Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
298 lines (268 loc) · 16.1 KB

sec-design.md

File metadata and controls

298 lines (268 loc) · 16.1 KB

BUSINESS POSTURE

  • Business priorities and goals:
    • Provide a simple and universal logging API for Java applications.
    • Decouple application code from specific logging frameworks.
    • Allow developers to switch logging frameworks without code changes.
    • Improve code maintainability and reduce dependencies on specific logging implementations.
    • Facilitate adoption of best logging practices in Java development.
  • Most important business risks:
    • Dependency vulnerability: If slf4j itself has vulnerabilities, all applications using it might be affected.
    • Supply chain risk: Compromised build or distribution process could lead to malicious versions of slf4j being used.
    • Compatibility issues: Changes in slf4j API might break backward compatibility and require application code changes.
    • Performance overhead: Inefficient logging implementation could negatively impact application performance.
    • Misuse of logging: Improper logging practices by developers using slf4j could lead to security vulnerabilities (e.g., logging sensitive data).

SECURITY POSTURE

  • Existing security controls:
    • security control: Open source project with public code repository (GitHub). Location: GitHub repository.
    • security control: Community review of code through pull requests and issue tracking. Location: GitHub repository.
    • security control: Use of standard build tools (e.g., Maven). Location: pom.xml in repository.
    • security control: Distribution through Maven Central Repository. Location: Maven Central.
    • security control: Version control using Git. Location: GitHub repository.
  • Accepted risks:
    • accepted risk: Reliance on community security contributions.
    • accepted risk: Potential vulnerabilities in dependencies used by slf4j.
    • accepted risk: Risk of vulnerabilities in the logging frameworks that slf4j binds to.
  • Recommended security controls:
    • security control: Implement automated security scanning (SAST/DAST) in the CI/CD pipeline.
    • security control: Dependency vulnerability scanning to identify and address vulnerable dependencies.
    • security control: Code signing of released artifacts to ensure integrity and authenticity.
    • security control: Security awareness training for developers contributing to the project.
  • Security requirements:
    • Authentication: Not directly applicable to slf4j library itself. Authentication is relevant for systems that use logs generated by applications using slf4j.
    • Authorization: Not directly applicable to slf4j library itself. Authorization is relevant for systems that process and access logs generated by applications using slf4j.
    • Input validation: slf4j should perform input validation to prevent log injection attacks. This is primarily relevant to the API that accepts log messages.
    • Cryptography: Not directly applicable to slf4j library itself. Cryptography might be relevant for logging frameworks that slf4j binds to, if they offer features like encrypted logging.

DESIGN

C4 CONTEXT

flowchart LR
    subgraph "Organization System"
        slf4j["SLF4J Library"]
    end
    Developer["Developer"]
    Application["Java Application"]
    LoggingFramework["Logging Framework (Logback, Log4j)"]

    Developer --> slf4j: Uses
    Application --> slf4j: Uses for Logging
    slf4j --> LoggingFramework: Binds at Runtime
    Application --> LoggingFramework: Indirectly Uses for Logging

    style slf4j fill:#f9f,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px
Loading
  • Context Diagram Elements:
      • Name: Developer
      • Type: Person
      • Description: Software developers who use the SLF4J library in their Java applications.
      • Responsibilities: Integrate SLF4J into applications, configure logging, and use SLF4J API for logging.
      • Security controls: Security controls are applied to developer workstations and development environment, including access control, code review, and secure coding practices.
      • Name: SLF4J Library
      • Type: Software System
      • Description: Simple Logging Facade for Java. Provides an abstraction layer for various logging frameworks.
      • Responsibilities: Provide a consistent logging API, delegate logging operations to underlying logging frameworks, and minimize performance overhead.
      • Security controls: Input validation on log messages to prevent injection attacks, secure build and release process, and vulnerability scanning.
      • Name: Java Application
      • Type: Software System
      • Description: Any Java application that uses the SLF4J library for logging.
      • Responsibilities: Generate log messages using SLF4J API, configure logging levels, and handle application logic.
      • Security controls: Application-level security controls, including authentication, authorization, input validation, and secure configuration management.
      • Name: Logging Framework (Logback, Log4j)
      • Type: Software System
      • Description: Concrete logging implementations that SLF4J binds to at runtime. Examples include Logback and Log4j.
      • Responsibilities: Handle actual logging operations, write logs to configured destinations (files, consoles, network), and provide advanced logging features.
      • Security controls: Security controls implemented by the specific logging framework, including secure configuration, protection against log injection, and secure log storage.

C4 CONTAINER

flowchart LR
    subgraph "Organization System"
        slf4j["SLF4J Library"]
    end
    Developer["Developer"]
    Application["Java Application"]
    LoggingFramework["Logging Framework (Logback, Log4j)"]
    SLF4J_API["SLF4J API (JAR)"]

    Developer --> SLF4J_API: Develops against
    Application --> SLF4J_API: Uses at Compile Time
    SLF4J_API --> LoggingFramework: Binds at Runtime

    style slf4j fill:#f9f,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px
    style SLF4J_API fill:#ccf,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px
Loading
  • Container Diagram Elements:
      • Name: SLF4J API (JAR)
      • Type: Library
      • Description: The SLF4J API library distributed as a JAR file. Contains interfaces and classes for logging.
      • Responsibilities: Define the logging API, provide implementation for API, and allow binding to different logging frameworks.
      • Security controls: Code signing of JAR artifacts, vulnerability scanning of dependencies used in build process.
      • Name: Logging Framework (Logback, Log4j)
      • Type: Library
      • Description: Concrete logging implementation libraries (e.g., Logback JAR, Log4j JAR).
      • Responsibilities: Implement actual logging functionality, handle log output, and provide configuration options.
      • Security controls: Security controls are specific to each logging framework. Users should choose and configure secure logging frameworks.

DEPLOYMENT

Deployment of SLF4J is about how the library is included and used within Java applications. There isn't a "deployment environment" for SLF4J itself, but rather for applications that use it.

Deployment Architecture: Library Inclusion in Java Applications

flowchart LR
    subgraph "Developer Workstation"
        Developer["Developer"]
        IDE["IDE (IntelliJ, Eclipse)"]
        LocalMaven["Local Maven Repository"]
    end
    subgraph "Build Server"
        BuildServer["Build Server (Jenkins, GitHub Actions)"]
        CentralMaven["Central Maven Repository"]
        ArtifactRepository["Artifact Repository (Nexus, Artifactory)"]
    end
    subgraph "Application Runtime Environment"
        JavaApplication["Java Application Instance"]
        LoggingFrameworkInstance["Logging Framework Instance"]
    end

    Developer --> IDE: Uses
    IDE --> LocalMaven: Downloads Dependencies
    LocalMaven --> CentralMaven: Resolves Dependencies
    BuildServer --> CentralMaven: Downloads Dependencies
    BuildServer --> ArtifactRepository: Publishes Artifacts
    JavaApplication --> LoggingFrameworkInstance: Uses for Logging (via SLF4J)

    style Developer fill:#ccf,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px
    style IDE fill:#ccf,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px
    style LocalMaven fill:#ccf,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px
    style BuildServer fill:#fcf,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px
    style CentralMaven fill:#fcf,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px
    style ArtifactRepository fill:#fcf,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px
    style JavaApplication fill:#efe,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px
    style LoggingFrameworkInstance fill:#efe,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px
Loading
  • Deployment Diagram Elements:
      • Name: Developer Workstation
      • Type: Environment
      • Description: Developer's local machine used for coding and development.
      • Responsibilities: Code development, local testing, dependency management.
      • Security controls: Workstation security policies, access control, endpoint protection.
      • Name: IDE (IntelliJ, Eclipse)
      • Type: Software
      • Description: Integrated Development Environment used by developers.
      • Responsibilities: Code editing, building, debugging, dependency management.
      • Security controls: IDE security plugins, secure configuration, and update management.
      • Name: Local Maven Repository
      • Type: Data Store
      • Description: Local cache of Maven dependencies on developer's machine.
      • Responsibilities: Store downloaded dependencies, speed up build process.
      • Security controls: Access control to local file system.
      • Name: Build Server (Jenkins, GitHub Actions)
      • Type: Environment
      • Description: Automated build and CI/CD server.
      • Responsibilities: Automated building, testing, and publishing of SLF4J library.
      • Security controls: Access control, secure build pipelines, secret management, and vulnerability scanning.
      • Name: Central Maven Repository
      • Type: Service
      • Description: Public repository for Maven artifacts (e.g., Maven Central).
      • Responsibilities: Host and distribute public Maven artifacts.
      • Security controls: Security controls managed by Maven Central maintainers.
      • Name: Artifact Repository (Nexus, Artifactory)
      • Type: Service
      • Description: Internal artifact repository used by organizations to manage and cache dependencies.
      • Responsibilities: Store and manage internal and external dependencies, improve build speed and reliability.
      • Security controls: Access control, vulnerability scanning, and secure configuration.
      • Name: Java Application Instance
      • Type: Software Instance
      • Description: Running instance of a Java application that uses SLF4J.
      • Responsibilities: Execute application logic, generate logs using SLF4J.
      • Security controls: Application runtime security controls, container security, and infrastructure security.
      • Name: Logging Framework Instance
      • Type: Software Instance
      • Description: Instance of a logging framework (e.g., Logback) running within the Java application.
      • Responsibilities: Handle logging operations, write logs to configured destinations.
      • Security controls: Logging framework specific security configurations, secure log storage, and log monitoring.

BUILD

flowchart LR
    subgraph "Developer"
        Developer["Developer"]
        DevWorkstation["Developer Workstation"]
    end
    subgraph "Version Control"
        GitHub["GitHub Repository"]
    end
    subgraph "Build System"
        BuildServer["Build Server (GitHub Actions)"]
        Maven["Maven"]
        SAST["SAST Scanner"]
        DependencyCheck["Dependency Check"]
    end
    subgraph "Artifact Repository"
        MavenCentral["Maven Central"]
    end

    Developer -- Code Changes --> DevWorkstation
    DevWorkstation -- Push --> GitHub
    GitHub -- Trigger --> BuildServer
    BuildServer -- Checkout Code --> GitHub
    BuildServer -- Build --> Maven
    BuildServer -- Run SAST --> SAST
    BuildServer -- Dependency Check --> DependencyCheck
    BuildServer -- Publish Artifacts --> MavenCentral

    style Developer fill:#ccf,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px
    style DevWorkstation fill:#ccf,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px
    style GitHub fill:#fcf,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px
    style BuildServer fill:#fcf,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px
    style Maven fill:#fcf,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px
    style SAST fill:#fcf,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px
    style DependencyCheck fill:#fcf,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px
    style MavenCentral fill:#efe,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px
Loading
  • Build Process Elements:
      • Name: Developer
      • Type: Person
      • Description: Software developer contributing to the SLF4J project.
      • Responsibilities: Write code, commit changes, and create pull requests.
      • Security controls: Secure coding practices, code review, and access control to development environment.
      • Name: Developer Workstation
      • Type: Environment
      • Description: Developer's local machine.
      • Responsibilities: Code development and local testing.
      • Security controls: Workstation security policies, endpoint protection.
      • Name: GitHub Repository
      • Type: Code Repository
      • Description: Git repository hosting the SLF4J source code.
      • Responsibilities: Version control, code collaboration, and issue tracking.
      • Security controls: Access control, branch protection, and audit logging.
      • Name: Build Server (GitHub Actions)
      • Type: CI/CD System
      • Description: Automated build and CI/CD environment using GitHub Actions.
      • Responsibilities: Automated build, testing, security scanning, and publishing.
      • Security controls: Secure build pipelines, secret management, access control, and audit logging.
      • Name: Maven
      • Type: Build Tool
      • Description: Maven build tool used to compile, package, and manage dependencies for SLF4J.
      • Responsibilities: Build automation, dependency management.
      • Security controls: Plugin management, secure dependency resolution.
      • Name: SAST Scanner
      • Type: Security Tool
      • Description: Static Application Security Testing tool used to scan code for vulnerabilities.
      • Responsibilities: Automated code analysis for security vulnerabilities.
      • Security controls: Tool configuration, vulnerability reporting.
      • Name: Dependency Check
      • Type: Security Tool
      • Description: Tool to check for known vulnerabilities in project dependencies.
      • Responsibilities: Identify vulnerable dependencies.
      • Security controls: Tool configuration, vulnerability reporting.
      • Name: Maven Central
      • Type: Artifact Repository
      • Description: Public repository for Maven artifacts.
      • Responsibilities: Distribution of SLF4J library.
      • Security controls: Security controls managed by Maven Central maintainers.

RISK ASSESSMENT

  • Critical business process: Ensuring application stability, debuggability, and auditability through effective logging. While SLF4J itself is a library, its proper functioning is critical for applications that rely on logging for operational visibility and security monitoring.
  • Data being protected:
    • Source code of SLF4J: Sensitivity: Medium. Confidentiality is not paramount as it's open source, but integrity and availability are crucial.
    • SLF4J library artifacts (JARs): Sensitivity: High. Integrity and availability are critical to prevent supply chain attacks.
    • Log messages generated by applications using SLF4J: Sensitivity: Varies. Logs can contain sensitive data (PII, secrets, etc.). Sensitivity depends on what applications log and how logs are managed downstream.

QUESTIONS & ASSUMPTIONS

  • BUSINESS POSTURE:
    • Assumption: The primary business goal is to provide a stable, reliable, and widely adopted logging facade for the Java ecosystem.
    • Question: Are there specific performance benchmarks or compliance requirements that SLF4J needs to meet?
  • SECURITY POSTURE:
    • Assumption: Security is a secondary but important consideration for an open-source library like SLF4J.
    • Question: Are there any specific security certifications or standards that SLF4J aims to comply with?
    • Question: What is the process for handling reported security vulnerabilities in SLF4J?
  • DESIGN:
    • Assumption: SLF4J is designed to be lightweight and have minimal performance impact on applications.
    • Question: Are there any specific design considerations for handling different logging frameworks with varying security features?
    • Question: What is the strategy for maintaining backward compatibility while introducing new features or security improvements?