Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
196 lines (156 loc) · 20 KB

attack-tree.md

File metadata and controls

196 lines (156 loc) · 20 KB

Attack Tree Analysis for jodaorg/joda-time

Objective: Compromise Application via Joda-Time Vulnerabilities

Attack Tree Visualization

Compromise Application via Joda-Time Vulnerabilities [CRITICAL NODE] ├───[OR]─ Exploit Input Handling Vulnerabilities [HIGH-RISK PATH] [CRITICAL NODE] │ ├───[OR]─ Malicious Date/Time String Parsing [HIGH-RISK PATH] [CRITICAL NODE] │ │ ├───[AND]─ Identify Input Points Parsing Dates (e.g., API endpoints, user input fields) [CRITICAL NODE] │ │ └───[AND]─ Craft Malicious Date/Time String [CRITICAL NODE] │ │ ├───[OR]─ Trigger Unexpected Behavior [CRITICAL NODE] │ ├───[OR]─ Time Zone Manipulation [HIGH-RISK PATH] [CRITICAL NODE] │ │ ├───[AND]─ Identify Input Points Handling Time Zones (e.g., user preferences, API parameters) [CRITICAL NODE] │ │ └───[AND]─ Manipulate Time Zone Data [CRITICAL NODE] │ │ ├───[OR]─ Exploit Time Zone Data Discrepancies/Ambiguities [CRITICAL NODE] ├───[OR]─ Exploit Logic/Calculation Vulnerabilities [HIGH-RISK PATH] │ ├───[OR]─ Incorrect Handling of Date/Time Boundaries and Edge Cases [HIGH-RISK PATH] [CRITICAL NODE] │ │ ├───[AND]─ Identify Boundary-Sensitive Logic (e.g., start/end of day, month, year) [CRITICAL NODE] │ │ └───[AND]─ Exploit Boundary Conditions [CRITICAL NODE] │ │ ├───[OR]─ Off-by-One Errors in Date/Time Comparisons [CRITICAL NODE] └───[OR]─ Information Disclosure via Error Messages/Logging [HIGH-RISK PATH] [CRITICAL NODE] └───[OR]─ Verbose Error Messages Exposing Internal Date/Time Details [HIGH-RISK PATH] [CRITICAL NODE] └───[AND]─ Trigger Date/Time Related Errors [CRITICAL NODE] └───[AND]─ Analyze Error Messages/Logs [CRITICAL NODE]

Attack Tree Path: 1. Compromise Application via Joda-Time Vulnerabilities [CRITICAL NODE]

  • Attack Vector: This is the root goal. It represents the overall objective of exploiting weaknesses related to Joda-Time to compromise the application.
  • Exploitation: Attackers aim to leverage vulnerabilities stemming from how the application uses Joda-Time, not necessarily direct flaws in Joda-Time itself (though dependency vulnerabilities are considered).
  • Potential Impact: Full application compromise, data breach, denial of service, business logic disruption.
  • Mitigation: Implement all mitigations outlined in the sub-nodes, focusing on input validation, secure coding, thorough testing, and dependency management.

Attack Tree Path: 2. Exploit Input Handling Vulnerabilities [HIGH-RISK PATH] [CRITICAL NODE]

  • Attack Vector: Exploiting weaknesses in how the application handles date/time inputs, specifically when parsing date/time strings and processing time zones using Joda-Time.
  • Exploitation: Attackers target input points that process date/time data (e.g., API parameters, form fields). They attempt to inject malicious or unexpected date/time strings or manipulate time zone information to cause errors or unexpected behavior.
  • Potential Impact: Application errors, denial of service (DoS), logic errors leading to incorrect data processing or business logic bypasses, information disclosure.
  • Mitigation:
    • Strict Input Validation: Validate all date/time inputs against expected formats and ranges.
    • Use Joda-Time Parsing with Error Handling: Utilize Joda-Time's parsing capabilities but implement robust error handling to catch invalid inputs gracefully.
    • Sanitize and Normalize Inputs: Cleanse and standardize date/time inputs before processing.
    • Validate Time Zone IDs: Verify time zone IDs against a known and valid list.

Attack Tree Path: 3. Malicious Date/Time String Parsing [HIGH-RISK PATH] [CRITICAL NODE]

  • Attack Vector: Injecting specially crafted date/time strings designed to exploit parsing logic within Joda-Time or the application's use of Joda-Time parsing.
  • Exploitation: Attackers identify input points where the application parses date/time strings using Joda-Time. They then craft malicious strings that could:
    • Cause Parsing Errors/Exceptions: Leading to application crashes or instability (DoS).
    • Trigger Unexpected Behavior: Resulting in logic errors, incorrect data processing, or access control bypasses due to misinterpreted dates.
  • Potential Impact: Application crashes, denial of service, logic errors, business logic bypasses, data corruption.
  • Mitigation:
    • Robust Error Handling: Implement comprehensive error handling for date/time parsing operations.
    • Input Validation: Validate date/time strings against strict formats and ranges before parsing.
    • Thorough Testing: Test date/time parsing logic with a wide variety of valid and invalid inputs, including edge cases and different locales.

Attack Tree Path: 4. Identify Input Points Parsing Dates (e.g., API endpoints, user input fields) [CRITICAL NODE]

  • Attack Vector: Reconnaissance step where attackers identify where the application accepts and processes date/time strings.
  • Exploitation: Attackers analyze the application's functionality, API documentation, and user interfaces to pinpoint input fields or API parameters that are likely to be parsed as dates using Joda-Time.
  • Potential Impact: Enables subsequent attacks like malicious date/time string parsing and time zone manipulation.
  • Mitigation:
    • Minimize Exposed Input Points: Reduce the number of input points that directly handle date/time strings if possible.
    • Secure Code Review: Review code to identify all date/time input points and ensure proper validation and handling.

Attack Tree Path: 5. Craft Malicious Date/Time String [CRITICAL NODE]

  • Attack Vector: The act of creating specific date/time strings designed to exploit parsing vulnerabilities or trigger unexpected behavior in Joda-Time or the application.
  • Exploitation: Attackers use knowledge of date/time formats, edge cases, and potential parsing ambiguities to create strings that can cause errors or logic flaws when processed by Joda-Time.
  • Potential Impact: Parsing errors, application crashes, logic errors, business logic bypasses, data corruption.
  • Mitigation:
    • Input Validation: Effective input validation is crucial to prevent malicious strings from being processed.
    • Secure Parsing Practices: Use Joda-Time parsing methods securely and with proper error handling.

Attack Tree Path: 6. Trigger Unexpected Behavior (via Malicious Date/Time String) [CRITICAL NODE]

  • Attack Vector: Successfully crafting a malicious date/time string that, when parsed, leads to unintended consequences in the application's logic.
  • Exploitation: Attackers aim to manipulate application logic by providing date/time strings that are parsed without error but are misinterpreted by the application, leading to incorrect decisions or actions. This could involve bypassing access controls, manipulating data, or causing incorrect workflows.
  • Potential Impact: Business logic bypasses, data corruption, incorrect application behavior, unauthorized access.
  • Mitigation:
    • Thorough Testing of Logic: Rigorously test all application logic that relies on parsed date/time values with a wide range of inputs, including potentially ambiguous or edge-case dates.
    • Secure Logic Design: Design application logic to be resilient to unexpected date/time values and handle potential ambiguities gracefully.

Attack Tree Path: 7. Time Zone Manipulation [HIGH-RISK PATH] [CRITICAL NODE]

  • Attack Vector: Exploiting vulnerabilities related to how the application handles time zones using Joda-Time. This includes injecting invalid time zone IDs or exploiting discrepancies and ambiguities in time zone data.
  • Exploitation: Attackers target input points that handle time zone information (e.g., user preferences, API parameters). They attempt to manipulate time zone data to cause errors or logic flaws.
  • Potential Impact: Application errors, logic errors, business logic bypasses (e.g., scheduling issues, access control based on time), data corruption due to incorrect time zone conversions.
  • Mitigation:
    • Validate Time Zone IDs: Strictly validate time zone IDs against a known and valid list.
    • Consistent Time Zone Handling: Implement consistent time zone handling practices throughout the application.
    • Thorough Testing of Time Zone Logic: Test all time zone related functionality with different time zones, including edge cases and daylight saving time transitions.
    • Up-to-date Time Zone Database: Ensure the application uses an up-to-date and trusted time zone database (e.g., tzdata).

Attack Tree Path: 8. Identify Input Points Handling Time Zones (e.g., user preferences, API parameters) [CRITICAL NODE]

  • Attack Vector: Reconnaissance step to identify where the application handles time zone information.
  • Exploitation: Attackers analyze the application to find input points where time zones are accepted or processed, such as user profile settings, API parameters for scheduling or time-sensitive operations, etc.
  • Potential Impact: Enables subsequent time zone manipulation attacks.
  • Mitigation:
    • Minimize Exposed Time Zone Inputs: Reduce the number of input points that directly handle time zone information if possible.
    • Secure Code Review: Review code to identify all time zone input points and ensure proper validation and handling.

Attack Tree Path: 9. Manipulate Time Zone Data [CRITICAL NODE]

  • Attack Vector: The act of altering or injecting malicious time zone data to exploit vulnerabilities.
  • Exploitation: Attackers attempt to inject invalid time zone IDs or manipulate valid IDs in ways that cause errors or logic flaws in the application's time zone handling.
  • Potential Impact: Application errors, logic errors, business logic bypasses, data corruption.
  • Mitigation:
    • Input Validation: Validate time zone IDs against a known list.
    • Secure Time Zone Handling Practices: Follow secure coding practices for time zone conversions and calculations.

Attack Tree Path: 10. Exploit Time Zone Data Discrepancies/Ambiguities [CRITICAL NODE]

  • Attack Vector: Exploiting subtle discrepancies or ambiguities in time zone data to cause logic errors. This can involve issues with daylight saving time transitions, historical time zone changes, or edge cases in time zone definitions.
  • Exploitation: Attackers leverage their understanding of time zone nuances to craft inputs or scenarios that expose weaknesses in the application's time zone handling logic. This could lead to incorrect scheduling, access control bypasses based on time, or data corruption due to incorrect conversions.
  • Potential Impact: Logic errors, business logic bypasses, data corruption, incorrect application behavior.
  • Mitigation:
    • Thorough Understanding of Time Zones: Developers need a deep understanding of time zone concepts, including daylight saving time and historical changes.
    • Rigorous Testing: Extensive testing of time zone logic, especially around DST transitions and edge cases.
    • Consistent Time Zone Handling: Maintain consistency in time zone handling throughout the application.

Attack Tree Path: 11. Incorrect Handling of Date/Time Boundaries and Edge Cases [HIGH-RISK PATH] [CRITICAL NODE]

  • Attack Vector: Exploiting logic errors arising from incorrect handling of date/time boundaries (start/end of day, month, year) and edge cases (like leap years).
  • Exploitation: Attackers target application logic that involves date/time comparisons, calculations, or scheduling around boundaries and edge cases. They attempt to trigger off-by-one errors or incorrect logic due to mishandling of these boundaries.
  • Potential Impact: Logic errors, business logic bypasses, data corruption, incorrect application behavior, unauthorized access.
  • Mitigation:
    • Precise Date/Time Comparisons: Use Joda-Time's precise comparison methods to avoid off-by-one errors.
    • Thorough Testing of Boundary Conditions: Specifically test date/time logic around boundaries (start/end of day, month, year, leap years).
    • Secure Logic Design: Design application logic to correctly handle date/time boundaries and edge cases.

Attack Tree Path: 12. Identify Boundary-Sensitive Logic (e.g., start/end of day, month, year) [CRITICAL NODE]

  • Attack Vector: Reconnaissance step to identify application logic that is sensitive to date/time boundaries.
  • Exploitation: Attackers analyze the application's code and functionality to pinpoint areas where logic depends on specific date/time boundaries (e.g., daily reports, monthly billing cycles, yearly subscriptions).
  • Potential Impact: Enables subsequent attacks exploiting boundary conditions.
  • Mitigation:
    • Secure Code Review: Review code to identify boundary-sensitive logic and ensure it is implemented correctly and securely.

Attack Tree Path: 13. Exploit Boundary Conditions [CRITICAL NODE]

  • Attack Vector: Actively triggering logic errors by manipulating date/time inputs to fall precisely on or around date/time boundaries.
  • Exploitation: Attackers craft inputs that exploit weaknesses in boundary-sensitive logic, such as off-by-one errors in comparisons or incorrect handling of start/end dates.
  • Potential Impact: Logic errors, business logic bypasses, data corruption, incorrect application behavior.
  • Mitigation:
    • Thorough Testing: Specifically test boundary conditions with inputs designed to fall exactly on boundaries and just before/after boundaries.
    • Secure Logic Implementation: Implement boundary-sensitive logic carefully and correctly, using precise date/time methods.

Attack Tree Path: 14. Off-by-One Errors in Date/Time Comparisons [CRITICAL NODE]

  • Attack Vector: Exploiting common programming errors where date/time comparisons are implemented incorrectly, often leading to off-by-one day or time discrepancies.
  • Exploitation: Attackers leverage off-by-one errors in date/time comparisons to bypass access controls, manipulate scheduling logic, or cause incorrect data processing. For example, if a system incorrectly checks if a date is "before or equal to" instead of "before," an attacker might gain access to resources they shouldn't.
  • Potential Impact: Logic errors, business logic bypasses, unauthorized access, data corruption.
  • Mitigation:
    • Use Precise Comparison Methods: Utilize Joda-Time's precise date/time comparison methods (e.g., isBefore, isAfter, isEqual) correctly.
    • Code Review: Carefully review date/time comparison logic for potential off-by-one errors.
    • Thorough Testing: Test comparison logic extensively, especially around boundary conditions.

Attack Tree Path: 15. Information Disclosure via Error Messages/Logging [HIGH-RISK PATH] [CRITICAL NODE]

  • Attack Vector: Exploiting verbose error messages or overly detailed logging that reveals sensitive information about the application's internal workings, date/time handling logic, or configurations.
  • Exploitation: Attackers trigger date/time related errors (e.g., by providing invalid inputs) and then analyze the resulting error messages or logs to gather information.
  • Potential Impact: Information disclosure of internal paths, configurations, logic details, potentially aiding further attacks.
  • Mitigation:
    • Secure Error Handling: Implement secure error handling that avoids exposing sensitive internal details in error messages.
    • Secure Logging Practices: Log errors in a structured and secure manner, ideally to a separate logging system. Sanitize logs and avoid verbose logging in production environments.
    • Regular Log Review: Periodically review logs for sensitive information leaks and adjust logging configurations as needed.

Attack Tree Path: 16. Verbose Error Messages Exposing Internal Date/Time Details [HIGH-RISK PATH] [CRITICAL NODE]

  • Attack Vector: Specific type of information disclosure where error messages related to date/time operations are overly verbose and reveal internal details.
  • Exploitation: Attackers intentionally trigger date/time errors to observe the error messages and extract sensitive information.
  • Potential Impact: Information disclosure, aiding further attacks.
  • Mitigation:
    • Sanitize Error Messages: Ensure error messages displayed to users or logged do not contain sensitive internal details.
    • Implement Generic Error Responses: Provide generic error responses to users while logging detailed errors securely for debugging purposes.

Attack Tree Path: 17. Trigger Date/Time Related Errors (for Information Disclosure) [CRITICAL NODE]

  • Attack Vector: Intentionally causing date/time related errors to generate error messages or log entries that can be analyzed for information disclosure.
  • Exploitation: Attackers provide invalid date/time inputs, manipulate time zones, or trigger other date/time related issues to force the application to generate error messages.
  • Potential Impact: Information disclosure.
  • Mitigation:
    • Input Validation: Effective input validation reduces the likelihood of triggering errors with invalid inputs.
    • Secure Error Handling: Secure error handling prevents sensitive information from being exposed even when errors occur.

Attack Tree Path: 18. Analyze Error Messages/Logs (for Information Disclosure) [CRITICAL NODE]

  • Attack Vector: The act of examining error messages and logs to extract sensitive information disclosed due to verbose error handling or logging practices.
  • Exploitation: Attackers analyze error messages and logs generated by date/time related errors to find information about the application's internal workings, configurations, or potential vulnerabilities.
  • Potential Impact: Information disclosure, aiding further attacks.
  • Mitigation:
    • Secure Logging Practices: Implement secure logging practices to prevent sensitive information from being logged in the first place.
    • Log Monitoring and Anomaly Detection: Monitor logs for suspicious activity and potential information leaks.