Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
128 lines (97 loc) · 8.47 KB

mitigations.md

File metadata and controls

128 lines (97 loc) · 8.47 KB

Mitigation Strategies Analysis for restic/restic

Mitigation Strategy: Append-Only Repository Configuration (via Restic and Backend)

  • Description:

    1. Backend Configuration (as prerequisite): Configure the storage backend (S3, B2, SFTP, etc.) for append-only access. This is essential for restic's append-only mode to function correctly. (See previous detailed description for backend-specific steps).
    2. Separate Credentials: Create separate credentials for backup (append-only) and forget/prune (delete-capable) operations.
    3. Restic Initialization (if new repository): When initializing a new repository, use the append-only credentials.
    4. Restic Configuration (existing repository): If using an existing repository, ensure restic is configured to use the append-only credentials for regular backup operations. This usually involves setting environment variables or using command-line flags (e.g., --repo, --password-file, and backend-specific options) correctly.
    5. forget and prune with Restricted Credentials: Use the separate, highly restricted credentials only when running restic forget and restic prune. These commands can delete data, so their use must be carefully controlled.
    6. Testing: Verify that backups can be created, but existing data cannot be modified or deleted using the regular backup credentials. Use restic snapshots to list snapshots and attempt to modify/delete them with the append-only credentials – this should fail.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Repository Compromise (Data Tampering/Deletion): Severity: Critical.
    • Accidental Deletion: Severity: High.

  • Impact:

    • Repository Compromise: Risk reduction: Very High.
    • Accidental Deletion: Risk reduction: High.

  • Currently Implemented:

    • (Hypothetical Project): Partially Implemented. Backend configured for append-only, but separate credentials for forget/prune are not consistently used in scripts.
    • (Real Project): Replace with your project's status.

  • Missing Implementation:

    • (Hypothetical Project): Consistent use of separate, restricted credentials for all forget and prune operations, including those within automated scripts.
    • (Real Project): Identify gaps.

Mitigation Strategy: Regular Integrity Checks (using restic check)

  • Description:

    1. Automated Script: Create a script that runs restic check --read-data (strongly recommended) or, at a minimum, restic check. The --read-data flag verifies the actual data blocks, providing a much more thorough check.
    2. Scheduling: Schedule the script to run regularly (e.g., daily, weekly) using a task scheduler.
    3. Alerting: Configure the script to send alerts if any errors are detected.
    4. Logging: Log the output of the restic check command.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Repository Compromise (Data Tampering): Severity: Critical.
    • Data Corruption: Severity: High.

  • Impact:

    • Repository Compromise: Risk reduction: Medium.
    • Data Corruption: Risk reduction: High.

  • Currently Implemented:

    • (Hypothetical Project): A weekly restic check is scheduled, but --read-data is not used consistently.
    • (Real Project): Replace with your project's status.

  • Missing Implementation:

    • (Hypothetical Project): Consistent use of restic check --read-data in the scheduled script.
    • (Real Project): Identify gaps.

Mitigation Strategy: Versioned Restores (using restic restore)

  • Description:

    1. Identify Snapshots: Use restic snapshots to list available snapshots and identify the desired point in time for restoration. Note the snapshot ID.
    2. Targeted Restore: Use restic restore <snapshot_id> --target <restore_directory> [options] to restore to a specific snapshot.
      • --target: Specifies the directory where the data will be restored. Crucially, this should not be the original location, but a separate, safe location (ideally a sandboxed environment).
      • --include, --exclude: Use these options to restore only specific files or directories, minimizing the amount of data restored and reducing the potential attack surface.
    3. Verification: After restoring, verify the integrity of the restored data and ensure it matches the expected state at the chosen snapshot.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Compromised Backup Source (Malware Included in Backup): Severity: Critical (when combined with a sandboxed restore environment). Allows restoring to a point before a potential compromise.
    • Accidental File Deletion/Modification: Severity: High.

  • Impact:

    • Compromised Backup Source: Risk reduction: Medium (High when combined with sandboxing).
    • Accidental File Deletion/Modification: Risk reduction: High

  • Currently Implemented:

    • (Hypothetical Project): Developers are aware of restic restore, but there's no standardized procedure for versioned restores, and restores are often done directly to non-production systems without a dedicated sandbox.
    • (Real Project): Replace with your project's status.

  • Missing Implementation:

    • (Hypothetical Project): Documented procedure for performing versioned restores, including the use of --target to a safe location and the use of --include/--exclude for targeted restores. Integration with a sandboxed restore environment (as described previously).
    • (Real Project): Identify gaps.

Mitigation Strategy: Secure Key Management (for Restic Encryption)

  • Description:

    1. Strong Password/Key: Generate a strong, random password or key for the restic repository.
    2. Secure Storage: Store the password/key outside the repository and outside any system that has direct access to the repository. Use a password manager, secrets management service, or HSM.
    3. Key Rotation: Implement a process for regularly rotating the restic repository password/key using restic key add and restic key remove. This involves:
      • Generating a new key.
      • Adding the new key to the repository: restic key add.
      • Removing the old key: restic key remove.
      • Securely storing the new key and securely deleting the old key.
    4. Access Control: Limit access to the password/key.

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Key Compromise (Unauthorized Access to Backups): Severity: Critical.

  • Impact:

    • Key Compromise: Risk reduction: High.

  • Currently Implemented:

    • (Hypothetical Project): Password is in a password manager, but key rotation is not automated or regularly performed.
    • (Real Project): Replace with your project's status.

  • Missing Implementation:

    • (Hypothetical Project): Automated or documented procedure for key rotation using restic key add and restic key remove.
    • (Real Project): Identify gaps.

Mitigation Strategy: Restic Updates

  • Description:

    1. Monitor Releases: Regularly check for new restic releases on GitHub.
    2. Review Changelogs: Examine changelogs for security fixes.
    3. Update Procedure:
      • Download the latest release binary.
      • Verify the binary's integrity (checksums, GPG signatures).
      • Replace the existing restic binary.
      • Test the updated version (restic version, restic snapshots).

  • Threats Mitigated:

    • Restic Vulnerabilities: Severity: Variable.

  • Impact:

    • Restic Vulnerabilities: Risk reduction: High.

  • Currently Implemented:

    • (Hypothetical Project): Updates are performed ad-hoc, without a formal procedure.
    • (Real Project): Replace with your project's status.

  • Missing Implementation:

    • (Hypothetical Project): Formalized update procedure, including verification of binaries and testing after updates.
    • (Real Project): Identify gaps.