Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
222 lines (192 loc) · 17.4 KB

attack-tree.md

File metadata and controls

222 lines (192 loc) · 17.4 KB

Attack Tree Analysis for stjohnjohnson/smartthings-mqtt-bridge

Objective: Gain Unauthorized Control of SmartThings Devices and/or Access Sensitive Data via Exploiting the SmartThings MQTT Bridge.

Attack Tree Visualization

  • Root: Achieve Unauthorized Control/Data Access via SmartThings MQTT Bridge [CRITICAL NODE]
      1. Compromise SmartThings MQTT Bridge Application Directly [CRITICAL NODE]
      • 1.2 Exploit Configuration Weaknesses [CRITICAL NODE]
        • 1.2.2 Insecure Storage of Credentials/API Keys [CRITICAL NODE]
          • 1.2.2.1 Credentials stored in plaintext configuration files [HIGH-RISK PATH]
    • 1.3 Man-in-the-Middle (MitM) Attacks on Bridge Communication [CRITICAL NODE]
      • 1.3.1 Intercept MQTT Communication [CRITICAL NODE]
        • 1.3.1.1 MQTT communication not encrypted (plain TCP) [HIGH-RISK PATH]
          • 1.3.1.1.1 Sniff network traffic to capture MQTT messages containing device data and potentially control commands [HIGH-RISK PATH]
        • 1.3.1.3 Lack of MQTT Authentication/Authorization [HIGH-RISK PATH]
          • 1.3.1.3.1 Connect to MQTT broker as unauthorized client and subscribe/publish to topics used by the bridge [HIGH-RISK PATH]
      1. Compromise MQTT Broker to Affect Bridge and Application [CRITICAL NODE]
      • 2.2 Exploit Weak MQTT Broker Security Configuration [CRITICAL NODE]
        • 2.2.1 Default Credentials on MQTT Broker [HIGH-RISK PATH]
          • 2.2.1.1 Use default credentials to gain administrative access to the MQTT broker [HIGH-RISK PATH]
        • 2.2.2 No Authentication/Authorization on MQTT Broker [HIGH-RISK PATH]
          • 2.2.2.1 Connect to MQTT broker without credentials and subscribe/publish to topics used by the bridge and application [HIGH-RISK PATH]
        • 2.2.4 Unencrypted MQTT Broker Communication [HIGH-RISK PATH]
          • 2.2.4.1 Sniff network traffic to capture MQTT messages and potentially inject malicious messages [HIGH-RISK PATH]
      1. Indirect Attacks via SmartThings Ecosystem [CRITICAL NODE]
      • 3.1 Compromise SmartThings Account [CRITICAL NODE]
        • 3.1.1 Phishing for SmartThings Account Credentials [HIGH-RISK PATH]
          • 3.1.1.1 Trick user into revealing SmartThings username/password [HIGH-RISK PATH]

Attack Tree Path: 1.2.2.1 Credentials stored in plaintext configuration files [HIGH-RISK PATH]

1.2.2.1 Credentials stored in plaintext configuration files [HIGH-RISK PATH] * Attack Vector: Insecure Storage of Credentials * Description: SmartThings API keys, MQTT broker credentials, or other sensitive information are stored in plaintext within configuration files accessible to the system running the bridge. * Likelihood: Medium to High * Impact: High (Direct access to SmartThings account and/or MQTT broker, leading to device control and data access) * Effort: Low (Requires access to the file system where configuration files are stored, which might be achievable through various means depending on deployment) * Skill Level: Low * Detection Difficulty: Low (If attacker gains file system access, hard to detect credential theft itself, but access to the system might be logged) * Mitigation Strategies: * Never store credentials in plaintext configuration files. * Utilize environment variables for sensitive configuration. * Employ secure secret management solutions or encrypted configuration files. * Restrict file system access to configuration files.

Attack Tree Path: 1.3.1.1 MQTT communication not encrypted (plain TCP) [HIGH-RISK PATH]

1.3.1.1 MQTT communication not encrypted (plain TCP) [HIGH-RISK PATH] * Attack Vector: Unencrypted MQTT Communication * Description: MQTT communication between the bridge, MQTT broker, and applications is conducted over plain TCP without TLS/SSL encryption. * Likelihood: Medium to High (If users do not explicitly configure encryption, plain TCP is often the default) * Impact: High (Network sniffing can easily intercept MQTT messages, revealing device data, control commands, and potentially sensitive information) * Effort: Low (Network sniffing tools are readily available and easy to use) * Skill Level: Low * Detection Difficulty: Low (Hard to detect network sniffing itself, but unusual network traffic patterns might be noticeable in some environments) * Mitigation Strategies: * Always configure TLS/SSL encryption for MQTT communication. * Use strong cipher suites for encryption. * Enforce encrypted connections on the MQTT broker.

Attack Tree Path: 1.3.1.1.1 Sniff network traffic to capture MQTT messages containing device data and potentially control commands [HIGH-RISK PATH]

1.3.1.1.1 Sniff network traffic to capture MQTT messages containing device data and potentially control commands [HIGH-RISK PATH] * Attack Vector: Network Sniffing of Unencrypted MQTT * Description: An attacker on the same network segment as the bridge or MQTT broker uses network sniffing tools to capture unencrypted MQTT traffic. * Likelihood: Medium to High (If MQTT is unencrypted and network access is possible) * Impact: High (Exposure of device data, potential for replay attacks or crafting malicious control commands based on observed traffic) * Effort: Low (Readily available network sniffing tools) * Skill Level: Low * Detection Difficulty: Low (Network sniffing itself is hard to detect passively, but active sniffing might be detectable with network intrusion detection systems) * Mitigation Strategies: * Enforce MQTT encryption (TLS/SSL) to render sniffed traffic unreadable. * Implement network segmentation to limit the attacker's network access. * Use network intrusion detection systems to detect suspicious network activity.

Attack Tree Path: 1.3.1.3 Lack of MQTT Authentication/Authorization [HIGH-RISK PATH]

1.3.1.3 Lack of MQTT Authentication/Authorization [HIGH-RISK PATH] * Attack Vector: Unauthenticated MQTT Access * Description: The MQTT broker is configured without authentication or authorization, allowing anyone to connect and subscribe/publish to topics. * Likelihood: Medium to High (If MQTT broker is not properly secured, especially in default configurations) * Impact: High (Full control over MQTT topics, allowing unauthorized device control, data manipulation, and disruption of the application) * Effort: Low (Connecting to an unauthenticated MQTT broker is trivial using standard MQTT clients) * Skill Level: Low * Detection Difficulty: Low (Easy to detect unauthorized connections in MQTT broker logs if logging is enabled) * Mitigation Strategies: * Enable strong authentication on the MQTT broker (username/password, client certificates). * Implement robust authorization mechanisms (ACLs) to restrict topic access based on client roles. * Regularly review and audit MQTT broker security configurations.

Attack Tree Path: 1.3.1.3.1 Connect to MQTT broker as unauthorized client and subscribe/publish to topics used by the bridge [HIGH-RISK PATH]

1.3.1.3.1 Connect to MQTT broker as unauthorized client and subscribe/publish to topics used by the bridge [HIGH-RISK PATH] * Attack Vector: Unauthorized MQTT Client Connection * Description: An attacker connects to the MQTT broker without valid credentials (due to lack of authentication) and gains access to MQTT topics used by the bridge and application. * Likelihood: Medium to High (If MQTT broker lacks authentication) * Impact: High (Ability to subscribe to topics to monitor device data, publish to control topics to manipulate devices, and disrupt communication) * Effort: Low (Standard MQTT clients can be used to connect without credentials) * Skill Level: Low * Detection Difficulty: Low (Unauthorized connection attempts should be logged by a properly configured MQTT broker) * Mitigation Strategies: * Implement MQTT broker authentication and authorization as described above. * Monitor MQTT broker logs for unauthorized connection attempts.

Attack Tree Path: 2.2.1 Default Credentials on MQTT Broker [HIGH-RISK PATH]

2.2.1 Default Credentials on MQTT Broker [HIGH-RISK PATH] * Attack Vector: Default MQTT Broker Credentials * Description: The MQTT broker is running with default administrative credentials that are publicly known or easily guessable. * Likelihood: Medium (Common if users fail to change default settings during installation and configuration) * Impact: Critical (Full administrative access to the MQTT broker, allowing complete control over the broker, all connected clients, and MQTT topics) * Effort: Low (Checking default credentials is trivial; default credentials are often documented or easily found online) * Skill Level: Low * Detection Difficulty: Low (Easy to detect in broker logs if administrative actions are logged) * Mitigation Strategies: * Immediately change all default credentials on the MQTT broker to strong, unique passwords. * Regularly audit and enforce strong password policies for MQTT broker accounts.

Attack Tree Path: 2.2.1.1 Use default credentials to gain administrative access to the MQTT broker [HIGH-RISK PATH]

2.2.1.1 Use default credentials to gain administrative access to the MQTT broker [HIGH-RISK PATH] * Attack Vector: Exploitation of Default MQTT Credentials * Description: An attacker uses default credentials to log in to the MQTT broker's administrative interface or API, gaining full control. * Likelihood: Medium (If default credentials are not changed) * Impact: Critical (Complete compromise of the MQTT broker) * Effort: Low (Using default credentials is trivial) * Skill Level: Low * Detection Difficulty: Low (Administrative logins should be logged by the MQTT broker) * Mitigation Strategies: * Change default credentials immediately. * Disable or restrict access to administrative interfaces if possible. * Implement account lockout policies to prevent brute-force attempts on administrative accounts.

Attack Tree Path: 2.2.2 No Authentication/Authorization on MQTT Broker [HIGH-RISK PATH]

2.2.2 No Authentication/Authorization on MQTT Broker [HIGH-RISK PATH] * Attack Vector: Unsecured MQTT Broker * Description: The MQTT broker is deployed without any form of authentication or authorization enabled. * Likelihood: Medium to High (If security is not explicitly configured, brokers might default to no authentication) * Impact: High (Anyone can connect to the broker and interact with MQTT topics, bypassing any access control) * Effort: Low (Connecting to an unsecured MQTT broker is trivial) * Skill Level: Low * Detection Difficulty: Low (Easy to detect unauthorized connections in broker logs) * Mitigation Strategies: * Enable and enforce authentication and authorization on the MQTT broker. * Follow security best practices for MQTT broker deployment.

Attack Tree Path: 2.2.2.1 Connect to MQTT broker without credentials and subscribe/publish to topics used by the bridge and application [HIGH-RISK PATH]

2.2.2.1 Connect to MQTT broker without credentials and subscribe/publish to topics used by the bridge and application [HIGH-RISK PATH] * Attack Vector: Unauthorized Access to Unsecured MQTT Broker * Description: An attacker connects to an MQTT broker that lacks authentication and gains full access to MQTT topics. * Likelihood: Medium to High (If MQTT broker is unsecured) * Impact: High (Full control over MQTT communication, device control, data access) * Effort: Low (Connecting to an unsecured broker is trivial) * Skill Level: Low * Detection Difficulty: Low (Unauthorized connections should be logged) * Mitigation Strategies: * Secure the MQTT broker with authentication and authorization. * Monitor broker logs for unauthorized connections.

Attack Tree Path: 2.2.4 Unencrypted MQTT Broker Communication [HIGH-RISK PATH]

2.2.4 Unencrypted MQTT Broker Communication [HIGH-RISK PATH] * Attack Vector: Unencrypted MQTT Broker Network Traffic * Description: The MQTT broker itself is configured to allow or default to unencrypted communication (plain TCP). * Likelihood: Medium to High (If encryption is not explicitly configured on the broker) * Impact: High (All MQTT traffic to and from the broker is vulnerable to network sniffing, exposing all data and control commands) * Effort: Low (Network sniffing tools are readily available) * Skill Level: Low * Detection Difficulty: Low (Network sniffing is hard to detect passively) * Mitigation Strategies: * Configure the MQTT broker to enforce TLS/SSL encryption for all connections. * Disable or restrict plain TCP connections to the broker.

Attack Tree Path: 2.2.4.1 Sniff network traffic to capture MQTT messages and potentially inject malicious messages [HIGH-RISK PATH]

2.2.4.1 Sniff network traffic to capture MQTT messages and potentially inject malicious messages [HIGH-RISK PATH] * Attack Vector: Network Sniffing of Unencrypted Broker Traffic * Description: An attacker sniffs network traffic to/from the MQTT broker when communication is unencrypted, capturing all MQTT messages. * Likelihood: Medium to High (If broker allows unencrypted communication and network access is possible) * Impact: High (Complete exposure of all MQTT data, ability to inject malicious messages into the MQTT system) * Effort: Low (Network sniffing tools are readily available) * Skill Level: Low * Detection Difficulty: Low (Passive sniffing is hard to detect) * Mitigation Strategies: * Enforce MQTT encryption on the broker and all clients. * Implement network segmentation. * Use network intrusion detection systems.

Attack Tree Path: 3.1.1 Phishing for SmartThings Account Credentials [HIGH-RISK PATH]

3.1.1 Phishing for SmartThings Account Credentials [HIGH-RISK PATH] * Attack Vector: SmartThings Account Phishing * Description: An attacker uses phishing techniques (e.g., fake login pages, deceptive emails) to trick the user into revealing their SmartThings account username and password. * Likelihood: Medium (Phishing is a common and effective attack vector targeting human users) * Impact: Critical (Full control of the user's SmartThings account and all connected devices) * Effort: Low (Phishing campaigns can be launched with relatively low effort using readily available tools and templates) * Skill Level: Low * Detection Difficulty: Low to Medium (User awareness training and email filtering can help, but it's difficult to prevent all phishing attacks) * Mitigation Strategies: * User education and awareness training on phishing attacks. * Implement multi-factor authentication (MFA) for SmartThings accounts. * Use email filtering and anti-phishing tools. * Encourage users to verify website URLs before entering credentials.

Attack Tree Path: 3.1.1.1 Trick user into revealing SmartThings username/password [HIGH-RISK PATH]

3.1.1.1 Trick user into revealing SmartThings username/password [HIGH-RISK PATH] * Attack Vector: Successful Phishing Attack * Description: The user falls victim to a phishing attack and enters their SmartThings credentials on a fake login page controlled by the attacker. * Likelihood: Medium (Depends on user awareness and sophistication of the phishing attack) * Impact: Critical (Account compromise) * Effort: Low (Once phishing campaign is set up, success depends on user action) * Skill Level: Low * Detection Difficulty: Low to Medium (Hard to detect from a system perspective, relies on user reporting or account monitoring for suspicious activity after compromise) * Mitigation Strategies: * User education is paramount. * Multi-factor authentication significantly reduces the impact of compromised passwords. * Account activity monitoring for unusual logins or device control actions.