Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
95 lines (69 loc) · 13.3 KB

mitigations.md

File metadata and controls

95 lines (69 loc) · 13.3 KB

Mitigation Strategies Analysis for airbnb/lottie-android

Mitigation Strategy: JSON Schema Validation for Animation Files

  • Description:

    • Step 1: Define a strict JSON schema that accurately represents the expected structure of valid Lottie JSON animation files. This schema should be as restrictive as possible, only allowing necessary properties and data types as defined by the Lottie specification. Tools like online JSON schema validators or libraries within your development environment can assist in creating and validating schemas.
    • Step 2: Integrate a JSON schema validation library into your application's animation loading process. This validation should occur before the animation JSON is passed to the LottieAnimationView or LottieCompositionFactory.
    • Step 3: Before loading any animation file using LottieAnimationView or related classes, validate the JSON content of the file against the defined schema. This can be done programmatically using the chosen JSON schema validation library.
    • Step 4: If the validation fails, reject the animation file and prevent it from being loaded and rendered by Lottie. Log the validation failure with details about the schema violation for debugging and security monitoring. Provide a fallback mechanism, such as a default static image or a safe error message, to avoid application crashes or unexpected behavior when an invalid animation is encountered.

  • List of Threats Mitigated:

    • Malicious JSON Injection (High Severity): Prevents loading animation files with unexpected or malicious JSON structures designed to exploit parsing vulnerabilities within the Lottie library itself or its underlying JSON parsing mechanisms.
    • Unexpected Animation Behavior due to Format Deviations (Medium Severity): Reduces the risk of loading animation files that, while potentially not malicious, deviate from the expected Lottie JSON format and could lead to unexpected rendering behavior, application errors, or crashes when processed by Lottie.

  • Impact:

    • Malicious JSON Injection: Significantly Reduces risk by preventing Lottie from processing potentially harmful JSON structures that could exploit vulnerabilities in its parsing logic.
    • Unexpected Animation Behavior due to Format Deviations: Moderately Reduces risk by ensuring that Lottie only processes animation files that conform to the expected format, minimizing the chance of unexpected rendering outcomes or errors caused by format inconsistencies.

  • Currently Implemented: No

  • Missing Implementation: Missing in the animation loading logic throughout the application where Lottie animations are loaded from external sources or user-provided files. Needs to be implemented in the data processing layer before passing animation data to Lottie library's loading methods (e.g., LottieCompositionFactory.fromJsonReader, LottieAnimationView.setAnimation).

Mitigation Strategy: Content Type Verification for Animation Files

  • Description:

    • Step 1: When fetching animation files from remote servers that will be used by lottie-android, always check the Content-Type header of the HTTP response before attempting to load the file with Lottie.
    • Step 2: Verify that the Content-Type header explicitly indicates a JSON format suitable for Lottie, typically application/json or text/json. Be strict and avoid accepting ambiguous or less specific content types.
    • Step 3: If the Content-Type header is missing, incorrect (not JSON), or indicates a different file type, reject the file and do not attempt to load it as a Lottie animation. Prevent Lottie from even attempting to parse the file.
    • Step 4: Log any instances of incorrect or missing Content-Type headers for security monitoring and investigation of potential server-side issues, misconfigurations, or malicious attempts to deliver non-JSON content to Lottie.

  • List of Threats Mitigated:

    • File Extension Mismatch/Masquerading Exploiting Lottie Parsing (Medium Severity): Prevents loading files that are not actually JSON animation files but are disguised as such (e.g., with a .json extension) and could potentially trigger unexpected behavior or errors when Lottie attempts to parse them as JSON. This could be used to probe for parsing vulnerabilities in Lottie.
    • Accidental Loading of Incorrect File Types Leading to Lottie Errors (Low Severity): Reduces the risk of accidentally loading non-JSON files due to misconfiguration or errors in file handling, which could lead to parsing errors and application instability specifically within Lottie's parsing process.

  • Impact:

    • File Extension Mismatch/Masquerading Exploiting Lottie Parsing: Moderately Reduces risk by adding a layer of verification beyond just file extension, making it harder to trick the application into feeding non-JSON content to Lottie's JSON parser.
    • Accidental Loading of Incorrect File Types Leading to Lottie Errors: Minimally Reduces risk, mainly improving application robustness and preventing minor errors that could arise from Lottie attempting to parse incompatible file formats.

  • Currently Implemented: Partially

  • Missing Implementation: Partially implemented in network request handling for some animation sources, but needs to be consistently applied across all network requests for animation files intended for Lottie throughout the application. Missing in local file loading scenarios if applicable, especially if local files are obtained from potentially untrusted sources.

Mitigation Strategy: Size Limits for Animation Files

  • Description:

    • Step 1: Determine reasonable maximum file size limits for Lottie animation files based on your application's performance requirements, target device capabilities, and typical animation complexity as rendered by Lottie. Consider the impact of large animations on memory usage and rendering time within the Lottie library.
    • Step 2: Implement checks to enforce these size limits before attempting to load animation files into LottieAnimationView or using LottieCompositionFactory. The size check should occur before Lottie starts parsing or processing the file.
    • Step 3: If an animation file exceeds the defined size limit, reject it and prevent loading by Lottie. Display an informative error message to the user or use a fallback animation.
    • Step 4: Log instances of oversized animation files for monitoring and potential investigation of malicious activity (e.g., attempts to cause DoS by providing excessively large animations to Lottie) or inefficient animation generation processes that create unnecessarily large files for Lottie to process.

  • List of Threats Mitigated:

    • Denial of Service (DoS) via Large Animation Files Targeting Lottie Rendering (Medium Severity): Mitigates the risk of attackers providing excessively large animation files specifically designed to consume excessive resources (memory, processing power) during Lottie's rendering process and potentially crash the application or degrade performance.
    • Resource Exhaustion (Memory/CPU) due to Lottie Rendering Complex Animations (Medium Severity): Reduces the likelihood of legitimate but poorly optimized large animation files causing resource exhaustion on user devices when rendered by Lottie, leading to slow performance, battery drain, or application crashes.

  • Impact:

    • Denial of Service (DoS) via Large Animation Files Targeting Lottie Rendering: Moderately Reduces risk by limiting the impact of oversized files on application resources specifically during Lottie rendering.
    • Resource Exhaustion (Memory/CPU) due to Lottie Rendering Complex Animations: Moderately Reduces risk by preventing Lottie from attempting to process extremely large animations that could strain device resources during rendering.

  • Currently Implemented: No

  • Missing Implementation: Not implemented at all. Needs to be added to the animation loading process, especially when loading from network or user-provided sources that will be rendered by Lottie. Size checks should be performed before attempting to parse the animation file with Lottie.

Mitigation Strategy: Regular Lottie Library Updates

  • Description:

    • Step 1: Regularly monitor the airbnb/lottie-android GitHub repository and release notes for new versions and security advisories specifically related to Lottie.
    • Step 2: Subscribe to security vulnerability databases and alerts that may specifically mention vulnerabilities in lottie-android.
    • Step 3: Establish a process for promptly updating the lottie-android library to the latest stable version whenever updates are released, especially those explicitly addressing security vulnerabilities within Lottie.
    • Step 4: After updating Lottie, thoroughly test the application's animation rendering functionality to ensure compatibility and that the update has not introduced any regressions in Lottie's behavior within your application.

  • List of Threats Mitigated:

    • Exploitation of Known Lottie Vulnerabilities (High Severity): Directly mitigates the risk of attackers exploiting publicly known vulnerabilities within the lottie-android library itself. These vulnerabilities could be parsing bugs, rendering flaws, or other security issues specific to Lottie's code.

  • Impact:

    • Exploitation of Known Lottie Vulnerabilities: Significantly Reduces risk by patching known vulnerabilities in the Lottie library and staying ahead of potential exploits targeting outdated, vulnerable library versions.

  • Currently Implemented: Yes

  • Missing Implementation: Currently implemented as part of general dependency update practices, but could be improved by establishing a more proactive and automated monitoring and update process specifically focused on security-related updates of lottie-android. Consider setting up alerts or notifications for new Lottie releases and security announcements.

Mitigation Strategy: Animation Complexity Limits and Optimization Guidelines

  • Description:

    • Step 1: Define clear and specific guidelines for animation complexity that are relevant to Lottie's rendering performance. These guidelines should specify limits on the number of layers, shapes, keyframes, effects, and overall file size in the context of how Lottie processes and renders these elements.
    • Step 2: Educate designers and developers on animation optimization techniques specifically for Lottie, emphasizing practices that minimize resource consumption during Lottie rendering.
    • Step 3: Implement automated checks or linters (if feasible) to detect animations that exceed complexity guidelines in terms of Lottie-relevant metrics during development. This might involve analyzing the animation JSON structure for complexity indicators relevant to Lottie.
    • Step 4: Conduct performance testing of animations, especially complex ones, on target devices to identify potential performance bottlenecks and resource issues specifically related to Lottie's rendering performance. Use profiling tools to analyze Lottie's resource usage during animation playback.

  • List of Threats Mitigated:

    • Performance Degradation due to Lottie Rendering Complex Animations (Medium Severity): Reduces the risk of complex animations causing performance issues, slow rendering within Lottie, UI lag, and poor user experience, especially on lower-powered devices when using Lottie for rendering.
    • Resource Exhaustion (Memory/CPU) due to Lottie Rendering Complex Animations (Medium Severity): Mitigates the risk of overly complex animations consuming excessive device resources (CPU, memory, battery) during Lottie's rendering process, potentially leading to application crashes or device instability caused by Lottie's resource demands.

  • Impact:

    • Performance Degradation due to Lottie Rendering Complex Animations: Moderately Reduces risk by promoting the creation of more efficient animations specifically for Lottie rendering and preventing the introduction of excessively complex ones that strain Lottie's performance.
    • Resource Exhaustion (Memory/CPU) due to Lottie Rendering Complex Animations: Moderately Reduces risk by limiting animation complexity and encouraging optimization, thus reducing the strain on device resources caused by Lottie's rendering workload.

  • Currently Implemented: Partially

  • Missing Implementation: Partially implemented through informal communication and best practices. However, formal guidelines specifically tailored to Lottie's performance characteristics, automated checks relevant to Lottie animation complexity metrics, and systematic performance testing of animations focused on Lottie's rendering behavior are missing. Needs to formalize animation complexity guidelines in the context of Lottie and integrate them into the development workflow.