Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
164 lines (143 loc) · 17.7 KB

mitigations.md

File metadata and controls

164 lines (143 loc) · 17.7 KB

Mitigation Strategies Analysis for pingcap/tidb

Mitigation Strategy: Implement TLS Encryption for Inter-Component Communication

  • Description:
    • Step 1: Generate TLS certificates and keys for each TiDB component (TiDB Server, PD Server, TiKV Server). Use tools like openssl or certificate management systems. Ensure certificates are properly signed and valid.
    • Step 2: Configure PD Servers to use TLS for client and peer communication by modifying the PD configuration file (pd.toml) to enable TLS and specify certificate paths.
    • Step 3: Configure TiKV Servers to use TLS for client and peer communication by modifying the TiKV configuration file (tikv.toml) to enable TLS and specify certificate paths.
    • Step 4: Configure TiDB Servers to use TLS for client and server communication with PD and TiKV by modifying the TiDB configuration file (tidb.toml) to enable TLS and specify certificate paths.
    • Step 5: Configure client applications connecting to TiDB to use TLS by specifying connection parameters in the client library or connection string.
    • Step 6: Test TLS configuration by monitoring network traffic and verifying encrypted connections between all components and clients.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Eavesdropping on inter-component communication (Severity: High) - Interception of sensitive data like SQL queries and internal cluster information.
    • Man-in-the-Middle (MITM) attacks within the cluster (Severity: High) - Interception and potential modification of communication between TiDB components.
  • Impact:
    • Eavesdropping: High reduction - TLS encryption renders intercepted data unreadable.
    • MITM attacks: High reduction - TLS prevents impersonation and malicious traffic injection.
  • Currently Implemented: No - Not currently implemented in the TiDB cluster.
  • Missing Implementation: TLS encryption is missing across all TiDB components (PD, TiKV, TiDB Servers) and client connections.

Mitigation Strategy: Enforce Strong Authentication and Authorization within the Cluster

  • Description:
    • Step 1: Enable TiDB's built-in user authentication system in the TiDB configuration (tidb.toml).
    • Step 2: Change default passwords for all TiDB administrative accounts (e.g., root). Use strong, unique passwords.
    • Step 3: Implement Role-Based Access Control (RBAC) using TiDB's privilege system. Define roles with specific privileges.
    • Step 4: Grant users and applications only necessary roles and privileges using GRANT and REVOKE SQL statements.
    • Step 5: Consider integrating with external authentication systems like LDAP or PAM if required, configuring TiDB to authenticate against them.
    • Step 6: Regularly audit user accounts and privileges to ensure appropriateness.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Unauthorized access to TiDB data and cluster management (Severity: High) - Access by unauthorized users due to weak credentials or permissive access controls.
    • Privilege escalation within TiDB (Severity: Medium) - Attackers gaining higher privileges within the TiDB cluster.
  • Impact:
    • Unauthorized access: High reduction - Strong authentication and authorization limit unauthorized access.
    • Privilege escalation: Moderate reduction - RBAC and least privilege limit potential damage.
  • Currently Implemented: Partial - Basic user authentication is enabled, but default root password might be in use and RBAC is not fully implemented in TiDB.
  • Missing Implementation: Strong password policy enforcement for TiDB users, full RBAC implementation within TiDB, potential external authentication integration, and regular privilege audits within TiDB.

Mitigation Strategy: Secure Access to TiDB Monitoring Tools

  • Description:
    • Step 1: Implement authentication and authorization for TiDB Dashboard access. Configure user accounts and roles within TiDB or integrate with external authentication if supported.
    • Step 2: Restrict access to TiDB Dashboard to authorized personnel only through network controls (firewall rules) and application-level authentication.
    • Step 3: Ensure HTTPS is enabled for TiDB Dashboard communication to encrypt traffic between users and the dashboard.
    • Step 4: If using Prometheus/Grafana for TiDB monitoring, secure access to these tools as well, implementing authentication and authorization and HTTPS.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Exposure of sensitive TiDB cluster information through monitoring tools (Severity: Medium) - Unauthorized access to dashboards revealing cluster status, performance metrics, and potentially sensitive configurations.
    • Manipulation of monitoring data (Severity: Low to Medium) - Insecure monitoring tools could be targets for manipulation, leading to misleading information and potentially masking real issues.
  • Impact:
    • Exposure of sensitive information: Moderate reduction - Authentication and authorization limit unauthorized access to monitoring data.
    • Manipulation of monitoring data: Low to Moderate reduction - Secure access reduces the risk of unauthorized modification.
  • Currently Implemented: No - Access to TiDB Dashboard and potentially Prometheus/Grafana is not secured with authentication and authorization.
  • Missing Implementation: Implement authentication and authorization for TiDB Dashboard and related monitoring tools, enforce HTTPS, and restrict network access.

Mitigation Strategy: Utilize Parameterized Queries (Prepared Statements)

  • Description:
    • Step 1: Identify all dynamic SQL query construction in the application code interacting with TiDB.
    • Step 2: Replace dynamic SQL with parameterized queries or prepared statements provided by the database driver used to connect to TiDB.
    • Step 3: Pass user input as parameters to prepared statements, not directly concatenated into SQL query strings.
    • Step 4: Test application functionalities interacting with TiDB to verify parameterized queries are correctly implemented.
    • Step 5: Conduct code reviews to ensure consistent use of parameterized queries for TiDB interactions.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • SQL Injection vulnerabilities in TiDB queries (Severity: High) - Injection of malicious SQL code through user input to manipulate TiDB queries.
  • Impact:
    • SQL Injection: High reduction - Parameterized queries prevent SQL injection by separating SQL code from user data when interacting with TiDB.
  • Currently Implemented: Partial - Parameterized queries are used in some parts of the application interacting with TiDB, but dynamic SQL might still exist in places.
  • Missing Implementation: Systematic review and refactoring of all TiDB database interaction code to ensure consistent use of parameterized queries.

Mitigation Strategy: Principle of Least Privilege for Database Users

  • Description:
    • Step 1: Define specific roles and privileges required for each application or user interacting with TiDB.
    • Step 2: Grant TiDB users only the necessary privileges for their tasks using GRANT SQL statements. Avoid granting broad privileges like SUPER or ALL PRIVILEGES unless absolutely necessary.
    • Step 3: Regularly review and audit TiDB user privileges to ensure they remain appropriate and aligned with the principle of least privilege. Revoke unnecessary privileges using REVOKE SQL statements.
    • Step 4: For applications, create dedicated TiDB users with limited privileges instead of using shared or administrative accounts.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Unauthorized data access and modification within TiDB (Severity: Medium to High) - Users or applications with excessive privileges could unintentionally or maliciously access or modify data beyond their intended scope.
    • Lateral movement within TiDB (Severity: Medium) - If an attacker compromises an account with excessive privileges, they can potentially access or control more of the TiDB system.
  • Impact:
    • Unauthorized data access/modification: Moderate to High reduction - Least privilege limits the impact of compromised accounts or application vulnerabilities.
    • Lateral movement: Moderate reduction - Reduces the potential for attackers to expand their access within TiDB.
  • Currently Implemented: Partial - Some level of privilege management might be in place, but not consistently enforced across all TiDB users and applications.
  • Missing Implementation: Full implementation of least privilege across all TiDB users and applications, regular privilege audits, and dedicated limited-privilege users for applications.

Mitigation Strategy: Encryption at Rest for TiKV (if supported and required)

  • Description:
    • Step 1: Evaluate if encryption at rest is required based on data sensitivity and compliance requirements. Check TiDB documentation for current encryption at rest capabilities and configuration options for TiKV.
    • Step 2: If supported and required, configure encryption at rest for TiKV. This typically involves configuring encryption keys and enabling encryption in the TiKV configuration (tikv.toml).
    • Step 3: Securely manage encryption keys. Use key management systems or secure storage mechanisms to protect encryption keys.
    • Step 4: Test encryption at rest configuration to ensure it is working correctly and does not impact performance significantly.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Data breach from physical media theft or unauthorized access to storage (Severity: High) - If storage media containing TiKV data is physically stolen or accessed without authorization, data at rest encryption protects data confidentiality.
  • Impact:
    • Data breach from physical media theft: High reduction - Encryption at rest renders data unreadable without the decryption key in case of physical compromise.
  • Currently Implemented: No - Encryption at rest for TiKV is not currently implemented.
  • Missing Implementation: Evaluate requirement for encryption at rest, configure encryption at rest for TiKV if needed, and implement secure key management.

Mitigation Strategy: Regularly Patch and Update TiDB Components

  • Description:
    • Step 1: Subscribe to TiDB security advisories and release notes from PingCAP and the TiDB community to stay informed about security updates.
    • Step 2: Establish a process for regularly checking for and applying updates and patches to all TiDB components (PD, TiKV, TiDB Servers, TiDB Operator if used).
    • Step 3: Prioritize security patches and critical updates for TiDB components.
    • Step 4: Test TiDB updates in a staging environment before applying them to production.
    • Step 5: Document the TiDB patching process and maintain a record of applied patches.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Exploitation of known vulnerabilities in TiDB components (Severity: High) - Attackers exploiting unpatched vulnerabilities in TiDB to compromise the cluster.
  • Impact:
    • Vulnerability Exploitation: High reduction - Patching eliminates known vulnerabilities in TiDB components.
  • Currently Implemented: No - Regular patching and updating of TiDB components is not currently performed.
  • Missing Implementation: Establish a formal TiDB patching process, subscribe to security advisories, implement a testing environment for TiDB updates, and schedule regular patching windows for TiDB components.

Mitigation Strategy: Secure Configuration of TiDB Components

  • Description:
    • Step 1: Review the default configuration of each TiDB component (PD, TiKV, TiDB Servers) and identify potential security hardening opportunities. Consult TiDB security documentation and best practices guides.
    • Step 2: Disable or restrict unnecessary features and services in TiDB components to reduce the attack surface.
    • Step 3: Configure security-related parameters in TiDB component configuration files (pd.toml, tikv.toml, tidb.toml) based on security best practices. This may include settings related to logging, auditing, access control, and network interfaces.
    • Step 4: Regularly review and update TiDB component configurations to maintain a secure posture and adapt to evolving security threats and best practices.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Exploitation of misconfigurations in TiDB components (Severity: Medium to High) - Attackers exploiting default or insecure configurations to gain unauthorized access or cause disruptions.
    • Information disclosure due to insecure configurations (Severity: Medium) - Misconfigurations potentially revealing sensitive information about the TiDB cluster.
  • Impact:
    • Exploitation of misconfigurations: Moderate to High reduction - Secure configuration reduces the attack surface and mitigates potential vulnerabilities.
    • Information disclosure: Moderate reduction - Hardening configurations prevents unintentional exposure of sensitive information.
  • Currently Implemented: No - Secure configuration hardening of TiDB components has not been systematically performed. Default configurations are likely in use.
  • Missing Implementation: Review and harden the configuration of all TiDB components based on security best practices, disable unnecessary features, and establish a process for ongoing configuration review.

Mitigation Strategy: Monitor TiDB Logs for Security Anomalies

  • Description:
    • Step 1: Ensure comprehensive logging is enabled for all TiDB components (PD, TiKV, TiDB Servers). Configure logging levels to capture relevant security events.
    • Step 2: Centralize TiDB logs using a log management system (e.g., ELK stack, Splunk) for efficient analysis and correlation.
    • Step 3: Define security anomaly detection rules and alerts based on TiDB log events. This could include rules for failed login attempts, suspicious SQL queries, privilege escalations, or configuration changes.
    • Step 4: Regularly review TiDB logs and security alerts to identify and respond to potential security incidents.
    • Step 5: Automate log analysis and alerting to enable timely detection of security threats.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Delayed detection of security breaches and attacks against TiDB (Severity: Medium to High) - Without proper logging and monitoring, security incidents might go unnoticed for extended periods, increasing potential damage.
    • Lack of audit trail for security events in TiDB (Severity: Medium) - Insufficient logging hinders security investigations and compliance efforts.
  • Impact:
    • Delayed breach detection: Moderate to High reduction - Log monitoring enables faster detection and response to security incidents.
    • Lack of audit trail: Moderate reduction - Comprehensive logs provide an audit trail for security events.
  • Currently Implemented: Partial - Basic logging might be enabled for TiDB components, but centralized logging, anomaly detection, and automated alerting are not implemented.
  • Missing Implementation: Implement centralized logging for TiDB components, define security anomaly detection rules and alerts, and establish a process for regular log review and incident response.

Mitigation Strategy: Secure TiDB Operator Configuration (if applicable)

  • Description:
    • Step 1: If deploying TiDB on Kubernetes using TiDB Operator, review the security configuration of the TiDB Operator itself.
    • Step 2: Implement RBAC and access controls for the TiDB Operator in Kubernetes to restrict who can manage TiDB clusters through the operator.
    • Step 3: Secure the storage of TiDB Operator configurations and secrets in Kubernetes. Use Kubernetes secrets management features and consider encryption at rest for secrets.
    • Step 4: Regularly update TiDB Operator to the latest version to benefit from security patches and improvements.
    • Step 5: Follow security best practices for deploying operators in Kubernetes environments.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Compromise of TiDB Operator leading to cluster compromise (Severity: High) - If the TiDB Operator is compromised, attackers could potentially gain control over the entire TiDB cluster managed by the operator.
    • Unauthorized management of TiDB clusters (Severity: Medium) - Insecure TiDB Operator configuration could allow unauthorized users to create, modify, or delete TiDB clusters.
  • Impact:
    • Compromise of TiDB Operator: High reduction - Secure operator configuration reduces the risk of operator compromise and subsequent cluster compromise.
    • Unauthorized cluster management: Moderate reduction - Access controls for the operator prevent unauthorized cluster management actions.
  • Currently Implemented: No - Security configuration of TiDB Operator is not specifically addressed. Default configurations are likely in use.
  • Missing Implementation: Review and harden TiDB Operator configuration, implement RBAC and access controls, secure storage of operator secrets, and establish a process for regularly updating the operator.