Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
152 lines (133 loc) · 11.9 KB

threat-modeling.md

File metadata and controls

152 lines (133 loc) · 11.9 KB

Threat Model Analysis for nextcloud/android

Threat: Insecure Local Data Storage

  • Description: Attacker gains unauthorized access to the Android device (physical access, malware, remote access) and exploits insecure storage practices to read sensitive data. This could involve reading plaintext files, decrypting weakly encrypted data, or bypassing file permission restrictions.
    • Impact: Confidentiality breach, exposure of user credentials, private files, encryption keys, and other sensitive information.
    • Affected Android Component: Local storage (SharedPreferences, internal storage, external storage, databases), file system access.
    • Risk Severity: High
    • Mitigation Strategies:
      • Developers:
        • Encrypt all sensitive data at rest using strong encryption algorithms (e.g., AES-256). Utilize Android Keystore System for secure key management.
        • Avoid storing sensitive data in plaintext.
        • Implement proper file permissions to restrict access to application data.
        • Minimize the amount of sensitive data stored locally.
        • Use secure storage mechanisms provided by Android (e.g., EncryptedSharedPreferences).
      • Users:
        • Enable device encryption.
        • Set a strong device lock (PIN, password, fingerprint, face unlock).
        • Avoid rooting or jailbreaking the device.
        • Keep the Android OS and Nextcloud app updated.

Threat: Content Provider Vulnerabilities

  • Description: If the Nextcloud application exposes Content Providers, vulnerabilities (e.g., SQL injection, path traversal) in these providers could be exploited by malicious applications to access, modify, or delete Nextcloud data without proper authorization.
    • Impact: Data leaks, data corruption, unauthorized access to Nextcloud data by other applications, potential for privilege escalation.
    • Affected Android Component: Android Content Provider component, database access, data sharing mechanisms.
    • Risk Severity: High
    • Mitigation Strategies:
      • Developers:
        • Avoid exposing Content Providers if not strictly necessary.
        • If Content Providers are required, implement robust security measures:
          • Use parameterized queries to prevent SQL injection.
          • Validate and sanitize all input parameters.
          • Implement proper permission checks and access control within Content Providers.
          • Follow secure coding practices for Content Provider development.
      • Users:
        • Keep the Nextcloud app updated to patch potential vulnerabilities.
        • Install applications only from trusted sources.

Threat: Device Loss or Theft

  • Description: The Android device containing the Nextcloud application is lost or stolen. An attacker who finds or steals the device could gain unauthorized access to Nextcloud data if the device is not properly secured.
    • Impact: Confidentiality breach, unauthorized access to Nextcloud data stored on the device, potential misuse of user account.
    • Affected Android Component: Entire device, device security features (screen lock, device encryption).
    • Risk Severity: High
    • Mitigation Strategies:
      • Developers:
        • Implement remote wipe functionality (if feasible and desired).
        • Ensure sensitive data is encrypted at rest.
        • Implement session timeouts and require re-authentication after inactivity.
      • Users:
        • Enable device encryption.
        • Set a strong device lock (PIN, password, fingerprint, face unlock).
        • Enable "Find My Device" or similar device tracking and remote wipe features.
        • Report lost or stolen devices immediately and remotely wipe data if possible.

Threat: Malware Infection on Device

  • Description: The Android device becomes infected with malware (viruses, trojans, spyware). Malware can steal credentials, intercept communications, access stored data, or manipulate the Nextcloud application's behavior.
    • Impact: Confidentiality breach, data theft, account compromise, unauthorized actions, privacy violation, potential financial loss.
    • Affected Android Component: Entire device, Android OS, Nextcloud application, all application components.
    • Risk Severity: High
    • Mitigation Strategies:
      • Developers:
        • Implement robust security measures within the application to mitigate the impact of malware (e.g., input validation, secure storage).
        • Keep the application updated to patch vulnerabilities that malware could exploit.
      • Users:
        • Install applications only from trusted sources like Google Play Store.
        • Enable "Google Play Protect" or similar malware scanning features.
        • Use a reputable mobile security solution.
        • Keep the Android OS and all applications updated.
        • Be cautious about clicking on suspicious links or downloading files from untrusted sources.

Threat: Compromised Android System or Firmware

  • Description: Vulnerabilities in the underlying Android operating system or device firmware are exploited by attackers. This could allow attackers to bypass security features, gain elevated privileges, and compromise applications like Nextcloud.
    • Impact: Complete compromise of the device and applications, data breaches, unauthorized access, loss of control over the device.
    • Affected Android Component: Android OS, device firmware, kernel, system services, all applications.
    • Risk Severity: Critical
    • Mitigation Strategies:
      • Developers:
        • Stay informed about Android security vulnerabilities and best practices.
        • Develop applications with security in mind, following secure coding principles.
        • Test applications on different Android versions and devices.
      • Users:
        • Keep the Android OS updated with the latest security patches.
        • Purchase devices from reputable manufacturers that provide timely security updates.
        • Avoid using outdated or unsupported Android versions.
        • Consider using custom ROMs with active security maintenance (if technically proficient and aware of risks).

Threat: Rooted/Jailbroken Devices

  • Description: The Nextcloud application is used on rooted or jailbroken Android devices. Rooting/jailbreaking weakens Android's security boundaries and increases the attack surface, making it easier for malware or attackers to compromise the application.
    • Impact: Increased risk of malware infection, easier for malware to gain elevated privileges, potential bypass of application security measures, data breaches.
    • Affected Android Component: Entire device, Android security model, application sandboxing, all application components.
    • Risk Severity: High
    • Mitigation Strategies:
      • Developers:
        • Implement root detection mechanisms and display warnings to users on rooted devices.
        • Consider limiting functionality or disabling certain features on rooted devices if security risks are deemed too high.
        • Focus on robust application security to mitigate risks even on rooted devices.
      • Users:
        • Avoid rooting or jailbreaking devices used for sensitive purposes like accessing Nextcloud.
        • If rooting is necessary, be fully aware of the security risks and take extra precautions.

Threat: Side-Loading and Unofficial App Stores

  • Description: Users install the Nextcloud application from unofficial app stores or side-load APKs. These sources may distribute compromised or malicious versions of the application, potentially containing malware or backdoors.
    • Impact: Installation of a malicious Nextcloud application, data theft, account compromise, malware infection, unauthorized actions.
    • Affected Android Component: Application installation process, APK files, application source, user behavior.
    • Risk Severity: High
    • Mitigation Strategies:
      • Developers:
        • Publish the official Nextcloud Android application on reputable app stores like Google Play Store and F-Droid.
        • Provide clear instructions on the official Nextcloud website on where to download the legitimate application.
        • Implement application signature verification to help users verify the authenticity of the downloaded APK.
      • Users:
        • Download and install the Nextcloud application only from official and trusted sources like Google Play Store or F-Droid.
        • Avoid side-loading APKs from untrusted websites or sources.
        • Verify the application signature if downloading APKs directly (advanced users).

Threat: Outdated Application or Dependencies

  • Description: The Nextcloud Android application or its dependencies (libraries, SDKs) become outdated and contain known security vulnerabilities. Attackers can exploit these vulnerabilities to compromise the application and potentially the user's data.
    • Impact: Exploitation of known vulnerabilities, data breaches, unauthorized access, application crashes, potential for remote code execution.
    • Affected Android Component: Entire application, application code, third-party libraries, SDKs, dependency management.
    • Risk Severity: High
    • Mitigation Strategies:
      • Developers:
        • Regularly update the Nextcloud Android application and all its dependencies to the latest versions.
        • Implement a robust dependency management process.
        • Monitor security advisories and vulnerability databases for known vulnerabilities in dependencies.
        • Perform regular security testing and code reviews.
      • Users:
        • Enable automatic application updates in Google Play Store or F-Droid.
        • Keep the Nextcloud application updated to the latest version.

Threat: Man-in-the-Middle (MitM) Attacks on Updates (Android Specific)

  • Description: An attacker intercepts the application update process and injects a malicious update. This could happen if the update mechanism is not secure and lacks proper verification of update sources and signatures.
    • Impact: Installation of a compromised version of the Nextcloud application, data theft, account compromise, malware infection, unauthorized actions.
    • Affected Android Component: Application update mechanism, APK download process, update server communication, signature verification.
    • Risk Severity: High
    • Mitigation Strategies:
      • Developers:
        • Use HTTPS for all update communication.
        • Implement robust signature verification for application updates to ensure authenticity and integrity.
        • Utilize secure update mechanisms provided by app stores (Google Play Store, F-Droid).
      • Users:
        • Enable automatic application updates through official app stores.
        • Download updates only through official channels (Google Play Store, F-Droid, official website if direct APK download is offered and signature is verifiable).