Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
247 lines (226 loc) · 28.2 KB

mitigations.md

File metadata and controls

247 lines (226 loc) · 28.2 KB

Mitigation Strategies Analysis for apolloconfig/apollo

Mitigation Strategy: Role-Based Access Control (RBAC) within Apollo Portal

Description:

  1. Access Apollo Portal as an administrator.
  2. Navigate to the "User Management" or "Role Management" section within the Apollo Portal. (Location may vary slightly depending on Apollo version).
  3. Define Roles in Apollo: Create custom roles directly within the Apollo Portal interface. Examples include "Namespace Reader", "Namespace Editor", "Release Approver", "Admin Manager".
  4. Assign Apollo Permissions to Roles: Within the Apollo Portal role configuration, grant specific Apollo permissions. These permissions control access to namespaces, clusters, and Apollo functionalities like configuration modification, release management, and administration. Apply the principle of least privilege, granting only necessary Apollo permissions.
  5. Assign Users to Apollo Roles: In the Apollo Portal user management section, assign users to the Apollo roles you have defined.
  6. Regularly Review Apollo RBAC Configuration: Periodically review the roles and user assignments within the Apollo Portal to ensure they remain appropriate and aligned with current team responsibilities. Remove access for users who no longer require it within Apollo.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Unauthorized Access to Configuration Data (High Severity) - Prevents users without proper Apollo roles from viewing or modifying configurations within Apollo.
    • Configuration Tampering (Medium Severity) - Reduces the risk of unauthorized or accidental configuration changes within Apollo by limiting modification access based on Apollo roles.
  • Impact:
    • Unauthorized Access to Configuration Data: High - Significantly reduces the risk of unauthorized access within Apollo's management interface.
    • Configuration Tampering: Medium - Reduces the risk of tampering within Apollo's management interface by controlling access.
  • Currently Implemented: Partially Implemented - Basic user accounts exist in Apollo Portal, but custom roles are not fully defined and utilized. Default "admin" role is still prevalent.
  • Missing Implementation:
    • Defining granular custom roles within Apollo Portal based on least privilege.
    • Systematic assignment of users to specific Apollo roles.
    • Regular audits and updates of Apollo RBAC configuration within the Apollo Portal.

Mitigation Strategy: Secure Apollo Portal and Admin Service Authentication within Apollo

Description:

  1. Enforce Strong Password Policies in Apollo Portal: Configure password policies directly within Apollo Portal settings, if available, or through underlying authentication mechanisms if integrated.
  2. Integrate Apollo with Enterprise Authentication (LDAP/AD/SSO):
    • Consult Apollo documentation for supported enterprise authentication integrations.
    • Configure Apollo Admin Service to delegate authentication to LDAP, Active Directory, or an SSO provider. This typically involves modifying Apollo's configuration files (e.g., application.yml) to point to your enterprise authentication system.
    • Test the integration thoroughly to ensure users can authenticate to Apollo Portal and Admin Service using enterprise credentials.
    • Disable local authentication within Apollo Portal if enterprise authentication is fully implemented to enforce centralized authentication.
  3. Disable Default/Test Accounts in Apollo:
    • Identify any default or test user accounts pre-configured within Apollo (e.g., "apollo", "admin" with default passwords).
    • Change the passwords for these default accounts immediately to strong, unique passwords directly within Apollo Portal.
    • Ideally, disable or remove these default accounts from Apollo if they are not required for ongoing operation.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Unauthorized Access to Configuration Data (High Severity) - Prevents unauthorized access to Apollo due to weak default credentials or lack of centralized authentication.
    • Account Takeover (High Severity) - Reduces the risk of attackers compromising Apollo user accounts through weak passwords or by exploiting default accounts.
  • Impact:
    • Unauthorized Access to Configuration Data: High - Significantly reduces risk of unauthorized access to Apollo itself.
    • Account Takeover: High - Significantly reduces risk of account compromise within Apollo.
  • Currently Implemented: Partially Implemented - Strong password policy is enforced in Apollo Portal, but default "admin" password is unchanged and enterprise authentication is not configured within Apollo.
  • Missing Implementation:
    • Changing default "admin" password in Apollo Portal.
    • Integrating Apollo authentication with company's Active Directory or SSO.
    • Disabling local authentication in Apollo Portal after enterprise integration.

Mitigation Strategy: Enforce HTTPS for Apollo Communication

Description:

  1. Obtain SSL/TLS Certificates: Acquire valid SSL/TLS certificates for the domains or hostnames used by Apollo Config Service, Admin Service, and Portal.
  2. Configure HTTPS for Apollo Config Service:
    • Modify the Apollo Config Service configuration file (e.g., application.yml) to enable HTTPS. This typically involves specifying the path to the SSL/TLS certificate and private key.
    • Ensure the server.ssl.enabled property is set to true and configure server.ssl.* properties accordingly.
  3. Configure HTTPS for Apollo Admin Service:
    • Similarly, modify the Apollo Admin Service configuration file to enable HTTPS using SSL/TLS certificates.
  4. Configure HTTPS for Apollo Portal:
    • Configure the web server hosting Apollo Portal (e.g., Nginx, Apache) to use HTTPS and the obtained SSL/TLS certificates.
  5. Configure Apollo Clients to Use HTTPS:
    • Ensure all Apollo client applications are configured to communicate with the Config Service using HTTPS URLs (starting with https://). Verify client configurations and connection strings.
  6. Enforce HTTPS Redirects (Optional but Recommended): Configure web servers to automatically redirect HTTP requests to HTTPS for Apollo Portal and potentially Config/Admin Services if direct browser access is intended.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Exposure of Sensitive Configuration Data in Transit (Medium Severity) - Protects sensitive configuration data from eavesdropping and interception during communication between Apollo components and clients.
    • Man-in-the-Middle (MITM) Attacks (Medium Severity) - Reduces the risk of MITM attacks that could intercept or modify configuration data in transit to/from Apollo.
  • Impact:
    • Exposure of Sensitive Configuration Data in Transit: Medium - Significantly reduces risk of data exposure during network communication with Apollo.
    • Man-in-the-Middle (MITM) Attacks: Medium - Reduces the risk of MITM attacks targeting Apollo communication channels.
  • Currently Implemented: Partially Implemented - HTTPS is enabled for Apollo Portal, but not fully enforced or configured for Config and Admin Services. Client communication might still be over HTTP in some cases.
  • Missing Implementation:
    • Enabling and enforcing HTTPS for Apollo Config Service and Admin Service.
    • Verifying and enforcing HTTPS communication for all Apollo clients.
    • Implementing HTTPS redirects for all Apollo services.

Mitigation Strategy: API Authentication and Authorization for Apollo Clients within Apollo

Description:

  1. Enable API Authentication in Apollo Config Service:
    • Configure Apollo Config Service to enable API authentication. This is typically done by setting properties in the Config Service's configuration file (e.g., application.yml) to activate authentication mechanisms like API keys or tokens. Refer to Apollo documentation for specific configuration details.
  2. Generate API Keys/Tokens within Apollo Admin Service/Portal:
    • Use the Apollo Admin Service or Portal interface to generate API keys or tokens. Apollo provides functionalities to create and manage API credentials for clients.
    • Associate API keys/tokens with specific Apollo namespaces or applications based on the required access control. Apollo's API key management should allow for scoping access.
  3. Configure Apollo Clients to Use API Keys/Tokens:
    • Modify Apollo client applications to include the generated API key or token in every request to the Config Service. This is usually done by setting HTTP headers (e.g., Authorization: Bearer <API_TOKEN>) or query parameters as specified by Apollo's API authentication method.
  4. Enforce API Key/Token Validation in Apollo Config Service:
    • Ensure Apollo Config Service is properly configured to validate incoming API keys/tokens against its internal store. This step is crucial to ensure only clients with valid credentials can access configurations.
  5. Regularly Rotate API Keys/Tokens within Apollo:
    • Establish a policy for periodic API key/token rotation within Apollo.
    • Utilize Apollo's API key management features (if available) to facilitate key rotation and minimize disruption to clients.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Unauthorized Access to Configuration Data (High Severity) - Prevents unauthorized applications or clients from retrieving configurations from Apollo Config Service.
    • Data Breach via Compromised Client (Medium Severity) - Limits the potential damage if an application client is compromised, as unauthorized configuration access is still prevented by API authentication in Apollo.
  • Impact:
    • Unauthorized Access to Configuration Data: High - Significantly reduces risk of unauthorized access to configurations from clients accessing Apollo.
    • Data Breach via Compromised Client: Medium - Reduces impact by limiting configuration access even if a client application is compromised.
  • Currently Implemented: Not Implemented - Apollo clients are currently accessing configurations without API authentication enforced by Apollo Config Service.
  • Missing Implementation:
    • Enabling API authentication within Apollo Config Service.
    • Generating and managing API keys/tokens using Apollo Admin Service/Portal.
    • Implementing API key/token usage in all Apollo client applications.
    • Establishing an API key rotation policy and process within Apollo.

Mitigation Strategy: Configuration Change Approval Workflow in Apollo

Description:

  1. Enable Workflow Feature in Apollo Portal: Activate the configuration change approval workflow feature within the Apollo Portal settings. (Availability depends on Apollo version).
  2. Define Approval Roles in Apollo: Within Apollo Portal, define roles specifically for configuration change approvals (e.g., "Configuration Approver", "Release Manager"). These roles are distinct from general RBAC roles.
  3. Assign Approvers to Namespaces/Clusters in Apollo: Configure namespaces or clusters within Apollo to require approval for configuration changes. Assign the defined approval roles to these namespaces/clusters, specifying who can approve changes.
  4. Implement Configuration Change Request Process in Apollo: When a user makes a configuration change in Apollo Portal for a protected namespace/cluster, the system should automatically initiate an approval request.
  5. Approvers Review and Approve/Reject in Apollo Portal: Designated approvers receive notifications within Apollo Portal and can review the proposed configuration changes. They can then approve or reject the changes directly within the Apollo Portal interface.
  6. Configuration Changes Applied After Approval in Apollo: Only after the required approvals are obtained within Apollo Portal, the configuration changes are applied and become active in the specified namespace/cluster.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Configuration Tampering (Medium Severity) - Reduces the risk of accidental or malicious configuration changes by requiring explicit approval before changes are applied within Apollo.
    • Accidental Misconfiguration (Medium Severity) - Provides a review step to catch potential errors or unintended consequences of configuration changes before they are deployed through Apollo.
  • Impact:
    • Configuration Tampering: Medium - Reduces risk of tampering within Apollo by adding an approval layer.
    • Accidental Misconfiguration: Medium - Reduces risk of errors by introducing a review process within Apollo.
  • Currently Implemented: Not Implemented - Configuration changes are currently applied directly without any approval workflow within Apollo.
  • Missing Implementation:
    • Enabling the workflow feature in Apollo Portal.
    • Defining approval roles and assigning approvers within Apollo.
    • Configuring namespaces/clusters to require approvals in Apollo.
    • Establishing a clear process for configuration change requests and approvals within Apollo.

Mitigation Strategy: Enable Audit Logging and Monitoring of Configuration Changes in Apollo

Description:

  1. Enable Audit Logging in Apollo Config Service: Configure Apollo Config Service to enable detailed audit logging. This usually involves setting properties in the Config Service's configuration file (e.g., application.yml) to activate logging and specify log output destinations.
  2. Enable Audit Logging in Apollo Admin Service: Similarly, enable audit logging in Apollo Admin Service by configuring its logging settings.
  3. Enable Audit Logging in Apollo Portal: Configure audit logging for user actions and administrative events within the Apollo Portal. This might involve configuring the web server or application server hosting the Portal to capture relevant logs.
  4. Configure Apollo to Log Relevant Events: Ensure Apollo logging captures critical security-related events, including:
    • Configuration changes (creation, modification, deletion).
    • Access attempts (successful and failed logins to Portal/Admin Service).
    • Role and permission changes.
    • API key/token management events.
    • System errors and exceptions.
  5. Centralize Apollo Logs (Recommended): Configure Apollo services to send logs to a centralized logging system (e.g., Elasticsearch, Splunk, Graylog). This facilitates easier monitoring, analysis, and alerting.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Unauthorized Configuration Tampering (Medium Severity) - Audit logs provide a record to detect and investigate unauthorized or malicious configuration changes made through Apollo.
    • Security Incident Detection and Response (Medium Severity) - Logs enable monitoring for suspicious activities and provide forensic information for incident response related to Apollo.
    • Compliance Violations (Low to Medium Severity) - Audit logs can be used to demonstrate compliance with security and regulatory requirements related to configuration management.
  • Impact:
    • Unauthorized Configuration Tampering: Medium - Improves detection and investigation capabilities after a tampering event.
    • Security Incident Detection and Response: Medium - Enhances ability to detect and respond to security incidents related to Apollo.
    • Compliance Violations: Low to Medium - Helps meet compliance requirements related to audit trails.
  • Currently Implemented: Partially Implemented - Basic logging is enabled for Apollo services, but audit logging is not comprehensively configured to capture all relevant security events. Logs are not centralized.
  • Missing Implementation:
    • Enabling detailed audit logging in Apollo Config Service, Admin Service, and Portal.
    • Configuring Apollo to log all critical security-related events.
    • Centralizing Apollo logs into a dedicated logging system.
    • Setting up monitoring and alerting based on Apollo audit logs.

Mitigation Strategy: Configuration Versioning and Rollback Mechanisms in Apollo

Description:

  1. Utilize Apollo's Built-in Versioning: Apollo inherently versions configurations for namespaces. Ensure that this versioning feature is actively used and understood by users.
  2. Promote Configuration Releases in Apollo Portal: Encourage users to use Apollo Portal's "Release" functionality for configuration changes. Releases create explicit versions and snapshots of configurations.
  3. Establish Rollback Procedures using Apollo Portal: Define clear procedures for rolling back to previous configuration versions using Apollo Portal's rollback features. Document these procedures and train users.
  4. Regularly Review Configuration History in Apollo Portal: Periodically review the configuration history and versioning information within Apollo Portal to understand configuration evolution and identify potential anomalies.
  5. Test Rollback Procedures: Regularly test the configuration rollback procedures in non-production environments to ensure they are effective and users are familiar with them.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Accidental Misconfiguration (Medium Severity) - Enables quick rollback to previous working configurations in case of accidental errors introduced through Apollo.
    • Configuration Tampering (Medium Severity) - Provides a mechanism to revert to a known good state if configuration tampering is detected within Apollo.
    • Service Disruption due to Configuration Issues (Medium Severity) - Minimizes downtime by allowing rapid rollback to stable configurations in case of configuration-related service disruptions.
  • Impact:
    • Accidental Misconfiguration: Medium - Significantly reduces impact by enabling quick recovery.
    • Configuration Tampering: Medium - Provides a recovery mechanism after tampering is detected.
    • Service Disruption due to Configuration Issues: Medium - Reduces downtime by enabling rapid rollback.
  • Currently Implemented: Partially Implemented - Apollo's versioning feature is used implicitly, but explicit releases are not consistently performed. Rollback procedures are not formally defined or tested.
  • Missing Implementation:
    • Promoting and enforcing the use of Apollo's "Release" functionality for all configuration changes.
    • Documenting and communicating clear rollback procedures using Apollo Portal.
    • Regularly testing rollback procedures in non-production environments.
    • Training users on configuration versioning and rollback within Apollo.

Mitigation Strategy: Implement Rate Limiting and Throttling for Apollo Client Requests on Apollo Config Service

Description:

  1. Identify Rate Limiting Configuration Options in Apollo Config Service: Consult Apollo Config Service documentation to find configuration parameters related to rate limiting and throttling client requests. These might be properties in application.yml or similar configuration files.
  2. Define Rate Limit Thresholds: Determine appropriate rate limit thresholds for client requests to Apollo Config Service. Consider factors like expected client load, service capacity, and acceptable latency. Start with conservative limits and adjust based on monitoring.
  3. Configure Rate Limiting in Apollo Config Service: Set the rate limiting configuration parameters in Apollo Config Service's configuration file. This might involve specifying limits on requests per second, minute, or hour, and defining throttling mechanisms.
  4. Test Rate Limiting Configuration: Thoroughly test the rate limiting configuration in a staging or testing environment. Simulate high client request loads to verify that rate limiting is effective and does not negatively impact legitimate client traffic under normal conditions.
  5. Monitor Rate Limiting Effectiveness: Monitor Apollo Config Service metrics related to rate limiting (e.g., rejected requests, throttling events). Adjust rate limit thresholds as needed based on monitoring data and observed traffic patterns.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Denial of Service (DoS) Attacks against Apollo Config Service (Medium Severity) - Protects Apollo Config Service from being overwhelmed by excessive client requests, whether intentional (DoS attack) or unintentional (e.g., misbehaving client application).
    • Resource Exhaustion on Apollo Config Service (Medium Severity) - Prevents resource exhaustion (CPU, memory, network) on Apollo Config Service caused by excessive client traffic, ensuring service availability and stability.
  • Impact:
    • Denial of Service (DoS) Attacks against Apollo Config Service: Medium - Reduces the impact of DoS attacks by limiting the rate of incoming requests.
    • Resource Exhaustion on Apollo Config Service: Medium - Prevents resource exhaustion and maintains service stability under high load.
  • Currently Implemented: Not Implemented - Rate limiting and throttling are not currently configured on Apollo Config Service.
  • Missing Implementation:
    • Identifying and configuring rate limiting parameters in Apollo Config Service.
    • Defining appropriate rate limit thresholds for client requests.
    • Testing and monitoring rate limiting effectiveness.

Mitigation Strategy: Regularly Update Apollo Components

Description:

  1. Establish Apollo Update Monitoring: Subscribe to Apollo project release announcements (e.g., GitHub releases, mailing lists) to stay informed about new versions and security advisories.
  2. Regularly Check for Apollo Updates: Periodically check the Apollo project website or GitHub repository for new releases of Apollo Config Service, Admin Service, Portal, and client libraries.
  3. Review Release Notes and Security Advisories: Carefully review release notes for each new Apollo version to understand new features, bug fixes, and especially security fixes. Pay close attention to security advisories associated with Apollo releases.
  4. Plan and Schedule Apollo Updates: Plan regular update cycles for Apollo components. Prioritize updates that address known security vulnerabilities. Schedule update windows to minimize disruption to applications.
  5. Test Updates in Non-Production Environments: Before applying updates to production Apollo environments, thoroughly test the updates in staging or testing environments to ensure compatibility and identify any potential issues.
  6. Apply Updates to Production Apollo Environment: After successful testing, apply the updates to the production Apollo Config Service, Admin Service, and Portal components according to your planned schedule and procedures.
  7. Update Apollo Client Libraries: Ensure that Apollo client libraries used by applications are also updated to compatible and secure versions to benefit from bug fixes and security improvements in the client libraries.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Vulnerabilities in Apollo Components and Dependencies (High Severity) - Addresses known security vulnerabilities in Apollo Config Service, Admin Service, Portal, and client libraries by applying security patches and updates.
    • Exploitation of Known Vulnerabilities (High Severity) - Reduces the risk of attackers exploiting publicly known vulnerabilities in outdated Apollo components.
  • Impact:
    • Vulnerabilities in Apollo Components and Dependencies: High - Significantly reduces risk by patching known vulnerabilities.
    • Exploitation of Known Vulnerabilities: High - Prevents exploitation of known weaknesses in Apollo.
  • Currently Implemented: Not Implemented - Apollo components are not regularly updated. The current Apollo version is likely outdated and potentially vulnerable.
  • Missing Implementation:
    • Establishing a process for monitoring Apollo releases and security advisories.
    • Regularly checking for and reviewing Apollo updates.
    • Planning and scheduling Apollo component updates.
    • Testing updates in non-production environments before production deployment.
    • Updating Apollo Config Service, Admin Service, Portal, and client libraries to the latest secure versions.

Mitigation Strategy: Enable Comprehensive Audit Logging within Apollo Services

Description:

  1. Configure Detailed Audit Logging in Apollo Config Service: Modify Apollo Config Service's logging configuration (e.g., application.yml) to enable verbose audit logging. Ensure logging captures detailed information about configuration access, modifications, and API requests.
  2. Configure Detailed Audit Logging in Apollo Admin Service: Similarly, configure Apollo Admin Service for comprehensive audit logging, capturing administrative actions, user management events, and security-related activities.
  3. Configure Detailed Audit Logging in Apollo Portal: Enable audit logging within the Apollo Portal application or the web server hosting it to track user logins, actions within the Portal UI, and administrative operations performed through the Portal.
  4. Log Security-Relevant Events in Apollo: Ensure Apollo audit logs capture a wide range of security-relevant events, including:
    • All configuration changes (create, update, delete, release, rollback).
    • User authentication attempts (successful and failed logins to Portal/Admin Service).
    • Authorization decisions (access granted or denied).
    • Role and permission modifications.
    • API key/token creation, modification, and deletion.
    • System errors, exceptions, and security-related warnings.
  5. Include Contextual Information in Apollo Logs: Configure Apollo logging to include sufficient contextual information in audit logs to facilitate investigation and analysis. This might include timestamps, user IDs, IP addresses, namespaces, clusters, and details of the changes made.
  • Threats Mitigated:
    • Unauthorized Configuration Tampering (Medium Severity) - Detailed audit logs provide a comprehensive record to detect, investigate, and respond to unauthorized or malicious configuration changes made through Apollo.
    • Security Incident Detection and Response (Medium Severity) - Comprehensive logs enable more effective monitoring for suspicious activities, faster incident detection, and improved forensic analysis during security incidents related to Apollo.
    • Compliance Violations (Low to Medium Severity) - Detailed audit logs are crucial for demonstrating compliance with security and regulatory requirements that mandate audit trails for configuration management systems.
  • Impact:
    • Unauthorized Configuration Tampering: Medium - Significantly improves detection and investigation capabilities for tampering events.
    • Security Incident Detection and Response: Medium - Enhances incident detection and response effectiveness due to richer log data.
    • Compliance Violations: Low to Medium - Strengthens compliance posture by providing detailed audit trails.
  • Currently Implemented: Partially Implemented - Basic logging is enabled, but audit logging is not configured to capture comprehensive security-relevant events with sufficient detail across all Apollo services.
  • Missing Implementation:
    • Configuring detailed audit logging in Apollo Config Service, Admin Service, and Portal to capture comprehensive security events.
    • Defining and configuring the specific security-relevant events to be logged in detail.
    • Ensuring audit logs include sufficient contextual information for effective analysis and investigation.