework that can interact with Fyne widgets. This is not just general UI testing; it requires understanding Fyne's widget structure and event handling. This might involve:
      • Creating custom test helpers that can find and interact with specific Fyne widgets (e.g., by name, type, or content).
      • Simulating user interactions (clicks, typing, scrolling) on Fyne widgets.
      • Asserting the state of Fyne widgets after interactions (e.g., checking the text content of a label, the selected item in a list).
    2. Input Validation Testing (Fyne Widget Focus): Specifically target Fyne widgets with a range of inputs, including:
      • Valid inputs within expected ranges.
      • Boundary conditions (e.g., maximum/minimum values, empty strings).
      • Invalid inputs (e.g., excessively long strings, special characters, unexpected data types).
      • Inputs designed to trigger edge cases in Fyne's rendering or layout logic.
    3. Fuzz Testing (Fyne API Targets):
      • Use a Go fuzzing framework (e.g., go-fuzz).
      • Create fuzz targets that directly call Fyne APIs, particularly those related to:
        • Widget creation and configuration.
        • Layout management.
        • Event handling.
        • Data binding.
        • Custom rendering (if used).
      • The fuzz targets should take random byte inputs and use them to generate Fyne API calls. This helps uncover unexpected behavior or crashes due to malformed input.
    4. Continuous Fuzzing and Crash Analysis: Run the fuzz tests continuously and analyze any crashes to identify and fix vulnerabilities in Fyne or in how your application uses Fyne.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Fyne-Specific Bugs/Vulnerabilities (Direct): (Severity: Medium to High) - Uncovers vulnerabilities in Fyne's core logic, widget implementations, rendering engine, and event handling. This is the primary threat this strategy addresses.
    • Misuse of Fyne APIs: (Severity: Medium) - Helps identify cases where your application code uses Fyne APIs incorrectly, leading to unexpected behavior or vulnerabilities within the context of Fyne's functionality.

  • Impact:

    • Fyne-Specific Bugs: Reduces the risk moderately (e.g., 30-50%) by proactively finding and fixing bugs in Fyne itself. The impact depends on the thoroughness of the fuzzing and testing.
    • Misuse of Fyne APIs: Reduces the risk slightly (e.g., 10-20%) by identifying some instances of API misuse that manifest as Fyne-related issues.

  • Currently Implemented:

    • Basic unit tests for application logic exist.
    • Some manual testing of UI interactions is performed.

  • Missing Implementation:

    • No dedicated UI testing framework with Fyne-specific helpers is used.
    • No fuzz testing targeting Fyne APIs is implemented.
    • Input validation testing is not specifically focused on Fyne widget behavior and edge cases.

Mitigation Strategy: Fyne-Focused Code Reviews and Developer Training

  • Description:

    1. Fyne-Specific Code Review Checklist: Develop a checklist specifically for reviewing how Fyne APIs are used. This goes beyond general code review and focuses on Fyne's nuances. Items should include:
      • Correct Widget Usage: Verify that Fyne widgets are used according to their intended purpose and documentation. For example, check that Entry widgets with Password = true are used for sensitive input.
      • Data Handling within Widgets: Ensure that data passed to and retrieved from Fyne widgets is handled securely. This includes checking for proper sanitization, validation, and encryption where necessary.
      • Event Handler Security: Review Fyne event handlers (e.g., OnChanged, OnTapped) to ensure they don't introduce vulnerabilities. Check for potential race conditions, denial-of-service issues, or unintended side effects.
      • Custom Widget/Renderer Review: If the application uses custom Fyne widgets or renderers, scrutinize these very carefully for potential vulnerabilities. Custom code interacting with Fyne's internals has a higher risk.
      • Layout and Sizing Issues: Check for potential layout or sizing issues that could lead to unexpected behavior or visual glitches, especially on different screen sizes or resolutions.
    2. Fyne Security Training: Provide training to developers that specifically covers:
      • The architecture of Fyne and how it interacts with the underlying OS.
      • Common security pitfalls when using Fyne.
      • Best practices for secure Fyne development.
      • Examples of secure and insecure Fyne code snippets.
      • How to use the Fyne-specific code review checklist.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Misuse of Fyne APIs: (Severity: Medium) - This is the primary target. Reduces the risk of developers introducing vulnerabilities due to misunderstanding or incorrect usage of Fyne's API.
    • Fyne-Specific Bugs (Indirectly): (Severity: Low) - By promoting a deeper understanding of Fyne, it can indirectly reduce the chance of developers triggering latent bugs in Fyne.

  • Impact:

    • Misuse of Fyne APIs: Reduces the risk moderately (e.g., 40-60%) by improving developer knowledge and code quality specifically related to Fyne.
    • Fyne-Specific Bugs: Reduces the risk slightly (e.g., 5-10%) through indirect effects.

  • Currently Implemented:

    • General code reviews are conducted.
    • Informal knowledge sharing among developers.

  • Missing Implementation:

    • No Fyne-specific code review checklist exists.
    • No formal training materials or sessions dedicated to Fyne security are provided.

Mitigation Strategy: Secure Theme and Style Handling (Within Fyne's Constraints)

  • Description:

    1. Static Theme Definition (Preferred): Define application themes as Go code within the application, using Fyne's built-in theming APIs. Avoid loading themes from external files or user input.
    2. Input Sanitization (for Customization): If any user input, even seemingly innocuous choices like color preferences, influences the appearance through Fyne's theming system, strictly sanitize this input. Use a whitelist approach, allowing only a predefined set of safe values. Do not allow arbitrary CSS or other styling languages.
    3. Review Custom Theme Code: If you create custom themes by extending Fyne's theming system, review this code carefully for potential vulnerabilities. Ensure that your custom theme code doesn't introduce any security risks.
    4. Avoid Dynamic Theme Loading: Do not load themes or styles from untrusted sources.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Theme and Styling Vulnerabilities (within Fyne): (Severity: Low to Medium) - Prevents injection of malicious code or unexpected behavior through Fyne's theming mechanisms. The severity depends on how much customization is allowed.

  • Impact:

    • Theme and Styling Vulnerabilities: Reduces the risk significantly (e.g., 80-90%) if dynamic theme loading is avoided and any user-influenced styling is strictly sanitized.

  • Currently Implemented:

    • The application uses a built-in Fyne theme.
    • No user customization of themes is allowed.

  • Missing Implementation:

    • No specific input sanitization is performed for the limited styling options (e.g., light/dark mode) that are available, although the risk is very low in this case because these are typically handled by Fyne's built-in mechanisms.