Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
166 lines (137 loc) · 15.1 KB

sec-design-deep-analysis.md

File metadata and controls

166 lines (137 loc) · 15.1 KB

Okay, let's perform a deep security analysis of MyBatis 3 based on the provided design review.

1. Objective, Scope, and Methodology

  • Objective: To conduct a thorough security analysis of the key components of MyBatis 3, identifying potential vulnerabilities, assessing their impact, and providing actionable mitigation strategies. The analysis will focus on how MyBatis's design and implementation choices impact the security of applications that use it. We will pay particular attention to SQL injection, data leakage, and configuration-based vulnerabilities.

  • Scope: This analysis covers MyBatis 3's core components, including:

    • Configuration (XML and Java-based)
    • SQL Session Factory and SQL Session
    • Executor
    • Statement Handler
    • Parameter Handler
    • Result Set Handler
    • Dynamic SQL handling
    • Caching mechanisms
    • Interaction with external systems (Database, Caching Provider)
    • Build process and dependency management

    The analysis excludes the security of the underlying database system, application-specific authentication/authorization logic, and network-level security. It also assumes a containerized (Docker/Kubernetes) deployment, as described in the design review.

  • Methodology:

    1. Architecture and Data Flow Review: Analyze the provided C4 diagrams and component descriptions to understand the data flow and interactions between components.
    2. Codebase Inference: Based on the design review and common MyBatis usage patterns (and referencing the GitHub repository if needed), infer the likely implementation details and potential security implications.
    3. Threat Identification: Identify potential threats based on the architecture, data flow, and known vulnerabilities associated with persistence frameworks.
    4. Vulnerability Analysis: Analyze each identified threat, considering the likelihood of exploitation and potential impact.
    5. Mitigation Strategy Recommendation: Propose specific, actionable mitigation strategies tailored to MyBatis 3 and the containerized deployment environment.

2. Security Implications of Key Components

Let's break down the security implications of each key component, focusing on potential threats and vulnerabilities:

  • Configuration (XML and Java-based):

    • Threats:
      • XML External Entity (XXE) Injection: If the XML parser is misconfigured, an attacker could inject external entities, potentially leading to file disclosure, server-side request forgery (SSRF), or denial of service.
      • Insecure Configuration: Misconfiguration of settings (e.g., enabling dangerous features, disabling security controls) could expose the application to various attacks.
      • Hardcoded Credentials: Storing database credentials directly in the configuration file is a major security risk.
    • Analysis: MyBatis uses a schema to validate XML configurations, which helps prevent some misconfigurations. However, the underlying XML parser's configuration is crucial. Java-based configuration offers more type safety and reduces the risk of XML-related vulnerabilities.
    • Mitigation:
      • Disable External Entities: Ensure the XML parser used by MyBatis is configured to disallow the resolution of external entities. This is a critical mitigation for XXE. Check the underlying XML parser's documentation (likely Xerces or a similar library) for specific configuration options.
      • Use Environment Variables/Secrets Management: Never store credentials directly in configuration files. Use environment variables (in the Docker container) or a dedicated secrets management solution (e.g., Kubernetes Secrets, HashiCorp Vault) to inject credentials at runtime.
      • Validate Configuration: Implement programmatic checks to validate configuration settings beyond the XML schema validation. For example, check for overly permissive settings or insecure defaults.
      • Prefer Java Configuration: Where possible, favor Java-based configuration over XML to leverage type safety and reduce XML parsing risks.

  • SQL Session Factory and SQL Session:

    • Threats: While these components themselves don't directly handle SQL, they manage the lifecycle of database connections. Leaking sessions or failing to close them properly could lead to resource exhaustion and potentially denial of service.
    • Analysis: These components are primarily responsible for managing resources. The main security concern is proper resource management.
    • Mitigation:
      • Use try-with-resources: Always use the try-with-resources statement (or equivalent) when working with SqlSession objects to ensure they are closed properly, even in the event of exceptions. This is a standard Java best practice, but critical for security.
      • Connection Pooling: Use a robust connection pool (like HikariCP, often integrated via Spring) to manage database connections efficiently and prevent resource exhaustion. Configure the pool with appropriate timeouts and maximum connection limits.
      • Monitor Session Usage: Monitor the number of active SqlSession instances and database connections to detect potential leaks or resource exhaustion issues.

  • Executor:

    • Threats: The Executor is responsible for executing SQL statements. While it doesn't directly handle parameterization, its interaction with the StatementHandler is crucial for security.
    • Analysis: The Executor's security relies heavily on the correct implementation of the StatementHandler and ParameterHandler.
    • Mitigation: Focus mitigation efforts on the StatementHandler and ParameterHandler.

  • Statement Handler:

    • Threats:
      • SQL Injection: This is the primary threat. If the StatementHandler doesn't properly use prepared statements and parameter binding, attackers could inject malicious SQL code.
    • Analysis: MyBatis's core defense against SQL injection is its use of prepared statements and parameterized queries. The StatementHandler is responsible for creating these prepared statements. The #{} syntax in MyBatis mapper XML files should trigger the use of prepared statements.
    • Mitigation:
      • Always Use Parameterized Queries: Strictly enforce the use of #{} placeholders for all user-supplied data in mapper XML files. Never use string concatenation or interpolation (e.g., ${}) with untrusted input. ${} is for dynamic SQL parts (table/column names), not values.
      • Code Review: Conduct thorough code reviews of all mapper XML files and Java code that interacts with MyBatis, specifically looking for any instances where parameterized queries are not used correctly.
      • SAST Integration: Integrate a SAST tool that is specifically aware of MyBatis and can detect potential SQL injection vulnerabilities related to its usage. This is a high-priority recommendation.

  • Parameter Handler:

    • Threats:
      • SQL Injection (Bypass): Even with prepared statements, vulnerabilities could exist if the ParameterHandler doesn't properly handle type conversions or escaping.
      • Second-Order SQL Injection: If data is retrieved from the database, stored, and then later used in another query without proper sanitization, second-order SQL injection could occur.
    • Analysis: The ParameterHandler is responsible for setting the parameters on the prepared statement. It must handle different data types correctly and ensure that special characters are properly escaped.
    • Mitigation:
      • Type-Safe Parameters: Use appropriate Java types for parameters to ensure correct type handling by the ParameterHandler.
      • Input Validation (Application Level): Always validate user input at the application level before passing it to MyBatis. This provides a defense-in-depth approach, even if MyBatis's parameter handling has flaws. This is critical.
      • Output Encoding: When displaying data retrieved from the database, ensure proper output encoding to prevent cross-site scripting (XSS) vulnerabilities. This is not directly related to MyBatis, but important for overall application security.
      • Avoid Storing Unsanitized Data: If data retrieved from the database needs to be stored and reused later, ensure it is properly sanitized before being stored to prevent second-order SQL injection.

  • Result Set Handler:

    • Threats: Generally low risk. The main concern would be vulnerabilities in the mapping logic that could lead to unexpected behavior or data leakage, but this is less likely than SQL injection.
    • Analysis: This component maps database results to Java objects.
    • Mitigation: Focus mitigation efforts on other components.

  • Dynamic SQL Handling:

    • Threats:
      • SQL Injection: Dynamic SQL (using <if>, <choose>, <where>, <set>, <foreach> tags) is a major source of potential SQL injection vulnerabilities if used incorrectly.
    • Analysis: MyBatis provides these tags for building dynamic SQL queries. While they offer flexibility, they can be easily misused, leading to injection vulnerabilities. The ${} syntax, often used within dynamic SQL, is particularly dangerous if used with untrusted input.
    • Mitigation:
      • Minimize Dynamic SQL: Use dynamic SQL only when absolutely necessary. Prefer static SQL whenever possible.
      • Use #{} within Dynamic SQL: Even within dynamic SQL tags, always use #{} for user-supplied values. Never use ${} with untrusted input.
      • Careful Use of <foreach>: Be extremely cautious when using the <foreach> tag, as it can be a common source of injection vulnerabilities. Ensure proper escaping and validation of the collection being iterated.
      • Code Review and SAST: Thorough code reviews and SAST analysis are essential for identifying potential vulnerabilities in dynamic SQL usage.

  • Caching Mechanisms:

    • Threats:
      • Cache Poisoning: If the caching mechanism is not properly secured, an attacker could inject malicious data into the cache, which would then be served to other users.
      • Data Leakage: If sensitive data is cached without proper access controls, it could be exposed to unauthorized users.
      • Denial of Service: An attacker could flood the cache with excessive data, leading to denial of service.
    • Analysis: MyBatis supports various caching providers (Ehcache, Redis, etc.). The security of the cache depends on the chosen provider and its configuration.
    • Mitigation:
      • Secure Cache Configuration: Configure the caching provider securely, following its documentation and best practices. This includes setting appropriate access controls, timeouts, and eviction policies.
      • Encrypt Cached Data: If sensitive data is cached, encrypt it to protect it from unauthorized access.
      • Input Validation: Validate data before it is cached to prevent cache poisoning.
      • Monitor Cache Usage: Monitor cache usage to detect potential attacks or performance issues.
      • Limit Cached Data: Avoid caching large amounts of data or data that changes frequently.

  • Interaction with External Systems (Database, Caching Provider):

    • Threats: Vulnerabilities in the database or caching provider could impact the security of the application.
    • Analysis: MyBatis relies on the security of these external systems.
    • Mitigation:
      • Secure Database Configuration: Configure the database system securely, following its documentation and best practices. This includes setting strong passwords, disabling unnecessary features, and applying security patches.
      • Secure Caching Provider Configuration: Configure the caching provider securely, as described above.
      • Network Security: Use network security measures (e.g., firewalls, network segmentation) to protect the database and caching provider from unauthorized access.

  • Build Process and Dependency Management:

    • Threats: Vulnerabilities in third-party dependencies could be exploited.
    • Analysis: MyBatis uses Maven and OWASP Dependency-Check.
    • Mitigation:
      • Regular Dependency Updates: Keep dependencies up-to-date to address known vulnerabilities.
      • SCA Tooling: Use Software Composition Analysis (SCA) tools like OWASP Dependency-Check to identify and track vulnerabilities in dependencies. Automate this as part of the CI/CD pipeline.
      • Review Dependency-Check Reports: Carefully review the reports generated by OWASP Dependency-Check and address any identified vulnerabilities promptly.

3. Summary of Key Mitigation Strategies (Actionable Items)

This summarizes the most critical and actionable mitigation strategies:

  1. SQL Injection Prevention:

    • Strictly enforce parameterized queries (#{}) for all user-supplied data. This is the most important mitigation.
    • Never use string concatenation or ${} with untrusted input.
    • Thorough code reviews of mapper XML and Java code.
    • Integrate a MyBatis-aware SAST tool.
    • Application-level input validation before passing data to MyBatis.

  2. Secure Configuration:

    • Disable XML external entities (XXE) in the XML parser.
    • Use environment variables or secrets management for credentials. Never hardcode credentials.
    • Prefer Java-based configuration over XML.
    • Programmatically validate configuration settings.

  3. Resource Management:

    • Always use try-with-resources for SqlSession objects.
    • Use a robust connection pool (e.g., HikariCP).
    • Monitor session and connection usage.

  4. Dynamic SQL Safety:

    • Minimize dynamic SQL usage.
    • Always use #{} for values within dynamic SQL.
    • Be extremely cautious with <foreach>.
    • Code reviews and SAST are crucial.

  5. Secure Caching:

    • Securely configure the caching provider.
    • Encrypt sensitive cached data.
    • Validate data before caching.

  6. Secure External Systems:

    • Securely configure the database and caching provider.
    • Use network security measures.

  7. Dependency Management:

    • Regularly update dependencies.
    • Use SCA tools (OWASP Dependency-Check) and review reports.

  8. Security Hardening Guide: Create and maintain a comprehensive security hardening guide for developers using MyBatis, covering all the above points.

  9. Regular Security Audits: Perform periodic security audits and penetration testing.

By implementing these mitigation strategies, the security posture of applications using MyBatis 3 can be significantly improved. The most critical areas to focus on are preventing SQL injection, securing the configuration, and managing dependencies.