Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
103 lines (86 loc) · 9.5 KB

attack-tree.md

File metadata and controls

103 lines (86 loc) · 9.5 KB

Attack Tree Analysis for eleme/mess

Objective: To achieve unauthorized access to sensitive information, disrupt application functionality, or gain control over application users by exploiting vulnerabilities within the eleme/mess real-time communication component.

Attack Tree Visualization

  • Exploit Server-Side Vulnerabilities in mess Component
    • Authentication/Authorization Bypass or Weakness (within mess context) [CRITICAL PATH]
      • Lack of Authentication for Publish/Subscribe [CRITICAL NODE]
    • Input Validation Vulnerabilities (Message Content) [CRITICAL PATH]
      • Message Injection (Command Injection, Code Injection - if server processes messages) [CRITICAL NODE]
      • Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) via Message Content (if messages are displayed to other users via mess) [CRITICAL NODE]
    • Dependency Vulnerabilities in mess Server Libraries [CRITICAL PATH]
  • Exploit Client-Side Vulnerabilities related to mess Interaction [CRITICAL PATH]
    • Client-Side Logic Vulnerabilities in Message Handling [CRITICAL PATH]
      • Client-Side XSS via Unsafe Message Rendering [CRITICAL NODE]
  • Insecure Communication Channel (related to mess deployment) [CRITICAL PATH]
    • Man-in-the-Middle (MitM) Attacks (if communication is not encrypted) [CRITICAL NODE]
  • Configuration Vulnerabilities in mess Deployment [CRITICAL PATH]
    • Default Credentials or Weak Configuration [CRITICAL NODE]

Attack Tree Path: Exploit Server-Side Vulnerabilities in mess Component

  • Critical Node: Lack of Authentication for Publish/Subscribe [CRITICAL NODE] * Attack Vector Name: Lack of Authentication for Publish/Subscribe * Description: If mess doesn't enforce authentication for publishing or subscribing to channels, attackers can freely send messages to any channel or eavesdrop on communications. * Actionable Insight: [CRITICAL] Critical: Implement robust authentication and authorization mechanisms within mess. Ensure that only authenticated and authorized users can publish to and subscribe to specific channels. Consider using tokens or session-based authentication. * Likelihood: Low (Hopefully implemented, but misconfigurations possible) * Impact: High (Unauthorized access to communication, data breach) * Effort: Low * Skill Level: Low * Detection Difficulty: Low (If monitoring message flow and user permissions)

    • High-Risk Path: Input Validation Vulnerabilities (Message Content) [CRITICAL PATH]

      • Critical Node: Message Injection (Command Injection, Code Injection - if server processes messages) [CRITICAL NODE]

        • Attack Vector Name: Message Injection (Command/Code Injection)
        • Description: If the mess server processes message content (e.g., for logging, filtering, or triggering server-side actions) without proper input validation, attackers could inject malicious commands or code that are executed by the server.
        • Actionable Insight: [CRITICAL] Critical if server processes messages: Strictly validate and sanitize all message content received by the server. Use parameterized queries or prepared statements if messages are used in database operations. Avoid executing dynamic code based on message content.
        • Likelihood: Low (If developers are aware of injection risks)
        • Impact: High (Server compromise, data breach, complete control)
        • Effort: Medium
        • Skill Level: Medium (Requires understanding of injection vulnerabilities)
        • Detection Difficulty: Low to Medium (Depending on logging and monitoring of server actions)

      • Critical Node: Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) via Message Content (if messages are displayed to other users via mess) [CRITICAL NODE]

        • Attack Vector Name: Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) via Message Content (Server-Side)
        • Description: If messages sent via mess are displayed to other users in the application without proper output encoding (on the server-side if messages are stored and re-served), attackers can inject malicious scripts that are executed in the browsers of other users.
        • Actionable Insight: [CRITICAL] Critical if messages are displayed: Implement robust output encoding (escaping) of all message content before displaying it to users. Use a Content Security Policy (CSP) to mitigate XSS risks.
        • Likelihood: Medium (Common web vulnerability, especially in real-time chat)
        • Impact: Medium to High (Client-side compromise, session hijacking, defacement)
        • Effort: Low
        • Skill Level: Low
        • Detection Difficulty: Low (If monitoring for script execution on client-side, CSP violations)

    • High-Risk Path: Dependency Vulnerabilities in mess Server Libraries [CRITICAL PATH]

      • Attack Vector Name: Dependency Vulnerabilities
      • Description: Vulnerabilities in third-party libraries used by the mess server (e.g., WebSocket libraries, networking libraries) could be exploited to compromise the server.
      • Actionable Insight: Regularly update all dependencies of the mess server to the latest secure versions. Use vulnerability scanning tools to identify and address known vulnerabilities in dependencies.
      • Likelihood: Medium (Dependencies often have vulnerabilities, requires ongoing maintenance)
      • Impact: High (Server compromise, depending on the vulnerability)
      • Effort: Low (Using automated vulnerability scanners) to Medium (Exploiting complex vulnerabilities)
      • Skill Level: Low (For scanning) to Medium/High (For exploiting)
      • Detection Difficulty: Low (Vulnerability scanners can detect known vulnerabilities)

Attack Tree Path: Exploit Client-Side Vulnerabilities related to mess Interaction [CRITICAL PATH]

  • High-Risk Path: Client-Side Logic Vulnerabilities in Message Handling [CRITICAL PATH]

    *   **Critical Node: Client-Side XSS via Unsafe Message Rendering [CRITICAL NODE]**
    *   Attack Vector Name: Client-Side XSS via Unsafe Message Rendering
    *   Description: If the client-side application renders messages received via `mess` without proper output encoding, attackers can send malicious messages that execute scripts in the victim's browser.
    *   Actionable Insight: **[CRITICAL] Critical:** Implement robust output encoding of all message content on the client-side before rendering it. Use secure templating libraries and frameworks that provide automatic output encoding.
    *   Likelihood: Medium (Common client-side vulnerability, especially in dynamic content)
    *   Impact: Medium to High (Client-side compromise, session hijacking, defacement)
    *   Effort: Low
    *   Skill Level: Low
    *   Detection Difficulty: Low (If monitoring for script execution on client-side, CSP violations)

Attack Tree Path: Insecure Communication Channel (related to mess deployment) [CRITICAL PATH]

  • Critical Node: Man-in-the-Middle (MitM) Attacks (if communication is not encrypted) [CRITICAL NODE] * Attack Vector Name: Man-in-the-Middle (MitM) Attacks * Description: If the communication between the client and the mess server is not properly encrypted (e.g., using plain WebSockets over HTTP instead of secure WebSockets over HTTPS), attackers can intercept and eavesdrop on messages in transit. * Actionable Insight: [CRITICAL] Critical: Always use secure communication channels (WSS - WebSocket Secure) for mess communication. Ensure HTTPS is used for the initial application connection and all subsequent WebSocket connections. Enforce TLS/SSL encryption. * Likelihood: Low (Should be standard practice to use WSS, but misconfigurations possible) * Impact: High (Eavesdropping on all communication, data breach, potential manipulation) * Effort: Low (If attacker is on the network path) * Skill Level: Low * Detection Difficulty: High (Passive attack, difficult to detect without network monitoring)

Attack Tree Path: Configuration Vulnerabilities in mess Deployment [CRITICAL PATH]

  • Critical Node: Default Credentials or Weak Configuration [CRITICAL NODE] * Attack Vector Name: Default Credentials or Weak Configuration * Description: If the mess server or related components are deployed with default credentials or weak configurations, attackers could gain unauthorized access to administrative interfaces or server settings. * Actionable Insight: [CRITICAL] Critical: Change all default credentials immediately upon deployment. Follow security best practices for server configuration. Regularly review and harden server configurations. * Likelihood: Low to Medium (Common deployment mistake, especially in quick setups) * Impact: High (Server compromise, full control) * Effort: Low * Skill Level: Low * Detection Difficulty: Low (If monitoring for unauthorized administrative access attempts)