Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
132 lines (96 loc) · 10.7 KB

attack-tree.md

File metadata and controls

132 lines (96 loc) · 10.7 KB

Attack Tree Analysis for inconshreveable/ngrok

Objective: Attacker's Goal: To compromise application that use ngrok by exploiting high-risk weaknesses or vulnerabilities within the project itself, focusing on the most probable and impactful attack vectors.

Attack Tree Visualization

Attack Goal: **Compromise Application via ngrok [CRITICAL NODE]**

└── **Exploit ngrok-Specific Vulnerabilities/Misconfigurations [CRITICAL NODE]**
    ├── **1. Unintended Public Exposure & Access [HIGH RISK PATH]**
    │   ├── **1.1. Application Not Designed for Public Access [HIGH RISK PATH]**
    │   │   ├── **1.1.1. Exploit Application Vulnerabilities (Now Publicly Accessible) [HIGH RISK PATH]**
    │   │   │   ├── **1.1.1.1. Exploit Known Web App Vulnerabilities (SQLi, XSS, etc.) [HIGH RISK]**
    │   │   │   ├── 1.1.1.2. Exposure of Internal API Endpoints [HIGH RISK]
    │   │   ├── **1.2. Weak or Default ngrok Configuration [HIGH RISK PATH]**
    │   │   │   ├── **1.2.1. Lack of Authentication/Authorization on Application [HIGH RISK]**
    │   │   │   ├── **1.2.2. Overly Permissive ngrok Tunnel Configuration (e.g., open to all IPs) [HIGH RISK]**
    ├── **2. Abuse of ngrok Service Features [CRITICAL NODE]**
    │   ├── **2.1. Session Replay/Hijacking via Public URL (if HTTP used) [HIGH RISK PATH]**
    │   │   ├── **2.1.1. Intercept and Replay Requests via Public ngrok URL (if HTTP used) [HIGH RISK]**
    │   ├── **2.2. Denial of Service (DoS) via Public URL [HIGH RISK PATH]**
    │   │   ├── **2.2.1. Overload Application via Publicly Accessible Endpoint [HIGH RISK]**
    ├── 3. MitM Attack on ngrok Tunnel (If HTTP is used) [HIGH RISK PATH]
    │   ├── **3.1. MitM Attack on ngrok Tunnel (If HTTP is used) [HIGH RISK PATH]**
    │   │   ├── **3.1.1. Intercept Traffic between User and ngrok Server (If HTTP) [HIGH RISK]**
    ├── **4. Social Engineering related to Public ngrok URL [CRITICAL NODE]**
    │   ├── **4.1. Phishing using Public ngrok URL [HIGH RISK PATH]**
    │   │   ├── **4.1.1. Deceive Users into Accessing Malicious Content via ngrok URL [HIGH RISK]**
    │   ├── **4.2. Credential Harvesting via Publicly Exposed Login Pages [HIGH RISK PATH]**
    │   │   ├── **4.2.1. Set up Fake Login Page behind ngrok and Harvest Credentials [HIGH RISK]**

Attack Tree Path: 1. Exploit ngrok-Specific Vulnerabilities/Misconfigurations [CRITICAL NODE]

  • This is the overarching category of threats directly related to using ngrok. It encompasses issues arising from how ngrok exposes the application and how it's configured.

    • Actionable Insights: Focus on secure application development practices, proper configuration of both the application and ngrok, and understanding the implications of public exposure.

Attack Tree Path: 2. Unintended Public Exposure & Access [HIGH RISK PATH]

  • This path highlights the fundamental risk of making an application, potentially designed for internal use, publicly accessible via ngrok.

    • Actionable Insights:

      • Principle of Least Privilege: Only expose what is absolutely necessary via ngrok.
      • Assume Public Access: Treat any application exposed via ngrok as if it's directly on the public internet and secure it accordingly.

    • 2.1. Application Not Designed for Public Access [HIGH RISK PATH]:

      • Applications built for internal networks often lack robust security controls expected in public-facing applications. ngrok bypasses network-level security, exposing these weaknesses.

        • Actionable Insights:

          • Security Review: Conduct a thorough security review of the application specifically considering public access scenarios.
          • Harden Application: Implement necessary security controls (authentication, authorization, input validation, output encoding, etc.) before exposing via ngrok.

        • 2.1.1. Exploit Application Vulnerabilities (Now Publicly Accessible) [HIGH RISK PATH]:

          • Existing web application vulnerabilities (SQL Injection, Cross-Site Scripting, etc.) become easily exploitable when the application is made public through ngrok.

            • Actionable Insights:
              • Vulnerability Scanning & Penetration Testing: Regularly scan and test the application for known web vulnerabilities.
              • Secure Coding Practices: Enforce secure coding practices throughout the development lifecycle.
              • 1.1.1.1. Exploit Known Web App Vulnerabilities (SQLi, XSS, etc.) [HIGH RISK]: Attackers can leverage common web vulnerabilities to gain unauthorized access, manipulate data, or compromise user accounts.
              • 1.1.1.2. Exposure of Internal API Endpoints [HIGH RISK]: APIs intended for internal use, when exposed publicly, can be abused to bypass intended workflows or access sensitive data.

      • 2.2. Weak or Default ngrok Configuration [HIGH RISK PATH]:

        • Misconfigurations or reliance on default settings in ngrok can lead to security vulnerabilities.

          • Actionable Insights:
            • Configuration Review: Carefully review ngrok configuration and ensure it aligns with security requirements.
            • Principle of Least Privilege (Configuration): Configure ngrok with the least permissive settings necessary.
            • 1.2.1. Lack of Authentication/Authorization on Application [HIGH RISK]: If the application relies solely on network security and lacks its own authentication/authorization, ngrok makes it completely open to the internet.
            • 1.2.2. Overly Permissive ngrok Tunnel Configuration (e.g., open to all IPs) [HIGH RISK]: While default ngrok is public, understanding this and not adding further permissive configurations is crucial.

Attack Tree Path: 3. Abuse of ngrok Service Features [CRITICAL NODE]

  • Attackers can exploit the features of ngrok itself to facilitate attacks against the application.

    • Actionable Insights:

      • HTTPS Enforcement: Always use HTTPS for ngrok tunnels to prevent traffic interception.
      • Rate Limiting & DoS Protection: Implement application-level DoS protection mechanisms.

    • 3.1. Session Replay/Hijacking via Public URL (if HTTP used) [HIGH RISK PATH]:

      • If HTTP is used for the ngrok tunnel, traffic is unencrypted and vulnerable to interception and replay attacks.

        • Actionable Insights:
          • HTTPS Mandatory: Never use HTTP for sensitive applications over ngrok.
          • Session Management Security: Ensure robust session management in the application itself.
          • 2.1.1. Intercept and Replay Requests via Public ngrok URL (if HTTP used) [HIGH RISK]: Attackers can intercept unencrypted HTTP traffic and replay requests to gain unauthorized access or perform actions as a legitimate user.

    • 3.2. Denial of Service (DoS) via Public URL [HIGH RISK PATH]:

      • The public nature of ngrok URLs makes the application easily targetable for DoS attacks.

        • Actionable Insights:
          • DoS Mitigation: Implement rate limiting, request throttling, and other DoS prevention measures in the application.
          • 2.2.1. Overload Application via Publicly Accessible Endpoint [HIGH RISK]: Attackers can flood the publicly accessible ngrok URL with requests, overwhelming the application and causing service disruption.

Attack Tree Path: 4. MitM Attack on ngrok Tunnel (If HTTP is used) [HIGH RISK PATH]

  • If HTTP is used, the ngrok tunnel becomes a vulnerable point for Man-in-the-Middle attacks.

    • Actionable Insights:

      • HTTPS is Critical: Reinforce the absolute necessity of using HTTPS.
      • Network Security Awareness: Understand the network path and potential MitM risks if HTTP is ever considered.

    • 4.1. MitM Attack on ngrok Tunnel (If HTTP is used) [HIGH RISK PATH]:

      • Attackers can intercept and manipulate traffic between the user and the ngrok server if HTTP is used.

        • Actionable Insights:
          • HTTPS Only: Again, emphasize HTTPS.
          • 3.1.1. Intercept Traffic between User and ngrok Server (If HTTP) [HIGH RISK]: Attackers positioned on the network path can intercept unencrypted HTTP traffic, potentially stealing credentials or modifying requests and responses.

Attack Tree Path: 5. Social Engineering related to Public ngrok URL [CRITICAL NODE]

  • The public and sometimes less familiar nature of ngrok URLs can be exploited for social engineering attacks.

    • Actionable Insights:

      • User Education: Educate users about the risks of clicking on unfamiliar links, even if they seem to relate to your application via ngrok.
      • URL Awareness: Be mindful of how ngrok URLs are presented and shared.

    • 5.1. Phishing using Public ngrok URL [HIGH RISK PATH]:

      • Attackers can use ngrok to host phishing sites and distribute the ngrok URL, potentially deceiving users.

        • Actionable Insights:
          • URL Verification: Train users to carefully verify URLs and security indicators.
          • 4.1.1. Deceive Users into Accessing Malicious Content via ngrok URL [HIGH RISK]: Attackers can create convincing phishing pages hosted via ngrok and trick users into entering credentials or downloading malware.

    • 5.2. Credential Harvesting via Publicly Exposed Login Pages [HIGH RISK PATH]:

      • Attackers can set up fake login pages behind ngrok to harvest credentials, leveraging the public accessibility.

        • Actionable Insights:
          • Login Page Security: Ensure login pages are always served over HTTPS and have strong security indicators.
          • 4.2.1. Set up Fake Login Page behind ngrok and Harvest Credentials [HIGH RISK]: Attackers can create fake login pages mimicking legitimate services and host them via ngrok to steal user credentials.