Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
108 lines (83 loc) · 11.6 KB

mitigations.md

File metadata and controls

108 lines (83 loc) · 11.6 KB

Mitigation Strategies Analysis for nsqio/nsq

Mitigation Strategy: Utilize TLS Encryption for All Communication

  • Description:

    • Step 1: Generate TLS certificates for nsqd and nsqlookupd servers. Use a trusted Certificate Authority (CA) or an internal CA.
    • Step 2: Configure nsqd and nsqlookupd to enable TLS encryption using the generated certificates.
      • For nsqd, use --tls-cert and --tls-key flags when starting the nsqd process.
      • For nsqlookupd, use --tls-cert and --tls-key flags when starting the nsqlookupd process.
    • Step 3: Configure nsqd and nsqlookupd to require TLS for client connections.
      • For nsqd, use --tls-required=true flag when starting the nsqd process.
      • For nsqlookupd, use --tls-required=true flag when starting the nsqlookupd process.
    • Step 4: Configure client applications (producers and consumers) to connect to nsqd and nsqlookupd using TLS.
      • Use NSQ client libraries that support TLS and configure them to use TLS connections.
      • Provide the CA certificate path to clients to verify server certificates during connection.
    • Step 5: Ensure TLS configuration is applied to all communication channels: nsqd-to-nsqd (if applicable via client connections), nsqd-to-nsqlookupd, and client-to-nsqd/nsqlookupd.
    • Step 6: Regularly renew TLS certificates before expiration to maintain continuous encryption.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Eavesdropping/Data Interception: Prevents attackers from intercepting and reading messages in transit over the network. - Severity: High
    • Man-in-the-Middle (MitM) Attacks: Prevents attackers from intercepting and manipulating communication between NSQ components and clients by verifying server identity. - Severity: High
    • Data Breach in Transit: Protects sensitive data from exposure during network transmission related to NSQ communication. - Severity: High

  • Impact:

    • Eavesdropping/Data Interception: High reduction - Encrypts data in transit, making it unreadable to eavesdroppers targeting NSQ communication.
    • Man-in-the-Middle (MitM) Attacks: High reduction - TLS provides authentication and encryption, making MitM attacks on NSQ communication significantly harder.
    • Data Breach in Transit: High reduction - Effectively mitigates data breaches due to network sniffing of NSQ traffic.

  • Currently Implemented: No - TLS encryption is not currently enabled for NSQ communication within the project.

  • Missing Implementation: TLS needs to be configured and enabled for all NSQ components (nsqd, nsqlookupd) and client applications. Certificates need to be generated, deployed, and managed for NSQ infrastructure.

Mitigation Strategy: Implement Client Authentication (TLS Client Certificates)

  • Description:

    • Step 1: Generate client certificates for authorized producers and consumers that will interact with NSQ.
    • Step 2: Configure nsqd and nsqlookupd to require client certificate authentication.
      • For nsqd, use --tls-client-auth-policy=require-and-verify-client-cert flag when starting the nsqd process. This enforces strong client authentication.
      • For nsqlookupd, use --tls-client-auth-policy=require-and-verify-client-cert flag when starting the nsqlookupd process.
    • Step 3: Distribute client certificates securely to authorized producer and consumer applications.
    • Step 4: Configure client applications to present their client certificates when establishing TLS connections to nsqd and nsqlookupd.
      • Use NSQ client libraries that support TLS client certificates and configure them to load and present the certificates during connection.
    • Step 5: Manage client certificates lifecycle, including secure storage, revocation, and renewal processes for NSQ clients.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Unauthorized Access by Malicious Clients: Prevents unauthorized applications or users from connecting to and interacting with NSQ services by enforcing client-side authentication. - Severity: High
    • Spoofing/Impersonation of Clients: Makes it significantly harder for attackers to impersonate legitimate producers or consumers interacting with NSQ. - Severity: Medium
    • Data Tampering by Unauthorized Clients: Prevents unauthorized clients from publishing malicious or incorrect messages to NSQ topics. - Severity: Medium

  • Impact:

    • Unauthorized Access by Malicious Clients: High reduction - Client certificate authentication strongly verifies the identity of clients connecting to NSQ.
    • Spoofing/Impersonation of Clients: Medium reduction - Significantly harder to impersonate clients with valid certificates, although certificate compromise remains a potential risk.
    • Data Tampering by Unauthorized Clients: Medium reduction - Restricts publishing and consumption to authenticated clients, reducing the risk of unauthorized data manipulation within NSQ.

  • Currently Implemented: No - Client certificate authentication is not currently implemented for NSQ clients in the project.

  • Missing Implementation: Client certificate generation, secure distribution to NSQ clients, and configuration on both NSQ servers (nsqd, nsqlookupd) and client applications are required. A certificate management process needs to be established for NSQ client certificates.

Mitigation Strategy: Configure Resource Limits in nsqd

  • Description:

    • Step 1: Analyze application message characteristics (size, volume) and overall system resource capacity.
    • Step 2: Configure nsqd with appropriate resource limits using command-line flags or configuration file settings when starting the nsqd process.
      • Set --max-msg-size=<bytes> to define a maximum allowed message size to prevent oversized messages from overwhelming nsqd.
      • Set --mem-queue-size=<bytes> to limit the in-memory queue size for each topic/channel, controlling memory usage per queue.
      • Set --max-bytes-per-file=<bytes> to control the maximum disk space used by a single message persistence file, managing disk usage.
      • Set --max-req-timeout=<duration> to define timeouts for client requests to prevent long-running requests from consuming resources indefinitely.
      • Set --max-output-buffer-size=<bytes> and --max-output-buffer-timeout=<duration> to manage output buffers for client connections, preventing resource exhaustion due to slow consumers.
    • Step 3: Monitor nsqd resource utilization (CPU, memory, disk I/O) after applying limits to ensure they are effective and not negatively impacting legitimate application traffic flow. Use nsqadmin or monitoring tools.
    • Step 4: Adjust resource limits in nsqd configuration as needed based on monitoring data and evolving application requirements to maintain optimal performance and security.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Denial of Service (DoS) via Resource Exhaustion: Prevents attackers or misbehaving applications from overwhelming nsqd by consuming excessive resources like memory, disk, or processing power. - Severity: High
    • Resource Starvation for Legitimate Clients: Ensures fair resource allocation within nsqd and prevents one client or topic/channel from monopolizing resources, impacting others. - Severity: Medium
    • System Instability due to Resource Overload: Protects the overall stability of the NSQ infrastructure and the host system by preventing nsqd from consuming excessive resources and causing crashes or performance degradation. - Severity: High

  • Impact:

    • Denial of Service (DoS) via Resource Exhaustion: High reduction - Resource limits effectively constrain resource usage within nsqd, mitigating resource exhaustion-based DoS attacks.
    • Resource Starvation for Legitimate Clients: Medium reduction - Improves fairness in resource allocation within NSQ, but overly restrictive limits can still impact legitimate clients if not properly tuned.
    • System Instability due to Resource Overload: High reduction - Prevents nsqd itself from becoming a source of system instability due to uncontrolled resource consumption.

  • Currently Implemented: Partial - Default resource limits within nsqd might be in effect, but they are not explicitly configured and tuned based on the project's specific application needs and resource constraints.

  • Missing Implementation: Detailed analysis of resource requirements for the application using NSQ, explicit configuration of relevant resource limits in nsqd startup parameters or configuration files, and ongoing monitoring and adjustment of these limits based on operational data.

Mitigation Strategy: Regularly Update NSQ Components

  • Description:

    • Step 1: Subscribe to the NSQ security mailing list, monitor the official NSQ GitHub repository for releases, and check for security advisories related to NSQ components (nsqd, nsqlookupd, nsqadmin, and client libraries).
    • Step 2: Establish a routine process for regularly checking for new NSQ versions and security updates. This could be part of a regular security patching cycle.
    • Step 3: Before deploying updates to production, thoroughly test new NSQ versions in a staging or testing environment to ensure compatibility and identify any potential issues.
    • Step 4: Plan and execute updates of NSQ components in production environments promptly after successful testing and validation. Follow a documented update procedure to minimize disruption.
    • Step 5: Maintain an inventory of NSQ component versions deployed in each environment to track update status and ensure consistency.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Exploitation of Known Vulnerabilities in NSQ: Prevents attackers from exploiting publicly disclosed security vulnerabilities present in outdated versions of NSQ components. - Severity: High
    • Zero-Day Vulnerabilities (reduced window of exposure): Reduces the time window during which the project's NSQ infrastructure is vulnerable to newly discovered zero-day exploits by staying up-to-date with security patches. - Severity: Medium
    • Compromise of NSQ Infrastructure: Mitigates the overall risk of NSQ components being compromised due to unpatched security flaws, which could lead to data breaches, service disruption, or other security incidents. - Severity: High

  • Impact:

    • Exploitation of Known Vulnerabilities in NSQ: High reduction - Applying updates and patches eliminates known vulnerabilities, directly reducing the risk of exploitation.
    • Zero-Day Vulnerabilities: Medium reduction - Reduces the window of vulnerability, but does not eliminate the risk entirely until a patch is available and deployed for a newly discovered zero-day.
    • Compromise of NSQ Infrastructure: High reduction - Significantly reduces the likelihood of successful attacks targeting known vulnerabilities in NSQ components, enhancing overall security posture.

  • Currently Implemented: Partial - There is a general system update process in place, but NSQ component updates might not be specifically prioritized or performed on a regular, security-focused schedule.

  • Missing Implementation: Establish a dedicated, proactive process for monitoring NSQ releases and security advisories, including testing updates in a staging environment and promptly deploying them to production. Consider implementing automated update mechanisms where feasible and safe for NSQ components.