Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
123 lines (87 loc) · 13.7 KB

mitigations.md

File metadata and controls

123 lines (87 loc) · 13.7 KB

Mitigation Strategies Analysis for reactivex/rxjava

Mitigation Strategy: Backpressure Management

  • Mitigation Strategy: Implement Reactive Streams Backpressure

    • Description:

      1. Identify Potential Backpressure Points: Analyze RxJava streams to find producers emitting data faster than consumers can handle. Focus on high-volume data sources within RxJava pipelines.
      2. Choose RxJava Backpressure Strategy: Select appropriate RxJava operators for backpressure: onBackpressureBuffer(), onBackpressureDrop(), onBackpressureLatest(), or reactive streams flow control via Subscription.request(n).
      3. Apply RxJava Backpressure Operators: Integrate chosen operators into RxJava stream pipelines near data sources or before resource-intensive RxJava operations.
      4. Test and Monitor RxJava Streams: Test application load, ensuring chosen RxJava backpressure strategy prevents resource exhaustion and performance issues within RxJava streams. Monitor memory and CPU usage related to RxJava stream processing.

    • Threats Mitigated:

      • Denial of Service (DoS) due to Resource Exhaustion (High Severity): Uncontrolled RxJava data streams leading to memory/CPU overload within the reactive application logic.
      • Performance Degradation (Medium Severity): Excessive buffering or backlog processing in RxJava streams slowing down application responsiveness.

    • Impact:

      • DoS Prevention (High Impact): Effectively mitigates DoS risks specifically arising from RxJava backpressure issues.
      • Performance Improvement (High Impact): Significantly improves RxJava application stability and responsiveness under load by managing data flow within reactive streams.

    • Currently Implemented: Partially implemented in API data processing pipelines using onBackpressureBuffer() with bounded buffers in request processing Observables.

    • Missing Implementation: Backpressure not consistently applied in internal RxJava data streams for background tasks and data synchronization. RxJava streams processing database updates and external service integrations lack explicit backpressure handling.

Mitigation Strategy: Secure Scheduler and Concurrency Management

  • Mitigation Strategy: Controlled and Isolated RxJava Schedulers

    • Description:

      1. Review RxJava Scheduler Usage: Audit code for RxJava Scheduler usage: subscribeOn(), observeOn(), Schedulers.io(), Schedulers.computation(), Schedulers.newThread(), Schedulers.from(Executor).
      2. Limit RxJava Thread Pool Sizes: Configure bounded thread pool sizes for RxJava Schedulers backed by pools (e.g., Schedulers.io(), custom Executor based Schedulers used in RxJava). Avoid unbounded pools in RxJava contexts.
      3. Isolate Sensitive RxJava Operations: For sensitive operations within RxJava streams, use dedicated, isolated RxJava Schedulers with restricted resources and security contexts. Use Schedulers.from(Executor) with custom ExecutorService for RxJava isolation.
      4. Avoid Schedulers.newThread() in RxJava Production Code: Discourage Schedulers.newThread() in production RxJava code due to potential thread exhaustion. Prefer managed RxJava thread pools like Schedulers.io() or Schedulers.computation().
      5. Monitor RxJava Thread Usage: Monitor thread counts and pool statistics related to RxJava Schedulers to detect thread exhaustion or inefficient RxJava scheduler configurations.

    • Threats Mitigated:

      • Denial of Service (DoS) due to Thread Exhaustion (High Severity): Uncontrolled RxJava thread creation or unbounded RxJava thread pools exhausting system resources.
      • Information Leakage via Thread-Local Storage (Medium Severity): In shared RxJava Schedulers, thread-local storage potentially exposing data between unrelated RxJava operations on the same thread.
      • Performance Degradation due to Context Switching (Medium Severity): Excessive RxJava thread creation and context switching degrading application performance within reactive components.

    • Impact:

      • DoS Prevention (High Impact): Reduces DoS risks specifically related to RxJava thread exhaustion.
      • Information Leakage Prevention (Medium Impact): Mitigates data sharing risks through thread-local storage within RxJava concurrency.
      • Performance Improvement (Medium Impact): Improves RxJava application performance by controlling thread usage within reactive streams.

    • Currently Implemented: Partially implemented. Schedulers.io() and Schedulers.computation() are used. Thread pool sizes for Schedulers.io() are implicitly managed by RxJava defaults.

    • Missing Implementation: Bounded thread pool sizes not explicitly configured for Schedulers.io() in RxJava context. Sensitive operations in RxJava streams (authentication, authorization) are not isolated to dedicated RxJava Schedulers. Thread-local storage usage within RxJava operators not reviewed for information leakage.

Mitigation Strategy: Robust and Secure Error Handling in RxJava Streams

  • Mitigation Strategy: Comprehensive RxJava Error Handling and Secure Error Reporting

    • Description:

      1. Implement RxJava onErrorReturn()/onErrorResumeNext(): Use these RxJava operators in streams to handle expected errors gracefully, providing fallbacks or alternative streams within RxJava pipelines.
      2. Centralized RxJava Error Logging: Implement centralized logging to capture exceptions within RxJava streams, including context like timestamps, user IDs, and error details specific to RxJava operations.
      3. Sanitize RxJava Error Messages for User Output: Sanitize error messages displayed to users originating from RxJava streams, removing sensitive information like internal paths or RxJava stack traces.
      4. Secure RxJava Error Log Storage: Securely store error logs from RxJava streams with access controls to prevent unauthorized access to potentially sensitive information logged from RxJava operations.
      5. Avoid Swallowing RxJava Errors Silently: Do not catch and ignore exceptions in RxJava streams without logging or handling. Ensure all RxJava errors are at least logged for debugging and security auditing.

    • Threats Mitigated:

      • Information Disclosure via Error Messages (Medium Severity): Detailed RxJava error messages exposed to users or in public logs revealing internal application workings related to RxJava.
      • Application Instability due to Unhandled Exceptions (Medium Severity): Unhandled exceptions in RxJava streams leading to stream termination and potential application issues within reactive components.
      • Masking of Underlying Issues (Low to Medium Severity): Silently swallowing RxJava errors hiding problems that could lead to vulnerabilities or failures in reactive logic.

    • Impact:

      • Information Disclosure Prevention (Medium Impact): Reduces risk of exposing sensitive information through RxJava error messages.
      • Application Stability Improvement (Medium Impact): Enhances application robustness by handling RxJava errors and preventing stream termination.
      • Improved Debuggability and Maintainability (Medium Impact): Centralized RxJava error logging improves diagnostics and issue resolution in reactive streams.

    • Currently Implemented: Basic error logging is in place. onErrorReturn() is used in some API request processing RxJava streams for default responses on expected errors.

    • Missing Implementation: Error message sanitization for user output from RxJava streams is not consistently implemented. RxJava error logs are in standard logs without specific access controls. Some RxJava errors are logged but not handled further. Centralized error handling across all RxJava streams is not fully established.

Mitigation Strategy: Operator Usage Review and Simplification in RxJava

  • Mitigation Strategy: Code Reviews and Operator Simplification for RxJava

    • Description:

      1. RxJava Focused Code Reviews: Conduct code reviews specifically for RxJava usage. Reviewers should have RxJava expertise to identify issues in operator misuse, complex chains, concurrency, and error handling within RxJava.
      2. Simplify RxJava Operator Chains: Refactor complex RxJava operator chains into smaller, manageable, and testable reactive components. Break down complex RxJava logic into reusable functions or custom operators.
      3. RxJava Operator Understanding Documentation: Ensure developers understand RxJava operator documentation and best practices. Promote RxJava training and knowledge sharing within the team.
      4. Unit Testing of RxJava Reactive Logic: Implement unit tests for RxJava streams and operators to verify behavior and ensure expected function. Focus on testing RxJava error conditions and edge cases.

    • Threats Mitigated:

      • Logic Errors due to Operator Misunderstanding (Medium Severity): Misunderstanding RxJava operator behavior leading to incorrect data transformations and logic flaws in reactive streams.
      • Increased Complexity and Maintainability Issues (Medium Severity): Complex RxJava operator chains harder to understand, debug, and maintain, increasing vulnerability risks over time.
      • Testing Gaps (Medium Severity): Complex RxJava reactive logic harder to test comprehensively, potentially leaving vulnerabilities undetected in reactive components.

    • Impact:

      • Reduced Logic Errors (Medium Impact): RxJava focused code reviews and simplification help prevent logic errors from operator misuse.
      • Improved Code Maintainability (High Impact): Simplified and tested RxJava code is easier to maintain and less prone to vulnerabilities during updates.
      • Enhanced Code Quality (High Impact): Promotes better RxJava code quality and reduces overall vulnerability risks in reactive logic.

    • Currently Implemented: Standard code reviews are conducted, but without specific RxJava focus. Unit tests exist for core logic, but reactive streams are not always tested in isolation.

    • Missing Implementation: Dedicated RxJava focused code review guidelines and checklists are missing. No formal process for simplifying complex RxJava operator chains. Unit testing of RxJava streams is inconsistent and lacks focus on operator behavior.

Mitigation Strategy: Side Effect Management in RxJava Operators

  • Mitigation Strategy: Minimize and Isolate Side Effects in RxJava Operators

    • Description:

      1. Identify RxJava Side Effects: Review RxJava operator chains to identify operators performing side effects (logging, database updates, API calls, state modifications within RxJava streams).
      2. Minimize Side Effects in RxJava Operators: Refactor code to minimize side effects within RxJava operators. Ideally, operators should be pure functions transforming data within reactive pipelines.
      3. Isolate RxJava Side Effects to Dedicated Components: Isolate necessary side effects to dedicated components or operators outside core RxJava data transformation logic. Use doOnNext(), doOnError(), doOnComplete(), or custom operators for RxJava side effects.
      4. Document RxJava Side Effects Clearly: Document unavoidable side effects within RxJava operators clearly for understanding and management in reactive streams.
      5. Test RxJava Side Effects Separately: Test side effects separately from core RxJava reactive logic to verify behavior and prevent unintended consequences.

    • Threats Mitigated:

      • Unintended Side Effects and Logic Errors (Medium Severity): Side effects in RxJava operators making streams harder to reason about and test, increasing logic error risks.
      • Security Vulnerabilities due to Uncontrolled Side Effects (Medium Severity): Uncontrolled RxJava side effects, especially involving external systems or data modifications, potentially introducing vulnerabilities.
      • Debugging and Maintainability Challenges (Medium Severity): Side effects in RxJava operators making debugging and maintaining reactive streams more complex.

    • Impact:

      • Reduced Logic Errors (Medium Impact): Minimizing RxJava side effects makes streams easier to understand and reduces logic error risks.
      • Improved Code Maintainability (Medium Impact): RxJava code with fewer side effects is easier to maintain and modify.
      • Enhanced Testability (Medium Impact): Isolating RxJava side effects makes testing core reactive logic and side effect operations separately easier.

    • Currently Implemented: Developers are generally aware of minimizing side effects in RxJava operators, but it's not strictly enforced or systematically reviewed. doOnNext() and similar operators are used for logging and non-critical side effects in RxJava streams.

    • Missing Implementation: No formal guideline or process for minimizing and isolating side effects in RxJava operators. Code reviews do not specifically focus on RxJava side effect management. Testing of RxJava side effects is not systematically performed.