Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
131 lines (110 loc) · 15.7 KB

mitigations.md

File metadata and controls

131 lines (110 loc) · 15.7 KB

Mitigation Strategies Analysis for juanfont/headscale

Mitigation Strategy: Keep Headscale Updated

  • Description:
    1. Monitoring Releases: Subscribe to Headscale's release announcements (e.g., GitHub releases, mailing lists) to stay informed about new versions and security updates.
    2. Regular Updates: Establish a process for regularly updating Headscale to the latest stable version. Test updates in a staging environment before deploying to production.
    3. Automated Updates (Carefully): Consider automating Headscale updates using scripting or configuration management tools, but ensure thorough testing and rollback procedures are in place.
  • List of Threats Mitigated:
    • Known Headscale Vulnerabilities (High Severity): Patches known security vulnerabilities in Headscale itself, preventing exploitation by attackers.
  • Impact: High risk reduction for known Headscale vulnerabilities.
  • Currently Implemented: Partial. Release announcements are monitored. Updates are performed manually every few months.
  • Missing Implementation: Automated update process is not implemented. Updates are not performed as frequently as recommended.

Mitigation Strategy: Secure Configuration

  • Description:
    1. Strong Secrets: Generate strong, random secrets for DERP_API_SECRET and other sensitive configuration parameters. Use tools like openssl rand -base64 32 to generate secrets.
    2. Configuration Review: Thoroughly review all Headscale configuration options and understand their security implications. Configure options according to security best practices and the principle of least privilege within Headscale's capabilities.
    3. Secure Storage: Store the Headscale configuration file with appropriate file permissions (e.g., chmod 600 headscale.yaml, owned by the Headscale user). Restrict access to the configuration file to only authorized users and processes.
  • List of Threats Mitigated:
    • Credential Compromise (High Severity): Weak or default secrets can be easily compromised, allowing unauthorized access to the Headscale server and control over the VPN.
    • Misconfiguration Vulnerabilities (Medium Severity): Incorrect configuration settings within Headscale can introduce security vulnerabilities or weaken the overall security posture of the VPN.
  • Impact: High risk reduction for credential compromise and Medium risk reduction for misconfiguration vulnerabilities.
  • Currently Implemented: Yes. Strong secrets are used. Configuration file permissions are restricted.
  • Missing Implementation: Periodic review of the entire Headscale configuration against security best practices is not regularly performed.

Mitigation Strategy: Robust Authentication and Authorization

  • Description:
    1. Strong Admin Credentials: Enforce strong passwords for Headscale administrative users (if using web UI or CLI). Consider using password complexity requirements and regular password rotation.
    2. Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA): Implement MFA for administrative access to Headscale. This can be achieved through reverse proxy integration with an identity provider that supports MFA (e.g., using Authelia, Keycloak, or cloud provider's IAM).
    3. Node Authentication Policies: Carefully choose node authentication methods. If possible, move away from pre-shared keys to more robust methods like OIDC integration for user-based authentication and authorization.
    4. Access Control Lists (ACLs): Implement and rigorously test Headscale ACLs to enforce the principle of least privilege. Define granular rules to restrict network access between nodes based on roles and responsibilities. Regularly review and update ACLs.
  • List of Threats Mitigated:
    • Unauthorized Access (High Severity): Weak authentication or lack of authorization controls within Headscale can allow unauthorized users or nodes to access the Headscale network and resources.
    • Privilege Escalation (Medium Severity): Insufficient authorization controls within Headscale can allow users or nodes to gain access to resources beyond their intended privileges within the VPN.
  • Impact: High risk reduction for unauthorized access and Medium risk reduction for privilege escalation.
  • Currently Implemented: Partial. Strong passwords are enforced for admin users. Basic ACLs are implemented.
  • Missing Implementation: MFA for admin access is not implemented. OIDC integration for node authentication is not implemented. ACLs are not regularly reviewed and updated.

Mitigation Strategy: Secure Logging and Monitoring

  • Description:
    1. Enable Comprehensive Logging: Configure Headscale to log all relevant events, including authentication attempts, authorization decisions, errors, and administrative actions.
    2. Centralized Logging: Forward Headscale logs to a centralized logging system (e.g., ELK stack, Splunk, cloud provider's logging services) for aggregation, analysis, and long-term retention.
    3. Monitoring and Alerting: Set up monitoring and alerting rules in the centralized logging system to detect suspicious activities, unauthorized access attempts, errors, and performance issues related to Headscale. Configure alerts to notify security and operations teams in real-time.
    4. Log Review and Analysis: Regularly review and analyze Headscale logs to identify security incidents, investigate suspicious activities related to Headscale, and improve Headscale security posture.
  • List of Threats Mitigated:
    • Security Incident Detection (High Severity): Enables timely detection of security incidents and breaches related to Headscale, allowing for faster response and mitigation.
    • Unauthorized Activity Detection (Medium Severity): Helps identify and investigate unauthorized access attempts, policy violations, and other suspicious activities within Headscale.
    • Operational Issues Detection (Low Severity): Assists in identifying and resolving operational issues and performance problems within Headscale.
  • Impact: High risk reduction for security incident detection, Medium risk reduction for unauthorized activity detection, and Low risk reduction for operational issues detection.
  • Currently Implemented: Yes. Headscale logging is enabled and logs are forwarded to a centralized logging system (ELK stack). Basic monitoring is set up for Headscale server availability.
  • Missing Implementation: Detailed alerting rules for security events within Headscale are not fully configured. Regular log review and analysis processes specific to Headscale are not formalized.

Mitigation Strategy: Controlled Node Enrollment

  • Description:
    1. Disable Open Enrollment (if possible): Avoid enabling open enrollment in Headscale if possible. Require administrator approval for new nodes to join the network.
    2. Manual Approval Process: Implement a manual approval process for node enrollment within Headscale. When a new node requests to join, an administrator reviews the request and manually approves it through the Headscale CLI or web UI.
    3. Pre-approved Node Lists (if applicable): Maintain a list of pre-approved node identifiers (e.g., machine names, MAC addresses) within Headscale and only allow nodes from this list to enroll.
  • List of Threats Mitigated:
    • Unauthorized Node Access (High Severity): Prevents unauthorized devices or users from joining the Headscale network and gaining access to VPN resources through Headscale.
    • Rogue Node Introduction (Medium Severity): Reduces the risk of malicious or compromised nodes being introduced into the network via Headscale.
  • Impact: High risk reduction for unauthorized node access and Medium risk reduction for rogue node introduction.
  • Currently Implemented: Yes. Open enrollment is disabled in Headscale. Manual approval is required for new nodes.
  • Missing Implementation: Pre-approved node lists are not implemented within Headscale.

Mitigation Strategy: Node Authorization Policies

  • Description:
    1. Define Authorization Policies: Clearly define policies for authorizing new nodes within Headscale based on factors like user identity, device type, location, or security posture (if integrated with external systems).
    2. Automated Authorization (if feasible): Implement automated authorization processes within Headscale based on predefined criteria. This could involve integrating with an identity provider or device management system to verify node attributes before granting access through Headscale.
    3. Regular Policy Review: Regularly review and update node authorization policies within Headscale to ensure they remain effective and aligned with security requirements.
  • List of Threats Mitigated:
    • Policy Bypass (Medium Severity): Ensures that node enrollment and access through Headscale are consistently enforced according to defined security policies.
    • Policy Drift (Low Severity): Prevents Headscale authorization policies from becoming outdated or ineffective over time.
  • Impact: Medium risk reduction for policy bypass and Low risk reduction for policy drift.
  • Currently Implemented: Partial. Basic authorization policies are defined (manual approval within Headscale).
  • Missing Implementation: Automated authorization processes based on node attributes or integration with external systems are not implemented within Headscale. Regular policy review is not formalized.

Mitigation Strategy: Regular Node Audits

  • Description:
    1. Node Inventory: Maintain an inventory of all enrolled Headscale nodes, including their identifiers, users, and roles within Headscale.
    2. Periodic Review: Regularly review the Headscale node inventory and compare it against expected nodes. Identify and investigate any unexpected or unauthorized nodes within Headscale.
    3. Node Removal Process: Establish a process for removing inactive, unauthorized, or compromised nodes from the Headscale network using Headscale's node management features.
  • List of Threats Mitigated:
    • Compromised Node Persistence (Medium Severity): Detects and removes compromised nodes that may remain connected to the network through Headscale undetected.
    • Stale Node Accounts (Low Severity): Removes inactive node accounts within Headscale, reducing potential attack surface and improving network hygiene.
  • Impact: Medium risk reduction for compromised node persistence and Low risk reduction for stale node accounts.
  • Currently Implemented: Partial. Node inventory is maintained manually.
  • Missing Implementation: Automated node inventory and audit processes within Headscale are not implemented. Formal node removal process using Headscale features is not defined.

Mitigation Strategy: Network Segmentation within the VPN (using Headscale ACLs)

  • Description:
    1. ACL Refinement: Utilize Headscale ACLs to segment the VPN network logically. Define granular ACL rules to restrict communication between different groups of nodes based on their roles and responsibilities within Headscale.
  • List of Threats Mitigated:
    • Lateral Movement within VPN (Medium Severity): Limits lateral movement of attackers within the VPN if a node is compromised, by using Headscale's built-in ACL capabilities.
    • VPN-Wide Compromise (Low Severity): Reduces the risk of a single compromised node leading to a compromise of the entire VPN network, through Headscale's ACL enforcement.
  • Impact: Medium risk reduction for lateral movement within VPN and Low risk reduction for VPN-wide compromise.
  • Currently Implemented: Partial. Basic ACLs are implemented in Headscale.
  • Missing Implementation: ACLs are not granular enough for fine-grained segmentation within the VPN using Headscale's capabilities. Regular review and refinement of Headscale ACLs is needed.

Mitigation Strategy: Secure DNS Configuration within VPN (Headscale Context)

  • Description:
    1. Headscale DNS Configuration: Leverage Headscale's DNS configuration options to manage DNS settings for nodes within the VPN. Configure a dedicated internal DNS resolver if needed and integrate it with Headscale.
    2. Prevent External DNS Leakage (Headscale Configuration): Utilize Headscale's configuration to prevent DNS queries from leaking outside the VPN. Ensure nodes are configured through Headscale to use the intended DNS resolvers.
  • List of Threats Mitigated:
    • DNS Spoofing/Hijacking (Medium Severity): Prevents DNS spoofing or hijacking attacks within the VPN, which could redirect traffic to malicious servers, by controlling DNS settings through Headscale.
    • DNS Leakage (Low Severity): Prevents sensitive DNS queries from being exposed to external DNS resolvers, by managing DNS configuration within Headscale.
  • Impact: Medium risk reduction for DNS spoofing/hijacking and Low risk reduction for DNS leakage.
  • Currently Implemented: No. Headscale's DNS configuration features are not actively utilized. Nodes are currently using default public DNS resolvers or external resolvers, not managed by Headscale.
  • Missing Implementation: Headscale's DNS configuration features are not implemented. Dedicated internal DNS resolver integration with Headscale is missing. DNS leakage prevention through Headscale configuration is not configured.

Mitigation Strategy: Regular Security Assessments of VPN Configuration (Headscale Focus)

  • Description:
    1. Periodic Review: Schedule periodic reviews of the overall security configuration of the Headscale VPN, specifically focusing on Headscale's configuration, including ACLs, node authorization policies, and DNS configuration within Headscale.
    2. Configuration Validation: Validate that the Headscale VPN configuration is still aligned with security best practices and organizational security requirements, specifically in the context of Headscale's features and settings.
    3. Testing and Verification: Conduct testing and verification of Headscale VPN security controls to ensure they are functioning as intended within the Headscale environment.
  • List of Threats Mitigated:
    • Configuration Drift (Medium Severity): Detects and corrects configuration drift within Headscale that may weaken the security posture of the VPN over time.
    • Policy Ineffectiveness (Low Severity): Identifies and addresses situations where Headscale security policies or controls are no longer effective or relevant.
  • Impact: Medium risk reduction for configuration drift and Low risk reduction for policy ineffectiveness.
  • Currently Implemented: No. Regular security assessments of Headscale VPN configuration are not scheduled.
  • Missing Implementation: Formal process for periodic Headscale VPN security assessments is not defined and implemented.