Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
169 lines (133 loc) · 12.9 KB

attack-tree.md

File metadata and controls

169 lines (133 loc) · 12.9 KB

Attack Tree Analysis for go-martini/martini

Objective: Gain unauthorized access, control, or disrupt the Martini-based application by exploiting vulnerabilities inherent in the Martini framework or its common usage patterns.

Attack Tree Visualization

Attack Goal: Compromise Martini Application (Martini-Specific) ├───[AND] Exploit Martini Framework Weaknesses │ ├───[OR] Routing Exploitation [CRITICAL NODE] │ │ ├─── Route Misconfiguration [CRITICAL NODE] [HIGH-RISK PATH] │ │ │ └─── Expose Internal Routes [HIGH-RISK PATH] │ │ │ └─── Access Admin/Debug Routes [CRITICAL NODE] │ │ └─── Parameter Manipulation in Routes [HIGH-RISK PATH] [CRITICAL NODE] │ │ └─── Bypass Authorization Checks (if based on route params) [CRITICAL NODE] │ ├───[OR] Middleware Exploitation [CRITICAL NODE] │ │ ├─── Conditional Logic Flaws in Middleware [HIGH-RISK PATH] │ │ ├─── Vulnerable Middleware (Core or Community) [CRITICAL NODE] │ │ │ └─── Research Publicly Disclosed Vulnerabilities [HIGH-RISK PATH] │ │ └─── Middleware Misconfiguration [CRITICAL NODE] [HIGH-RISK PATH] │ │ └─── Incorrect Middleware Ordering [CRITICAL NODE] │ │ └─── Bypass Security Middleware (e.g., Authentication) [CRITICAL NODE] [HIGH-RISK PATH] │ ├───[OR] Dependency Injection (DI) Exploitation │ │ └─── Service Misconfiguration Leading to Vulnerabilities [CRITICAL NODE] [HIGH-RISK PATH] │ │ └─── Misconfigured Database Connection injected as Service [CRITICAL NODE] [HIGH-RISK PATH] │ │ └─── Exploit Database Credentials or Connection [CRITICAL NODE] [HIGH-RISK PATH] │ └───[OR] Error Handling Exploitation [CRITICAL NODE] │ └─── Information Disclosure via Error Pages [HIGH-RISK PATH] [CRITICAL NODE] │ └─── Trigger Errors to Reveal Sensitive Information (Path Disclosure, Internal Configuration) [CRITICAL NODE] [HIGH-RISK PATH] └───[AND] Application-Specific Weaknesses (Leveraged via Martini) └─── (Omitted - General Web App Vulnerabilities)

Attack Tree Path: 1. Routing Exploitation - Route Misconfiguration - Expose Internal Routes - Access Admin/Debug Routes [HIGH-RISK PATH, CRITICAL NODES]

  • Attack Vector:

    • Attackers attempt to access commonly known or predictable paths associated with administrative or debugging functionalities (e.g., /admin, /debug, /internal/metrics).
    • If these routes are unintentionally exposed due to misconfiguration, attackers can gain access without proper authorization.

  • Actionable Insight:

    • Principle of Least Privilege: Restrict route exposure to only necessary functionalities. Internal or debug routes should not be accessible in production environments.
    • Route Review: Regularly audit route definitions to identify and remove any unintentionally exposed internal routes.
    • Route Security: Implement robust authentication and authorization middleware specifically for sensitive routes.

  • Estimations:

    • Likelihood: Medium
    • Impact: Moderate (Information Disclosure, Potential Privilege Escalation)
    • Effort: Low
    • Skill Level: Low
    • Detection Difficulty: Medium

Attack Tree Path: 2. Routing Exploitation - Parameter Manipulation in Routes - Bypass Authorization Checks [HIGH-RISK PATH, CRITICAL NODES]

  • Attack Vector:

    • Applications using route parameters (e.g., /users/:id) for authorization might be vulnerable if authorization logic solely relies on these parameters without proper validation and context.
    • Attackers can manipulate route parameters in subsequent requests to potentially bypass authorization checks and access resources they should not be allowed to.

  • Actionable Insight:

    • Robust Authorization: Avoid relying solely on route parameters for authorization decisions. Implement secure session management, JWTs, or other established authentication and authorization mechanisms.
    • Parameter Validation: Always validate and sanitize route parameters to prevent unexpected input and potential injection vulnerabilities (though less directly Martini-specific).

  • Estimations:

    • Likelihood: Medium
    • Impact: Moderate (Unauthorized Access)
    • Effort: Low
    • Skill Level: Low
    • Detection Difficulty: Medium

Attack Tree Path: 3. Middleware Exploitation - Conditional Logic Flaws in Middleware [HIGH-RISK PATH]

  • Attack Vector:

    • Custom middleware with flawed conditional logic can be exploited to bypass intended security checks.
    • Attackers analyze middleware code to identify weaknesses in conditional statements (e.g., incorrect boolean logic, missing edge cases) and craft requests to trigger bypass conditions.

  • Actionable Insight:

    • Middleware Code Review: Conduct thorough code reviews of all custom middleware to identify and rectify logic errors and potential bypass conditions.
    • Unit Testing Middleware: Implement comprehensive unit tests for middleware to ensure it functions as expected under various conditions and input scenarios, specifically testing edge cases and boundary conditions.

  • Estimations:

    • Likelihood: Medium
    • Impact: Moderate to Critical (Depends on middleware function)
    • Effort: Medium
    • Skill Level: Medium
    • Detection Difficulty: Medium

Attack Tree Path: 4. Middleware Exploitation - Vulnerable Middleware - Research Publicly Disclosed Vulnerabilities [HIGH-RISK PATH, CRITICAL NODE]

  • Attack Vector:

    • Martini applications using vulnerable middleware libraries (either Martini core extensions or community-developed middleware) are susceptible to exploitation if known vulnerabilities exist.
    • Attackers research publicly disclosed vulnerabilities in Martini middleware dependencies and attempt to exploit them in target applications.

  • Actionable Insight:

    • Dependency Management: Maintain a strict dependency management process. Keep Martini core and all middleware dependencies up-to-date to patch known vulnerabilities promptly.
    • Vulnerability Scanning: Utilize dependency vulnerability scanning tools to automatically identify vulnerable middleware libraries used in the application.
    • Middleware Auditing: Before incorporating community middleware, conduct security audits and reviews to assess their security posture and identify potential vulnerabilities.

  • Estimations:

    • Likelihood: Low (Martini core is small, community middleware varies)
    • Impact: Critical (Depends on vulnerability)
    • Effort: Low to Medium (If vulnerability is known and easily exploitable) to Medium (If requires adaptation)
    • Skill Level: Low to Medium (If exploit is readily available) to Medium (For adaptation)
    • Detection Difficulty: Medium

Attack Tree Path: 5. Middleware Exploitation - Exploit Logic Flaws in Custom Middleware [HIGH-RISK PATH]

  • Attack Vector:

    • Logic flaws and vulnerabilities can be present in custom middleware developed specifically for the application.
    • Attackers analyze custom middleware code to identify logic errors and vulnerabilities that can be exploited to compromise security.

  • Actionable Insight:

    • Secure Coding Practices: Adhere to secure coding practices during the development of custom middleware to minimize the introduction of vulnerabilities.
    • Peer Review: Implement mandatory peer reviews for all custom middleware code to have other developers scrutinize the code for potential security vulnerabilities and logic flaws.

  • Estimations:

    • Likelihood: Medium
    • Impact: Moderate to Critical (Depends on middleware function)
    • Effort: Medium
    • Skill Level: Medium
    • Detection Difficulty: Medium

Attack Tree Path: 6. Middleware Misconfiguration - Incorrect Middleware Ordering - Bypass Security Middleware [HIGH-RISK PATH, CRITICAL NODES]

  • Attack Vector:

    • Incorrect ordering of middleware in the Martini application pipeline can lead to security middleware being bypassed.
    • For example, if authentication middleware is placed after middleware serving static files, unauthenticated users might gain access to protected static content.

  • Actionable Insight:

    • Middleware Order Awareness: Carefully consider and document the intended order of middleware execution. Ensure that security-related middleware (authentication, authorization, rate limiting, etc.) is always placed before middleware that handles request processing or content serving.
    • Middleware Documentation: Maintain clear documentation outlining the intended middleware order and its security implications for developers and operations teams.

  • Estimations:

    • Likelihood: Medium
    • Impact: Critical (Complete Bypass of Security)
    • Effort: Low
    • Skill Level: Low
    • Detection Difficulty: Medium

Attack Tree Path: 7. Dependency Injection (DI) Exploitation - Service Misconfiguration Leading to Vulnerabilities - Misconfigured Database Connection - Exploit Database Credentials or Connection [HIGH-RISK PATH, CRITICAL NODES]

  • Attack Vector:

    • If services injected via Martini's DI system are misconfigured, especially those handling sensitive resources like database connections, they can become a vulnerability.
    • A common example is a misconfigured database connection service with weak credentials or exposed connection details, allowing attackers to exploit these weaknesses.

  • Actionable Insight:

    • Secure Service Configuration: Implement secure configuration practices for all services, particularly those managing sensitive resources. Utilize environment variables or secure configuration management systems to store and manage credentials. Avoid hardcoding credentials directly in the application code.
    • Principle of Least Privilege for Services: Grant services only the necessary permissions and access required for their intended functionality. Limit database user permissions to the minimum required for the application.

  • Estimations:

    • Likelihood: Low to Medium (Depends on configuration practices)
    • Impact: Critical (Data Breach, Data Manipulation)
    • Effort: Low to Medium (If misconfiguration is easily discoverable)
    • Skill Level: Low to Medium (Basic database exploitation skills)
    • Detection Difficulty: Medium

Attack Tree Path: 8. Error Handling Exploitation - Information Disclosure via Error Pages - Trigger Errors to Reveal Sensitive Information [HIGH-RISK PATH, CRITICAL NODES]

  • Attack Vector:

    • Martini's default error handling or poorly configured custom error handling might inadvertently reveal sensitive information in error responses.
    • This can include stack traces, internal paths, configuration details, and other information valuable for attackers during reconnaissance. Attackers intentionally trigger errors (e.g., by sending invalid requests) to elicit detailed error pages and gather this sensitive information.

  • Actionable Insight:

    • Custom Error Handling: Implement custom error handlers to control the information disclosed in error responses. Ensure that error responses in production environments are generic and do not reveal sensitive internal details.
    • Production Error Handling: In production, configure error handling to log detailed errors securely for debugging purposes but return only generic error messages to clients, preventing information leakage.

  • Estimations:

    • Likelihood: Medium
    • Impact: Low to Moderate (Information Gathering, Reconnaissance)
    • Effort: Very Low
    • Skill Level: Very Low
    • Detection Difficulty: Very Easy