Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
110 lines (87 loc) · 8.74 KB

mitigations.md

File metadata and controls

110 lines (87 loc) · 8.74 KB

Mitigation Strategies Analysis for spring-projects/spring-framework

Mitigation Strategy: Data Binding and Injection Vulnerabilities

Mitigation Strategy: Secure Data Binding with Spring's Mechanisms

Description:

  1. Specific DTOs: Use Data Transfer Objects (DTOs) with well-defined fields for request data, rather than binding directly to domain or generic objects. This limits the attack surface.
  2. @InitBinder Whitelisting: Within your Spring controllers, use @InitBinder methods to explicitly define which fields are allowed to be bound from request parameters. This provides a whitelist approach. 
    @InitBinder
public void initBinder(WebDataBinder binder) {
    binder.setAllowedFields("firstName", "lastName", "email"); // Only these fields
}
  3. DataBinder.setDisallowedFields() Blacklisting: Use DataBinder.setDisallowedFields() to explicitly disallow binding to sensitive fields, such as those related to class loaders or other internal mechanisms (e.g., class, classLoader, protectionDomain). This is a crucial defense against vulnerabilities like Spring4Shell. 
    @InitBinder
public void initBinder(WebDataBinder binder) {
    binder.setDisallowedFields("class.*", "Class.*", "*.class.*", "*.Class.*");
}
  4. Avoid @ModelAttribute on Class Objects: Never use @ModelAttribute to bind request data directly to java.lang.Class or related objects. This is a high-risk practice.
  5. Leverage Spring's Validation Framework: Use Spring's built-in validation features (@Valid, validation annotations like @NotBlank, @Size, @Email, etc.) on your DTOs. This integrates with Spring's data binding and provides a convenient way to enforce validation rules.

List of Threats Mitigated:

  • Remote Code Execution (RCE) via Property Injection (e.g., Spring4Shell) (Severity: Critical): Exploiting vulnerabilities in Spring's data binding mechanisms to inject malicious values and execute arbitrary code.
  • Property Manipulation (Severity: High): Unauthorized modification of object properties through Spring's data binding, leading to unexpected behavior.

Impact:

  • RCE: Risk significantly reduced (from Critical to Low/Medium, depending on the completeness of the implementation, especially the use of setDisallowedFields()).
  • Property Manipulation: Risk significantly reduced (from High to Low).

Currently Implemented:

  • Example: @InitBinder used in UserController and ProductController. DTOs used for most request payloads. Basic validation with @Valid.

Missing Implementation:

  • Example: DataBinder.setDisallowedFields() not consistently used across all controllers. Some older controllers still use broad @ModelAttribute binding.

Mitigation Strategy: Expression Language Injection (SpEL Injection)

Mitigation Strategy: Secure SpEL Usage within Spring

Description:

  1. Avoid User Input in SpEL: The primary mitigation is to avoid directly embedding user-supplied input into SpEL expressions used within Spring (e.g., in @PreAuthorize, view templates, or other Spring components).
  2. Parameterized SpEL (Spring Security): When using SpEL in Spring Security annotations (like @PreAuthorize, @PostAuthorize), use parameterized expressions instead of string concatenation. This is a key Spring Security best practice. 
    // Vulnerable:
@PreAuthorize("hasRole('" + userRole + "')")

// Mitigated (using parameter):
@PreAuthorize("hasRole(#role)")
public void someMethod(@Param("role") String role) { ... }
  3. Restricted EvaluationContext (Advanced): If you must use dynamic SpEL evaluation with some influence from user input, create a custom StandardEvaluationContext and restrict the available variables and functions. This significantly limits the attacker's capabilities, even if they can inject some SpEL code. This is a Spring-specific technique. 
    StandardEvaluationContext context = new StandardEvaluationContext();
context.setVariable("userInput", sanitizedUserInput); // Sanitize!
// ... restrict available functions and properties ...
ExpressionParser parser = new SpelExpressionParser();
Expression exp = parser.parseExpression("someExpression");
Object result = exp.getValue(context);

List of Threats Mitigated:

  • Remote Code Execution (RCE) via SpEL Injection (Severity: Critical): Attackers can execute arbitrary code by injecting malicious SpEL expressions into Spring components.
  • Information Disclosure (Severity: Medium/High): Attackers can access sensitive data exposed through SpEL expressions within Spring.

Impact:

  • RCE: Risk significantly reduced (from Critical to Low/Medium, depending on the strictness of the restrictions and the avoidance of direct user input).
  • Information Disclosure: Risk reduced (from Medium/High to Low/Medium).

Currently Implemented:

  • Example: Most uses of @PreAuthorize use parameterized expressions.

Missing Implementation:

  • Example: A custom EvaluationContext is not yet implemented for a specific feature that uses dynamic SpEL based on user-configured settings. A comprehensive audit of all SpEL usage within Spring components is needed.

Mitigation Strategy: Spring Security Misconfigurations (Focusing on Spring Security Features)

Mitigation Strategy: Correct and Complete Spring Security Configuration

Description:

  1. Proper Authentication and Authorization: Use Spring Security's features (e.g., @EnableWebSecurity, @PreAuthorize, @PostAuthorize, method security) correctly. Define clear authentication and authorization rules. Avoid overly permissive configurations.
  2. CSRF Protection (Spring Security): Ensure that Cross-Site Request Forgery (CSRF) protection is enabled (it's on by default in recent Spring Security versions) and that your forms include the CSRF token. This is a core Spring Security feature.
  3. Session Management (Spring Security): Configure Spring Security's session management to prevent session fixation attacks. Use features like sessionManagement().sessionFixation().migrateSession() (or newSession()) in your Spring Security configuration.
  4. Secure Actuator Endpoints (Spring Boot): If using Spring Boot Actuator, secure its endpoints appropriately. Either disable them in production if not needed (management.endpoints.web.exposure.exclude=*) or restrict access using Spring Security.
  5. Disable TRACE Method (Spring MVC): If you are using Spring MVC, disable the HTTP TRACE method using Spring configuration.

List of Threats Mitigated:

  • Authentication Bypass (Severity: Critical): Unauthorized access due to misconfigured Spring Security authentication.
  • Authorization Bypass (Severity: Critical): Users accessing resources they shouldn't, due to misconfigured Spring Security authorization.
  • Cross-Site Request Forgery (CSRF) (Severity: High): Attackers performing actions on behalf of users, mitigated by Spring Security's CSRF protection.
  • Session Fixation (Severity: High): Attackers hijacking sessions, mitigated by Spring Security's session management.
  • Information Disclosure via Actuator (Severity: Medium/High): Leakage of sensitive information through Spring Boot Actuator, mitigated by securing or disabling the endpoints using Spring Security.
  • Cross-Site Tracing (XST) (Severity: Medium): Potential exposure of cookies or headers, mitigated by disabling TRACE method.

Impact:

  • Authentication/Authorization Bypass: Risk significantly reduced (from Critical to Low, with proper Spring Security configuration).
  • CSRF: Risk significantly reduced (from High to Low, with Spring Security's CSRF protection enabled).
  • Session Fixation: Risk significantly reduced (from High to Low, with proper Spring Security session management).
  • Information Disclosure (Actuator): Risk reduced (from Medium/High to Low/Medium, by securing or disabling Actuator endpoints with Spring Security).
  • XST: Risk reduced.

Currently Implemented:

  • Example: Spring Security configured with basic role-based access control. CSRF protection is enabled. Actuator endpoints are secured using Spring Security.

Missing Implementation:

  • Example: Session fixation protection not explicitly configured (relying on default, which might not be the most secure option). A comprehensive review of all @PreAuthorize and @PostAuthorize annotations is needed. TRACE method is not disabled.