Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
140 lines (106 loc) · 14.2 KB

mitigations.md

File metadata and controls

140 lines (106 loc) · 14.2 KB

Mitigation Strategies Analysis for apache/dubbo

Mitigation Strategy: 1. Deserialization Vulnerabilities Mitigation (Dubbo Specific)

Mitigation Strategy: Use Secure Serialization Frameworks (Dubbo Configuration)

  • Description:

    1. Identify Current Dubbo Serialization: Determine the serialization framework configured in your Dubbo application. Check dubbo.properties, Spring XML/Annotations for dubbo.protocol's serialization attribute. Default is often hessian.
    2. Evaluate Dubbo Serialization Security: Recognize that hessian and java原生 (Java native serialization) are less secure for untrusted input due to known deserialization vulnerabilities.
    3. Configure Secure Dubbo Serialization: Change the serialization attribute in your Dubbo configuration to a more secure option like protobuf or fastjson2 (with fastjson2 being generally safer than original fastjson). Example in dubbo.properties: dubbo.protocol.serialization=protobuf.
    4. Dubbo Dependency Management: Ensure your project includes necessary dependencies for the chosen serialization framework. For protobuf, you'll need Protobuf libraries. For fastjson2, include fastjson2 dependency.
    5. Dubbo Service Interface Compatibility: Verify that your Dubbo service interfaces and data transfer objects (DTOs) are compatible with the new serialization framework. Protobuf often requires .proto schema definitions. fastjson2 generally works with standard Java objects.
    6. Dubbo Testing: Thoroughly test Dubbo services after changing serialization to ensure proper communication and data exchange between providers and consumers.

  • List of Threats Mitigated:

    • Remote Code Execution (RCE) via Dubbo Deserialization (High Severity): Exploiting insecure Dubbo serialization to execute arbitrary code on Dubbo provider or consumer.
    • Denial of Service (DoS) via Dubbo Deserialization (Medium Severity): Sending malicious payloads to Dubbo services that cause excessive resource consumption during deserialization.
    • Information Disclosure via Dubbo Deserialization (Medium Severity): Potentially extracting sensitive data from Dubbo service memory through deserialization exploits.

  • Impact:

    • RCE via Dubbo Deserialization: High Risk Reduction. Using secure serialization significantly reduces RCE risk.
    • DoS via Dubbo Deserialization: Medium Risk Reduction. Secure frameworks are generally more resilient to DoS attacks.
    • Information Disclosure via Dubbo Deserialization: Medium Risk Reduction. Secure frameworks are less prone to information leaks.

  • Currently Implemented:

    • Location: Let's assume currently using default hessian serialization configured implicitly in Dubbo.

  • Missing Implementation:

    • Missing: Project-wide configuration change to a secure Dubbo serialization framework like protobuf or fastjson2.

Mitigation Strategy: 2. Authentication and Authorization in Dubbo Services (Dubbo Specific)

Mitigation Strategy: Implement Dubbo Authentication

  • Description:

    1. Choose Dubbo Authentication Mechanism: Select a suitable Dubbo authentication mechanism. Dubbo provides built-in options like SimpleCredentialsAuthenticator or allows integration with external systems via custom Authenticator implementations.
    2. Configure Dubbo Authentication Filter: Enable and configure the AuthenticationFilter in your Dubbo provider configuration. This filter intercepts incoming Dubbo requests and enforces authentication.
    3. Implement Authenticator (if custom): If using a custom authentication mechanism, implement the Authenticator interface. This component will verify client credentials (e.g., tokens, usernames/passwords) against your authentication system.
    4. Client Credential Provisioning: Establish a secure way for Dubbo consumers to obtain and manage authentication credentials. This could involve API keys, JWT tokens, or other credential exchange mechanisms.
    5. Dubbo Configuration for Credentials: Configure Dubbo consumers to send authentication credentials with each request. This is often done through attachments in the Dubbo invocation context.
    6. Testing Dubbo Authentication: Thoroughly test Dubbo service authentication to ensure only authenticated clients can access protected services. Test both successful and failed authentication scenarios.

  • List of Threats Mitigated:

    • Unauthorized Access to Dubbo Services (High Severity): Prevents unauthorized clients from invoking Dubbo services and accessing sensitive data or functionalities.
    • Data Breaches via Unauthorized Access (High Severity): Reduces the risk of data breaches resulting from unauthorized access to Dubbo service endpoints.
    • Service Misuse and Abuse (Medium Severity): Authentication helps control service usage and prevent abuse by malicious or unintended clients.

  • Impact:

    • Unauthorized Access to Dubbo Services: High Risk Reduction. Dubbo authentication is a primary control against unauthorized access.
    • Data Breaches via Unauthorized Access: High Risk Reduction. Authentication significantly reduces the risk of data breaches.
    • Service Misuse and Abuse: Medium Risk Reduction. Authentication helps in controlling service usage patterns.

  • Currently Implemented:

    • Location: No Dubbo authentication is currently implemented. Services are accessible without any client authentication.

  • Missing Implementation:

    • Missing: Project-wide implementation of Dubbo authentication is needed for all sensitive services. Configuration of AuthenticationFilter and selection/implementation of an Authenticator are required.

Mitigation Strategy: Implement Dubbo Authorization

  • Description:

    1. Choose Dubbo Authorization Mechanism: Select an authorization mechanism for Dubbo. Dubbo provides AccessControlFilter for basic role-based access control or allows custom AccessFilter implementations for more complex policies.
    2. Configure Dubbo Authorization Filter: Enable and configure the chosen authorization filter (e.g., AccessControlFilter or custom filter) in your Dubbo provider configuration.
    3. Define Authorization Policies: Define fine-grained authorization policies that specify which clients (or roles) are allowed to access specific Dubbo services or methods. Policies can be based on roles, permissions, or other attributes.
    4. Implement Authorization Logic (if custom): If using a custom AccessFilter, implement the authorization logic to evaluate policies and make access decisions based on client identity and requested resource.
    5. Integrate with Policy Decision Point (PDP) (Optional): For complex authorization scenarios, consider integrating Dubbo with an external PDP (e.g., using XACML or OAuth 2.0 scopes) to centralize policy management.
    6. Dubbo Configuration for Roles/Permissions: Configure Dubbo consumers to provide role or permission information (if needed by the authorization mechanism) in the invocation context.
    7. Testing Dubbo Authorization: Thoroughly test Dubbo service authorization to ensure that access control policies are correctly enforced. Test authorized and unauthorized access attempts for different services and methods.

  • List of Threats Mitigated:

    • Unauthorized Access to Specific Dubbo Services/Methods (High Severity): Prevents authorized but not permitted clients from accessing certain services or methods they shouldn't.
    • Privilege Escalation (Medium to High Severity): Authorization prevents clients from gaining access beyond their intended privileges within the Dubbo application.
    • Data Breaches due to Over-Permissive Access (Medium Severity): Reduces the risk of data breaches caused by overly broad access permissions.

  • Impact:

    • Unauthorized Access to Specific Dubbo Services/Methods: High Risk Reduction. Dubbo authorization provides fine-grained access control.
    • Privilege Escalation: Medium to High Risk Reduction. Authorization limits the potential for privilege escalation.
    • Data Breaches due to Over-Permissive Access: Medium Risk Reduction. Authorization enforces least privilege access.

  • Currently Implemented:

    • Location: No Dubbo authorization is currently implemented. Authentication (if implemented later) would only verify identity, not permissions.

  • Missing Implementation:

    • Missing: Project-wide implementation of Dubbo authorization is needed, especially for services handling sensitive operations or data. Configuration of an authorization filter and definition of access control policies are required.

Mitigation Strategy: 3. Protocol Security (Dubbo Specific)

Mitigation Strategy: Protocol Configuration Hardening (Dubbo Protocol)

  • Description:

    1. Review Dubbo Protocol Configuration: Examine the <dubbo:protocol> configuration in your Dubbo provider settings (e.g., dubbo.properties, Spring XML).
    2. Disable Unnecessary Dubbo Protocol Features: Identify and disable any Dubbo protocol features that are not essential for your application's functionality. This might include features related to specific transports or serialization options if not in use.
    3. Limit Payload Sizes (Dubbo Protocol): Configure limits on the maximum request and response payload sizes in the Dubbo protocol configuration. This can help prevent denial-of-service attacks that rely on sending excessively large payloads. Check for configuration options like payload or transporter.
    4. Timeout Configuration (Dubbo Protocol): Ensure appropriate timeout values are configured for Dubbo requests and responses. This prevents indefinite waits and resource exhaustion in case of slow or unresponsive services. Configure timeout attribute in <dubbo:method> or <dubbo:service>.
    5. Expose Only Necessary Dubbo Ports: Ensure that only the necessary ports for Dubbo communication are exposed on your provider servers. Use firewalls to restrict access to Dubbo ports from unauthorized networks.

  • List of Threats Mitigated:

    • Denial of Service (DoS) via Large Payloads (Medium Severity): Limiting payload sizes prevents attackers from overwhelming Dubbo services with massive requests.
    • Resource Exhaustion due to Timeouts (Medium Severity): Proper timeouts prevent resource leaks and DoS caused by hanging requests.
    • Unnecessary Attack Surface (Low Severity): Disabling unused protocol features reduces the overall attack surface of the Dubbo service.

  • Impact:

    • Denial of Service (DoS) via Large Payloads: Medium Risk Reduction. Payload limits mitigate payload-based DoS.
    • Resource Exhaustion due to Timeouts: Medium Risk Reduction. Timeouts improve service resilience and prevent resource leaks.
    • Unnecessary Attack Surface: Low Risk Reduction. Reducing attack surface is a general security best practice.

  • Currently Implemented:

    • Location: Default Dubbo protocol configuration is used. No specific hardening measures are in place.

  • Missing Implementation:

    • Missing: Review and hardening of Dubbo protocol configuration parameters, including payload size limits and timeout settings.

Mitigation Strategy: Rate Limiting and Throttling (Dubbo Service Level)

  • Description:

    1. Choose Dubbo Rate Limiting Mechanism: Select a rate limiting mechanism for your Dubbo services. Dubbo provides built-in rate limiting filters or allows integration with external rate limiting services.
    2. Configure Dubbo Rate Limiting Filter: Enable and configure a rate limiting filter (e.g., using Dubbo's SPI extension points to create a custom filter or using a pre-built filter if available) in your Dubbo provider configuration.
    3. Define Rate Limits: Define appropriate rate limits for your Dubbo services based on their capacity and expected traffic patterns. Rate limits can be defined per service, per method, or per client.
    4. Rate Limiting Policies: Configure rate limiting policies, including:
      • Rate Limit Thresholds: Define the maximum number of requests allowed within a specific time window.
      • Rate Limiting Algorithm: Choose a rate limiting algorithm (e.g., token bucket, leaky bucket, fixed window).
      • Response to Rate Limiting: Define how the Dubbo service should respond when rate limits are exceeded (e.g., return an error code, delay requests).
    5. Monitoring Rate Limiting: Monitor rate limiting metrics to track service usage and identify potential abuse or misconfigurations.

  • List of Threats Mitigated:

    • Denial of Service (DoS) Attacks (Medium to High Severity): Rate limiting protects Dubbo services from being overwhelmed by excessive requests, whether intentional DoS attacks or unintentional traffic spikes.
    • Brute-Force Attacks (Medium Severity): Rate limiting can slow down brute-force attacks against authentication or other security-sensitive endpoints in Dubbo services.
    • Resource Exhaustion (Medium Severity): Prevents resource exhaustion caused by uncontrolled request volume.

  • Impact:

    • Denial of Service (DoS) Attacks: Medium to High Risk Reduction. Rate limiting is a key defense against DoS.
    • Brute-Force Attacks: Medium Risk Reduction. Rate limiting makes brute-force attacks less effective.
    • Resource Exhaustion: Medium Risk Reduction. Rate limiting improves service stability under load.

  • Currently Implemented:

    • Location: No rate limiting is currently implemented at the Dubbo service level.

  • Missing Implementation:

    • Missing: Project-wide implementation of rate limiting for critical Dubbo services to protect against DoS and abuse. Configuration of a rate limiting filter and definition of rate limiting policies are needed.