Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
72 lines (63 loc) · 10.6 KB

attack-surface.md

File metadata and controls

72 lines (63 loc) · 10.6 KB

Attack Surface Analysis for nextcloud/android

Attack Surface: Permissions Misconfiguration and Abuse

  • Description: The application requests or uses Android permissions in a way that is excessive, insecure, or leads to unintended access to device resources.
  • Android Contribution: Android's permission system is the core mechanism for controlling access to sensitive device features and data. Misconfigurations here directly undermine Android's security model.
  • Example: The Nextcloud app requests ACCESS_FINE_LOCATION permission, seemingly for geotagging uploaded photos. However, if this permission is also used in background services without clear user consent or necessity, it becomes over-permissioning. A vulnerability in a background service could then leverage this location permission to track user location without legitimate reason.
  • Impact: Unauthorized access to sensitive device resources (camera, microphone, location, contacts, storage), data breaches, privacy violations, malware propagation.
  • Risk Severity: High
  • Mitigation Strategies:
    • Developers:
      • Principle of Least Privilege: Request only the absolute minimum permissions necessary for core, user-facing functionality.
      • Runtime Permissions Best Practices: Implement runtime permission requests correctly, provide clear justification to users, and gracefully handle permission denials.
      • Regular Audits & Reduction: Periodically audit requested permissions and actively reduce them whenever possible as features evolve or are refactored.
      • Secure Permission Enforcement: Consistently and rigorously enforce permission checks throughout the application codebase, especially in sensitive components.
    • Users:
      • Permission Scrutiny: Carefully examine the entire list of permissions requested by the app before installation. Be wary of apps requesting permissions that seem unrelated to their stated purpose.
      • Runtime Permission Management: Pay close attention to runtime permission prompts. Deny permissions that seem excessive or unnecessary. Revoke granted permissions via Android settings if functionality isn't negatively impacted.
      • Utilize Permission Monitoring Tools: Employ Android's built-in permission manager or third-party tools to monitor app permission usage and identify potentially abusive behavior.

Attack Surface: Unprotected Exported Components (Intent-Based Vulnerabilities)

  • Description: Exported Activities, Services, or Broadcast Receivers are not properly secured, allowing malicious applications to interact with them in unintended and harmful ways via Android Intents.
  • Android Contribution: Android's Intent system is fundamental to inter-application communication. Exported components are explicitly designed to be accessible from other apps. If security is lacking, this intentional openness becomes a vulnerability.
  • Example: The Nextcloud app exports a Service intended for handling file uploads initiated by other apps (e.g., "Share to Nextcloud"). If this Service lacks proper input validation and authorization, a malicious app could craft a carefully crafted Intent to trigger the Service to upload malicious files to the user's Nextcloud account, potentially leading to account compromise or data corruption.
  • Impact: Data manipulation, unauthorized access to core application functionality, data exfiltration, denial of service, complete bypass of intended authentication and authorization mechanisms.
  • Risk Severity: High
  • Mitigation Strategies:
    • Developers:
      • Minimize Exported Components (Re-evaluate Necessity): Strictly minimize the number of exported components. Question the necessity of each exported component and explore alternative, more secure inter-process communication methods if possible.
      • android:exported="false" by Default: Default to android:exported="false" for all components and only explicitly export those absolutely required for inter-app interaction.
      • Robust Permission & Signature Checks: Implement mandatory permission checks within exported components to verify the caller's identity and authorization. For critical operations, implement signature verification to ensure the caller is a trusted application.
      • Comprehensive Intent Data Validation: Thoroughly and rigorously validate all data received via Intents. Sanitize inputs to prevent injection attacks and ensure data integrity.
    • Users:
      • Limited User Mitigation (Focus on Updates): Users have very limited direct mitigation. The primary defense is to ensure the Nextcloud app and Android system are always updated to receive developer-provided security fixes.

Attack Surface: Insecure Local Data Storage

  • Description: Sensitive user data (credentials, encryption keys, personal files, etc.) is stored insecurely on the Android device's local storage, making it vulnerable to unauthorized access by malicious apps or through physical device compromise.
  • Android Contribution: Android provides various storage mechanisms (SharedPreferences, internal/external storage). The developer's choice of storage method and security practices directly determines the data's vulnerability within the Android environment.
  • Example: The Nextcloud app stores the user's Nextcloud password in plain text within SharedPreferences. Any malicious app with READ_EXTERNAL_STORAGE permission (or by exploiting other vulnerabilities) could access SharedPreferences and directly steal the user's password, granting full access to their Nextcloud account.
  • Impact: Data breaches of highly sensitive user information (credentials, personal files), complete compromise of user accounts, severe privacy violations, identity theft, potential financial loss.
  • Risk Severity: Critical
  • Mitigation Strategies:
    • Developers:
      • Mandatory Encryption at Rest (KeyStore): Absolutely mandate encryption for all sensitive data stored locally. Utilize Android's KeyStore system for secure key management and robust encryption algorithms.
      • Minimize Local Storage of Sensitive Data (Server-Side Preference): Minimize the amount of sensitive data stored locally on the device. Prioritize secure server-side storage or temporary, in-memory storage whenever feasible.
      • Secure Storage APIs (Encrypted Shared Preferences): Utilize Android's Encrypted Shared Preferences or similar secure storage APIs specifically designed for sensitive data.
      • Strict File Permissions (Internal Storage Focus): Store sensitive data only on internal storage with the most restrictive file permissions. Never store sensitive data on external storage.
      • Secure Backup Practices (Avoid Plaintext Backups): Implement secure backup mechanisms that do not expose sensitive data in plaintext. Consider using Android's Backup API with encryption enabled.
    • Users:
      • Enable Device Encryption (Crucial): Always enable device encryption in Android settings. This is a fundamental security measure to protect data at rest.
      • Strong Device Lock (PIN/Password/Biometrics): Use a strong device lock (PIN, password, or biometrics) to prevent unauthorized physical access to the device and its data.
      • Keep Android Updated (Security Patches): Ensure the Android system is always updated with the latest security patches, as these often address vulnerabilities related to local data storage and access control.

Attack Surface: Third-Party Library and SDK Vulnerabilities

  • Description: Critical vulnerabilities within third-party libraries and SDKs integrated into the Nextcloud Android application can be exploited to severely compromise the application and the user's device.
  • Android Contribution: Android apps are built upon a vast ecosystem of third-party libraries. The Android platform itself doesn't inherently protect against vulnerabilities within these external components. Developers are responsible for managing and securing their dependencies.
  • Example: The Nextcloud app includes a vulnerable image processing library. A remote attacker discovers a critical remote code execution (RCE) vulnerability in this library. By crafting a malicious image and tricking the user into opening it within the Nextcloud app (e.g., via a shared link), the attacker can execute arbitrary code on the user's device with the app's permissions, potentially leading to complete device compromise.
  • Impact: Remote code execution (RCE), complete device compromise, data breaches, denial of service, malware injection, silent data theft, and a wide range of other severe security consequences.
  • Risk Severity: Critical
  • Mitigation Strategies:
    • Developers:
      • Robust Dependency Management (Automated Tools): Implement a robust dependency management system (like Gradle) and utilize automated dependency scanning tools to continuously monitor for known vulnerabilities in third-party libraries.
      • Proactive Dependency Updates (Security Focus): Prioritize and proactively update third-party libraries and SDKs, especially focusing on security updates and patches. Establish a rapid response process for addressing newly discovered vulnerabilities.
      • Vulnerability Scanning Integration (CI/CD): Integrate vulnerability scanning tools into the CI/CD pipeline to automatically detect and flag vulnerable dependencies before code is deployed.
      • Library Auditing & Minimal Dependencies: Conduct periodic security audits of third-party libraries. Minimize the number of third-party dependencies used and carefully select libraries from reputable sources with strong security track records and active maintenance.
    • Users:
      • Regular App Updates (Critical): Always keep the Nextcloud app updated to the latest version. App updates frequently include critical security patches for third-party library vulnerabilities.
      • Install from Trusted Sources Only (Play Store/F-Droid): Download and install the Nextcloud app only from official and trusted sources like the Google Play Store or F-Droid. Avoid sideloading apps from unknown or untrusted websites.