Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
398 lines (335 loc) · 37.1 KB

sec-design.md

File metadata and controls

398 lines (335 loc) · 37.1 KB

Project Design Document: Milvus - Vector Database System

Document Version: 1.1 Date: 2023-10-27 Author: AI Expert

1. Introduction

This document provides a detailed design overview of the Milvus vector database system, an open-source platform engineered for large-scale vector similarity search and analytics. This document is intended to serve as a robust foundation for threat modeling and comprehensive security analysis of the Milvus project. It meticulously outlines the key components, their intricate interactions, and the flow of data within the system, specifically highlighting areas of significant relevance to security considerations. This document aims to provide a clear and structured understanding of Milvus's architecture for security stakeholders.

2. Project Overview: Milvus

Milvus is a cloud-native, distributed vector database meticulously designed to efficiently manage and query extremely large vector datasets. It is specifically optimized for applications demanding high-performance similarity search capabilities, such as sophisticated recommendation systems, advanced image and video retrieval, complex natural language processing tasks, and bioinformatics research. Milvus offers support for a wide array of vector indexing techniques and provides a scalable, reliable, and robust infrastructure for comprehensive vector data management.

3. System Architecture

Milvus employs a distributed microservices architecture, where several independent services collaborate to deliver its core functionalities. This architecture is logically divided into Control Plane and Data Plane components, complemented by essential external dependencies.

3.1. High-Level Architecture Diagram

graph LR
    subgraph "Milvus Cluster"
        subgraph "Control Plane"
            "RootCoord"
            "Meta Storage"
            "DataCoord"
            "IndexCoord"
            "QueryCoord"
        end
        subgraph "Data Plane"
            "Data Node"
            "Index Node"
            "Query Node"
        end
        "Log Broker"
        "Object Storage"
    end
    "SDK/Client" --> "Milvus Cluster"

    "RootCoord" --> "Meta Storage"
    "DataCoord" --> "Meta Storage"
    "IndexCoord" --> "Meta Storage"
    "QueryCoord" --> "Meta Storage"

    "Data Node" --> "Object Storage"
    "Index Node" --> "Object Storage"
    "Query Node" --> "Object Storage"

    "RootCoord" --> "Log Broker"
    "DataCoord" --> "Log Broker"
    "IndexCoord" --> "Log Broker"
    "QueryCoord" --> "Log Broker"
    "Data Node" --> "Log Broker"
    "Index Node" --> "Log Broker"
    "Query Node" --> "Log Broker"

    subgraph "External Dependencies"
        "Meta Storage"
        "Log Broker"
        "Object Storage"
    end

    style "Milvus Cluster" fill:#f9f,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px
    style "Control Plane" fill:#ccf,stroke:#333,stroke-width:1px
    style "Data Plane" fill:#cff,stroke:#333,stroke-width:1px
    style "External Dependencies" fill:#eee,stroke:#333,stroke-width:1px
Loading

3.2. Component Descriptions

3.2.1. SDK/Client

  • Description: Milvus provides Software Development Kits (SDKs) in various popular programming languages (Python, Java, Go, C++, etc.) and a command-line interface (CLI) to enable users and applications to interact seamlessly with the Milvus cluster.
  • Functionality:
    • Establishes connections to the Milvus cluster, managing communication sessions.
    • Offers comprehensive APIs for Data Definition Language (DDL) operations, including collection and index management (e.g., create/drop collection, create/drop index, alter collection).
    • Provides APIs for Data Manipulation Language (DML) operations, enabling data interaction (e.g., insert, search, query, get, delete, flush, compact).
    • Handles underlying communication protocols, ensuring efficient data exchange.
    • Manages data serialization and deserialization, translating data formats for internal processing.
    • May implement client-side caching and load balancing for improved performance.
  • Security Relevance:
    • Serves as the primary entry point for all user interactions, making it a critical control point for authentication, authorization, and access control.
    • Potential source of vulnerabilities if SDKs are not developed with security best practices in mind, including secure coding and dependency management.
    • Insufficient client-side input validation can lead to injection attacks or other client-side exploits that could impact the Milvus cluster.
    • Secure communication protocols (e.g., TLS/SSL) must be enforced between the SDK/Client and the Milvus cluster to protect data in transit.

3.2.2. Milvus Cluster - Control Plane

The Control Plane is the brain of the Milvus cluster, responsible for managing cluster-wide metadata, coordinating operations across components, and maintaining the overall system state.

3.2.2.1. RootCoord
  • Description: The central coordinator for the Milvus cluster and the primary entry point for metadata management operations. It oversees cluster-level metadata and orchestrates the activities of other coordinators.
  • Functionality:
    • Handles all Data Definition Language (DDL) requests, such as creating and dropping collections, partitions, and indexes.
    • Manages the cluster topology, including node registration, health monitoring, and node lifecycle management.
    • Acts as the global Timestamp Oracle (TSO), providing globally unique and monotonically increasing timestamps for transaction consistency.
    • Manages cluster-level parameters, configurations, and system settings.
    • Coordinates with other Control Plane coordinators (DataCoord, IndexCoord, QueryCoord) to ensure consistent cluster operations.
    • Responsible for cluster-level load balancing and resource management.
  • Security Relevance:
    • A highly critical component due to its central role in cluster management and metadata control.
    • Compromise of RootCoord could have catastrophic consequences, potentially leading to cluster-wide disruption, data corruption, or unauthorized access to all data.
    • Handles highly sensitive metadata and configuration information, requiring stringent access control and encryption.
    • Vulnerabilities in RootCoord could be exploited to gain complete control over the Milvus cluster.
3.2.2.2. Meta Storage
  • Description: A persistent and reliable storage system for all critical metadata within the Milvus cluster. This includes collection schemas, partition information, index metadata, cluster state, and user/role information for access control. Typically implemented using a distributed key-value store like etcd, or a relational database like MySQL or PostgreSQL.
  • Functionality:
    • Persistently stores and efficiently retrieves metadata for all Milvus components.
    • Ensures data consistency and durability for metadata, even in the face of component failures.
    • Supports transactional operations for metadata updates, guaranteeing atomicity and consistency.
    • Provides mechanisms for data replication and backup for high availability and disaster recovery.
  • Security Relevance:
    • Stores the most critical metadata of the Milvus system; unauthorized access, modification, or deletion can lead to severe data corruption, system instability, or complete system failure.
    • Requires robust access control mechanisms to strictly limit access to authorized components and administrators only.
    • Encryption at rest is absolutely necessary to protect sensitive metadata, including potentially user credentials or access tokens, stored within Meta Storage.
    • Regular backups and disaster recovery plans are crucial to protect against data loss and ensure business continuity.
3.2.2.3. DataCoord
  • Description: Responsible for managing the distribution and placement of data segments across Data Nodes within the cluster. It ensures efficient data management and load balancing for data ingestion and storage.
  • Functionality:
    • Manages metadata related to data segments, including their location, status, and size.
    • Assigns new data segments to appropriate Data Nodes based on load balancing strategies and data distribution policies.
    • Handles data load balancing and migration between Data Nodes to optimize resource utilization and performance.
    • Coordinates data flushing from memory to persistent storage (Object Storage).
    • Manages data compaction to optimize storage efficiency and query performance.
    • Collaborates with RootCoord and Data Nodes to ensure data consistency and availability.
  • Security Relevance:
    • Indirectly manages data access control by controlling data placement and distribution.
    • Compromise of DataCoord could potentially lead to data unavailability if data distribution is disrupted or manipulated maliciously.
    • Vulnerabilities could be exploited to influence data placement in a way that compromises data locality or performance, potentially leading to denial of service.
    • Access control to DataCoord itself is important to prevent unauthorized manipulation of data distribution strategies.
3.2.2.4. IndexCoord
  • Description: Manages the entire lifecycle of vector indexes within Milvus, from index building requests to index metadata management and distribution. It orchestrates index creation and ensures efficient index utilization for query processing.
  • Functionality:
    • Receives index building requests from RootCoord or users (via SDK/Client).
    • Manages index building tasks and schedules index creation jobs on available Index Nodes.
    • Manages index metadata, including index types, parameters, and locations.
    • Distributes index metadata to Query Nodes to enable efficient query routing and execution.
    • Coordinates index updates and maintenance operations, such as rebuilding or merging indexes.
    • Monitors the health and status of Index Nodes and index building processes.
  • Security Relevance:
    • Manages critical index metadata, which is essential for query performance and efficient data access.
    • Compromise of IndexCoord could lead to denial of service by disrupting indexing processes, corrupting index metadata, or preventing Query Nodes from accessing indexes.
    • Manipulation of index metadata could lead to incorrect query results or performance degradation.
    • Access control to IndexCoord is necessary to prevent unauthorized index creation, deletion, or modification.
3.2.2.5. QueryCoord
  • Description: The central coordinator for query processing in Milvus. It receives query requests from SDK/Client, plans query execution, routes queries to appropriate Query Nodes, and merges query results.
  • Functionality:
    • Receives vector similarity search requests and other query types from SDK/Client.
    • Analyzes query requests and generates optimized query execution plans.
    • Routes queries to the most suitable Query Nodes based on data distribution, query plan, and node availability.
    • Manages query load balancing across Query Nodes to ensure optimal query performance.
    • Merges and aggregates query results received from multiple Query Nodes into a unified response.
    • Caches query results to improve performance for repeated queries.
    • Monitors the health and performance of Query Nodes and query execution.
  • Security Relevance:
    • Serves as the primary entry point for all query requests, making it a critical point for enforcing authentication, authorization, and access control for data retrieval.
    • Potential target for injection attacks (e.g., query injection) if query parameters and input are not rigorously validated and sanitized.
    • Must ensure secure communication with Query Nodes and clients to protect query requests and results in transit.
    • Vulnerabilities in QueryCoord could be exploited to bypass access controls, gain unauthorized access to data, or launch denial-of-service attacks by overloading the query processing system.

3.2.3. Milvus Cluster - Data Plane

The Data Plane components are the workhorses of Milvus, responsible for the actual storage, indexing, and execution of queries on vector data.

3.2.3.1. Data Node
  • Description: Responsible for the persistent storage and management of vector data segments. Data Nodes are the fundamental storage units in Milvus, holding the raw vector data.
  • Functionality:
    • Receives and stores incoming vector data from SDK/Client (indirectly, via coordinators and internal communication).
    • Manages data segments in persistent Object Storage, ensuring data durability and scalability.
    • Performs data flushing from memory to Object Storage to ensure data persistence.
    • Executes data compaction operations to optimize storage space and improve data access performance.
    • Provides data access to Query Nodes and Index Nodes for query processing and index building.
    • May implement local caching mechanisms to improve data access latency.
  • Security Relevance:
    • Directly handles and stores highly sensitive vector data, making it a prime target for attackers seeking to access or exfiltrate this data.
    • Requires robust access control mechanisms to prevent unauthorized data access, modification, or deletion.
    • Data at rest encryption is absolutely crucial for protecting stored vector data in Object Storage against unauthorized access in case of storage breaches or misconfigurations.
    • Secure communication channels must be established between Data Nodes and other components (Control Plane, Query Nodes, Index Nodes) to protect data in transit within the cluster.
3.2.3.2. Index Node
  • Description: Dedicated to building and managing vector indexes. Index Nodes offload the computationally intensive index building process from other components, improving overall system performance and scalability.
  • Functionality:
    • Receives index building requests from IndexCoord, specifying the data segments to index and the index type to build.
    • Reads vector data segments from Object Storage (potentially via Data Nodes).
    • Builds vector indexes on the retrieved data segments using various indexing algorithms (e.g., IVF, HNSW, ANNOY).
    • Stores the built indexes persistently in Object Storage.
    • Provides index access to Query Nodes for efficient vector similarity search.
    • May implement index caching to improve query performance.
  • Security Relevance:
    • Handles indexed data, which is derived from sensitive vector data and can be considered sensitive itself.
    • Requires secure access control to prevent unauthorized index manipulation, which could compromise query accuracy or performance.
    • Index data stored in Object Storage should also be protected with appropriate access controls and potentially encryption.
    • Integrity of the index building process is critical; compromised Index Nodes could build malicious or inaccurate indexes, leading to incorrect query results or denial of service.
3.2.3.3. Query Node
  • Description: Executes vector similarity search queries. Query Nodes are responsible for performing the computationally intensive similarity calculations and retrieving relevant vectors based on user queries.
  • Functionality:
    • Receives query requests from QueryCoord, specifying the search vectors, query parameters, and target collections/partitions.
    • Loads necessary data segments and vector indexes from Object Storage (potentially via Data Nodes and Index Nodes).
    • Performs vector similarity search using loaded indexes and data, employing efficient search algorithms.
    • Filters and ranks search results based on query criteria.
    • Returns query results to QueryCoord for aggregation and delivery to the client.
    • May implement data and index caching to improve query latency and throughput.
  • Security Relevance:
    • Processes sensitive vector data and indexes during query execution, requiring secure handling of this data in memory and during computation.
    • Needs to ensure secure and authorized access to data segments and indexes from Object Storage.
    • Query execution logic should be robust against potential vulnerabilities, such as buffer overflows or algorithmic complexity attacks.
    • Resource consumption by queries should be carefully managed to prevent denial-of-service attacks by resource exhaustion.

3.2.4. External Dependencies

Milvus relies on several external systems for core functionalities like metadata storage, inter-component communication, and persistent data storage. Securing these dependencies is crucial for the overall security of the Milvus system.

3.2.4.1. Log Broker
  • Description: A distributed message queue system used for asynchronous inter-component communication, event logging, and stream processing within the Milvus cluster. Common examples include Apache Pulsar, Apache Kafka, or RabbitMQ.
  • Functionality:
    • Facilitates reliable and asynchronous communication between various Milvus components, decoupling services and improving system resilience.
    • Provides a persistent log of events, operations, and state changes within the cluster, enabling auditing, debugging, and system monitoring.
    • Used for data replication and fault tolerance mechanisms within Milvus, ensuring data consistency and high availability.
    • Can be used for building real-time data pipelines and stream processing applications on top of Milvus events.
  • Security Relevance:
    • Carries inter-component communication, which may include sensitive data, control commands, and internal system information.
    • Requires secure configuration and robust access control to prevent unauthorized access to communication channels, message interception, or message tampering.
    • Logs stored in the Log Broker may contain sensitive information and require secure storage, access control, and retention policies to comply with security and privacy regulations.
    • Vulnerabilities in the Log Broker itself could be exploited to compromise the Milvus cluster or gain access to sensitive information.
3.2.4.2. Object Storage
  • Description: The primary persistent storage system for vector data segments and vector indexes in Milvus. Object Storage provides scalable, durable, and cost-effective storage. Examples include Amazon S3, Google Cloud Storage, Azure Blob Storage, MinIO (for on-premise deployments), or even network-attached file systems (though less common in production).
  • Functionality:
    • Stores vector data segments and vector indexes persistently, ensuring data durability and long-term retention.
    • Provides scalable and cost-effective storage capacity to accommodate massive vector datasets.
    • Offers high availability and fault tolerance, ensuring data accessibility even in the face of storage node failures.
    • Accessed by Data Nodes, Index Nodes, and Query Nodes for data storage, index building, and query processing.
    • May offer features like versioning, lifecycle management, and data replication for enhanced data management and protection.
  • Security Relevance:
    • Stores the most sensitive data within Milvus – the raw vector embeddings and their associated indexes.
    • Requires the strongest possible access control mechanisms to prevent unauthorized data access, modification, or deletion. Access control should be configured at the object storage level (e.g., using IAM roles and policies in cloud object storage).
    • Data at rest encryption is absolutely essential for protecting stored vector data and indexes against unauthorized access in case of storage breaches, misconfigurations, or insider threats. Encryption should be enabled at the object storage level.
    • Network security for communication between Milvus components (Data Nodes, Index Nodes, Query Nodes) and Object Storage is critical to protect data in transit. Secure protocols (e.g., HTTPS) should be enforced.
    • Regular security audits and vulnerability assessments of the Object Storage system are necessary to identify and mitigate potential security weaknesses.

4. Data Flow

The following outlines the typical data flow within Milvus, with a strong focus on security-relevant aspects at each stage:

  1. Data Ingestion (Secure Data Insertion):

    • SDK/Client initiates an insert request, authenticating the user/application and authorizing the operation against the target collection.
    • The request is routed through Control Plane components (typically RootCoord or QueryCoord depending on SDK implementation), which enforce access control policies and validate the request.
    • Input data is rigorously validated and sanitized by the SDK/Client and Milvus components to prevent injection attacks (e.g., data format validation, schema enforcement).
    • Data is transmitted securely over encrypted channels (TLS/SSL) from the SDK/Client to the Milvus cluster.
    • Data is written to Data Nodes, which enforce internal access controls and potentially data encryption in memory.
    • Data Nodes persist data segments to Object Storage, ensuring data at rest encryption is enabled and access controls are properly configured on the Object Storage system.
    • Metadata updates related to data ingestion are securely written to Meta Storage and logged in the Log Broker, with appropriate access controls on these systems.
    • Security Considerations:
      • Authentication and Authorization: Verify the identity of the client and ensure they have the necessary permissions to insert data into the specified collection. Implement Role-Based Access Control (RBAC) or similar mechanisms.
      • Input Validation: Thoroughly validate all input data against the collection schema and expected data types to prevent data corruption and injection attacks.
      • Secure Communication: Enforce TLS/SSL encryption for all communication channels between the SDK/Client and the Milvus cluster, and internally between Milvus components.
      • Data at Rest Encryption: Ensure data at rest encryption is enabled for data stored in Object Storage and potentially Meta Storage.
      • Access Control to Storage: Implement strict access controls on Object Storage and Meta Storage to limit access to authorized Milvus components and administrators.
      • Auditing: Log all data ingestion events, including user identity, timestamp, collection name, and data volume, for auditing and security monitoring.

  2. Index Building (Secure Index Creation):

    • Index building is initiated based on user requests or automated policies, authorized by RootCoord and managed by IndexCoord.
    • IndexCoord authenticates with Index Nodes and Data Nodes to authorize index building tasks and data access.
    • Index Nodes securely read data segments from Object Storage (potentially via Data Nodes), ensuring authorized access to the underlying data.
    • Index building processes should be designed to prevent resource exhaustion and denial-of-service attacks.
    • Built indexes are securely stored in Object Storage, with data at rest encryption and access controls in place.
    • Index metadata is securely updated in Meta Storage and logged in the Log Broker, with appropriate access controls.
    • Security Considerations:
      • Authorization: Ensure only authorized users or processes can initiate index building operations.
      • Secure Data Access: Verify that Index Nodes have authorized and secure access to read data from Object Storage.
      • Resource Management: Implement resource limits and quotas for index building processes to prevent denial-of-service attacks.
      • Index Integrity: Ensure the integrity of the index building process to prevent the creation of malicious or inaccurate indexes. Implement checksums or other integrity checks for built indexes.
      • Secure Index Storage: Protect built indexes stored in Object Storage with data at rest encryption and access controls.
      • Auditing: Log all index building events, including index type, collection name, index parameters, and initiating user/process.

  3. Query Processing (Secure Data Retrieval):

    • SDK/Client sends search requests, authenticating the user/application and authorizing the query against the target collection.
    • QueryCoord receives the query, enforces access control policies, and validates query parameters to prevent injection attacks.
    • QueryCoord routes the query to authorized Query Nodes based on data distribution and query plan.
    • Query Nodes authenticate with Object Storage and potentially Data Nodes and Index Nodes to authorize data and index access.
    • Query Nodes securely load necessary data segments and indexes from Object Storage, ensuring authorized data retrieval.
    • Query Nodes perform vector similarity search, ensuring secure processing of sensitive vector data in memory.
    • Query results are filtered and ranked, and then securely returned to QueryCoord and ultimately to the SDK/Client over encrypted channels (TLS/SSL).
    • Security Considerations:
      • Authentication and Authorization: Verify the identity of the client and ensure they have the necessary permissions to query the specified collection. Enforce fine-grained access control policies based on users, roles, and data partitions.
      • Query Validation: Validate query parameters and search vectors to prevent injection attacks and ensure query integrity.
      • Secure Data Access: Verify that Query Nodes have authorized and secure access to read data and indexes from Object Storage.
      • Secure Communication: Enforce TLS/SSL encryption for all communication channels involved in query processing, including client-to-QueryCoord, QueryCoord-to-QueryNode, and QueryNode-to-ObjectStorage communication.
      • Data Confidentiality in Memory: Implement measures to protect sensitive vector data while it is being processed in Query Node memory, such as memory scrubbing or secure memory allocation techniques.
      • Resource Management: Implement query timeouts and resource limits to prevent denial-of-service attacks through resource exhaustion by malicious or poorly constructed queries.
      • Auditing: Log all query events, including user identity, query details, timestamp, collection name, and query performance metrics.

  4. Metadata Operations (DDL/DCL - Secure Metadata Management):

    • SDK/Client sends metadata operation requests (e.g., create collection, grant permissions), authenticating as an administrator or authorized user.
    • RootCoord receives the request, performs strict authentication and authorization checks to ensure only authorized users can perform metadata operations. Implement robust authentication mechanisms and Role-Based Access Control (RBAC) for metadata management.
    • RootCoord validates the metadata operation request and parameters to prevent injection attacks or invalid metadata configurations.
    • RootCoord interacts with Meta Storage to update metadata securely, ensuring transactional integrity and data consistency.
    • Metadata changes are securely logged in Log Broker for auditing and traceability.
    • Access control policies are enforced for all metadata operations, ensuring only authorized users can modify metadata.
    • Security Considerations:
      • Strong Authentication and Authorization: Implement robust authentication mechanisms (e.g., username/password, API keys, OAuth 2.0) and Role-Based Access Control (RBAC) to strictly control access to metadata operations.
      • Input Validation: Thoroughly validate all metadata operation requests and parameters to prevent injection attacks and ensure metadata integrity.
      • Access Control to Meta Storage: Restrict access to Meta Storage to only authorized Control Plane components and administrators.
      • Auditing: Log all metadata operations, including user identity, operation type, timestamp, and affected metadata objects, for comprehensive auditing and security monitoring.
      • Secure Metadata Storage: Protect metadata stored in Meta Storage with data at rest encryption and access controls.

5. Security Considerations (Categorized and Detailed)

This section categorizes and details the key security considerations for Milvus, aligning with common security principles (CIAAA - Confidentiality, Integrity, Availability, Authentication, Authorization, and Audit).

  • 5.1. Confidentiality (Data Protection):

    • Data at Rest Encryption: Mandatory for vector data and indexes in Object Storage, and for sensitive metadata in Meta Storage. Use strong encryption algorithms (e.g., AES-256) and robust key management practices (e.g., KMS).
    • Data in Transit Encryption: Enforce TLS/SSL encryption for all communication channels:
      • SDK/Client to Milvus Cluster (QueryCoord/RootCoord).
      • Inter-component communication within the Milvus Cluster (Control Plane to Data Plane, Control Plane to Control Plane, Data Plane to Data Plane).
      • Milvus components to external dependencies (Object Storage, Meta Storage, Log Broker).
    • Memory Protection: Consider memory encryption or secure memory allocation techniques for sensitive data processed in memory by Data Nodes, Index Nodes, and Query Nodes.
    • Access Control to Logs: Secure access to logs stored in Log Broker and other log management systems to prevent unauthorized viewing of potentially sensitive information.
    • Secure Configuration Management: Protect configuration files and settings that may contain sensitive information (e.g., database credentials, API keys).

  • 5.2. Integrity (Data Accuracy and Trustworthiness):

    • Input Validation and Sanitization: Implement rigorous input validation and sanitization at all entry points (SDK/Client, inter-component communication) to prevent data corruption and injection attacks.
    • Data Integrity Checks: Employ checksums or other data integrity mechanisms to verify the integrity of data segments and indexes stored in Object Storage.
    • Immutable Logs: Ensure logs stored in Log Broker are immutable and tamper-proof to maintain audit trail integrity.
    • Secure Index Building Process: Protect the index building process from interference or manipulation to ensure the accuracy and reliability of built indexes.
    • Data Replication and Consistency: Utilize data replication and consistency mechanisms provided by Milvus and its dependencies (Meta Storage, Log Broker, Object Storage) to protect against data loss and ensure data integrity in case of failures.

  • 5.3. Availability (System Resilience and Uptime):

    • High Availability Architecture: Deploy Milvus in a distributed, highly available configuration with redundancy for all critical components (Control Plane, Data Plane, external dependencies).
    • Fault Tolerance: Implement fault tolerance mechanisms to automatically detect and recover from component failures without service disruption.
    • Resource Management and Quotas: Implement resource management and quota mechanisms to prevent resource exhaustion and denial-of-service attacks.
    • Monitoring and Alerting: Implement comprehensive monitoring and alerting systems to proactively detect and respond to system issues and security incidents.
    • Disaster Recovery Planning: Develop and regularly test disaster recovery plans to ensure business continuity in case of major outages or disasters.
    • Rate Limiting and Throttling: Implement rate limiting and throttling mechanisms to protect against denial-of-service attacks by limiting the rate of incoming requests.

  • 5.4. Authentication (Identity Verification):

    • Strong Authentication Mechanisms: Implement strong authentication mechanisms for users and applications accessing Milvus, such as:
      • Username/Password authentication.
      • API Keys.
      • OAuth 2.0 or other industry-standard authentication protocols.
      • Mutual TLS (mTLS) for inter-component authentication.
    • Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA): Consider implementing MFA for administrative access to enhance security.
    • Regular Password Rotation: Enforce regular password rotation policies for user accounts.
    • Secure Credential Storage: Store user credentials and API keys securely, using hashing and salting for passwords and encryption for API keys.

  • 5.5. Authorization (Access Control):

    • Role-Based Access Control (RBAC): Implement RBAC to manage user permissions and control access to Milvus resources and operations based on roles (e.g., administrator, read-only user, data scientist).
    • Fine-Grained Access Control: Implement fine-grained access control policies to control access at the collection, partition, and even data segment level if necessary.
    • Least Privilege Principle: Grant users and components only the minimum necessary permissions required to perform their tasks.
    • Access Control Lists (ACLs): Utilize ACLs provided by Object Storage, Meta Storage, and Log Broker to control access to these external dependencies.
    • Regular Access Review: Conduct regular reviews of user permissions and access control policies to ensure they are still appropriate and up-to-date.

  • 5.6. Audit (Logging and Monitoring):

    • Comprehensive Logging: Implement comprehensive logging of security-relevant events, including:
      • Authentication attempts (successful and failed).
      • Authorization decisions (access granted and denied).
      • Data access events (insert, query, delete, get).
      • Metadata operations (DDL/DCL).
      • System events and errors.
      • Security configuration changes.
    • Centralized Logging: Centralize logs from all Milvus components and external dependencies into a secure log management system for efficient analysis and monitoring.
    • Security Monitoring and Alerting: Implement security monitoring and alerting rules to detect and respond to suspicious activities and security incidents in real-time.
    • Log Retention Policies: Define and enforce appropriate log retention policies to comply with security and regulatory requirements.
    • Regular Log Review and Analysis: Regularly review and analyze logs to identify security trends, potential vulnerabilities, and security incidents.

6. Deployment Model Security Implications

The deployment model significantly impacts the security posture of Milvus.

  • Standalone Mode:

    • Security Implications: Simplified security configuration as all components are on a single node. However, it lacks redundancy and high availability, making it less resilient to attacks or failures. Security relies heavily on the security of the single host. Network security is less complex but host-level security becomes paramount.
    • Security Focus: Host-level security hardening, strong local access controls, and basic network security. Not recommended for production environments with stringent security requirements.

  • Distributed Mode (Cluster):

    • Security Implications: Increased complexity in security configuration due to distributed components and inter-component communication. Requires robust network segmentation, inter-component authentication (mTLS), and centralized security management. Attack surface is larger due to multiple nodes.
    • Security Focus: Network security (segmentation, firewalls, intrusion detection), inter-component authentication (mTLS), centralized authentication and authorization, secure configuration management across multiple nodes, and robust monitoring and alerting. Recommended for production environments requiring scalability and high availability.

  • Cloud-Managed Service:

    • Security Implications: Shared security responsibility model. Cloud provider manages infrastructure security, while users are responsible for configuring Milvus security settings, access controls, and data security within their cloud environment. Security posture depends heavily on the cloud provider's security controls and the user's configuration.
    • Security Focus: Understanding the cloud provider's security model and shared responsibility, properly configuring Milvus security settings provided by the cloud service, managing access controls within the cloud environment (IAM roles, security groups), ensuring data encryption is enabled and properly managed, and leveraging cloud provider's security services (e.g., security monitoring, vulnerability scanning). Requires careful review of the cloud provider's security documentation and compliance certifications.

This improved document provides a more detailed and security-focused design overview of Milvus, suitable for threat modeling and security analysis. It emphasizes key security considerations and provides a categorized approach for better understanding and mitigation of potential security risks.