Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
24 lines (18 loc) · 3.38 KB

threat-modeling.md

File metadata and controls

24 lines (18 loc) · 3.38 KB

Threat Model Analysis for jakewharton/butterknife

Threat: Critical Vulnerability in Butter Knife's Code Generator (Hypothetical)

  • Description: A hypothetical, severe bug exists in Butter Knife's annotation processor (the code that generates the *_ViewBinding classes). This bug introduces a critical vulnerability into the generated code. For example, the generated code might have a buffer overflow vulnerability, a format string vulnerability, or a code injection vulnerability due to improper handling of user input or data related to view binding. This is extremely unlikely, but we're considering a hypothetical worst-case scenario.
    • Impact:
      • Could allow for arbitrary code execution within the application, potentially leading to complete device compromise. This is the defining characteristic of a "Critical" vulnerability. The exact impact depends on the specific nature of the hypothetical bug.
    • Affected Butter Knife Component:
      • The Butter Knife annotation processor itself (part of the Butter Knife library, not the application code).
      • All generated *_ViewBinding classes.
    • Risk Severity: Critical (Hypothetical, before mitigation). This is based on the assumption of a severe vulnerability in the code generator.
    • Mitigation Strategies:
      • Keep Butter Knife Updated: This is the most important mitigation. If such a vulnerability were discovered, it would almost certainly be patched in a new release.
      • Security Audits (of Butter Knife): Regular security audits of the Butter Knife library itself (by the maintainers or security researchers) are crucial for identifying such vulnerabilities.
      • General Android Security Best Practices: Follow secure coding practices in your application code. This provides defense-in-depth. For example, even if the generated code has a buffer overflow, proper input validation and memory management in your application code might prevent it from being exploited.
      • Switch to ViewBinding: Consider using Android's official View Binding, which is a built-in feature and does not rely on a third-party library.

Why this is "Hypothetical" and Doesn't Perfectly Fit:

  1. No Known Critical Vulnerability: There is currently no known critical vulnerability in Butter Knife's code generator. This threat is purely hypothetical to illustrate a worst-case scenario.
  2. R8/ProGuard Mitigation: Even if such a vulnerability existed, enabling R8/ProGuard would likely mitigate many of the exploitation vectors, reducing the severity. The threat description assumes a vulnerability that is exploitable even after R8/ProGuard optimization, which is even less likely.

In summary: There are no currently known direct threats to Butter Knife that are both directly related to the library's functionality and have a High or Critical severity rating before mitigation, especially when R8/ProGuard is used as recommended. The hypothetical threat above is included to illustrate what a worst-case scenario could look like, but it's important to emphasize its hypothetical nature. The practical risks associated with Butter Knife are generally low to medium, and are primarily related to reflection (mitigated by R8/ProGuard) and dependency management.